Scum Thread OH NO! IT IS THE DEN OF THE LOVELESS!

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Welcome to SUPERIOR BOAT MEETUP OF THE LOVELESS.

The souls controlling the three costume accounts behind The Loveless are discussing here…

It is up to your discretion if you want to reveal your identities to each other.

You can only use the costume account to post here.
 
Last edited:

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Here is a sample role PM and a generic Town Lovers Chat OP:

Sample Role PM:

Welcome to the Love Boat Spin-Off Mafia!

You and another anonymous player have invaded the body of a costume account Placeholder. You both will post in the game using this same account.

You are aligned with THE BOATS which means Town.

Your shared role is Vanilla Town. You have no special powers, but may vote.

If your shared costume account dies during the game, both of you leave the game in the process.

You do not know who the other player controlling the account is. But you both share the same alignment and role.

You may talk with the other player in the special Partner Chat during the game. You both must use the singular costume account to post in that chat.

You win the game, when all threats to THE BOATS have been defeated.

Costume account username:
Costume account password:


Generic Town Lovers Chat OP:

The thread titles for these chats follow the template of THE LOVE BOAT OF... OF X! (So for example: THE LOVE BOAT... OF ROWING BOAT!)

Welcome to your very own SPECIAL LOVEBOAT!

The two souls controlling this costume account may communicate here privately.

Normal thread rules apply.

It is up to your discretion, if you want to reveal your identities to each other.

You can only use the costume account to post here.
 
Last edited:

Gondola

Costume
donniecrash.gif
 

Gondola

Costume
Yeah, this should be some good memes lol not a stacked set of powers so i guess town won't be crazy powerful either. Seems possible they could have some powers dependant on knowing/guessing the account holders as well
 

Gondola

Costume
Gondola 2 is Kyan?
ye

For the record, should anyone ask, I did not disclose this in our totally existent town boat chat. Don't think I've ever outed my costume as town. Of course, nothing prevents you from... "deducing" my identity through the ten or so posts that I'll make on D1. Alternatively, we can just "lie" about not being sure, in the case that we ever want to claim a town role with an identity condition (what exactly, no idea).
 

Gondola

Costume
Alright no worries. If anyone ever asks, you can just say I told you my identity off the bat, I would definitely just have YOLO'ed and told you lol especially since the PM says alignment is locked together. I'll just say my partner hasn't told me and I have no idea lol when I specced geno's last game I genuinely had no clue who anyone was in the costume phase :cor: will just see how long it takes me to figure out I'm with the mighty Kyaa :donnieyes: fake claim we could keep the guessing part since it sounds real enough and not overly scummy, just need to change what we're actually checking/getting back
 

Gondola

Costume
Just a warning to you all, lest there be mistakes: if both halves of a boat are in, both get the draft that one is writing. That might be fun, come EOD.
 

Gondola

Costume
Tracker (or something similar) should be a given, as all scum actions involve movement. Don't personally see the point of a cop here, but who knows what the balance math said.
 

Gondola

Costume
hum hum okay. Just thinking what we could fake claim lol town don't know there's no godfather, we could just straight up claim cop (who has to guess the account holder for result) lol
 

Yacht

Costume
Trying to guess the identities will be a fun scum minigame, I like those.
Agreed that a tracker is likely.
I'm wondering if town at some point will want to distinguish between the two halves of a pair and if we should embrace or reject that. Having it muddled together seems convenient for us since you can be as inconsistent as you like although it might make identity guessing harder.

Here is my super secret identity:
It is me, The Wizard
Other yacht I don't think I would reveal straight up in our chat but would instead give a hint like I've never played a Love boat game before and say you're free to guess as the game goes on.
 

Gondola

Costume
Yeah the vote tool is in use as normal so same way of voting, highlight + the account name you want to vote
 

Gondola

Costume
Pardon me, I was wondering - in abstract - how people will behave when they realize that their votes are shared with their mates. Mostly in relation to EOD and the rapid vote switches that are the tradition. What if one wants something that the other does not? There are all these interesting dilemmas here and we are stuck here faking them LOL.

