Game Thread MafiEra Mafia Ultimate Day 3

[Captain Skunkbeard]

If we blast Yami Bakura out o' a long cannon, draggin' Minecraft Steve along wit' 'em, will be hardly a loss since Steve here has done naught but sow harsh feelings 'n speculation.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

seems to me you are "just asking questions" while contradicting yourself from what you said a few moments prior.

seems to me you are lookin for nitpick instead of scum

 

[Minecraft Steve]

YOU ALSO IMPLICATED HONEY IN THIS WHO HAS SHOWN NO LIKELY FAKERY,
MINECRAFT STEVE YOUR ACTIONS ARE AT ODDS WITH YOUR STATED INTENTIONS, ARE YOU INSIDIOUS OR ARE YOU A FOOL?

the latter

I think I know who Steve is now.

i think its obvious

 

[Minecraft Steve]

what if both sparkses are town and they want to force scum to shoot betwee them

Unvote

dont really see scum shooting sparks regardless of role tho

 

[Yami Bakura]

If we blast Yami Bakura out o' a long cannon, draggin' Minecraft Steve along wit' 'em, will be hardly a loss since Steve here has done naught but sow harsh feelings 'n speculation.

 

[Niko]

My name is Nico

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Why do we care about Spider =? Sparks? If fellas wanna RP, let 'em. This particular fake, if it is that, only starts mattering when the magic words about additional alignment checks are spoken. Have they been said yet?

Besides, real Sparks has a very distinctive posting style and if he wants to show some very obvious signs without outright mentioning that "'TIS I, THE SPARKLIEST OF THE FUNKY DUDES", I am sure he can do that.

 

[Goldar]

If we blast Yami Bakura out o' a long cannon, draggin' Minecraft Steve along wit' 'em, will be hardly a loss since Steve here has done naught but sow harsh feelings 'n speculation.

GOLDAR SEES LITTLE DIFFERENCE IN THE DEATH OF A FOOL OR AN ENEMY, THIS APPROACH WILL BE CONSIDERED.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

This particular fake, if it is that, only starts mattering when the magic words about additional alignment checks are spoken. Have they been said yet?

they could fake red check yea

 

[Illuminati member 2]

i truly do not understand why you posted what you did though. there was no speculation about what it means, you are just dropping potential links to people despite you saying that we shouldn't speculate.

You honestly think scum is not going to figure out who is who? They probably have a smaller poll of people to guess from (If they do know who their partner is. Hey, @Baba Yaga, how is that for useless speculation)

Geno did say the spirit of the game is to figure out who is who, removing that incentive is hindering the game.

 

[Claude]

seems to me you are lookin for nitpick instead of scum

if you are who i am pretty sure you are i have not really scum read you but what you did with the honey spiderman thing is just fluff busy work to make it look like you are doing something without doing it. then add in that you just contradicted yourself. its not a great look.

 

[Claude]

You honestly think scum is not going to figure out who is who? They probably have a smaller poll of people to guess from (If they do know who their partner is. Hey, @Baba Yaga, how is that for useless speculation)

Geno did say the spirit of the game is to figure out who is who, removing that incentive is hindering the game.

the thing is steve just said that we shouldn't and then did it himself just a few moments after. that's the issue here, the quick contradiction on what they said we should do with no substance behind it.

 

[Rita Repulsa]

then add in that you just contradicted yourself

If I'm right with my guess this is NAI lol.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Fuck. That's it, isn't it?!

HAVING FUN IS ANTI-TOWN

You're supposed to be miserable!

That's 100% it, goddammit

 

[Thresh]

If Spider Man is lying about being Sparks then it is being done maliciously since they revealed checks to me behind closed doors

 

[Minecraft Steve]

If Spider Man is lying about being Sparks then it is being done maliciously since they revealed checks to me behind closed doors

thank you

 

[Illuminati member 2]

the thing is steve just said that we shouldn't and then did it himself just a few moments after. that's the issue here, the quick contradiction on what they said we should do with no substance behind it.

Hmm I guess I could see that, I'll see how it plays out a little more, I'm kind of tired right now.

