Backstage

Abby Cadabby

Costume
IF Fozzie dies, and isn't the poisoner, it's still a plus for us because we don't want the poisoner wasting a night on you when they could be helping us kill town on accident too. So it all goes back to my post 99. And with Mew and Piggy having the heat they do, I think it's good to buy our alts another day and keep on fighting.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
chaos.gif
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
But of course this is your game too so do what is fun for you. I'll have a good time either way, and don't want you to do something you don't want especially if it blows up in our faces.

e3c775e70d0e0d2250c6c900237b9125.gif
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
(Note: not sure why I've been talking like we have a cop. We have no godfather, and we have a ninja kill. We're dealing with Watchers/Trackers and shit)
(Note Note: Going to be REAL fun trying to kill these damn PRs since smart town would feed their results through their alt accounts as a buffer)
(Note Note Note: Oscar a Doc? Watcher? Hrm)
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I'm trying to think what I was doing as town here. I think I would try to prod or scare the neutral without revealing because if they target me I get to use my ability.
Oh, and one more. For the setup to work, you have to yourself (Jeff) buy into this belief that you've found the poisoner. Therefore, Shang is Fozzie. Fozzie must be neutral. Neutral is likely poisoner.

Some might argue poisoner could be scum. Too much kill power in my mind so easily dismissed.

And if why no reveal D1---because you scare away poisoner from poisoning themselves once you reveal this obviously.
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
(Note: not sure why I've been talking like we have a cop. We have no godfather, and we have a ninja kill. We're dealing with Watchers/Trackers and shit)
(Note Note: Going to be REAL fun trying to kill these damn PRs since smart town would feed their results through their alt accounts as a buffer)
(Note Note Note: Oscar a Doc? Watcher? Hrm)
Yeah I was thinking on this. I guess the roleblock can counter a shot limited cop
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
I think I'll ease into it by pressuring Fozzie and maybe drop some hints about if suspecting an anti town neutral.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I think I'll ease into it by pressuring Fozzie and maybe drop some hints about if suspecting an anti town neutral.
Fozzie has gotten a bunch of pressure already that has gone nowhere and as time ticks down we have less chance of everyone being around to respond. So if you gonna ease in, I think it'll have to be a quick ease.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
All in all, I don't think you can pressure Fozzie in any way that yields much of anything. If I were town that had a eureka like we want to pretend Piggy just had, I'd drop what I think is a bomb. IF it doesn't land, I genuinely believe it'll come off innocent enough that town will give Piggy a pass. But this group hates teases, and they're gonna say, "there was no need to hold onto this. Just come out with it unless you're scum feeling your lie out."
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
Piggy has entered the arena. I am going to run and get some stuff done. Good luck with whatever path you take. I have faith :)
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
Sorry had a prod issue at work which has derailed me.
I'm ok with revealing the poison but unsure how to work it in organically:
1. I think people are coming around to Shang = Fozzie, so if as town I could wait a day and expect Fozzie to be chased if a double kill occurred
2. This will tie Piggy and Mew together e.g Piggy went off route to chase Fozzie when Mew was lined up on the table. Maybe we are ok with that if we think Mew is cooked anyway
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
Something like this?
"Ok I don't really like revealing role information but I'm not sure how useful my power will be at this point. I have something which counteracts poison, which I'm guessing is a scum or neutral ability. It doesn't detail what the poison is but I assume it's a slow acting kill. I tried looking at the wiki but didn't find much. I'm wondering if Shang's other half might be this poisoner and I'm trying to figure out if that's something we should act on today or sit on."

I'm not really sure what to do with the last part as a call to action?
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I wouldn't make a huge deal out of it. Ish.

"I'll just come out with it. My power is blah blah. I would've revealed day 1, but I'd rather the poisoner kill themselves coming for me. But if people think Fozzie is Shang and likely to be neutral, it only makes sense they're the poisoner.

Vote: Fozzie"

But in your words.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Busy day at my work too lol. Jumped to PC quickly so I can chat with you.

Something like this?
"Ok I don't really like revealing role information but I'm not sure how useful my power will be at this point. I have something which counteracts poison, which I'm guessing is a scum or neutral ability. It doesn't detail what the poison is but I assume it's a slow acting kill. I tried looking at the wiki but didn't find much. I'm wondering if Shang's other half might be this poisoner and I'm trying to figure out if that's something we should act on today or sit on."