#makeshitupasyougo
 

Gondola

Costume
oh that's easy we just vote for whoever is sus, this is just a loveboat friendly neighbour chat after all :eyes:
 

Gondola

Costume
town is probably going to be disorganised within their pairs and stepping on top of each others toes so I don't think it's too bad if we play this loose when we can
 

Yacht

Costume
The general flow I would follow as town would probably be something like you can vote freely in the early-mid part of the day phase and then toward EoD try to come to consensus/discuss the leading options and ask for permission before overriding a vote if your partner believes strongly in it.

It's probably very dependent on the personalities involved, some will play it loose and some might end up more cautious. Might not be a bad idea for us to disagree with ourselves at some point or be annoyed that our vote was switched.
 

Gondola

Costume
Even as town i really do not like to throw my vote around lol and i absolutely hate voting at day end, its too stressful so i usually just wait til two thirds through the day phase and vote as confidentially as i can on who i feel least good about so at least within our pair kyan I'll likely stick to that and deviate where and when the team needs me to. Vote as often or as authentically to yourself as you like and we can just play off each other naturally.

The good thing is we can kind of dither off a vote we dont like by saying the one of us did and the other didn't, it'll be harder for town to track vote movement or any particular backtracking when everyone can say well, I didnt really want to go there but my partner did
 

Yacht

Costume
The notification confuses me so much lol, I thought there were no new messages but there were and Wiz had just checked lol. Need to be more careful.
 

Yacht

Costume
@The Bear Can we know when the town chats were opened? Would it be night zero like this chat or at day 1 start in a few hours?

Also this might be a @RetroMG question but can we turn off the reaction scores or otherwise hide them? If you hover over our account you can see how many reactions we got, but since you can't react to your own posts and you can't react in the main thread they give away that we are in a chat. Would be angle shooting to point this out directly but it could spoil the game if someone tries to check post count and it pops up.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
@The Bear Can we know when the town chats were opened? Would it be night zero like this chat or at day 1 start in a few hours?

Also this might be a @RetroMG question but can we turn off the reaction scores or otherwise hide them? If you hover over our account you can see how many reactions we got, but since you can't react to your own posts and you can't react in the main thread they give away that we are in a chat. Would be angle shooting to point this out directly but it could spoil the game if someone tries to check post count and it pops up.

Town pair chats were opened the same time as this scum chat aka. players were able to access them from the moment they received their role PMs.
 

Gondola

Costume
Also this might be a @RetroMG question but can we turn off the reaction scores or otherwise hide them? If you hover over our account you can see how many reactions we got, but since you can't react to your own posts and you can't react in the main thread they give away that we are in a chat. Would be angle shooting to point this out directly but it could spoil the game if someone tries to check post count and it pops up.

Good shout, I've removed the ones i used
 

RetroMG

Bergentrukung
Staff member
I'm checking. No one is supposed to be able to react to posts in the game threads at all, so it shouldn't matter, but that is clearly not the case.
 

RetroMG

Bergentrukung
Staff member
I found where you were allowed to react to posts. You should not be able to any more. @Houseboat please remove your reaction from Gondola's post (#6)
 

Houseboat

Costume
Yes the no notification is very confusing, I keep checking and going oh nobody has posted but it turns out I just already "seen" it

I will get better at that
 

Houseboat

Costume
I'm fine with my other half taking point on the posting, I will try to post in here before making reads in the main thread so we can be internally consistent. No worries or pressure here on "screwing things up", this is a very unique game and will be very different than normal. I will of course still try my best to win.

I would have absolutely told my partner my real identity immediately, as seen in this thread. I don't know if that will be relevant or how claim heavy people will be about their real identities. I will likely be more reserved in the main thread.

Letting town step all over each other sounds like a good plan.
 

Yacht

Costume
I (Geno) will mostly chill D1 because I might give myself away and I'm an easy target for a lynch.
 

Gondola

Costume
Lol yeah, its helping me too because all of these boat accounts are merging into one lmao theres no see who posted function on here is there?
 

Houseboat

Costume
Nah we good no worries, seems like a good amount. We don't want to draw too much attention but do want to be present.
 

Houseboat

Costume
I really want to quote Giant Rubber Duck's post and say "it's true, everyone knows scum aren't nerds and are a bunch of sick freak jocks" but I think that'd give me away
 

Houseboat

Costume
I think Chuggs, Sneeks, or nin are the most likely to have made the Launch joke, but Inflatable Boat is actually the account that brought it up, not Rubber Duck. Also it seems more likely Sneeks is Skiff with that Chaos sig meme.
 

Gondola

Costume
I think Chuggs, Sneeks, or nin are the most likely to have made the Launch joke, but Inflatable Boat is actually the account that brought it up, not Rubber Duck. Also it seems more likely Sneeks is Skiff with that Chaos sig meme.

Oooooh i missed inflatable mentioning it, cheers. Yeah i agree with skiff lol i should probably start a list of possible identities
 

Houseboat

Costume
Chuggs has admitted to being a filthy light theme user in the past as well, which Rubber Duck also talked about

:thonk:
 

Yacht

Costume
Jet Ski feels Chuggs-like to me between the use of the word motherfucking and this post
So while I don't think being a nerd says anything about your alignment because I'm like 95% there's scum in this game and I don't believe that you're all town, I do think Sub has had a pretty strong start. We'll see on if they keep that up.

Cruis'n USA worrying about the sanctity of the game at this point is a bit of a weird look. Not really a look I expect scum to want early game though so I feel okay about them for now.
 

Houseboat

Costume
An early thought of mine is we should vote out/kill at night one of the people townreading Submarine like Giant Rubber Duck or Jet Ski.
 

Gondola

Costume
Alright I'm going to drop a few thoughts that approximate what I would share where I'm at right now with Kyan with we had an actual pair chat. Tags in case the rest of you would rather not be influenced by that and just want to do your thing

- Feel good about anyone with double digital posts right now, the activity is enough for me so unless they present something particularly objectionable I would probably give them a pass today for being vocal and involved early.

- tagging the bottom posters to try and draw them into the game since it's a nice spot for maybe one scummy to sit, also just nice to get people involved in the game

- didn't love cruise ships post about exploiting the game, could see that as scum seeing if anyone else would push the issue
- keeping an eye on house boat for pushing against town reads, hoping they have a good response
- skiff had a decent point about authenticity but pinged me a bit that they put Sub no.1 down as NAI regardless, despite feeling in line with their usual posting - kind of bypasses the authenticity point

- if anyone asks me my partner hasn't posted in the thread yet and hasn't really said much at all in our chat, guessing they are in a different timezone, busy etc, hoping they show up by midpoint of the day
 

Gondola

Costume
I could see Ty being on skiff with the discussion about authenticity vs consistency? He has quite a cerebral playstyle and likes to get reads by having people relate how they felt and the thoughrs running through their head when they were posting a thing and stuff like that.

Anyone have any thoughts on sub's identity? I could see Thorny getting in the spirit of the roleplaying

Sorian and loki are both people i remember that like to call folks nerds lol theres an account or two that have been using that. Just gonna keep posting these identity observations while i remember them lol
 

Gondola

Costume
Alright I'm going to drop a few thoughts that approximate what I would share where I'm at right now with Kyan with we had an actual pair chat. Tags in case the rest of you would rather not be influenced by that and just want to do your thing

- Feel good about anyone with double digital posts right now, the activity is enough for me so unless they present something particularly objectionable I would probably give them a pass today for being vocal and involved early.

- tagging the bottom posters to try and draw them into the game since it's a nice spot for maybe one scummy to sit, also just nice to get people involved in the game

- didn't love cruise ships post about exploiting the game, could see that as scum seeing if anyone else would push the issue
- keeping an eye on house boat for pushing against town reads, hoping they have a good response
- skiff had a decent point about authenticity but pinged me a bit that they put Sub no.1 down as NAI regardless, despite feeling in line with their usual posting - kind of bypasses the authenticity point

- if anyone asks me my partner hasn't posted in the thread yet and hasn't really said much at all in our chat, guessing they are in a different timezone, busy etc, hoping they show up by midpoint of the day

In response:

- 50/50 agree/disagree with activity. In essence it ends up being true, I think, but ideal would be only to give a pass to those who do something D1-meaningful.

- Taggin' good, words of encouragement here.

- I don't see what's wrong with Cruise, if anything, it felt somewhat out of place and gave me hints of a person being alone. Moreover, that Cruise <-> Galleon interaction then does not feel SvS at all on a glance.

- Dunno Houseboat who.

- End with words about how busy is my MO these days and how I try to be around when I can. I will also give you the power to vote as you wish around EODs, since I won't be around most of the time.
 

Houseboat

Costume
I think one half of the submarine is loki, I don't know who else would bring up tumblr.

I think the italicized half of the submarine is posting more strongly as of post #189, I want to say I like them but then we're voting for them lmao. Maybe that looks more townie that we disagree right off the hop?
 

Gondola

Costume
lmao i was wondering if you would be able to call out loki. Let me know if I'm pushing too much with this thing that's come up around the sub town readers lol trying to walk the middle ground on it. I'm guessing EC posted those observations not rando?
 

Gondola

Costume
I think the italicized half of the submarine is posting more strongly as of post #189, I want to say I like them but then we're voting for them lmao. Maybe that looks more townie that we disagree right off the hop?

Up to you lol it's going to happen for real throughout this game I bet
 

Houseboat

Costume
lmao i was wondering if you would be able to call out loki. Let me know if I'm pushing too much with this thing that's come up around the sub town readers lol trying to walk the middle ground on it. I'm guessing EC posted those observations not rando?
Yeah I've barely posted, just the twitter blue joke and the gacha meme.
 

Gondola

Costume
lmao yeah I figured, you could always allude that what he posted is very inline for your partner , something like that, which it actually is lol if i knew that was EC I would not read it either way
 

Houseboat

Costume
lmao yeah I figured, you could always allude that what he posted is very inline for your partner , something like that, which it actually is lol if i knew that was EC I would not read it either way
If I'm pressed on what I posted I will say that, and also say my partner is not around to discuss at this minute so I didn't want to remove their vote for them.
 

Houseboat

Costume
Post #227 by Jetski really gives me Chuggs vibes, just the word choice and flow of the sentences. Maybe I am reading too much into things.
 

Gondola

Costume
If I'm pressed on what I posted I will say that, and also say my partner is not around to discuss at this minute so I didn't want to remove their vote for them.

Yeah this works

And i do thnk jetski might have chuggs. We can probably make up a good table of guesses later
 

Houseboat

Costume
Nah we're good, Rubber Duck is the only one really gung-ho but they've been very aggressive so folks are not completely inclined at following them.
 

Houseboat

Costume
My read of Rubber Duck would be NAI were I to be town so I'm going to not talk about them until I feel differently. I have had a bad habit of overposting so I'm trying to be more concise.
 

Houseboat

Costume
By the by, I've historically been pretty awful at votes, so I'll defer to you on whatever you decide by EOD Rando, unless I feel pretty strongly about something.
 

Houseboat

Costume
By the by, I've historically been pretty awful at votes, so I'll defer to you on whatever you decide by EOD Rando, unless I feel pretty strongly about something.
Okay no worries. I'm trying to find someone I can dig in on still.

I think Inflatable Boat might be Vere. Their style of asking questions to get folks to elaborate further is coming through.
 

Houseboat

Costume
Oh boy Rubber Duck just stepped in it with saying people play differently, that's not how they felt about nerds earlier.
 

Houseboat

Costume
I'm not going to vote for Rubber Duck because that looks too OMGUS but I will engage with them a bit if they respond
 

Houseboat

Costume
Rubber Duck is also differentiating their posting styles between users, the aggressive one starts their sentences with lower case. The other starts their sentences with uppercase. I think the uppercase one might be Hawthorn, #266 is my biggest indication.
 
Top Bottom