Game Thread MafiEra Mafia Ultimate Day 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Ghost of Stealin Stan

The Ghost of Stealin Stan

Costume Account (He/Him)
Pink Ranger said:
No voting is suspect as hell.

Look at the number of no voters and know that there are mafia votes there. From ECs flip we know there are two teams who probably don't know each other.

they are scared of voting out other mafia. they want the no vote. It is the way they can avoid death and they are voting for it.

Voting out the mafia is how we win. Not voting is the slow way to lose.
Click to expand...
Imagine looking at a group of 14 players, saying "there's scum there," and thinking that's a statement.

If anyone could've been able to argue for a single consistent case today, I bet people would've been less inclined to No Vote. Hell, I didn't want to No Vote earlier. The boredom and the fear of potentially losing 4/6 townies in a single information-less day phase made a better case than any trigger-happy costume-wearer today.

Town shooting in the dark is not the way to win.
 
Rey

Rey

Costume Account
The Ghost of Stealin Stan said:
Imagine looking at a group of 14 players, saying "there's scum there," and thinking that's a statement.

If anyone could've been able to argue for a single consistent case today, I bet people would've been less inclined to No Vote. Hell, I didn't want to No Vote earlier. The boredom and the fear of potentially losing 4/6 townies in a single information-less day phase made a better case than any trigger-happy costume-wearer today.

Town shooting in the dark is not the way to win.
Click to expand...

Well said.
 
Pink Ranger

Pink Ranger

Costume Account
The Ghost of Stealin Stan said:
Imagine looking at a group of 14 players, saying "there's scum there," and thinking that's a statement.

If anyone could've been able to argue for a single consistent case today, I bet people would've been less inclined to No Vote. Hell, I didn't want to No Vote earlier. The boredom and the fear of potentially losing 4/6 townies in a single information-less day phase made a better case than any trigger-happy costume-wearer today.

Town shooting in the dark is not the way to win.
Click to expand...

Hmmm. Didn't we just have a bunch of ITAs that got one mafia and 1 town. That was a win.

Let's get another shot off.

No voting right now is saying you don't want a town vig.
 
The Ghost of Stealin Stan

The Ghost of Stealin Stan

Costume Account (He/Him)
Pink Ranger said:
Hmmm. Didn't we just have a bunch of ITAs that got one mafia and 1 town. That was a win.

Let's get another shot off.

No voting right now is saying you don't want a town vig.
Click to expand...
No, it's really not. It's saying I'd rather not kill two townies in the dark on top of maybe the vig doing the exact same a bit earlier.

Here's a suggestion: instead of hedging and heckling people, how about you follow your own clues and put a vote down so we can maybe follow you towards certain town victory?
 
Pink Ranger

Pink Ranger

Costume Account
The Ghost of Stealin Stan said:
No, it's really not. It's saying I'd rather not kill two townies in the dark on top of maybe the vig doing the exact same a bit earlier.

Here's a suggestion: instead of hedging and heckling people, how about you follow your own clues and put a vote down so we can maybe follow you towards certain town victory?
Click to expand...

Why do you assume two townies are going to die?

I don't know who a lot of people are. I am happy to have the day end with Kawl.

And did i say it was certain victory? I said it was the way to lose slowly. if we are going to lose we might as well do it at a reasonable pace.
 
The Ghost of Stealin Stan

The Ghost of Stealin Stan

Costume Account (He/Him)
Pink Ranger said:
Why do you assume two townies are going to die?

I don't know who a lot of people are. I am happy to have the day end with Kawl.

And did i say it was certain victory? I said it was the way to lose slowly. if we are going to lose we might as well do it at a reasonable pace.
Click to expand...
Because the only people who know who others are are... scum. Town has no info. We don't know what the fuck we're doing.

There's more of us than of them, so chances are we'll be wrong.

Kawl has the decision. I just don't have any informed suggestions as to what the best move is. It's a shot in the dark.
 
Pink Ranger

Pink Ranger

Costume Account
The Ghost of Stealin Stan said:
Because the only people who know who others are are... scum. Town has no info. We don't know what the fuck we're doing.