I'm not really sure what to do with the last part as a call to action?
This town doesn't react well to leaking info for someone at the top of the scum list. When you post, say 100% what your ability does. Then you just have to sell that there was no point in revealing it (there wasn't, it'd be a bad move) until you knew who the potential threat was that was poisoning people. More than one have said they think Fozzie is Shang so you don't have to say "And I believe Mew" or anything---just the room and leave it general--- and the room also thinks the other role would be neutral or scum at worst. Stir that all up and you have a chance of Fozzie being the room poisoner. Vote Fozzie or don't Fozzie---I'll leave that to you---and let the room digest and see where it goes. But whatever you do, come out strong on this claim. Don't hem and haw around it and your info or town will eat you alive :)
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
Claiming this doesn't land as strong if they think its in self-preservation so trying to think best way to logic them into seeing this as a town move because you assume we've caught our neutral poisoner----Fozzie.

But I don't know if that thread works now. I think that had to be laid out immediately. Hrm. Lets see how this shakes out. I'll ponder if I can nudge the thought towards Fozzie.
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
Awh sorry, I probably needed to give it more juice. I've shifted to Fozzie now but they've been pretty competent so I expect a defense
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
Also I can leave Jeff until near EoD to boost a wagon, can easily move off Piggy based on the fact a claim occured.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Awh sorry, I probably needed to give it more juice. I've shifted to Fozzie now but they've been pretty competent so I expect a defense
All good. I think the plan required a very precise order and manipulation that Sauron would've struggled to nail perfectly. You did good, and I'll try and pepper in some questions for Piggy like why you chose to reveal now and such.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
And I don't think the plan is dead either.

Read Fozzie's back-and-forth with Triump on page 5 (my quoting isn't working properly right now):
Fozzie says things like:

"And? It works completely against a scum aligned puppet too. They could be two neutrals as well but I highly doubt it."
"Shang’s other puppet is never scum. A built in 1 for 1 against a vanilla townie would be the worst role for one of the scum members to have."

So, puts out idea that Shang's alt could be neutral (though doubts). Definitely not scum. Then in response to Howdy Doody:

Then read their posts with Howdy Doody:
"If you actually think that then you are actively choosing to vote for town or a neutral here, I would never be scum in that world you asserted."

Fozzie then breaks down in detail what a poisoner would look like. X-shots, this many deaths, etc etc.

Fozzie has loaded Piggy up for quotes on Page 5 that could be used against them if we can convince the room they're the poisoner, and under no circumstances should we let a poisoner live.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Bert is pulling at a good thread. If Fozzie has a chance of being viewed as the poisoner, they wouldn't want you flipped. Your reveal would show that poison is in fact on the table.
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
Kind of a hectic day here. I can hop in but idk if I spin it around. If the votes are close I guess could tie or try to flip mew?
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Sorry for the day. Mine was bananas too. We can find some positive out of it. One of us was likely going down, so we at least stirred up some in-fighting between people and we know Kermit isn't a threat we have to worry about anymore. It's not much, but hey...I guess I'll take it?
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
I'm not really sure the play at this point. It's you or Kermit unless they can be convinced one of you is neutral, so maybe if you get time to show up and just do your best townie self to answer questions why you revealed and you know....ham it up :)
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
In all honesty, I think the best thing is to come in as Jeff and comment, and leave Piggy quiet. If you both show up it'll link you both. Just get Jeff's voice in there since he has been radio silent today.
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
Sorry have work and personal stuff to juggle that will make it hard to post much of anything.
I think you can go Piggy with Abby and hammer as Mew? If I pick up Mews playstyle it fits for them to want to be a hammer
 

Miss Piggy

Costume
There is the funny world where I can tie it 7-7 with Piggy and Jeff but I think we just lose more accounts that way and realistically someone will hammer before that point.

Realistically I think we were mostly going to lose one of Piggy or Mew today anyway so just look to what we can build out of the wreckage
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Sorry have work and personal stuff to juggle that will make it hard to post much of anything.
I think you can go Piggy with Abby and hammer as Mew? If I pick up Mews playstyle it fits for them to want to be a hammer
No problem at all. I think even if Jeff makes an appearance to make a single post that is good. Then call it and deal with personal stuff and such :)

And if you can't do even that, it's no biggie. don't push it. You got personal shit to deal with, then you got stuff to deal with!
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
So I read through day end, a lot of mechanics speculation and Bert and Fozzie back and forth. No one comes away cleared from Piggys flip (well, maybe Kermit) but the flip itself should open up a lot of new avenues which may be predictable (notably partner hunting on Piggy)

  • Bert is confirmed town and putting in good effort
  • Fozzie got some heat but has been hard to push. I def think they are 2nd half of Shang but might just be town (Vanilla?)
    • I think it's possible Bert and Fozzie could switch from butting heads to being friends, at which point they might run the game until dealt with
  • Oscar def looked like a PR. Worth checking if Charlie confidence is a pair thing or a PR thing. Mentioned being better alive than dead so thinking a PR with shots left?
    • If not a cop, not sure what would clear Charlie?
  • Howdy doody had some good insights on Jeff, I think they might push me again tomorrow
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Never getting voted, must kill at some point:
  • Bert
Likely to look town:
  • Kermit (via Piggy flip)
  • Charlie (if Oscar has info on them)
  • Oscar (if uncontested PR claim)
  • Maybe Fozzie - mostly by effort
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
If people look at the timing of Piggys claim closely they might ask why not just vote Mew. I can push that as Jeff theory, but I think I need to get away from bussing and find reasons to feel good about one of your two accounts and firm up some scum read on a towny tomorrow.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I'm still not sure we have a cop without having a godfather, which makes you wonder what the fuck is up with Oscar's claim lol. Oscar could just be that confident of a player, and they could also be baiting.

We could always go for a surprise pick and kill a lower post player. No one will be protecting, and we have a good chance of hitting a loud player's backup where they might be hiding a PR.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
One thing to watch out for is to not make a super strong showing tomorrow in terms of post count else people might piece together you're Piggy with more free time on your hands.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Not much movements in the votes given how many were for mew or piggy
yReWjOA.png


Going to put some confidence behind Fozzie = Shang and Grogu = Dynamite. I think both are a really good fit.
Usmw4a8.png
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
Kermit also supposedly poisoned someone. I have my doubts they are an X-shot, but it's someone they claim they think is scum. So who knows. One of us might drop dead tomorrow
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
All right. Got the laptop loaded up in bed while The Office goes in the background. Let's see if I can find anything interesting.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I think the next easiest/quickest to solve is Oscar after that slip. Quick look and that seems to be Topo Gigio. When Oscar first slips into 3rd person on accident, it was quoting you (Jeff) who was responding to Topo. And Topo was the only other vote on Oscar outside of Mew and Jeff.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Never getting voted, must kill at some point:
  • Bert
Likely to look town:
  • Kermit (via Piggy flip)
  • Charlie (if Oscar has info on them)
  • Oscar (if uncontested PR claim)
  • Maybe Fozzie - mostly by effort
Ok I updated the matrix with some deduction from reading these players (I would go insane doing the full roster). Some are small leaps, like say you wouldn't put your other town account as I or K and you wouldn't argue with yourself on theories back to back.
SY8Dvih.png

  • Bert has 4 living potential partners: Elmo, Howdy, Topo and Triumph
    • It's also not impossible that he really was paired with Ernie. It seems like a meme, but masons are still better than vanilla town on the same account because one death confirms the other.
  • Kermit has 6 living potential pairs
  • Charlie has 6
  • Oscar has 7
Can't quite use this just use but maybe one more day of voting will sudoku it out
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
I think the next easiest/quickest to solve is Oscar after that slip. Quick look and that seems to be Topo Gigio. When Oscar first slips into 3rd person on accident, it was quoting you (Jeff) who was responding to Topo. And Topo was the only other vote on Oscar outside of Mew and Jeff.
I did think this but didn't Topo vote Oscar? Kinda weird as town, weird PR gambit?
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I did think this but didn't Topo vote Oscar? Kinda weird as town, weird PR gambit?
Yeah. IF Oscar even has a power. But Oscar's 3rd person comment is them unvoting while saying Oscar is trying now. Had to be intended to be Topo unvoting for Oscar. That has to be same person.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Honestly it might just be a fine night to strong Bert. Removes a discussion leader, freezes his read on Fozzie as negative. Only risk is movement from Abby on Bert but I don't know if anyone was looking that was as of yet, Abby made a lot of protect lists (day end could hurt tho)
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
And if Jeff or Mew are tracked instead it's better there.

The alternative would be to do something with Oscar. Block Oscar, kill Charlie? Or just kill Oscar. Or kill a suspected pair of Oscar if we think it's a a bluff.

Idk, what are you thinking?
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
Personally, I love the fighting with Bert and Fozzie. I would like to keep them alive just one more day because Bert very well might be able to get Fozzie killed. But more than that, everyone and their mother said Bert was the obvious choice for tonight's death so much that even if we strong kill, they're might be watchers/trackers/whatever the hell out there with a spotlight on them. I'm honestly a little nervous of the same with Oscar too. I'm so confident in Oscar being Topo that I honestly like that idea of Topo going bye-bye. I don't mind Charlie either.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
And I don't know if Fanto plays anymore, but Oscar kind of gives me Fanto vibes...? Could be waaaay wrong. But if that's them thenI don't mind cutting one of their accounts off. Fanto scares me. Well, everyone scares me. I always play the game with the assumption everyone is smarter and better at this than I am.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I need to try and get time before tomorrow starts to have built up Piggy's potential partners too. Get an idea where people might be coming at us from, but also to keep us looking like we're scum hunting. I think Abby started the day strong, but really fell apart by the end. Tomorrow I gotta come in like a thunderbolt on someone.

Mew might come in hard on Kermit. "Oh, this account is useless, do whatever you want against me." "I'm only X-shot." Then if mid-day hits and a town player dies from poison, Mew will be ready to go bananas on Kermit. (If you want this angle, it's all yours).

Abby---no idea. I'll wing it as normal with her.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Personally, I love the fighting with Bert and Fozzie. I would like to keep them alive just one more day because Bert very well might be able to get Fozzie killed.
The bickering was good and generated a lot of noise but in my head I don't know if it will last when Fozzie knows Bert is town. Like they clashed more here because neither of them knew if any of their reads were spot on, but tomorrow will be about looking outwards from Piggy and I would expect both Bert and Fozzie to be throwing out well measured arguments. And I think that might just dominate the thread in a way that will be pretty punishing.
But more than that, everyone and their mother said Bert was the obvious choice for tonight's death so much that even if we strong kill, they're might be watchers/trackers/whatever the hell out there with a spotlight on them. I'm honestly a little nervous of the same with Oscar too.
While this is true, I do think a tracker is probably not thinking Abby as their #1 right this minute. I get that end of day looks worse for Abby, but if the tracker had them as town before I don't think they will flip and immediately sus that slot.
A watcher would suck and is the big risk with making that move, but I think we need to take some risk wherever we move.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
I'm honestly a little nervous of the same with Oscar too. I'm so confident in Oscar being Topo that I honestly like that idea of Topo going bye-bye. I don't mind Charlie either.
Yeah I think others could make the leap to Oscar being a cop, especially without knowing about the lack of a godfather. I need to look at the Topo/Oscar connection too.
One thing with Charlie is Abby had that post which kinda put Charlie as scum with Piggy which could look bad if it looks like it was a setup based on knowing Piggys alignment. Also if the confidence on Charlie is just the vote switching, that gets reversed on learning it was TvS and Charlie jumped to save Piggy.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Mew might come in hard on Kermit. "Oh, this account is useless, do whatever you want against me." "I'm only X-shot." Then if mid-day hits and a town player dies from poison, Mew will be ready to go bananas on Kermit. (If you want this angle, it's all yours).
Kermit will probably just look good with Piggys flip regardless of who they hit with the poison, I think the trap there was they are basically a vig and without Piggys flip they claim poison and everyone flips and thinks it's a scum role.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Is there ever a world where we ninja Bert? Doctor has a bit of a mind game on their hands of do they protect Bert or do they assume scum think Bert is so reasonably well protected that they can be greedy and protect somewhere else? Downside would be losing the ninja and a no kill night but nobody's getting for sure caught off of that.
There's also the funny possibility where there is a watcher + doctor + something on Bert and the watcher outs the doctor thinking the other is the assassin.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
The bickering was good and generated a lot of noise but in my head I don't know if it will last when Fozzie knows Bert is town. Like they clashed more here because neither of them knew if any of their reads were spot on, but tomorrow will be about looking outwards from Piggy and I would expect both Bert and Fozzie to be throwing out well measured arguments. And I think that might just dominate the thread in a way that will be pretty punishing.

While this is true, I do think a tracker is probably not thinking Abby as their #1 right this minute. I get that end of day looks worse for Abby, but if the tracker had them as town before I don't think they will flip and immediately sus that slot.
A watcher would suck and is the big risk with making that move, but I think we need to take some risk wherever we move.
Their back-and-forth is very much a personality and playstyle conflict. They could get big flashing neon signs above their heads that say "TOWN CONFIRMED" and they'll still go at it. They'll likely go at it even more today because Fozzie gets to rub it in people's faces how much they were right about there being poison, while Bert is going to come in and say, "Of course you knew it because Piggy was on your team" and go right back into "why did you back off of Piggy?"

Kermit will probably just look good with Piggys flip regardless of who they hit with the poison, I think the trap there was they are basically a vig and without Piggys flip they claim poison and everyone flips and thinks it's a scum role.
If I were truly town, I'd be paranoid of Kermit even with that flip. Bussing means even less with us all having two accounts. I'm just looking at all the potential avenues, and I think there's one for Kermit making people nervous as hell.

And yeah. Watcher is what scares me more than anything. I love a risk and gamble, but not necessarily with Abby tonight after losing Piggy until we have a bit more confidence in who has a PR. What truly scares me is that Oscar could very well be baiting a kill for some unknown power, and if we think Oscar is a threat of any kind (especially an info one) lets chop off their legs by taking their alt out where they don't expect.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
Their back-and-forth is very much a personality and playstyle conflict. They could get big flashing neon signs above their heads that say "TOWN CONFIRMED" and they'll still go at it. They'll likely go at it even more today because Fozzie gets to rub it in people's faces how much they were right about there being poison, while Bert is going to come in and say, "Of course you knew it because Piggy was on your team" and go right back into "why did you back off of Piggy?"
And if Bert dies, Fozzie loses their strongest attacker, which is bad for us. Fozzie scares me more than Bert. That's why I want to nudge and pull strings today and help get Fozzie out of here, then we can kill Bert after doing our dirty work. In my mind, that's Plan A. Another fire is lighting something under Kermit. Another is Charlie with D1 end-of-day vote saving Piggy. Need to find a few more. But we've got mud to fling everywhere.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Oscar/Topo stuff
vote: Jeff Tracy
Rolled 1-20 and got a 19, so let’s drum up
Some conversation!
Oscar likes exclamation marks!
Ok I have reread page 2, but outside of fixing votes it seems like we are mostly just trying to guess how many pairs of scum there are.

8 pairs of scum sounds like so much!
So does Topo!
It’s probably 2 scum teams of 4. Not to say we don’t have 3 non town pairs, but 4 scum in 20 players is still a bunch of scum. Six scum would be crazy!
Chats with Topo here, but it's riffing on a theory rather than a disagreement.
I posted it and laughed too!
Shows you how close attention I was paying. Missed the joke entirely
If these are the same person, they are starting to try to look distinct here.
So Oscar, are you going to change your vote from a “random” one to something with a bit more of a read?
Topo questions Oscar here.
In fact, Charlie is so for sure town. I guarantee it.
Put an Oscar the grouch seal of approval on Charlie McCarthy.
What?!?

how do you go from town aligned to top town?
Your approval is trash.

vote: Oscar the Grouch
Topo reaction to Oscar town reading Charlie. This is very strange if Topo and Oscar are the same and have info on Charlie.
@Jeff Tracy believe what you want, but I’m better alive than dead.
This is a pretty clear "I'm a PR" type claim.
Do you have any actual thoughts on Oscar's vote?
I wasn’t asked but I’ll chime in, it is day one, but it could be alignment indicative. Come in and make a splashy show of a random vote vs just coming in and posting it
Topo volunteers to read Oscar here.
Very honorable.

not sure what I would do for the I or K,

but the P is definitely Bert.
It definitely looks like the slipped post from oscar was meant to follow up on me asking why they would only protect Bert as Topo.
K: Mr. mew or Jeff Tracy.
Mr. mew seems to be trying to spin something after having a not so good vote yesterday.

Jeff Tracy has that weird gotcha like you said.

I’d probably investigate Oscar now too.
Stating they would investigate Oscar.
So I’ll swap my vote

vote: Mr. Mew
Topo swaps their vote later, I think this what was the intended followup to the unvote by Oscar.
Maybe, maybe not. Since Shang was a survivor neutral I’m not exactly sure how Randomless would have classified that role (town threat or not). Definitely Dynamite Heady threat, but not necessarily a town threat.

So Shang’s puppet pal could be any alignment,
Topo double posts this a few hours apart. After the second one, Oscar shows up a few mins later.
So Shang’s puppet pal could be any alignment,
Also note the trailing comma here
Yes I am Oscar,
and here

So the language features, activity and slip ups really look like the same account. But the interacting and vote makes it look like someone who doesn't want people knowing it is the same account. Why?
  1. They got excited by the unique gimmick of this game and wanted to have fun with talking to themself / voting themself
  2. They thought by voting Oscar with Topo they could gain insight into bad votes on Oscar?
  3. They don't want scum knowing they are the same because one is a PR and one is a mouthpiece
  4. They don't want scum knowing they are the same because they can keep their implicit trust in each account secret until it is useful in voting
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
I think you are spot on with #3, then a dash of the rest is likely. One of those accounts is definitely cooking a power.

I plan to use my lunch here in a bit to plan my opening day reads for both Mew and Abby.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Their back-and-forth is very much a personality and playstyle conflict. They could get big flashing neon signs above their heads that say "TOWN CONFIRMED" and they'll still go at it. They'll likely go at it even more today because Fozzie gets to rub it in people's faces how much they were right about there being poison, while Bert is going to come in and say, "Of course you knew it because Piggy was on your team" and go right back into "why did you back off of Piggy?"


If I were truly town, I'd be paranoid of Kermit even with that flip. Bussing means even less with us all having two accounts. I'm just looking at all the potential avenues, and I think there's one for Kermit making people nervous as hell.

And yeah. Watcher is what scares me more than anything. I love a risk and gamble, but not necessarily with Abby tonight after losing Piggy until we have a bit more confidence in who has a PR. What truly scares me is that Oscar could very well be baiting a kill for some unknown power, and if we think Oscar is a threat of any kind (especially an info one) lets chop off their legs by taking their alt out where they don't expect.
Agreed on Bert and Fozzie having a personality clash. TBH they both seem like tryhard players who want to command the room and if it weren't for the mason part would likely be very good for us they are butting heads so hard.
But Bert really does have a flashing confirmed town sign above their head, so I think Fozzie is savvy enough to start solving now that real info about scum is out there. And with the two of them dissecting Piggy pairs and reactions to the claim I think the thread will make pretty good solving progress.
---
Yeah I think Kermit can see some paranoia, but the levelheaded voices will probably just express that until a neutral poison ability shows up kermit can be left alone as a counter role to scum.
---
Watcher is just stupid strong unfortunately, I'd love to think we don't have one and it's just a tracker but yeah there's no way to know yet.
Would you be sad to lose the ninja + maybe have the kill be blocked? I think I'm ok with it cause it shouldn't have any of us dead to rights.
I think I agree with Oscar baiting, it feels pretty heavy handed and if Topo is being tricky with the distance I don't see why they are so obvious on Oscar.
And if Bert dies, Fozzie loses their strongest attacker, which is bad for us. Fozzie scares me more than Bert. That's why I want to nudge and pull strings today and help get Fozzie out of here, then we can kill Bert after doing our dirty work. In my mind, that's Plan A. Another fire is lighting something under Kermit. Another is Charlie with D1 end-of-day vote saving Piggy. Need to find a few more. But we've got mud to fling everywhere.
Agreed on Fozzie being maybe even a bigger threat. I just don't think Bert is easily manipulated and could easily ally with Fozzie instead.
Kermit - people will discuss but expect a balance argument that they are mechanically clear.
Charlie - could see this slot losing its shine with the shift to save Piggy and my WIFOM look into Charlie.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
So for kills:
  • I still really like the idea of Bert not being in the game and think solo Fozzie will struggle more than with the two of them together. Strong on Bert could be game losing in the wrong circumstance, so I guess it would be a ninja here and roll the dice on the doc actually protecting the mason - knowing we are still ok if we whiff but none of us move
  • I think the best way to deal with Oscar is to snipe Topo. Maybe we got a wire crossed there, but I wouldn't be surprised if Topo is our tracker and using Oscar to draw heat.
    • If both are alive, I do have an angle as Jeff to follow up at some point and make the Topo=Oscar connection based on the "slip" I caught, but I don't know how enthused town is about that angle. Maybe the "intentionally distancing your accounts is scummy" angle hasn't really sunk in until we try chasing Piggy's leads.
  • Howdy and Charlie would also be good picks for people who seem to pick up on things and could have good insights
    • I kind of wait to see if Charlies star fades with the Piggy reveal or if people thinks it confirms him. I think we could keep him a day.

If saving an Abby power, might be time to get Jeff in there - I have no idea how people feel about Mew after EoD but either seem like possible track targets.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Agreed on Bert and Fozzie having a personality clash. TBH they both seem like tryhard players who want to command the room and if it weren't for the mason part would likely be very good for us they are butting heads so hard.
But Bert really does have a flashing confirmed town sign above their head, so I think Fozzie is savvy enough to start solving now that real info about scum is out there. And with the two of them dissecting Piggy pairs and reactions to the claim I think the thread will make pretty good solving progress.
Turn off your brain to what you know, because you know a lot more than town. Even if Bert and Fozzie form an alliance, that doesn't mean they're going to find us today. Fozzie went to bat hard for Mew, and a ton of the room feels good about Abby. The biggest risk today for any of us is Jeff getting found out, which would stink because I don't wanna be here alone lol. So what we gotta do is see exactly what kind of connections they can make to Jeff and have Jeff prepped to defend from it, AND get Jeff scum-hunting. He has to present some targets (Abby and Mew too of course), but Jeff is likely going to be the most in the hot seat out of our 3 remaining.

Yeah I think Kermit can see some paranoia, but the levelheaded voices will probably just express that until a neutral poison ability shows up kermit can be left alone as a counter role to scum.
Town?! Level-headed?!
200w.gif
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Personally, I'd like to use Mew for the kill solely for the reason I don't want to lose you. The least amount of risk we can take for you right now, the better. I'd go crazy in here by my lonesome.

Since I'm being such an adamant butthead on Bert being left alive, I'll turn it to you on Topo, Howdy, or Charlie. Whatever you wanna do cowboy. I just really really wanna leave Bert alone tonight. Too much risk, and I'm in this for the long game. We're taking this to the superbowl, and we're just now getting past the pre-season.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Bert's suspects from yesterday:

"Miss piggy. Fozzie. Kermit. Kutaro"

Piggy dead. Fozzie and Kermit can easily be pushed. Kutaro is a complete blindspot for me. Gonna read there now.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Got it!
I think we Mew Topo and hope our hunch pays off to start clearing some PRs. Charlie has something going with Fozzie and Howdy has some higher Jeff suspicion that I would rather try to talk myself out of than draw attention to with a kill.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
And if you really, really want to kill Bert and strongarm them, I GUESS WE CAN WHATEVER. It is a game after all so if we get caught, we get caught :)
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
And I don't mean this as a slight against our current town in case anyone reads and is like, "What a butthead!" Just town mentality in general. We've all been there lol
Yeah of course, and this game is about to get information overload as town pours over the WIFOM of pair solving and is not an enviable position.
Will say there's def been a strong town in this game I think at least 3-4 players I'd love to just have wiped off the map :D
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
And if you really, really want to kill Bert and strongarm them, I GUESS WE CAN WHATEVER. It is a game after all so if we get caught, we get caught :)
I think I'm convinced we can wait the day, it's really an unknown factor if alive Bert helps or hinders us. They could have also checked out expecting to day and take a while to warm up again. As long as our day plans aren't all in on "Bert will push Fozzie" we should be okay.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
I think I'm convinced we can wait the day, it's really an unknown factor if alive Bert helps or hinders us. They could have also checked out expecting to day and take a while to warm up again. As long as our day plans aren't all in on "Bert will push Fozzie" we should be okay.
Yeah, definitely not. We're chimps swinging tree limb to tree limb. You and I are just making sure we have as many limbs as possible to swing to in case one snaps off, and sometimes these vocal players can be advantageous for creating new ones. And if one of those swings at us, I'm okay with it mostly because that's part of the fun for me. I don't mind having to talk my way out of something, because when I do and see town shift, that's when I get that little bit of joy deep down in my dark hollow heart.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Miss Piggy notes
They don't impress moi much taking the backseat. Did I miss why Fozzie is doubling down?
Shaded Fozzie for sheeping them.
1. Good instincts darling
2. It looks like Fozzie is not your #1 fan. Less doubling down but more saying they are good with the vote where it is
Miss piggy could never
Sometime left out periods at end of sentences. Unfortunately I've done this as Jeff too (I thought Piggy hadn't) but thankfully it is common enough across more players.
The Dynamite wagon is feeling loosey goosey to me. Needs more of a spark. I think there is more weight behind this one.
Hi-ya!
Vote: Howdy Doody
Shifted from Dynamite to Howdy.
I'm not tracking with either of these points. How was support dwindling on the vote? And when you say opportunistic what was the opportunity?
Disagreement with Charlie
If I flip, Charlie skeeves me the most on my wagon. Good luck!
WIFOM
I didn't like this post from Charlie:
Went back to Charlie well start of day 2, concluded town but did pull quotes on them.
Or it's the much simpler explanation that I moved my vote to somewhere I thought had a better chance of hitting Scum as town is supposed to do.

The votes on Dynamite were getting increasingly lazy whereas I was liking Shang who at least had a scrap of a reason to be on the Howdy vote. It might have gone somewhere if Shang didn't have an incentive to flip to Dynamite.

Why did you sit off wagon on Grogu?
Interacted with Jeff here which is good. I did try to make it like a defusing explanation you give to town.
Shang could have reasonably used both accounts to push Dynamite right?
Shade on Dynamite voters?
I do think the other half of Shang is a neutral as well and probably not a town friendly one.
Somewhere between Mew and Fozzie would be a good place to look.
Wanted to look at Mew and Fozzie
Fozzie did you act last night?
Role fishing
I don't know how much this helps things but I figure I'll just come out with it. I'm a Poison Mirror, if someone tries to attack me with poison it bounces back to them. I tried looking on the wiki to see if poison is more likely a Scum or Neutral thing but I couldn't be sure.

Fozzie insisting that Shang's other half, which as others have said could very well be Fozzie is nothing to worry about is making me nervous here. The only thing I'm not sure about is if a neutral poisoner would be worth flipping today or if we can shelf it and hunt scum.
Claim post, shades Fozzie.
Fozzie is looking increasingly calculated to me here, that Charlie vote doesn't look like their genuine best thoughts on hitting Scum.
Vote: Fozzie Bear
Last post is on Fozzie, then never shows up again.
Pretty focused on Fozzie and Charlie. Didn't interact with most of the roster. Voice is not crazy dissimilar to the Jeff voice but not necessarily distinct either (I hope?)
Lack of interaction with Mew and timing of the claim when Mew was on the block could be notable, unsure if I bring that up first or see if someone else goes there.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
The other thing I did with Piggy was capitalize Scum but that is also somewhat common, thankfully have kept it lowercase with Jeff.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Oscar needs more scrutiny. Puts down the first vote of the game, seemingly a joke vote that she gets heat on because of rng, then fades into the background. That reads like scared scum who wanted to fade back into the shadows.
I still kind of stand by this post. Oscar did vanish a bit. I'd place a bet Oscar is the role with the PR, but Mew then Fozzie were so damn loud about Mew's unvote that Oscar is as much a risk as Bert. A protector or watcher role might think Bert is so obvious and find Oscar the sneakier role to target for safety. BUT if we gamble with Mew and succeed in killing, maybe I'd still be happy with that if Oscar is a strong PR? And hell, if Oscar is thee watcher/tracker, they aren't going to see themselves getting killed.

HRM HRM HRM.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
In fact, Oscar voted for Mew and was going for them. So if Oscar happens to be a tracker and watches Mew kill their alt...lol

There are so many possibilities here that it's going to be 100% possible to nail this, but I'm now leaning towards Oscar and using Mew. Ugh. I dunno. What do you think?
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Also my "intended" pair of Jeff is Kermit. Both missed end of day 1 and both suspected Grogu for similar reasons. I put Kermit as my protect as well.

The worst thing anyone has on Jeff is this post
Piggy abandons the Dynamite vote here. Could be prescient knowing Dynamite will flip town? Or they could have realized that Dynamite was likely vanilla and tried to redirect to bait PR claims.
The more I think about it, the more scummy vibes I get from this post.

I think it's the convoluted logic and assumption that Miss Piggy is definitely scum. Which... Why? Townes vote for townies all the time

Total doody
Howdy totally clocked that I was solving as if Piggy flipped scum before we knew that for sure. I threw them off the trail a bit yesterday but "assumption that piggy is definitely scum" is going to hurt in the morning.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
In fact, Oscar voted for Mew and was going for them. So if Oscar happens to be a tracker and watches Mew kill their alt...lol

There are so many possibilities here that it's going to be 100% possible to nail this, but I'm now leaning towards Oscar and using Mew. Ugh. I dunno. What do you think?
Could have Mew kill Topo while Abby blocks Oscar, should be relatively safe to any variation of where the PR is on that account?
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
Yeah...and we're putting a lot on Oscar just being confident in Charlie being town, which isn't a crazy thing to be confident on D2.

I could use Abby and kill Topo also. Maybe that is safest bet right now.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Cause like maybe we just ninja the movement role and if we miss maybe they are 2-shot and reveal. Feel like ninja abby is mostly useful late game if Abby is solo scum
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
How precious are you about saving the ninja?
I thought about it, but the more I ponder the more I think watcher is too damn strong and not a power we see much here. I don't think it's necessary to use tonight because low liklihood of Abby being specifically tracked. Then if Abby dies wind up making it to end game, that ninja becomes a lot more useful.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
I thought about it, but the more I ponder the more I think watcher is too damn strong and not a power we see much here. I don't think it's necessary to use tonight because low liklihood of Abby being specifically tracked. Then if Abby dies wind up making it to end game, that ninja becomes a lot more useful.
Ok in that case I'm probably 60/40 for having Mew do a vanilla kill over Abby. If a watcher even exists, I really doubt they are on Topo. Then the risk is Mew being tracked vs Abby. I think Mew is more likely to be tracked but Abby being tracked is more devastating.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
I also think watcher might be less likely due to the pair dynamic, you could do a lot of setups where you make yourself a good target for scum and then watch yourself.
 

Mr. Mew

Costume
While it'd suck to lose Abby, ponder that Mew and Abby went at it a lot. If Abby dies, I am confident Mew absorbs her town power and becomes stronger for it. The only stink is losing the remaining abilities she hasn't used, which yeah....we could just play safe and use ninja. But what jerk out there is tracking Abby!

Hrm

I'll leave final decision up to you! I can't decide
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
I think Mew to Topo. I think figuring out that Piggy claim was to save Mew is semi-advanced vs the more obvious Piggy claimed due to the pressure against her. And stuff like this at EoD
I'm here, but with what is happening there's no shot I'm convincing anyone to go for lamb or dog.
I think I would just read town. Like dead scum lit up on the board and still chasing your own reads.
 
Top Bottom