Pair Thread THE LOVE BOAT... OF SUBMARINE!

Submarine

Costume
EDITED BY GAMERUNNER TEAM

I'll try to let myself cool off before asking for a replacement, but 90% sure I will.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Submarine

Costume
I hate this so much. I've never been having to fight for my life in a mafia game like this. Especially against someone who is so clearly mafia.

Also he kept saying we were only scum reading him for the bussing BUT THAT'S BECAUSE THEY HAD DONE JACK SQUAT.

Also becuase i basically didn't play yesterday I had to reeval this day phase.
 

Submarine

Costume
Yeah, Skiff was Town, what do you know, the person all the scummiest people voted for right at EoD was Town.
Fuck this game man. I knew he wasn't scummy enough not enough to fully town read him, but I knew it and now people are going to be on my case for my correction and the mistake I made near day end.

EDITED BY GAMERUNNER TEAM
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Submarine

Costume
I don't want to sub out, I'm tired of subbing out, but it's so hard knowing what I'll have to do tomorrow. the only saving grace is I have tomorrow off, so i get to spend my fucking day playing mafia instead of doing anything else, but whatever.
 

Submarine

Costume
I should have stayed strong in my town reading of Skiff. I had doubts tho because of what pool we had left, but i should have stayed strong on it. Now I'm going to get scumread for it and I just can't. I can't play mafia anymore... it's just too much for me. I have been trying to find a balance where I put in work but also just live my life and do other stuff, but clearly it's not working.
 

Submarine

Costume
If Kayak is Town, then it comes down to Yacht/Gondola/Inflatable, with a side dish of Lifeboat the Godfather and/or Scum Messenger Beluga to consider. If they are Scum, then it's still one of those to consider as their partner. Gondola probably makes the most sense, their stock dropped a lot on D3, they are probably just Scum here regardless. In Town Kayak World, Gondola's partner would probably be either Inflatable or Godfather Lifeboat, which sucks.
 

Submarine

Costume
There's also the "we already lost" world which is where Duck and Lifeboat are just Scum together and there is no Cop, which would suck, but that's why it's called the "we already lost" world lol.
 

Coast Guard

Costume
Hey friends, I get it, mafia can be stressful and you can get heated and that can suck. Take a step back if you need to and try to clear your heads a bit and see if that helps. I'm truly sorry you're not having the best time right now.
 

Submarine

Costume
I suppose I probably should just sub out. I was the one who lost my temper, so it's probably best to just remove myself from the game before I do again.

It was a fun few days until that shitshow of an EoD though, definitely enjoyed playing with you a lot.

If you decide to sub out too, don't let me subbing out discourage you from doing what's best for you. As we both know, the replacement list is there for a reason, and they can always strongarm more people in if need be.
 

Coast Guard

Costume
why is another boat in here :o
Gamerunner boat.

I suppose I probably should just sub out. I was the one who lost my temper, so it's probably best to just remove myself from the game before I do again.

It was a fun few days until that shitshow of an EoD though, definitely enjoyed playing with you a lot.

If you decide to sub out too, don't let me subbing out discourage you from doing what's best for you. As we both know, the replacement list is there for a reason, and they can always strongarm more people in if need be.
I get what you're saying about wanting to avoid getting overheated again. But I think every day (in-game and out of game) is a new opportunity to be a different person. So while you can absolutely sub out, no judgement, I'd like you to consider the possibility of trying again. No pressure, just think it over.
 

Submarine

Costume
I've already asked bear to sub me out, I don't really want to get into it with anyone else in game, happens almost every time I play now. I'll scum read someone, and they will shoot me down, call out my reads and play as being bad, and aggressively scum read me in return for daring to have the audacity to think they were scum, and im sick of that attitude from not just one but multiple people in this community, makes playing in games miserable for me.
 

Submarine

Costume
Hopefully Sub Engineer #3 can support me with a very trying tomorrow. (if it's who I seriously hope it is, then maybe).
 

Submarine

Costume
I hope honestly I just get killed somehow during the night phase because there was actually a hunter after us, tho I know that doesn’t make sense game wise
 

Submarine

Costume
I think I will make a joke at day start:

Sub Engineer 2 subbed out (pun not intended). So please be patient with me today as I have to train Sub Engineer 3 and somehow do this mafia day :D

just to inform the game and also have a light joke, maybe it will keep the thread positive somehow
 

Submarine

Costume
I don’t have to work tomorrow, but I need to not fuck my sleep schedule, so I think I’ll try and go back to sleep.
 

Submarine

Costume
I also fully get that I probably won’t know who 3 is until night actions lock.
It’d be silly to bring in someone if there’s a chance the sub goes down tonight.

also I wanna make a joke about us having to secure our tables so the incident that happened post day end won’t happened again (as another fun reference to me being me) but not sure it’s appropriate.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
In order to maintain the core idea of the game, I haven't made any announcements about replacements done in the game (and I'm not confirming if there have been any so far) either in the main game thread or any of the secret chats.

That said, if there ends up being a replacement in this boat, the new Submariner is allowed freely to tell here (and in the main thread) that they are a replacement.
 

Submarine

Costume
In order to maintain the core idea of the game, I haven't made any announcements about replacements done in the game (and I'm not confirming if there have been any so far) either in the main game thread or any of the secret chats.

That said, if there ends up being a replacement in this boat, the new Submariner is allowed freely to tell here (and in the main thread) that they are a replacement.
Okay cool I saw that happen with the first possible replacement so I assumed it would be the case here
 

Submarine

Costume
what the fuck did I say in that last sentence. All I wanted to say is I won't mention training a new submariner until it's confirmed.
 

Submarine

Costume
Some pressure is off because LB isn't even focused on us, and I think most peeps will feel the same just cause it makes more sense to go after the unknowns than the confirmed powers.

They will for sure consider us, but later when they've exhausted all their leads.
 

Submarine

Costume
Good idea, as long as you remember that these boards will eventually be opened.
Yeah I'm completely aware. I'll def mention at end game that our thread is not pretty at one point so enter it with caution >>

Since We can't exactly unsay what we did already say.

I also get that scum is probably just as stressed as town is so peeps act out, it's why i'm trying to move on and keep goijng.

Kayak is makes it hard for me >>
 

Submarine

Costume
Hello new friend! I have not read a single thing about this game and I won't be able to be active in the thread for a little while but I wanted to come in and say you are no longer alone.

Can you do a brief TLDR and do you think it would be beneficial if I mentioned I am a sub sub when I get around?
 

Submarine

Costume
Hello new friend! I have not read a single thing about this game and I won't be able to be active in the thread for a little while but I wanted to come in and say you are no longer alone.

Can you do a brief TLDR and do you think it would be beneficial if I mentioned I am a sub sub when I get around?
Finally ;w; I just started crying again because Lifeboat made a post about considering us and Kayak of course automatically agreed, but when I've been pushing my main scum lead since yesterday (aka Kayak) it's tunneling and I'm scum for it (Kayak's own words)
 

Submarine

Costume
Can you do a brief TLDR and do you think it would be beneficial if I mentioned I am a sub sub when I get around?
Also yes please. Skiff having a sub in didn't help their case because town still voted them out anyways, but it can at least allow me to expalin that this early day phase has just been me by myself.
 

Submarine

Costume
Lifeboat is for sure town. They got greenchecked by the cop who only had one shot. Bear is not putting a Godfather when there's one cop shot.

Also we used our power already and people are still scum reading us.
 

Submarine

Costume
Fanto felt the best about Gondola and Inflatable and I have to agree. I'm trying to do a reread of Gondola but aside from the vote on Skiff yesterday, there's nothing sus about them honestly.
 

Submarine

Costume
That leaves the three biggest suspects, two of which Personally think can't be teamed.

Yacht, Beluga, and Kayak
 

Submarine

Costume
Beluga pushed Kayak hard and called out the fact that Kayak spent day one voting Houseboat in the same post they made a big whole argument on why Yacht is scum. They didn't explain much their vote on HB either and eventually with little push switched to Yacht. This was called out by Beluga as bussing as it was clear they never intended to vote HB in the first place or at least stay there.

For this reason I do not think they are teamed however.
 

Submarine

Costume
Beluga has claimed to be the messenger that sent us a message and my paranoia has me concerned they are scum. They also keep doubting us and wondering if Superstar is a scum power. They also voted for Skiff. All of it doesn't make them look good and I'm not willing to give them a pass.
 

Submarine

Costume
Finally Yacht I did an iso on and out of the peeps, i town read them the most but only put Beluga higher because of the proven power.

Yacht day 1 was consistently on HB and even doubted their fake doctor claim and kept the suspicion on them.

One thing of note about Beluga as well is that B also heavily debated whether Cruise ship (the actual doc) or HB was scum and both put in serious thought into it before voting and I town read both for that.

Honestly out of the three I still town read Yacht the most, but even then I'm not sure. They did a last minute swing to Skiff after being on Gondola all day and that was def sus.
 

Submarine

Costume
Also today Gondola claimed Motion detect.

3 shot.

Kayak no movement
Life boat movement (the cop check most likely)
Yacht no movement.
 

Submarine

Costume
The seas are salty enough without adding tears to it, feel free to take a little break and I can formerly jump in after a little bit.
 

Submarine

Costume
The seas are salty enough without adding tears to it, feel free to take a little break and I can formerly jump in after a little bit.
Can't really do that when i have to show how townie I am. we got a pass day one because 2 and I made like 99 posts and were active, but day 2 I basically wasn't there because I didn't expect the fuckers to turbo.

So I came into day 3 with no leads really because my vote was on town Galleon day 1 and I had to reassess. Also Kayak said it was scummy we reassessed but NOW says I'm tunneling because I only want to vote Kayak today. Fuck Kayak btw.

I spent hours yesterday putting in isos and posting thoughts and I came out of it with a scum read on Kayak and townish reading Skiff and what do they do??? VOTE OUT SKIFF.
 

Submarine

Costume
I guess i could def use some other thoughts on all this tho. Maybe another opinion from as 2 would say "someone I can trust" might help me reeval.
 

Submarine

Costume
Can't really do that when i have to show how townie I am. we got a pass day one because 2 and I made like 99 posts and were active, but day 2 I basically wasn't there because I didn't expect the fuckers to turbo.

So I came into day 3 with no leads really because my vote was on town Galleon day 1 and I had to reassess. Also Kayak said it was scummy we reassessed but NOW says I'm tunneling because I only want to vote Kayak today. Fuck Kayak btw.

I spent hours yesterday putting in isos and posting thoughts and I came out of it with a scum read on Kayak and townish reading Skiff and what do they do??? VOTE OUT SKIFF.
I think I can be pretty good a town telling once I get in so I will definitely help carry that load and hopefully fresh eyes will help.
 

Submarine

Costume
I'm committed to Kayak as they are my biggest scumread and have done shit all to convince people they are town, BUT also I'm paranoid that I'm wrong and considering how I have more or less figured out who one of them is... them tunneling on the person most sus of them is very on brand.
 

Submarine

Costume
Oh yeah Kayak also been the most vocal about Lifeboat still being scum despite the check when it doesn't make sense mechanically.
 

Submarine

Costume
Also Beluga was weird. They posted a pool of suspects, when HB claimed doc they narrowed it to just peeps on HB which were Inflatable and Kayak while completely ignoring Yacht who was also suspicious of HB.

They voted for Kayak because Inflatable was still suspicious of HB after the claim and scum wouldn't do that???

When trains developed between Galleon and Yacht they went for Galleon who they had previously said was a lot like inflatable??? The one they scum read less??? Also again no mention of Yacht.
 

Submarine

Costume
I think beluga and Yacht might be paired if I'm wrong about Kayak because of this recap... I can't mention that in thread tho because I have been less supicious of Yacht compared to the other two... or maybe I can if i'm willing to admit in thread that I have no clue what I'm fucking doing and I'll get scum read got not being as supicious of Kayak as i was previously.
 

Submarine

Costume
I'm still suspicious of Kayak BTW. The part of me that's not is the paranoia me that doesn't trust anything I decide on and this has been a consistent problem for me in mafia lol
 

Submarine

Costume
I wrote out my post explaining it and then just copied it into a note pad :ghostblush: I feel like if I post it Kayak is just going to be like "oh so you are still leaving yourself open to vote other people besides me then????" and I'll cry more or something stupid like that.

I'll save it for later tho just in case I do decide to post it.
 

