Scum Thread OverBlood 2 Mafia - Scum Chat

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Actually nevermind, seems you just pinging jman because the vote tool lists him as not having a vote.
Yeah.

Not sure how I feel about this. Will the c-word be enough to make ppl distance from VA? He might just be telling the truth, which increases the chance that Donnie is Doctor. Oh, there is no Doctor.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
We might even know the PRs now. VA, Donnie, LP, Swamped, 4 out of 11/12. Donnie is something movement related I'd bet.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Yeah.

Not sure how I feel about this. Will the c-word be enough to make ppl distance from VA? He might just be telling the truth, which increases the chance that Donnie is Doctor. Oh, there is no Doctor.
What c word? cop?
We might even know the PRs now. VA, Donnie, LP, Swamped, 4 out of 11/12. Donnie is something movement related I'd bet.
How many town PRs are there usually in a game this size? I can see Donnie possibly being the tracker or something movement related. He did have that "guiding hand" or w/e breadcrumb.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
If we ever get to a point lategame where we have to full claim, I gotta wait out the tracker. Me claiming PR or Vanilla partially depends on me seeing if they tracked me or not.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Yeah, cop. It is just his word though, he doesn't even know the result. I dunno, hard to tell how it will go.

Isn't the town PR ratio something like 33% of town? Not sure at all tbh, but if there is a fifth PR, there is no sixth.

I didn't even realize the scum shoots themselves angle lol, that is true. Dangerous. More powerful than I realized and it makes me bit more hopeful about the idea that this is it in relation to town roles. Though if that is the case, it is bit strange too from a meta POV: fake PR claims might stand out a bit.

Kill Donnie? I think I'd only shoot somewhere else if we are afraid of him being protected. Half-BP and Bodyguard-ish have already flipped, can there be more protection? He is mass town read by all but ATP. He is a PR. VA is a PR too, but he should be spent, if he is telling the truth about himself.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Town PRs all have been unorthodox so what does that tell about Donnie? He ain't a self-watcher, perhaps, since he did not say anything about any visitors. Tracker fits well, but what is the twist there? Dunno lol.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
O shit, I missed this post

I will mostly-ish:

I targeted someone D1. When I die, their alignment is revealed. So, while removing a town player sucks, eh, you gonna at least get a read. It does not specify whether this will be revealed immediately or next day though----sucks for whomever if they're town. Guessing scum will just murder immediately that night in order to keep a confirmed town out of the equation.

I was wondering where the cop stuff came from lmao
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Yeah, cop. It is just his word though, he doesn't even know the result. I dunno, hard to tell how it will go.

Isn't the town PR ratio something like 33% of town? Not sure at all tbh, but if there is a fifth PR, there is no sixth.

I didn't even realize the scum shoots themselves angle lol, that is true. Dangerous. More powerful than I realized and it makes me bit more hopeful about the idea that this is it in relation to town roles. Though if that is the case, it is bit strange too from a meta POV: fake PR claims might stand out a bit.

Kill Donnie? I think I'd only shoot somewhere else if we are afraid of him being protected. Half-BP and Bodyguard-ish have already flipped, can there be more protection? He is mass town read by all but ATP. He is a PR. VA is a PR too, but he should be spent, if he is telling the truth about himself.
Yea, Im cool with killing Donnie. Only risk I can think of is, he is protected or Sparks tracked me N1. If there is a doc, hopefully it's oddnight doc.

Im bout to feast on this VA stuff 2mrw though. Can get a lot of busywork off pushing him.
d7439ccb-4ea2-432c-8262-df8ce4526306_text.gif
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Food for thought. if we get to a final 7 with all 3 of us alive, we can win by bussing HP and getting a NK. Assuming there are no vote manipulators.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
We would also win in that scenario if we caused a misvote too......lol

but if it gets to a point where either us are on the chopping block and can't do a hammer. HP going is an option.
 

HPSauce

Wait, I was right? Fuck
I'd personally rather keep Donnie up because he town reads me but I think it is probably the right kill at this point.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Any ideas for who I should target?
Investigate: Fateshirou

This may be Donnie's character. He's posted Oliver Twist pics on several occasions like here in post 319:
3d0c7a8d2dccfc69c6efb1d55e928073.png


Which could be a problem if it functions like the role I planned to fakeclaim
:joffrey::joffrey::joffrey::joffrey::joffrey:
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Wait, you cool with me pushing VA? Would put you under a lot of fire for Day 3.
Please, go ahead. I think I'll push VA as well. I think it is not impossible to get him dead. I feel that I'll be under some fire no matter what. If I start backing up too much now, I effectively concede that I am the best flip out of me-VA-Jman. If I push VA, I can get a day and keep the dream alive that town reads it all as a townie solving in honest and self-cornering manner - something that scum might want to avoid.

Food for thought. if we get to a final 7 with all 3 of us alive, we can win by bussing HP and getting a NK. Assuming there are no vote manipulators.
I think I die a day or two before that, but good to keep in mind. Bomb plays are BIG fun.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Falling back to ATP-VA after all that feels iffy though, will take look at wagonomics and see how screwed I-we are.
 

HPSauce

Wait, I was right? Fuck
I think VA kinda has to be the vote tomorrow. I know that's 100% what I'd do if I was a town player anyway
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
So........assuming Sparks is tracker........and tracked me N1. The way he asked my plans for the night is still stuck in my head. I may need to be ready to claim depending on if Sparks claims day 3 or not.

I can also see Sparks tracking me 2 nights in a row :laughing:
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
We can play with this. RB claiming I blocked Kyan could be a decent play after getting VA outta here.

Seems we have a real fruit vendor in this game
:joffrey::joffrey::joffrey::joffrey::joffrey:
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Isn't the town PR ratio something like 33% of town? Not sure at all tbh, but if there is a fifth PR, there is no sixth.

Tracker - Sparks ???
VIP - Swamped
Even BG - LP
Fruit Vendor - ???
1 shot alignment checker - VA

That would be 5/11, which would be 45%. I think that may be all the PRs?
If that's all the PRs and Sparks is the tracker, I think we may be in good shape tbh. Assuming VA is telling the truth, but hasnt checked any of us.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Assuming Sparks is the tracker, Fruit vendor is the only one we really have to worry about imo. Oh yea and whoever VA chose.

I just hope VA cant change his target each day phase and didnt choose one of us.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
lmao Zipped is the fruit vendor. Look at this run of posts.

Donnie: *posts oliver twist beggar pick*

Zip's response to that
Not that there is a fruit vendor in this game, but he looks so hungry!

I quite liked Zipped little run of posts there, it reads like someone trying to figure the game out who's had a slow start.

:truffleshuffle: :truffleshuffle: :truffleshuffle: :truffleshuffle: :truffleshuffle:


Tracker -??? - Sparks?
VIP - Swamped
Even BG - LP
Fruit Vendor - Zipped
1 shot alignment checker - VA

Hopefully VA targeted Zipped last night.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Reading the day start was certainly a roller coaster.
The joy of seeing Donnie's role pm, thinking the kill went thru
The confusion of seeing rac congratulating Donnie on being killed.
Then the disappointment in scrolling up and seeing Donnie won lol
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Zipped can effectively confirm himself as the not-killer on N2. Scum FV is not an impossible angle to sell though, if it is reframed as something like town-seeming tracker bait and getting Donnie to leave without killing him. Both rather beneficial things for scum.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Just thinking, but we should probably try not to be the last votes on VA, just in case he is like a counterpoint to HP. Where he alignment checks the last person to vote him.

@HPSauce I dont think ATP meant any harm/venom in his comment. I think a few ppl read your "stupud" comment on the Me vs Nat thing wrong. You were calling the back and forth a stupid t v t situation that we have every game or a "stupid"/calculated scum v scum situation.

The dig at "you've done nothing" is just par for the course in a mafia game.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Funny thing about fate not liking this part of my post:
I would like a VA flip today, it would give us the most info from my pov
That was me sort of setting up for a town RB with "from my pov", if we decided to go that route :laughing:
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
The really sketchy thing about Vere or anyone trying to get out of me who I targeted is that it truly only helps scum. Let's say I tell everyone I targeted you (Jman)---if you aren't scum, then scum can now go, "We're safe to murder VA's ass." If you are scum though, suddenly the scum team won't be so interested in voting me out. I am genuinely very busy IRL right now, but I'm hoping the headache of having to dance around this risk will lead anyone on scum team to make some goofy switches onto me/away from me.
I think VA would have a good point here if we didnt come together as a team and discuss how to handle it. We weighed the pros and cons of pushing VA and came to the conclusion it's most logical to push VA and take what comes with the flip.

200w.gif

With VA's push on Rac, Im more confident VA chose Rac for the alignment check last night.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I think you are right that it's changed town and nothing more. I would say Zippped is in my top town spot, just a gut feeling.
I'm 99% sure he's fine. He made a post yesterday that gives me a lot of confidence in that. I'd like him to be a little louder but I appreciate how busy he is so him being basically solved in my opinion is good enough.
Think this post me be an issue HP. This is most likely gonna lead to Vere or someone else asking "What post" gives you so much confidence, especially to say "basically solved".
I also sorta said he was my top town in response to Vere, why would both of us say he is top town.
:joffrey: :joffrey: :joffrey: :joffrey: :joffrey:
 

HPSauce

Wait, I was right? Fuck
Think this post me be an issue HP. This is most likely gonna lead to Vere or someone else asking "What post" gives you so much confidence, especially to say "basically solved".
I also sorta said he was my top town in response to Vere, why would both of us say he is top town.
:joffrey: :joffrey: :joffrey: :joffrey: :joffrey:
It's fine don't worry about it
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I'm just gonna say I'll only point it out if Zipped is happy for me to do it
If I read that as town, I would grill you on why you would out a PR. That only helps scum.
Also puts a PR on the spot.

Sidenote: Like Kyan, I do wonder what the "unusual" aspect is in this game. Seems things are fairly run of the mill imo.
byP2HeF.gif
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
It seems as far as kills, our next few nights are sorta set?
N3(tonight)-Sparks
N4 - Zipped or whoever gets cleared by VA(Most likely Rac?)
N5- Whoever we didnt kill between Zipped/Confirmed
Day 6 - Win

Day 4 we go into the day hopefully 9-6/3. I think we can cause a mislynch and not worry about losing one of us. Kyan will come under a lot of fire this day with VA town flip. ATP or Vere would be decent targets for a misvote.

Day 5 is 7 alive. Us 3 and 4 town most likely consisting of Fate, Jman, Zipped, ATP or Vere. It's important for HP to be willing to be the one to take the fall here if we cant cause a misvote. We win with HP bomb going off and a nk going thru*

*Assuming no vote manipulation goes on. With that in mind I will check vere to see if he is a PR, just to be safe. Him mentioning an override is interesting, but I doubt he has one because Nat wouldve used it on me Day 2.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Might not be around eod, Need to go cross town and feed my nephews's dog(he and his mom are outta town). It shouldnt be a problem and I should be back in time, but just wanted to give a heads up.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Sparks might be the better theoretical alternative, but VA is inching bit by bit towards life. He might get there if given a day.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
You had that one good post about how we should not let VA go unless we were 100% sure that he was town. That's gonna come back I think.

But hey, that last voter fear. Absolutely the correct call there.
 

HPSauce

Wait, I was right? Fuck
Anyways we have lots of avenues to go down tomorrow between Sparks, Vere and ATP. We should *touch wood* be okay here.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I think we should kill Sparks. He is a PR and most likely the tracker(assuming Zipped is the vendor and our ninja is to counter a tracker).
I dont think a push on Sparks will get far. We risk w/e PR he does have, him being able to prove it.
On the off chance there is another town doc type(Odd night part for LP's even night), they will probably be on ATP.
I dont think any of ATP's reads have really put any of us in jeopardy.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
eb25e8fd97f21be3ac87188978459edb.png


With ATP cleared and a potential sparks flip. I probably come under fire for the the LP wagon. Kyan for being on a town VA for 3 days.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Feels like a notable difficulty increase.

ATP is likely not a PR. Otherwise a wonderful kill: he is confirmed and possibly will be more of a presence now that he cannot be suspected.
Sparks exposes me and Zeke on the D3 vote a bit. He is likely to be a nice enough PR. Could see a push going that way, but he'd respond with a claim, which could save him if it is good and fits in.
Jman isolates me on D1 and exposes HP on the D3 vote a bit. Vanilla. Feels townie to me, but clearly the sentiment is not universal and I think that VA defense might bite him back, at least with some crowds.
Zipped is just FV and might not have any mechanical significance other than annoying Sparks now that Donnie is gone. His existence might be possible to be spun as a scum role, but that'll require some work. Vote exposure, me, D2.

Protection will default to ATP.

If the kill was purely on me, all-in, ATP. It can fail if we are wrong about remaining powers. ATP being dead will ease my D4, but it will not guarantee my survival. If I die, Sparks becomes more of a threat and in a way this is perhaps the last safe night to take out Sparks.

Do you two feel like we have to play risky?
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Kill Sparks. I die. Kill ATP. 5-2. Lean on those who town read me, get... not Vere or Zipped, others are easier. Kill whomever you find problematic, mostly about who'll vote for who on the next day. 3-2 endgame and almost a win unless Zeke dies first.

I don't mind Sparks, he is either the best or the 2nd best kill I think.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I think the biggest thing going against you is wagonmics and that was always gonna be an issue whenever VA flipped. Your issues are still there whether ATP is alive or dead.

The issue with Sparks is if he is a tracker and tracked me and other targets that are alive. If he is allowed to claim and name his targets, that puts me under direct fire to claim a believable PR instead of just claiming vanilla. Depending on his targets, he could also solidify the vanilla claims of others.

I vote to kill Sparks. Looks like HP is the deciding vote. If we dont end up killing Sparks, none of us should pressure him to be voted out. That would just lead to him claiming, which possibly screws me over.

Investigate: FateShirou
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
There's always the chance that Sparks tracks me and can vouch for me not moving tonight. Remote, but it is there. Bit torn on this tbh, will mull it over and decide what I wanna do-

Depending on his targets, he could also solidify the vanilla claims of others.

That... is a threat.

We also don't know what Sparks actually is. Tracker or somesuch fits, but he could be something else as well.

Ninja: Funky Dude Sparks
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Could be. I think it'll depend on what Sparks flips as. Will there be room for one more town PR?
From our perspective, probably not. But from townies who dont know what scum have, probably. If one of us is on the chomping block, could be enough to stay the bloodthirsty a day phase. Besides could get a doc CC or whateever power that may be the odd night one(if there is one)
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Hmmmm, ok. Maybe a busdriver/switcher claim is up for grabs for someone too? Odd night switcher, that switched FDS with ATP? Risky claim tho.
 
Top Bottom