 

[Rita Repulsa]

If Spider Man is lying about being Sparks then it is being done maliciously since they revealed checks to me behind closed doors

That does seems scummy.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

they could fake red check yea

That they could. But have they yet? And if they will, who is to say that we won't be able to tell the real Sparks from the fake? I have faith we can do that, so in my mind, if someone wants to try it, let them.

The fakery itself is NAI unless done to nefarious ends. Personally I am more concerned about folks hiding behind RP, but at least we are getting some fun out of it so I end up not caring that much lol.

Lol I see that post. Nice. Now to deal with it.

 

[Yami Bakura]

I was marked last night

(I will always be paranoid of arsonists, always)

 

[Illuminati member 2]

seems to me you are lookin for nitpick instead of scum

That's how it felt when Claude went against me

 

[Illuminati member 3]

If Spider Man is lying about being Sparks then it is being done maliciously since they revealed checks to me behind closed doors

Do you think the check and the result are realistic?

 

[Thresh]

I purposely don’t want to reveal or act on the information I was told at this time, if it is Sparks we can deal with it out of costume. If it’s not Sparks, we aren’t going to out Spider-Man since they are going to keep the act up unless someone can specifically figure out who is behind a costume

 

[Illuminati member 2]

(I will always be paranoid of arsonists, always)

Yami, I'll just ask directly, are you still alive in the main game?

 

[Niko]

Who are we killing today?

 

[Thresh]

Do you think the check and the result are realistic?

I feel like they knew something only Sparks should have known but like I said, it could have been lucky guessed.

the target and results are whatever, result doesn’t shock me and I’m not going to pretend to know that I could guess at Sparks’ targeting

 

[Rey]

Who are we killing today?

Don't worry Nico we are killing Niko today

 

[The Ghost of Stealin Stan]

That's how it felt when Claude went against me

That’s how it felt when you went after Catalina…

A veritable OUROBOROS of nitpicking.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

I feel like they knew something only Sparks should have known but like I said, it could have been lucky guessed.

the target and results are whatever, result doesn’t shock me and I’m not going to pretend to know that I could guess at Sparks’ targeting

Aight. So it could be real.

Well, the next move is simple. Does anyone have alignment checks they want to mention? (Yeah, shit really ain't this simple when we start introducing alignment changes and such, is what is.) And if the real Sparks wants to step up and post like a mad man without getting modkilled, go for it.

 

[Cinderella]

To be fair this isn't a whole lot of pressure on Catalina, I think it's just me on there at this point.

Also, good morning! I am here

as in you life in a timezone where its morning atm ?

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Aight. So it could be real.

Well, the next move is simple. Does anyone have alignment checks they want to mention? (Yeah, shit really ain't this simple when we start introducing alignment changes and such, is what is.) And if the real Sparks wants to step up and post like a mad man without getting modkilled, go for it.

Sparks do not go for it and put a target on your back.

 

[Cinderella]

My name is Nico

Liar. Its niko

 

[Yami Bakura]

Yami, I'll just ask directly, are you still alive in the main game?

Psht, as if anyone could kill me. The Millenium Items have been keeping me safe

 

[Illuminati member 2]

That’s how it felt when you went after Catalina…

A veritable OUROBOROS of nitpicking.

I was trying to be useful. For the last time, since I I don't want to get incensed again, Catalina's "I have info but I'll save it for tomorrow" felt worth putting pressuring on AND IT WORKED. Catalina did went to Geno for clarification on how to proceed and once that played out I was convinced it was not worth persuing anymore.

I keep getting shit on for something I felt was beneficial to town. Did I just didn't explain myself properly? I still think I was pretty clear.

Anyway my partner finally responded on the chat and all they said to me is that I'm going to get them killed. Probably catching up, it's not been that long.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Sparks do not go for it and put a target on your back.

If Spider is Sparks, the target already is there. If Spider is not Sparks, someone is faking checks and Sparks can out them as the scum they are.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Psht, as if anyone could kill me. The Millenium Items have been keeping me safe

Somone use the dagger on Yami

 

[Illuminati member 4]

If Spider is Sparks, the target already is there. If Spider is not Sparks, someone is faking checks and Sparks can out them as the scum they are.

