Game Thread Love Boat: The Spin-off |OT| We Bare Boats

The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Houseboat (4 votes)
Galleon - #160
Giant Rubber Duck - #261 #491
Kayak - #364 #391
Yacht - #392
Inflatable Boat - #397
Gondola - #440

Yacht (3 votes)
Jet Ski - #380
Kayak - #391
Skiff - #490

Kayak (2 votes)
Lifeboat - #109
Houseboat - #456

Galleon (2 votes)
Submarine - #225
Cruise Ship - #457

Submarine (1 votes)
Beluga Whale - #113
Houseboat - #134 #382

Beluga Whale (0 votes)
Jet Ski - #105 #380
Submarine - #108 #225

Lifeboat (0 votes)
Skiff - #441 #490

Not voting: Giant Rubber Duck

Post Counts:
Submarine: 76 Jet Ski: 53 Giant Rubber Duck: 48 Houseboat: 48 Beluga Whale: 47 Lifeboat: 39 Gondola: 33 Galleon: 32 Inflatable Boat: 29 Yacht: 29 Cruise Ship: 25 Kayak: 24 Skiff: 18

Current Countdown:
xc5y3gu09k



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Jet Ski

Jet Ski

Costume
Yacht said:
Nah, how come when we're about to vote scum out it's always a doctor or a cop? Am I the only one that thinks it's a fake claim?
Click to expand...

Regardless of alignment it’s scum problems now. If they’re town it makes scums decision harder tonight. If they’re scum, we’ll probably see another protection role flip and that makes it real easy. Voting them out now would be silly
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Submarine said:
They claimed too early if it is fake imo, plenty of time to have wriggled out of this one naturally still without throwing the hail mary.

But regardless, it's very silly to vote for a claimed Doctor on D1 even if one thinks they're lying.
Click to expand...

This is wrong TBH.

if you fake claim doctor you are doing because you want the counterclaim so you post with a couple of hours to go so that everyone has time to see and react to the claim. The counterclaim is what a fake claiming mafia wants and it is why we should not give it to them.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
If I were to believe HB's claim then my vote is going to be between Kayak and Inflatable. They both were scum reading HB but Inflatable's insistence is more odd if knowing HB will flip town. Seeing as Kayak is in contention I'll go there for now.

Vote: Kayak
 
Giant Rubber Duck

Giant Rubber Duck

Costume
Vote: Yacht

Don’t have terribly strong reads RN. They looked sus when I gave them a quick ISO earlier, didn’t seem to care that much about their reads.
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
I am not 100% that Houseboat is town but I think it is way more likely that they the doctor than any fake claiming nonsense. Voting them today is ridiculous.

I read through Kayak's posts and there are no town vibes at all. it is all very stilted and strained. Someone who seems flustered and argumentative about everything. it is day 1. Townies should be chill
 
Gondola

Gondola

Costume
Houseboat said:
Alright, -2 with 2 hours to go is not where I wanted to be on Day 1. I will simply put my cards on the table.

I am the doctor.

I was trying to be more lowkey at the start because of this role. When my partner started getting heat I told them to play it cool. Perhaps that is why they were nervous and fumbled their explanation. Shit happens, no worries partner. You do not need to apologize or explain to me.

Do with that information as you will. I would like to live but I am still not going to vote my town reads. If you want to kill your doctor go ahead.
Click to expand...

Why did I have to come back to this

Unvote
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
I think Galleon and Yacht look the most sus out of the Houseboat voters to me. Yacht's vote post has a kind of bandwagony feel to it, could see myself switching there if that's the more likely wagon.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
One of the Kayak voices sounds better than the other to me, and I think I know who the second one is, so that kind of makes sense.

I'd vote Yacht over Kayak I think.
 
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
If I were to believe HB's claim then my vote is going to be between Kayak and Inflatable. They both were scum reading HB but Inflatable's insistence is more odd if knowing HB will flip town. Seeing as Kayak is in contention I'll go there for now.

Vote: Kayak
Click to expand...
1. Why are you voting for me?
2. It seems my vote was on Yacht, not HB. So why are you voting for me(who didnt have a vote on HB) isntead of Inflatable, who did have a vote on HB before the claim?
3. "inflatables insistence is more odd if they knew HB would flip town" makes no sense. Anytime scum would vote for town, they would know they are flipping a townie.
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
Don't want to weigh in too much on the protective claim but I think I agree that waiting is the lower risk play as house should be caught scum or dead town walking.
Skiffs attempt to tie me us in to Lifeboat looks opportunistic.
Not really seeing the Kayak case just yet, seemed like the disagreement with Gondola was more a playstyle difference (find town vs hunt scum) more than anything telling.
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Submarine said:
One of the Kayak voices sounds better than the other to me, and I think I know who the second one is, so that kind of makes sense.

I'd vote Yacht over Kayak I think.
Click to expand...

I can see Yacht. Sheeping and some fluff in their posts. I will follow onto Yacht if that is the call.

If Yacht is mafia i would let Kayak go for a bit. What Yacht has said about Kayak and the vote from Kayak onto Yacht does not seem like they are the same alignment.
 
Giant Rubber Duck

Giant Rubber Duck

Costume
Yacht said:
Don't want to weigh in too much on the protective claim but I think I agree that waiting is the lower risk play as house should be caught scum or dead town walking.
Skiffs attempt to tie me us in to Lifeboat looks opportunistic.
Not really seeing the Kayak case just yet, seemed like the disagreement with Gondola was more a playstyle difference (find town vs hunt scum) more than anything telling.
Click to expand...
How much do you read Kayak as town?
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Yacht (4 votes)
Jet Ski - #380
Kayak - #391
Skiff - #490
Giant Rubber Duck - #506

Kayak (3 votes)
Lifeboat - #109
Houseboat - #456
Beluga Whale - #504

Houseboat (3 votes)
Galleon - #160
Giant Rubber Duck - #261 #491
Kayak - #364 #391
Yacht - #392
Inflatable Boat - #397
Gondola - #440 #508

Galleon (2 votes)
Submarine - #225
Cruise Ship - #457

Beluga Whale (0 votes)
Jet Ski - #105 #380
Submarine - #108 #225

Lifeboat (0 votes)
Skiff - #441 #490

Submarine (0 votes)
Beluga Whale - #113 #504
Houseboat - #134 #382

Not voting: Gondola

Post Counts:
Submarine: 80 Jet Ski: 56 Giant Rubber Duck: 52 Houseboat: 49 Beluga Whale: 48 Lifeboat: 42 Gondola: 34 Galleon: 32 Yacht: 30 Inflatable Boat: 29 Kayak: 26 Cruise Ship: 25 Skiff: 18

Current Countdown:
xc5y3gu09k



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Gondola

Gondola

Costume
Trying to hail my partner. Kayak is the only other account that caught my eye in a strong way today since they didn't seem to want to actually discuss their observations, but I don't think I want to follow houseboat despite the claim. If Kayak is who I think they are, the forwardness is relatively within their wheelhouse anyway and probably isn't indicative of alignment either way.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Kayak said:
1. Why are you voting for me?
2. It seems my vote was on Yacht, not HB. So why are you voting for me(who didnt have a vote on HB) isntead of Inflatable, who did have a vote on HB before the claim?
3. "inflatables insistence is more odd if they knew HB would flip town" makes no sense. Anytime scum would vote for town, they would know they are flipping a townie.
Click to expand...
1. Read post #443 for my thoughts on you. If HB is town that makes me look for people who either wanted an easy vote or interacted weirdly.
2. Your initial vote was on HB but you changed to Yacht later on (tbf you mentioned wanting to vote Yacht and would like to in the same post you voted HB). The initial reasoning for your HB vote, to push it to contentious territory against Sub, made little sense and seemed to be testing the waters.
3. What I mean by that is being hardline from start to finish against someone you know is going to flip town is an odd scum strategy.
Kayak said:
@Beluga Whale There's still over an hour before eod, there is nothing stopping you from making a case on inflatable if you truly feel they are scummy.
Click to expand...
There's nothing stopping me, true, but why do you think I feel Inflatable is more apt than you to vote? I feel that there's something there but qualified it with you being the more odd one out of the two for how you backed down quickly on HB in comparison.
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
Giant Rubber Duck said:
How much do you read Kayak as town?
Click to expand...
I wouldn't say I have a town read on them, I shared some concerns around their vote on Houseboat not lining up well with their thoughts at the time but some of the newer stuff they are being scum read for just seems to be a playstyle thing and isn't convincing me. I definitely felt better about the push on HB earlier in the day and having delayed resolution on that slot is going to be annoying.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Okay I caught up and saw HB claim doc. I was really starting to like their posts so I like 2 am more willing to believe their claim.

also makes Galleon stand out more since their vote mentioned protection…


Cruise Ship said:
I still don't feel good about Galleon:

As has been previously mentioned this vote was really weird:



Early vote so it could easily be explained with claiming it being a joke but:



They double down on that read. It seems so sus.