Submarine

Costume
I'm going to give Gondola a pass, so maybe in that pool I can expand on my reasonings and theories for the pool of suspects. who knows.
 

Submarine

Costume
I think beluga and Yacht might be paired if I'm wrong about Kayak because of this recap... I can't mention that in thread tho because I have been less supicious of Yacht compared to the other two... or maybe I can if i'm willing to admit in thread that I have no clue what I'm fucking doing and I'll get scum read got not being as supicious of Kayak as i was previously.
Usually I think it should be OK to admit that upon further evaluation that you might have been wrong. Even if it causes suspicion everyone should be constantly evaluating and re-evaluating as the game goes along. I would just ask to hold your current stances publicly (go wild privately) until I get caught up.
 

Submarine

Costume
Okay nice entrance!

I made a big ole post explaining my shit at this point I don't give a fuck what peeps think i just want it out there. I'm going to eat and watch my video a bit, so please enjoy having some time to catch up and sorry we have posted too much in this thread XD XD XD
 

Submarine

Costume
Usually I think it should be OK to admit that upon further evaluation that you might have been wrong. Even if it causes suspicion everyone should be constantly evaluating and re-evaluating as the game goes along. I would just ask to hold your current stances publicly (go wild privately) until I get caught up.
Ahhhhhh fuck. I just made the post D: i'm sorry. I should have checked here. I'm so sorry ;w;
 

Submarine

Costume
It seems really dead.

I want to ask who you think is who but I also want to try to figure it out myself too.
LOL. Number 2 spent most of the game trying to figure out peeps are but I only participated in here because they were. Some have been way more obvious than others, but I don't play costume games to guess who anyone else is. I wanted to play to be able to role play and play a game with less meta than expected.

2 also came right out as you saw and revealed themselves and I followed suit in here XD
 

Submarine

Costume
Guess I should mention that 2 was running a gimmick to tell the submariners apart. They used italics and roleplayed that it was because they weren't close to the mike. It's up to you what you do on that end as I do not care if we make it distinct or not.
 

Submarine

Costume
LOL. Number 2 spent most of the game trying to figure out peeps are but I only participated in here because they were. Some have been way more obvious than others, but I don't play costume games to guess who anyone else is. I wanted to play to be able to role play and play a game with less meta than expected.

2 also came right out as you saw and revealed themselves and I followed suit in here XD
You gave yourself away pretty quickly in the thread...you swooned after a duck.

Before the green what was your feelings on Lifeboat. I am only on page 3 so still D1 but I am getting some light pings there.
 

Submarine

Costume
You gave yourself away pretty quickly in the thread...you swooned after a duck.
Oh hush you I was way more obvious in other ways XD One of my friends who doesn't play found me because of made a joke about Beluga being two Beluga in a trench coat for instants XD

I also wasn't the only one loving that duck xD
Before the green what was your feelings on Lifeboat. I am only on page 3 so still D1 but I am getting some light pings there.
Hmmm I remember both 2 and I were suspicious of them and we were up until Duck came into the thread yesterday town reading them.

2 automatically trusted Duck's read because they were town reading them, but I was more sus of them and Yacht so I did my iso on Yacht. Duck then came into the thread with the cop claim and a green check on Lifeboat, which is when I trusted them lol.

To be honest I was mostly just sus because of a gut feeling, their weird reads, and voting history.
 

Submarine

Costume
I feel like no one reads my posts in these games unless they are sheeping me or trying to scum read me :blobghost: Inflate just talked about Beluga and Yacht being a thing when i already pushed that argument lol.
 

Submarine

Costume
I responded to Inflate because Kayak is why 2 subbed out :I I'm not going to let them even suggest we are paired.
 

Submarine

Costume
Got through Day 2, at least no one is posting so I am not falling behind.

Still think Lifeboat feels bad. Setup wise I don't see much wrong with a GF, Goon, and maybe a Ninja for the motion detects even with the 1 shot cop.

Kayak I don't know. Seemed like D3 is when things came to a head between yourselves and them so interested in reading that tomorrow.

Inflatable is probably alright, Gondola too.

I know it's happened before so I really doubt all three are on Gally D1 so for me it's down to Beluga/Lifeboat and Kayak/Yacht. Maybe a world where it's Kayak or Yacht.
 
Top Bottom