Spider does not have to be lying. I'll wait for Thresh to say Spider insinuated being Sparks

 

[Illuminati member 2]

If Spider is Sparks, the target already is there. If Spider is not Sparks, someone is faking checks and Sparks can out them as the scum they are.

Sparks already claimed as a cop, not only that but Tresh already identified themselves. They are obviously linked before sharing lover status.

But if Spiderman is not sparks, then this is an obvious attempt at fishing out the real sparks.

Hmm,I think the obvious answer is that spider is sparks.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Spider does not have to be lying. I'll wait for Thresh to say Spider insinuated being Sparks

Was that not the whole premise of this nonsense lol did I miss something

 

[Yami Bakura]

Somone use the dagger on Yami

Now hold on, you can't just start asking for people to get stabbed. It's quite rude

 

[Niko]

Liar. Its niko

Some people call me Nico

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Was that not the whole premise of this nonsense lol did I miss something

Thresh said Spider claimed checks. I don't know about the Sparks impression. It is only scummy if they copied Sparks N1 Sorian checks to pass off as Sparks

 

[Illuminati member 2]

This does make me wonder if most pairs are related and predeterminated or just by some luck Sorian and Sparks ended up together. Seems like too much of a coincidence.

 

[Captain Skunkbeard]

Now hold on, you can't just start asking for people to get stabbed. It's quite rude

Gettin' skewered once gets the fear o' death out o' ye.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Eeh, probably a dead end there. Maybe they are just an exception

 

[Illuminati member 2]

@Michael , buddy, you wanna join us?

 

[Catalina]

@Catalina does it bother you that scum will be able to simply submit the command KILL: Catalina tonight? They don’t even need to guess who you really are

No

 

[Captain Skunkbeard]

Catalina showin' real conviction in the face o' death starin' down at 'em. A fine example o' the sort o' attitude we shall all strive fer.

 

[Yami Bakura]

No

You're going to get ninja strong shotted and regret that, but it seems like no one is convincing you on that today

 

[Illuminati member 2]

What if scum is Simon and they choose the no flip option and you somehow flip?

 

[Rey]

Whoever has the behelit should give it to Catalina

 

[Illuminati member 2]

What if scum is Simon and they choose the no flip option and you somehow flip?

That was for Catalina

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Thresh said Spider claimed checks. I don't know about the Sparks impression. It is only scummy if they copied Sparks N1 Sorian checks to pass off as Sparks

I interpret this as a hesitant yes:

I have spoken to Spider-Man privately and I do kind of agree with Zoltan in that this feels like a bad impression but they passed all my testing so I have to assume they are who they seem to be

Though on a quick glance actual names aren't mentioned and things are merely implied (Pazzo thinks Spider is fake Zordon agrees, Thresh agrees with Zordon). So the parties involved should clarify things if possible.

 

[Catalina]

You're going to get ninja strong shotted and regret that

 

[Rita Repulsa]

I wouldn't go for the fake Sparks today. There is a chance we find scum there but there is also a chance that we just lynch Sparks. Rereading Honey and Spider I'm not 100% sure who is Sparks, I'm not even sure if one of them is Sparks or the both of them are roleplaying and Sparks still haven't posted. I think we are still missing 3 players.

 

[Rita Repulsa]

I also think that there is a good chance that we just end with a modkill.

 

[Yami Bakura]

About 24 hours so I have something to share. I have a 50% ITA today - GALICK GUN(tm).

Before you ask, no it's not an item. And it's not costume related.

Any idea who you're thinking of blastin with this? 50% is pretty good odds!

 

[Illuminati member 2]

What if Salva uses that power that erases someone from the game on you.

 

[Q]

Wazzup you bunch of roleplaying sickos, having fun with unfiltered costumed-flavored chaos?

 

[Q]

About 24 hours so I have something to share. I have a 50% ITA today - GALICK GUN(tm).