This post read that someone else wrote it and, to me, it reads like they are doing some damage control:



But then they go back to calling Houseboat slimy and tried to make connections to another players:



And super scummy:



Something similar has been brought up for Houseboat here:



I agree that Houseboat vote looks bad but Galleon's early vote and how they are now trying to justify it also seems like someone who is worried about moving their vote and also trying to create a reason for not moving it.

Right now I think that I Galleon and Houseboat feel like a good place to vote. Planning to put a vote down on one of them later, after I talk it with myself a little bit more.
Click to expand...
Thank you for making this post as it was honestly what I was planning to do yesterday but I was too tired.

Galleon has been suspicious to me all game and I was trying to figure out why I had this gut feeling so I was planning to reread them. The posts you quoted helped me quite a bit.

the reason I feel so suspicious of them is not only their focus on HB this day phase, but how they seem to be trying to link and put suspicion on most of the players. Naturally we should be sus of everyone until we have reasons to think otherwise, but it just feels forced and like they are trying to keep suspicions up so a town core isn’t really formed.

I still want to do my own iso but I’m on mobile …

Giant Rubber Duck said:
ISOing on mobile is pain :thisisfine:
Click to expand...
And I gotta go close to day end (may be here still but have no idea honestly ) so all I can say is 100% agree
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
My preferred is Galleon > Yacht still, but I would switch to Yacht to keep them the top wagon over almost anyone else at this point I think.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Submarine said:
:surprised: Does anyone know how to use iso each accounts posts using the vote tool on mobile/if we can?
Click to expand...
Doesn't work for OM I don't think, I keep a separate OM tab open and use the search function on the user I want to ISO since all their posts are in here.
 
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
1. Read post #443 for my thoughts on you. If HB is town that makes me look for people who either wanted an easy vote or interacted weirdly.
2. Your initial vote was on HB but you changed to Yacht later on (tbf you mentioned wanting to vote Yacht and would like to in the same post you voted HB). The initial reasoning for your HB vote, to push it to contentious territory against Sub, made little sense and seemed to be testing the waters.
3. What I mean by that is being hardline from start to finish against someone you know is going to flip town is an odd scum strategy.

There's nothing stopping me, true, but why do you think I feel Inflatable is more apt than you to vote? I feel that there's something there but qualified it with you being the more odd one out of the two for how you backed down quickly on HB in comparison.
Click to expand...
2. I didnt make the votes so cant comment on it
3. Scum tunneling on someone they know will flip town is not odd scum strategy, it's fairly common.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
I was leaning over to show Engineer #1 what I was talking about, so you could hear me more clearly.

There, gimmick intact!
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Submarine said:
My preferred is Galleon > Yacht still, but I would switch to Yacht to keep them the top wagon over almost anyone else at this point I think.
Click to expand...

It is interesting that neither Galleon or Yacht have moved off Houseboat. No clue what it means but it certainly is INTERESTING. Where as Kayak moved off houseboat ASAP.
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
Skiff said:
Yacht asks many questions but comes up with a very boring answer. Personally I'd be interested in seeing their flip due to their partial defence of Lifeboat (I think it would be rad to be right about an early game read).
Vote: Yacht
Click to expand...
I don't like this kind of backward tying together where you vote you are creating a connection with your top scum read on instead of trying to convince others on to that scum read itself.
Vote: Skiff
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
I'm not sure how to evaluate Galleon without looking at houseboat since that scum read has been their bread and butter this game.
 
Cruise Ship

Cruise Ship

Costume
I’d like to see more people giving their thoughts on Galleon. With houseboat out of contention (which I agree is necessary for today) I’m surprised to see galleon not getting more votes. I haven’t seen many takes on my ISO explaining why galleon is suspicious other than Submarine who agrees with me
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Yacht (4 votes)
Jet Ski - #380
Kayak - #391
Skiff - #490
Giant Rubber Duck - #506

Kayak (3 votes)
Lifeboat - #109
Houseboat - #456
Beluga Whale - #504

Galleon (2 votes)
Submarine - #225
Cruise Ship - #457

Houseboat (2 votes)
Galleon - #160
Giant Rubber Duck - #261 #491
Kayak - #364 #391
Yacht - #392 #547
Inflatable Boat - #397
Gondola - #440 #508

Skiff (1 votes)
Yacht - #547

Beluga Whale (0 votes)
Jet Ski - #105 #380
Submarine - #108 #225

Lifeboat (0 votes)
Skiff - #441 #490

Submarine (0 votes)
Beluga Whale - #113 #504
Houseboat - #134 #382

Not voting: Gondola

Post Counts:
Submarine: 91 Jet Ski: 56 Giant Rubber Duck: 53 Beluga Whale: 52 Houseboat: 51 Lifeboat: 45 Gondola: 35 Yacht: 33 Galleon: 32 Inflatable Boat: 29 Cruise Ship: 28 Kayak: 27 Skiff: 19