There's more of us than of them, so chances are we'll be wrong.

Kawl has the decision. I just don't have any informed suggestions as to what the best move is. It's a shot in the dark.
Click to expand...

Kawl doesn't have that decision until 1 hour before day ends

Turboing no vote takes that decision away from him!
 
Pink Ranger

Pink Ranger

Costume Account
You are MrHedin

You are Aligned with the Players. (That's the TOWN.) You will win when all members of the Council are eliminated.

You are a 1 Shot Override, once in the game in the day you can post the public command Override: X to end the day, the chosen player will be voted out. You can only use this in the final 1 hour of the day.

You are 1 Shot Faction Knowledge, once in the game only after N6 and afterward with the command Battle Royale you will learn how many different factions are still in the game.

You worship the Faith.

You start with 1500 Mafiera Bucks.

Your Blood Type is AB.
Click to expand...


If kawl decides they don't want to take the shot then the day can end with a no vote. Just give Kawl the power.
 
The Ghost of Stealin Stan

The Ghost of Stealin Stan

Costume Account (He/Him)
I'll mention what Claude told me earlier, though, which is not something I'd not considered on my previous assessment of the situation: maybe scum will take a 2-for-1 deal for the NK as well. Probably, even. This could end up with 6T down for the day.
 
Pink Ranger

Pink Ranger

Costume Account
The Ghost of Stealin Stan said:
I'll mention what Claude told me earlier, though, which is not something I'd not considered on my previous assessment of the situation: maybe scum will take a 2-for-1 deal for the NK as well. Probably, even. This could end up with 6T down for the day.
Click to expand...

We could also get 2 mafia today.

Has Claude been focusing on the negatives?
 
Pazzo the Ghost Clown

Pazzo the Ghost Clown

Costume Account (He/Him)
Pazzo does not have enough information to vote someone out. Pazzo thinks even if we hit scum Pazzo is worried town dies too. Pazzo would like to not be in a costume anymore.
 
TommyV

TommyV

Pazzo is obviously kyan, who else would dedicate themselves to the 3rd person so hard?

(I have no idea if pazzo is kyan)
 
Q

Q

The Ghost of Stealin Stan said:
Imagine looking at a group of 14 players, saying "there's scum there," and thinking that's a statement.

If anyone could've been able to argue for a single consistent case today, I bet people would've been less inclined to No Vote. Hell, I didn't want to No Vote earlier. The boredom and the fear of potentially losing 4/6 townies in a single information-less day phase made a better case than any trigger-happy costume-wearer today.

Town shooting in the dark is not the way to win.
Click to expand...
Okay Brazil
 
Q

Q

Although it was definitely underused, I come off town reading Cind from our chat. Not really an unfailable read, and I don't really have a clue who he is on the main thread, but at least that's a concrete something coming off of the phase
 
Illuminati member 2

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
Illuminati Member 5 said:
I've finally caught up! And I have a partner!

So some thoughts:
I think Ephi hunting is a futile task today. The chance of miselimination seems too high to me for that to be the best possibility.
The whole time stone arc seems super towny, but I'm also terrible at identifying people behind costume accounts, so maybe that was already known?
One thing that really jumped out to me was this post:

They feel good about me when I have literally 3 posts in the thread, none of which relate to the game? Could this be someone who has a connection to Barack Obama and don't want them eliminated as collateral damage? Unless they know my real identity (which I guess wouldn't be too hard to figure out) and Town read that.
Click to expand...
I'll be honest, the list took me a while to make and I confused you with 3. I do remember you making a post about missing Obama and being lonely on the chat, and I related SINCE FUCKING MICHAEL HAS YET TO SAY SHIT TO ME.
 
TommyV

TommyV

When the game ends and you all see our chat you'll all be so jealous, we get on so well we're practically siblings at this point.
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
Okay I catch up here. That was terrible. Never reading again.

No idea the active roster in the main thread and I'm on mobile and too impatient to switch back and forth -- so we are gonna vibe it.

I don't feel great about Pazzo.

I get good vibes from Pink, Rey, and Rita. I think Steve used the Time Stone in a town-y way despite the backfire. I'm unsure what to make of Cat v IM2.

I feel decent about my partner IM5. They were helpful in answering my Qs.

I've enjoyed the Goldar and Zordon rp even if it amounted to nothing in helping me form any reads.

Q, Claude and Nico (Niko?) and Lightening Strikes have my interest.

That is all.
 
Illuminati member 2

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
I like the idea of letting Kawl choose, but it's also a huge responsabilty to let a single person who is lot in the game do that. Is Kawl even reading the game?

This whole day has been filled with cowards who won't try to get the ball rolling and vote out scum. If we forget the context of the first 2 days for a minute, this isn't that different from a day 1 with limited info. We should treat this day as a Super Day 1 and look at the costumed players that decided to either don't do shit or just play when it served them and flip them.

Sure, we lost a cop, but this is a war, we have to keep flipping. We will never be sure who is who, but only by applying pressure can we get more info and make a better flip.

Vote: Barney
 
San Franpsycho

San Franpsycho

Costume Account (She/Her)
One is not aware of any reasons to not receive things from senders; only night movements have been item giving which seems to be not counted in any way with roles.

one has not made any nighttime commands as yet.
 
Illuminati member 3

Illuminati member 3

Costume Account
At one point I looked at the player list, tried to think about who has made an impression on me and who has not, and had this thought:

"Illuminati 3, who the fuck is that? Don't think I've seen them do anything yet."
 
Captain Skunkbeard

Captain Skunkbeard

Costume Account (She/Her)
Illuminati member 2 said:
I like the idea of letting Kawl choose, but it's also a huge responsabilty to let a single person who is lot in the game do that. Is Kawl even reading the game?

This whole day has been filled with cowards who won't try to get the ball rolling and vote out scum. If we forget the context of the first 2 days for a minute, this isn't that different from a day 1 with limited info. We should treat this day as a Super Day 1 and look at the costumed players that decided to either don't do shit or just play when it served them and flip them.

Sure, we lost a cop, but this is a war, we have to keep flipping. We will never be sure who is who, but only by applying pressure can we get more info and make a better flip.

Vote: Barney
Click to expand...
I like yer spirit. I do reckon we shall run someone through wit' the pointy end o' a cutlass. Otherwise the vermin will get all comfortable like.

Vote: Barney
 
San Franpsycho

San Franpsycho

Costume Account (She/Her)
One may be affected by one’s fondness for a previous costume and may be looking at one’s own posts and thinking ”wow, monkey agrees with me”
 
Geno

Geno

==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

No vote (13 votes)
Rey - #1,289
Catalina - #1,305
Lightning Strikes - #1,306
Pazzo the Ghost Clown - #1,323
Illuminati Member 4 - #1,330
Claude - #1,380
Bob Ross - #1,583
Goldar - #1,835 (Double)
Rita Repulsa - #1,836
The Ghost of Stealin Stan - #1,837 #1,917
Black Ranger - #1,841
Q - #1,843
Minecraft Steve - #1,861

Barney (3 votes)
Illuminati Member 2 - #1,953
Captain Skunkbeard - #1,960
Pink Ranger - #1,962

Illuminati Member 2 (1 votes)
Zordon - #490 #669
Thresh - #495 #980
Claude - #564 #1,254
Baba Yaga - #601 #1,307
Catalina - #614 #1,128
San Franpsycho - #659

Illuminati Member 5 (1 votes)
Baba Yaga - #1,313

Pink Ranger (1 votes)
TommyV - #1,748

Honey (1 votes)
Minecraft Steve - #598 #804
Minecraft Steve - #1,163 #1,861
Thresh - #1,765

Catalina (0 votes)
Pazzo the Ghost Clown - #452 #504
Yami Bakura - #455 #961
Illuminati Member 2 - #483 #553

Captain Skunkbeard (0 votes)
Baba Yaga - #316 #601

Barack Obama (0 votes)
Baba Yaga - #127 #316

Yami Bakura (0 votes)
San Franpsycho - #317 #647
Lightning Strikes - #319 #1,306
Captain Skunkbeard - #321 #1,960
Illuminati Member 2 - #322 #483

Illuminati Member 4 (0 votes)
Illuminati Member 3 - #1,766 #1,874

Thresh (0 votes)
Spider-Man - #995 #1,378

Spider-Man (0 votes)
Thresh - #980 #1,378
Illuminati Member 4 - #985 #1,330
Minecraft Steve - #1,021 #1,163

Claude (0 votes)
Illuminati Member 2 - #581 #1,953
San Franpsycho - #647 #659

Not voting: Cinderella, Illuminati Member 5, Blue Ranger, The Ghost of Stealin Stan, Carl, Honey, Niko, Illuminati Member 3, Barack Obama, Captain Picard, Zordon, Yami Bakura, Kool-Aid Man, Barney, Michael

Post Counts:
Illuminati Member 2: 282 Minecraft Steve: 230 Thresh: 175 San Franpsycho: 141 Catalina: 122 Illuminati Member 4: 113 Lightning Strikes: 98 Illuminati Member 3: 93 Claude: 92 Pink Ranger: 89 Zordon: 89 Yami Bakura: 77 Black Ranger: 70 Baba Yaga: 66 Rey: 64 Pazzo the Ghost Clown: 63 Bob Ross: 54 Captain Skunkbeard: 52 Goldar: 46 The Ghost of Stealin Stan: 43 Rita Repulsa: 42 Cinderella: 40 Spider-Man: 40 Blue Ranger: 39 Barney: 39 Q: 22 Carl: 20 Illuminati Member 5: 19 Kool-Aid Man: 10 Niko: 10 TommyV: 8 Honey: 7 Barack Obama: 6 Captain Picard: 6 Michael: 2


Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Claude

Claude

Pink Ranger said:
We could also get 2 mafia today.

Has Claude been focusing on the negatives?
Click to expand...
i tend to be risk adverse when there is no reason to be risky, i do not think we need to take risks at this point. you say i am focusing on negatives which is true that i am thinking of the worst case scenario and i don't think it's worth it. we are at 1.5 deaths right now (counting sorian as a half since he can still somewhat participate). if we missed the vote it's 3.5 and if lovers last through the night then it could be 5.5. i guess my question to you is how many scum deaths do we need to make it worth the risk? let's say we vote out a pair and one of them is scum, we are then at 4.5 town to 1 scum lost this phase (assuming lover night kills), is that enough?

i think we have gotten some good info this phase that we can use to push in the next so this day has not been a waste, i just don't think it's worth pressing our luck when we know we have things to look at. if we didn't have the ephi lead and the im3/wee thing then just maybe we need to do something to get info but that's not where we are at.
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
I do think No vote is the best option to go for, especially since it's going to be really difficult to find Ephi today.

However, if I would vote for someone, I would go for Pink Ranger. This bullying people into going something else than No Vote is pretty suspicious:

1. Scum would want to thin the town as much as possible today. With Sparks/Sorian dead, two more today and probably two more next night (I assume these mechanics last until D4 starts) would give scum good leeway to gain a good majority.
2. We have probably caught Ephi as scum (with some leeway with the double spider-man) and Weemad getting some real heat, so scum are probably very worried that they are going to lose D4 and even possibly D5. They want to gain as much traction before then, and getting up to six townspeople killed is a good way to do that.
3. As someone already said here, scum has all the information, town is just shooting in the dark. At least I have almost zero idea who any of you people are.
 
Illuminati member 2

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
Barack Obama said:
Other than being terrible children's entertainment is there a real angle on this Barney vote?
Click to expand...
It's the pair that I feel has made the least, until know that I realized IM5 and Barack also have done few, but I would put that more on Barack getting replaced.

Barney and Kool-Aid arrived and made mostly costume posting. Barney was quick to participate in the poker game. Kool made a vote on Yami to start with. Then Kool made a lot of drink-posting. Then all Barney has done is be confused. Then barney asked for a summary of the last 3 pages (So didn't ask Kool for help).

So they have done shit, they are probably not doing anything in their chat either. They have not interest in reading each other or trying to solve each other.


They are coasting. Both of them.
 
Pazzo the Ghost Clown

Pazzo the Ghost Clown

Costume Account (He/Him)
Illuminati member 3 said:
How sure is Pazzo of this read? Illuminati member 3 is not sure of it, but he is not that much of a fate/whisperer. Does Pazzo see some obvious tells?



I should know who says this. I feel like I should.
Click to expand...

Pazzo thinks he sees a lot of Fate in Barney. Pazzo is maybe 80% sure. Pazzo would like Steve's opinion. Pazzo thinks Steve might have a good idea about this too.
 
Illuminati member 2

Illuminati member 2

Costume Account
And it's like nothing has happened this day. A LOT has happened. Everyone is dumbfounded but I see most players at least try to help when sparks was erratic or when Steve had the stone. Barney only cared during the poker game and Kool aid has not cared at all. The more you post the more likely people will know who you are. It's pretty safe bet that Barney is Fate, but do we have a clue who Kool is? Does it matter? I'm not 100% sure fate is town, but if we take the dagger action and general attitude, all together, I don't mind a flip there. I think chances are we hit scum in that pair.
 
Captain Skunkbeard

Captain Skunkbeard

Costume Account (She/Her)
Barack Obama said:
Asking for clarification is hardly jumpy. Having just read the thread this seems to be the first time they (Barney) have been brought up as a possible candidate. It felt abrupt.
Click to expand...
IM2 laid out a reasonable position t' vote fer 'em a few pages back. 'tisn't somethin' that sprang out o' the deep blue.
 
Blue Ranger

Blue Ranger

Costume Account
Illuminati member 3 said:
oh and if we have a evil simon, they might go max lols and pick no flip for tomorrow

xd
Click to expand...
Honestly if Simon is in town’s hands they should just claim a positive action was used even if they don’t want to reveal what. If that doesn’t happen I’m assuming scum have it and did bad things.

Pink Ranger said:
Yes.

I am Zeke and successfully completed my radio code mission from MGS:Redux and got added to the secret chat on day 2.
Click to expand...
Best reference, thank you Geno

Thresh said:
I also hope Kawl overrides someone. He has my blessing
Click to expand...
Tbh he should for the memes. I absolutely would if I was him. You’re dead anyways, what do you have to lose?
 
Barney

Barney

Costume Account
Illuminati member 2 said:
And it's like nothing has happened this day. A LOT has happened. Everyone is dumbfounded but I see most players at least try to help when sparks was erratic or when Steve had the stone. Barney only cared during the poker game and Kool aid has not cared at all. The more you post the more likely people will know who you are. It's pretty safe bet that Barney is Fate, but do we have a clue who Kool is? Does it matter? I'm not 100% sure fate is town, but if we take the dagger action and general attitude, all together, I don't mind a flip there. I think chances are we hit scum in that pair.
Click to expand...
chill out there sorian
 
Pazzo the Ghost Clown

Pazzo the Ghost Clown

Costume Account (He/Him)
Illuminati member 2 said:
And it's like nothing has happened this day. A LOT has happened. Everyone is dumbfounded but I see most players at least try to help when sparks was erratic or when Steve had the stone. Barney only cared during the poker game and Kool aid has not cared at all. The more you post the more likely people will know who you are. It's pretty safe bet that Barney is Fate, but do we have a clue who Kool is? Does it matter? I'm not 100% sure fate is town, but if we take the dagger action and general attitude, all together, I don't mind a flip there. I think chances are we hit scum in that pair.
Click to expand...

Pazzo likes this post. Pazzo is not this confident we hit scum though.
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
Illuminati member 2 said:
It's the pair that I feel has made the least, until know that I realized IM5 and Barack also have done few, but I would put that more on Barack getting replaced.
Click to expand...

The least amount of impact you mean? Oh yeah, I do recall the hyphenated discussion with Kool Aid. Was strange. Afterwards they've lacked any punch or impression on me.

Also, I was never replaced. Please don't put it the papers that I was replaced.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom