Pair Thread THE LOVE BOAT... OF LIFEBOAT!

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Welcome to your very own SPECIAL LOVEBOAT!

The two souls controlling this costume account may communicate here privately.

Normal thread rules apply.

It is up to your discretion, if you want to reveal your identities to each other.

You can only use the costume account to post here.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
Day 1 down

I am not very confident this is mafia. What a weird end to the day. Why were neither person in contention voting. Why was Jet Ski so antsy. Inflatible was talking.

Guess we will see on the flip. i think either Galleon or Yacht were good votes even if we don't get mafia.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
Yacht voting off wagon definitely isn't a good look, but they did say they weren't really around for EoD and they voted before the Galleon wagon took off.

I'll try to reread the Doctor claim situation to see if anything can be learned from the reactions.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
The doctor claim is what you do if you are are the real doctor and also mafia claiming doctor.

If they are real they should die tonight. Mafia can try to big brain it and leave them alive but unless there is a counter claim or another protection role i don't see them getting traction. Not killing them leaves them another chance at getting a save.

I think mafia would target submarine with their kill. If i was a doctor that is who I would protect. If I had a cop check then someone like Cruise Ship is probably a good one. Kind of middle of the road. Townie but not leading.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
I don't agree with the too many docs thing Why can't it be

5 vanilla
2 odd/even doc
1 investigator
1 us
1 other random kind of mid PR

3 mafia. 1 goon, 1 strongman, 1 godfather
 

Lifeboat

Costume
Green check takes the fire out my belly. i need the interactions.

Hopefully Duck has a red check they are holding to see how the day plays out and then they give it with an hour or so to go.

There must be a reason they only have given 1 check... unless they did pick cruise ship on night 1 which is what I would have done. Kind of unfortunate if that is the case.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
Sorry for being mostly absent last day phase. Weekends are tough for me.

I assume Duck will bite the dust tonight. Will be interesting what they flip as given the secrecy they kept around their role.
If they are a full fledged cop I think Beluga and Sub are clear. We already flipped a Goon, so another role that isn't directly useful to Mafia seems unrealistic. If it's actually a tracker or rolecop or something like that I could still see a Scum Messenger existing as a kind of Godfather Light.
Sub came across as very Towny in their push for Kayak, but I may also be very easily emotionally manipulated.
It's interesting that all my biggest Town reads (Duck, Inflatable, Submarine) are on Kayak, while the rest is on Skiff at EoD.
Yacht comes away not looking good at all. They again try to go off wagon with Gondola and only switch to Skiff to break the tie with Kayak.
Not quite sure what to think of Kayak. I feel like with how Skiff played the day, if Kayak were Town, Scum would be more interested to get rid of them than Skiff. Also their vote for us after the green check directly followed by another vote is very strange though probably comes from different people.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
I wasn't posting at the end of day either. i moved our vote and went for a nap. Oops woke up after the end of the day.

I only skimmed it but it seemed skiff had a little meltdown. Seems very unfortunate.

No idea what of the other powers. I guess they are fine. i only expect around half of town to be vanilla. And those roles, and our role are not clears.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
You have received a message!

Hello, this is the Belugas with some mail. We're thinking that you're safe with Duck in comparison and want to go over some our reads. I'll also be counting down how many misvotes we have until we hit a deadend.

Assuming there are 2 scum.

At day end: 8P-6T-2S
D4: 7P-5T-2S

If we misvote
D5: 5P-3T-2S

If we get scum
D5: 5P-4T-1S

We get 1 more day for mylo if we get scum tomorrow. I believe our best bet is to vote out Kayak tomorrow, and if they're town, Submarine the next day. Between the two there has to be scum.

This is where I was with my reads earlier today:
Rubber Ducky (Claimed Cop)
Lifeboat (Greenchecked by Duck/Ghost)
Inflatable Boat
Gondola
Yacht

Submarine (Superstar)
Skiff (Dead)
Kayak

I know this is hypocritical to say, but my read of Gondola has gone down after yesterday. I think, with the number of PRs we should go for a mass claim tomorrow, and can shorten the PoE.

I messed up on the Skiff read. My partner mentioned scum wouldn't self-vote in that situation but in my mind they were trying reverse psychology to make us believe scum wouldn't do that so that was exactly what they did.

Alright, that's all from us. Beluga out.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
weird we just get this message now.

rubber ducky was talking about a role blocker on day 2 and they only had one check so maybe they were roleblocked on night 1 but then they should have been roleblocked again unless mafia went all in and roleblocked and killed the doctor.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
With only one cop check I could see Mafia not having a Godfather and instead maybe a messenger or superstar as a confirmable power role.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
With only one cop check I could see Mafia not having a Godfather and instead maybe a messenger or superstar as a confirmable power role.

Yeah that is my thought too.

Like what is Beluga achieving with the role here. What is the point of sending us their town reads. We can see them in the game thread. i guess the role can be used if they wanted to send something they noticed and didn't want to highlight. But just a list of reads seems like a waste.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
I've put submarine and beluga in the frame today. Otherwise it was going to be lazy votes and reasoning we have already seen

So trying to mix things up a little.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
I think we have a the motion detector because the cop is 1 shot. Motion detector is super weak too. It doesn't really tell you anything.
 

Lifeboat

Costume
Enjoy yourself.

You were right too. i would have let gondola slip I think.

It is up to submarine. I won't be mad if they get it wrong but just a little disappointed.

My heart almost stopped when Gondola hammered.
Glad you were right.

They too their time to hammer. And Submarine didn't hammer. It was mechanically assured after the two of them posted that yacht was mafia.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
bear-hi.gif
 

Lifeboat

Costume
I suspected it was you after D1, lol. Sorry for not being more active, it seems I can only really solve based on mechanics (and even then it's based on wrong assumptions).
 
Top Bottom