Before you ask, no it's not an item. And it's not costume related.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

While EC flipped as a will forger, there still could be room for a PM retractor or a switcher. Or something of that nature, something that'd not overlap with EC and would destroy information instead of adding it.

 

[Illuminati member 4]

I interpret this as a hesitant yes:



Though on a quick glance actual names aren't mentioned and things are merely implied (Pazzo thinks Spider is fake Zordon agrees, Thresh agrees with Zordon). So the parties involved should clarify things if possible.

Thats why I'm waiting on Thresh

Any idea who you're thinking of blastin with this? 50% is pretty good odds!

No. Don't want to be too hasty!

 

[Catalina]

What if Salva uses that power that erases someone from the game on you.

Then I will be removed from the game.

What do you want from me?

It's simple Town will either kill me or Not. Then Scum will either kill me or not at night.

I'm mega annoyed at this costume stuff and don't wanna play anymore

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Thats why I'm waiting on Thresh

No. Don't want to be too hasty!

Is your shot role related or an item?

 

[Blue Ranger]

Sorry, been a rough time my way this last day. I’m gonna be back with thoughts after lunch. Need to catch up.

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Is your shot role related or an item?

I answered that when I first claimed. Not item related

 

[Catalina]

I mean no disrespect to geno when I say I am not having fun. this game is just not for me at least not right now.

Just want some normal mafia

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I answered that when I first claimed. Not item related

Sorry I must have missed that, I kind of skimmed when I was catching up today.

 

[Catalina]

like this is a super well designed Game and my role is super cool and i am grateful for the opportunity to play , im just miserable right now for a combination of factors outside anyone's control

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Sorry I must have missed that, I kind of skimmed when I was catching up today.

No problem

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Wazzup you bunch of roleplaying sickos, having fun with unfiltered costumed-flavored chaos?

Kinda simple so far really. Feels much like a normal costume D1, apart from the horde of folks we have here. And even then the post speed so far ain't that bad imo.

 

[Michael]

I was marked last night

That's funny, because I was marked last night. There are 2 marks now?

By the cupid?

Any flavor or extra info you can share?

Who are you and why do you want to know?

 

[Catalina]

I get so sad every time I play mafia. I don't know whats wrong with me. like im sitting in my room crying like a Idiot for something that should not be a big deal at all.

 

[Q]

While EC flipped as a will forger, there still could be room for a PM retractor or a switcher. Or something of that nature, something that'd not overlap with EC and would destroy information instead of adding it.

EC could destroy as much as add any information in the PM. don't see why would Geno add a role that is just worse in every way. But scratch that, what are you getting at with this again?

Then I will be removed from the game.

What do you want from me?

It's simple Town will either kill me or Not. Then Scum will either kill me or not at night.

I'm mega annoyed at this costume stuff and don't wanna play anymore

Persevere my generic video game character friend. Soon we will have to fight some final boss bullshit rigged to hell and back by Geno and co. It will be fun!

 

[Illuminati member 4]

I get so sad every time I play mafia. I don't know whats wrong with me. like im sitting in my room crying like a Idiot for something that should not be a big deal at all.

Take a break Cat. Come back when you want but take a break

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I get so sad every time I play mafia. I don't know whats wrong with me. like im sitting in my room crying like a Idiot for something that should not be a big deal at all.

Sorry if I made you feel this way, it wasn't my intention.

 

[Catalina]

Im frustrated that I can't even go full mask off because I have to put the mask back on if I live to tomorrow

 

[Illuminati member 3]

But scratch that, what are you getting at with this again?

+1 attempt to get Catalina to talk, even when I know it ain't likely to happen. That.

 

[Catalina]

Like Im dead anyway because your all Jerks that are mean to neutrals.

Even though I have all these cool abilities that could help town and ib wanna help town just because Im neutral everyone will treat me like an enemy

 

[Michael]

Why is my partner being voted?

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Like Im dead anyway because your all Jerks that are mean to neutrals.

Even though I have all these cool abilities that could help town and ib wanna help town just because Im neutral everyone will treat me like an enemy

Oh Thresh is a certified friend to neutral

 

[Catalina]

Like im a super strong character but town is gonna vote me out because yall are cowards who can't trust someone neutral

 

[Captain Skunkbeard]

Like Im dead anyway because your all Jerks that are mean to neutrals.

Even though I have all these cool abilities that could help town and ib wanna help town just because Im neutral everyone will treat me like an enemy

Catalina, I've got yer back. Don't let these vermin get t' ye. Ye're doin' a good job o' standin' yer ground 'n I respect that.

 

[Q]

Take a break, Catalina! There is absolutely nothing wrong with just backing off a bit and coming back when (and if) you're feeling better.

Oh Thresh is a certified friend to neutral

Thresh = Sorian? I missed that topic

 

[Rita Repulsa]

Is this neutral thing new?

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Like Im dead anyway because your all Jerks that are mean to neutrals.

Even though I have all these cool abilities that could help town and ib wanna help town just because Im neutral everyone will treat me like an enemy

 

[Claude]

Like im a super strong character but town is gonna vote me out because yall are cowards who can't trust someone neutral

not everyone is distrustful of neutrals. i understand why you think that but wish you had let things play out a bit, if you can help town them we'll help you the best we can.

 

[Yami Bakura]

Like Im dead anyway because your all Jerks that are mean to neutrals.

Even though I have all these cool abilities that could help town and ib wanna help town just because Im neutral everyone will treat me like an enemy

You're not dead at all, you're going to be okay. I was just teasing you a bit because I wanted to see the information, but it's honestly fine waiting a day for that. And town isn't interested in voting you out, there's only 1 vote on you and they immediately started voting for anyone who went after you.

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Is this neutral thing new?

Yes

Its not the end of the world Cat. We have worked with neutrals before

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Is this neutral thing new?

100%, otherwise they wouldn't be riding my ass so hard.

Now the whole "I have info but wait until tomorrow" makes perfect fucking sense. I was right on pressuring on.

Sorry if this is hard on you Cat, rolling neutral suuuuuuucks. I do believe now you have town interests in mind, even if you clearly prioritize self preservation.

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Take a break, Catalina! There is absolutely nothing wrong with just backing off a bit and coming back when (and if) you're feeling better.


Thresh = Sorian? I missed that topic

Thresh is heavily implied to be

 

[Illuminati member 3]

@Catalina I think moments before your revelation most people entertained the idea was that you were town. At least in my eyes the recent events and how you wanted to help people strengthened this idea. Now look at the reactions - I believe that if you are not a threat to town, we can coexist.

Town wins when the Council is defeated. Are you a member of the Council?

 

[Catalina]

Now the whole "I have info but wait until tomorrow" makes perfect fucking sense. I was right on pressuring on.

Nope you were completely wrong.

your dumb comments are the main reason I want to quit

You don't understand me at all. I was not trying to live to tomorrow at all

Nothing happens tomorrow related to my role at all

I just needed the costume Phase to be over so I can share the info correctly

 

[Pink Ranger]

neutral?

what did Catalina even hint that they had info if they weren't going to share it anyway

 

[Catalina]

@Illuminati member 2
You don't get to be smug jerk when you guessed everything about my motivation completely wrong

 

[Catalina]

neutral?

what did Catalina even hint that they had info if they weren't going to share it anyway

I was going to share it I had a Big post pre-typed.

But then I noticed it was a costume Phase :(

 

[Pink Ranger]

I was going to share it I had a Big post pre-typed.

But then I noticed it was a costume Phase :(

Why do costumes make a difference. People have memories and can act on the info the next day or it could focus minds on trying to find a specific person today

 

[Illuminati member 2]

@Illuminati member 2
You don't get to be smug jerk when you guessed everything about my motivation completely wrong

I guessed you wanted to survive and it sure is like something a neutral would want.

 

[Cinderella]

like this is a super well designed Game and my role is super cool and i am grateful for the opportunity to play , im just miserable right now for a combination of factors outside anyone's control

Its okay fandorin

 

[Catalina]

I guessed you wanted to survive and it sure is like something a neutral would want.

I didnt want to survive I am already Dead Genius