Current Countdown:
xc5y3gu09k



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Cruise Ship said:
I’d like to see more people giving their thoughts on Galleon. With houseboat out of contention (which I agree is necessary for today) I’m surprised to see galleon not getting more votes. I haven’t seen many takes on my ISO explaining why galleon is suspicious other than Submarine who agrees with me
Click to expand...
Reading back, I can see a scum Galleon if HB is town. They seem to just really dislike HB and instead of having a reason it's like the reason follows the intention of voting for HB. I'd say that Galleon's HB read is like a more disorganized Inflatable.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Personally, Houseboat's claim has just made Galleon look even more sus to me, and they've been the top of my Scum pile for like the whole day lol. Completely tunneled in on Houseboat and has made sus comments elsewhere too, it's a pretty bad looking slot compared to many others.
 
Houseboat

Houseboat

Costume
Vote: Galleon

Kayak wagon is not taking off. I do not love Yacht but I actively dislike Kayak and Galleon so I prefer them as the vote.
 
Gondola

Gondola

Costume
Cruise Ship said:
I’d like to see more people giving their thoughts on Galleon. With houseboat out of contention (which I agree is necessary for today) I’m surprised to see galleon not getting more votes. I haven’t seen many takes on my ISO explaining why galleon is suspicious other than Submarine who agrees with me
Click to expand...

Trying to give them a read through right now. I hadn't looked at them too closely this day phase because my partner had spoke to them and seemed to feel good about them so it felt better to focus on others, plus honestly they were on the houseboat vote and I thought there was something there. If houseboat is the doc, Galleon could be worth a decent punt.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Seems Kayak's train is dead now. Between Galleon and Yacht I'd vote for Galleon. The most I can say about Yacht is that I have no idea where their head is but they do keep poking.

Vote: Galleon
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
This is an EoD I can get behind for sure, I'm happy with either the Galleon or Yacht flip, though Galleon is my preferred.
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Vote: Yacht

Between Galleon and Yacht I get a slightly townier vibe from Galleon but that is just big VIBES in how they have posted.
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Yacht (5 votes)
Jet Ski - #380
Kayak - #391
Skiff - #490
Giant Rubber Duck - #506
Lifeboat - #561

Galleon (4 votes)
Submarine - #225
Cruise Ship - #457
Houseboat - #556
Beluga Whale - #558

Lifeboat (1 votes)
Skiff - #441 #490
Galleon - #562

Houseboat (1 votes)
Galleon - #160 #562
Giant Rubber Duck - #261 #491
Kayak - #364 #391
Yacht - #392 #547
Inflatable Boat - #397
Gondola - #440 #508

Skiff (1 votes)
Yacht - #547

Kayak (0 votes)
Lifeboat - #109 #561
Houseboat - #456 #556
Beluga Whale - #504 #558

Beluga Whale (0 votes)
Jet Ski - #105 #380
Submarine - #108 #225

Submarine (0 votes)
Beluga Whale - #113 #504
Houseboat - #134 #382

Not voting: Gondola

Post Counts:
Submarine: 94 Jet Ski: 56 Beluga Whale: 54 Giant Rubber Duck: 53 Houseboat: 52 Lifeboat: 46 Gondola: 36 Yacht: 33 Galleon: 33 Inflatable Boat: 29 Cruise Ship: 28 Kayak: 27 Skiff: 19

Current Countdown:
xc5y3gu09k



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Lifeboat said:
Vote: Yacht

Between Galleon and Yacht I get a slightly townier vibe from Galleon but that is just big VIBES in how they have posted.
Click to expand...
I'd still put Galleon at the top of my Scum reads, but Yacht is a close second, so I'm fine with that vote too.
 
Gondola

Gondola

Costume
Alright, partner hasn't showed and I'm not voting last minute or causing a tie last minute. There isn't much to Galleon on an iso beyond the houseboat stuff, they had a pretty singularly focused day so let try it

Vote: Galleon
 
Inflatable Boat

Inflatable Boat

Costume
Apologies for not being here. We warned earlier about work. I expected to get more free time prior to EoD. At this point, I don't have any confidence of catching up properly. With the claim from Houseboat:

Unvote
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Gondola said:
Alright, partner hasn't showed and I'm not voting last minute or causing a tie last minute. There isn't much to Galleon on an iso beyond the houseboat stuff, they had a pretty singularly focused day so let try it

Vote: Galleon
Click to expand...

not causing a tie... then votes to make it 5 v 5
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Galleon (5 votes)
Submarine - #225
Cruise Ship - #457
Houseboat - #556
Beluga Whale - #558
Gondola - #571

Yacht (5 votes)
Jet Ski - #380
Kayak - #391
Skiff - #490
Giant Rubber Duck - #506
Lifeboat - #561

Lifeboat (1 votes)
Skiff - #441 #490
Galleon - #562

Skiff (1 votes)
Yacht - #547

Kayak (0 votes)
Lifeboat - #109 #561
Houseboat - #456 #556
Beluga Whale - #504 #558

Beluga Whale (0 votes)
Jet Ski - #105 #380
Submarine - #108 #225

Submarine (0 votes)
Beluga Whale - #113 #504
Houseboat - #134 #382

Houseboat (0 votes)
Galleon - #160 #562
Giant Rubber Duck - #261 #491
Kayak - #364 #391
Yacht - #392 #547
Inflatable Boat - #397 #572
Gondola - #440 #508

Not voting: Inflatable Boat

Post Counts:
Submarine: 97 Jet Ski: 57 Beluga Whale: 57 Giant Rubber Duck: 53 Houseboat: 52 Lifeboat: 51 Gondola: 38 Yacht: 33 Galleon: 33 Inflatable Boat: 31 Cruise Ship: 28 Kayak: 27 Skiff: 19

Current Countdown:
xc5y3gu09k



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Inflatable Boat

Inflatable Boat

Costume
Thankfully, the Inflatable Boats discussed both Yacht and Galleon last night. Based on our back-and-forth, we feel the most comfortable here:

Vote: Yacht
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
Cruise Ship said:
if you assume houseboat is town due to the claim how does that affect your read of galleon?
Click to expand...
Tried to look back over them but don't have time for a reread on mobile. There are moments of confidence from Galleon that seem townier to me e.g asking to "prove the negative". If HB is town the odds of at least one scum on there is good and it'd probably be between duck and Galleon for me as I'm good with Gondola/Inflatable
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start - Day End

Galleon (7 votes)
Submarine - #225
Cruise Ship - #457
Houseboat - #556
Beluga Whale - #558
Gondola - #571
Jet Ski - #590
Lifeboat - #592

Yacht (4 votes)
Jet Ski - #380 #590
Kayak - #391
Skiff - #490
Giant Rubber Duck - #506
Lifeboat - #561 #592
Inflatable Boat - #591

Lifeboat (1 votes)
Skiff - #441 #490
Galleon - #562

Skiff (1 votes)
Yacht - #547

Kayak (0 votes)
Lifeboat - #109 #561
Houseboat - #456 #556
Beluga Whale - #504 #558

Beluga Whale (0 votes)
Jet Ski - #105 #380
Submarine - #108 #225

Submarine (0 votes)
Beluga Whale - #113 #504
Houseboat - #134 #382

Houseboat (0 votes)
Galleon - #160 #562
Giant Rubber Duck - #261 #491
Kayak - #364 #391
Yacht - #392 #547
Inflatable Boat - #397 #572
Gondola - #440 #508

Post Counts:
Submarine: 99 Jet Ski: 59 Beluga Whale: 59 Lifeboat: 55 Giant Rubber Duck: 54 Houseboat: 52 Gondola: 38 Yacht: 34 Galleon: 33 Inflatable Boat: 32 Cruise Ship: 28 Kayak: 27 Skiff: 19

Current Countdown:
xc5y3gu09k



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
The Bear looked at the boaties.

“Okay, so what did you talk about today?”

“Well you see it was–”


“Okay I’ve seen enough! It’s time to defeat the Loveless!”

Alas, Galleon was but a fighter for love, their life cut short.
Click to expand...

Galleon has died!

Welcome to the Love Boat Spin-Off Mafia!
You and another anonymous player have invaded the body of a costume account Galleon. You both will post in the game using this same account.

You are aligned with THE BOATS which means Town.

Your shared role is Vanilla Town. You have no special powers, but may vote.

If your shared costume account dies during the game, both of you leave the game in the process.

You do not know who the other player controlling the account is. But you both share the same alignment and role.

You may talk with the other player in the special Partner Chat during the game. You both must use the singular costume account to post in that chat.

You win the game, when all threats to THE BOATS have been defeated.

Costume account username: Galleon

Costume account password: (Removed)

Please confirm that you have received your role PM by replying here.
Click to expand...

Night 1 Begins

Day 2 begins in:
x0o229fvnq


Night Actions are due two hours before Day begins.
 
Last edited:
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I'll keep the game thread locked during night phases so players don't accidentally post here during the night.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom