Fozzie buys the claim and thinks poison will clear her.The timing is impeccable. Regardless, in what world do you think this is a good time to claim this?
VOTE: Charlie McCarthy
Miss Piggy is a useless vote now. We can come back to her later if there is no sign of poison by mid-late game.
I'm aware of what I said about Charlie earlier. He heavily changed my mind with all the peacocking he did pretending to work through the Shang thig.
I guess I don't see Mr Mew being overtly town. Went through his posts again, he heavily tunnels Oscar throughout, which is an easy stance for scum to take especially with a player like oscar who has had middling focus. Lightly shades Abby but doesn't do much with it. Says Fozzie bears investigation but doesn't do anything with that either. I might buy that they are a PR, but the Oscar tunnel has been present since D1.
That said, I could do a last minute for Miss Piggy out of the contenders. Some people believe pigs are as intelligent as dogs, but they've never met Miss Piggy AHAHAHAHA
I keed, I keed
Ok I missed Miss Pigg's claim lol
Triumph sets up to vote Piggy and then seems to indicate they like the claim.Honestly, I prefer an early claim than 10 minutes before the deadline
Elmo states a dislike without much reasoning.Elmo doesn't love miss piggy's claim.
Howdy setups to dislike the claim unless poison is real. Scum knew poison was real.This is easy, Miss Piggy's claim is likely false because nobody has come forward to claim they've been poisoned.
Even if it was x-shot I think a poisoner would want to use their powers asap
VOTE: Miss Piggy
I still don't like Fozzie or Jeff. Could come around on a quiet player like Kermit or Pinnochio
Pinocchio doubts the claim.A poisoner plus poison mirror in a normal complexity game sounds like a bit much. I don't really buy that claim.
Grogu too.That Miss Piggy claim is strange; I don't like it. Unless someone who was poisoned also died, which is a possibility. But I doubt that
VOTE: Miss Piggy
I think so. Would be more bastard than usual if not.
Triumph runs some interference here, trying to make excuses for piggy.Well poison kills are typically delayed by a day phase. So they would die tonight
Abby hems and haws a lot.I don't hate this....I likely would've moved my vote off of you already if I had someone stronger in my mind.
Just gonna hang tight in hopes Grogu about to drop some hot knowledge on us.
Pinocchio works up to a vote.vote: Miss Piggy
Gonna put my money where my mouth is.
Kutaro has doubt on the claim.I feel better about Grogu today.
Definitely think this piggy claim is iffy. And I'd rather vote there than mew today.
Kermit reveals.I'm the poison person, 1 shot and used it, person will die midway next day, I think they are scum so won't say who they are in case scum has an antidote.
Kutaro wants one of piggy or kermit.Yeah I'm not sure how to feel about this. Kind of still want to see where it goes flipping one of either piggy or Kermit now.
Abby still stalling. This might look better because it's pretty clear Piggy is toast at this point.I'd love all of you if you didn't hammer since I have to run away and cook, but I'll be back! ( I don't have any wisdom, just hoping Piggy shows up? Not sure it'll change much)
Mew doesn't go piggy the whole time, doesn't respond much to the claim. The obliviousness of still pushing for their personal reads kinda reads town here?I'm here, but with what is happening there's no shot I'm convincing anyone to go for lamb or dog.
:DI'm having fun here in scum chat Rando, I like designs that allow for a good amount of solving as scum :D
Command ReceivedKill: Topo Gigio
As a sledgehammer. Not gonna worry about it too much today, just gonna note that oscar/charlie/howdy won't be good pushesOh my god. Oscar is absolutely a cop or something lmao. That's not even subtle, right?
Howdy is the 2nd check or whatever mechanical clear they got.But if they checked Fozzie, that means Fozzie isn't going anywhere today. So yeah---Oscar has to die tonight, right? Bert is confirmed town, but now so is Charlie, and Fozzie. That confirmed town list is growing. Grossss.
Lmao. You are mad. I love it.Maybe this is me tilting / sunk cost fallacy but we do have the potential to do a very funny thing by leaving Oscar and their bread loaf sized crumbs alone all game lol.
Lmao. Love that we just posted similar thoughts same timeI guess you were right about the sniping/bickering. Unclear if it gets to a point where Bert votes Fozzie but looks like Fozzie will continue to ruffle feathers by insisting they are right.
Yeah. I am surprised at some of it. But some people busy as heck and that's playing a factor. I will say I love playing a game that doesn't have 30+ pages to reread.Nobody's been too motivated to reread this small game which is nice for us.
In terms on my night action, I won't reveal my target, but yes it's who you think it is. Will make sense after my flip
Lol. My mafia knowledge is still crap so I'm really clueless what on earth it might be.
So Oscar has no investigation and has been baiting scum like we thought in one of our 103890192312 conjectures?I’m a weak hider of limited but as of now I am not revealing how many shots.
if the poison had happened last night I would be poisoned too.
So I’m pissed
The weakness is the investigation, they die if they visit scum. But they're not pre-empting their visits and I think we offed their 2nd account with Topo so we maybe we don't have to deal with them.So Oscar has no investigation and has been baiting scum like we thought in one of our 103890192312 conjectures?
Oooh. I thought it was a role that hid with someone purely to try and stay safe. Didn't realize they investigate. Dumb question, but if we try to kill Oscar and they're hiding does that mean we miss?The weakness is the investigation, they die if they visit scum. But they're not pre-empting their visits and I think we offed their 2nd account with Topo so we maybe we don't have to deal with them.
What on earth is SGF?Watching SGF but I can hop in for a bit. I think I need to give up with hoping I can match with Kermits play or activity if they are gonna be sleep for most of the time I have free
They hide behind one of us = they dieOooh. I thought it was a role that hid with someone purely to try and stay safe. Didn't realize they investigate. Dumb question, but if we try to kill Oscar and they're hiding does that mean we miss?
Nice. Thank you.They hide behind one of us = they die
They don't hide (out of shots/ saving a shot) and we target a kill = they die
They hide behind X and we kill Oscar = no one dies
They hide behind X and we kill X = X and Oscar die
Seconded on not wanting to see anyone go out to modkill. In fact, LET THEM BREAK THE RULES. WE'LL MURDER THEM ALL ANYWAY.Maybe it's okay cause the rules talk about revealing after they die.
@Randomless sorry for the annoying rules questions but where does "my alt is dead already" sit
I'm guessing Oscar is okay cause its very much implied and I generally don't wanna see anyone go down to a modkill
Seconded on not wanting to see anyone go out to modkill. In fact, LET THEM BREAK THE RULES. WE'LL MURDER THEM ALL ANYWAY.
![]()
Kermits kills are on a 2 day delay. So by the time we catch them, they can have had 2 more kills lined up.If we lose another player in the middle of the day tomorrow Kermit can be kermitted. If you're for lamb or triumph though, why not come on over here. I've got plenty of space at the table.
Sure thing, we should see dead howdy in the next hour which will just stir the pot more.All right, my good murdering friend. I have to run and make supper. I'll drop back in later tonight to see what has gone down!
You could absolutely claim from your other account, you just couldn't say the results came from that other account.I guess it's worth us asking
@Randomless if we had a role that got results at night, we would be allowed to claim the results from account B even if they were delivered to account A - correct?
Saying your alt is dead is against the rules.Maybe it's okay cause the rules talk about revealing after they die.
@Randomless sorry for the annoying rules questions but where does "my alt is dead already" sit
I'm guessing Oscar is okay cause its very much implied and I generally don't wanna see anyone go down to a modkill
Ooh how come, I didn't catch that one.So, Lamb is Howdy.
Howdy as Lambs investigate.P: Elmo, because nothing has really made me want to protect someone but they feel genuine in their confusion
I: Howdy
K: Mr. Mew
Ahhh Mr mew is most likely town
Disagree on Mew.With takes like these? Doubt, Kermit is 100% town.
Vote: Mr. Mew
I agree we shouldn't make assumptions about Mr Mew, especially in a game where everyone has two accounts. I guess for me the thing was when Mr Mew was going hard for Oscar and then suddenly unvoted. Now I know it's because he saw Oscar's claim about Charlie and assumed an investigative role. So that behavior reads town to me.
Of course, I've acted similarly in the past as scum though.
The timing of the Unvote felt town to me though somehow
More disagreement on MewWorth a shot right? I mean it worked, if Mr. Mew had a good ability they kept them alive AND convinced everyone they're town. I'm not saying all that because they vote for me, but the whole "actually Mr. Mew is town now" feels ridiculous.
Lamb is one of the few kermit defenders and doesn't see him as neutral.With takes like these? Doubt, Kermit is 100% town.
Vote: Mr. Mew
More kermit defense and recalled something grogu said to kermit.You said this last phase too, something about a heist. There is 0 scenarios where Kermit is scum, we can debate neutral but not scum.
More kermit defense.Because
A. Kermit is telling the truth and is scum, first why draw attention to them, second why would scum have the poison and the poison mirror
B. Kermit is no poisoner and lied to gain town cred, again why bring attention to them and why open themselves up to a counter claim by the sure to exist actual poisoner.
Like am I crazy?
Spec on when kermit will show up.They still need to do 10 posts to avoid replacement so they might start posting before poison kicks in.
Was waiting to see who would engage pre-poisonI like this post, Grogu has been slightly hitting my scum radar every since day 1, that post totally feels like "Yeah I'm not gonna engage with the game at all until Kermit's poison hits"
More kermit defense. Also note, they tend to have, like just a few, too many commas. Here's the same thing from Kermit:Anyway the whole Kermit thing is ok by me, was already town reading them, the lie was whatever, wouldn't have done it myself but ok.
Kermit also likes using "Ok" at the start of a sentence and "btw, tbh, idk" and Lamb has some of these tooBecause I assumed that's where it went, and if that's the case I wanna know why, maybe they saw something I didn't, like if it didn't go to Oscar fine I don't mind, but Oscar felt very random.
Ooh. OKay...I think you might be right. Good catch. I say both as a Maybe.Ah gotcha, took a look:
Howdy as Lambs investigate.
Disagree on Mew.
More disagreement on Mew
I had a different thought - that lamb reacting to howdys flip was Kermit checking his handywork.
I think I convinced myself on Kermit and Lamb there.Kermit never mentions or quotes lamb.
Lamb is one of the few kermit defenders and doesn't see him as neutral.
More kermit defense and recalled something grogu said to kermit.
More kermit defense.
Spec on when kermit will show up.
Was waiting to see who would engage pre-poison
More kermit defense. Also note, they tend to have, like just a few, too many commas. Here's the same thing from Kermit:
Kermit also likes using "Ok" at the start of a sentence and "btw, tbh, idk" and Lamb has some of these too
I was wondering that myself. I noticed the flavor matched a bit, but I couldn't take the thought any further because I had no clue who would be what else.BTW it occurred to me that the roles have matched the flavor pretty well (except Howdy who seems a little random)
So is Grogu our protector (force healing)?
And maybe Triumph as a tracker? (bio days he's a mountain hound)
What I truly don't understand is how you can go yesterday being so very nonchalant about, "you can flip me now, this account useless" to this. I still think they're a neutral who has a wincon they're close to winning and is upset they're potentially going to die before.Awh I feel bad for Kermit there :(
Detriment? True. Giving a Shit? False. Maybe I'm just a weird ass scum player. I'm here to play, not to win. If I have two accounts and lose one:I don't think Scum having two accounts changes the approach too drastically. There's still the same number of Scum accounts as there would be in a normal game, so losing one still is a detriment.
Hrm. I didn't think we could do this, but Triumph might give us a path to Grogu.I'm thinking if Grogu could be a doc it might be worth a punt to start a late day wagon on them when they don't have time to effectively respond
Yeah tbh I'm having more fun solo as it is easier to manage and I have less to worry about in connecting my two accounts. I do think it was harder to decide to bus or stack with yourself than it would be with 4 different minds tho.Detriment? True. Giving a Shit? False. Maybe I'm just a weird ass scum player. I'm here to play, not to win. If I have two accounts and lose one:
![]()
Definitely not going to force it but if grogu feels relatively safe and isn't around much I'm happy to swing to them in the last 10-15 minsHrm. I didn't think we could do this, but Triumph might give us a path to Grogu.
*shots lolThat was fun! Prolly be busy most of the rest of the night, but we have some fun decisions to make. I'll start with the most obvious toughie:
-Does Oscar have any more shots of their ability? Do we risk leaving Oscar alive hoping they don't? If Oscar dies, their flip confirms all their town reads. If they stay alive, and are out of shorts, suspicion can fester.
Nope it is active the whole gameBtw @Randomless my vote bomb doesn't get switched off in endgame or anything like that right?
Oscar's anger was (I think) genuine when they got pissed at Kermit for nearly poisoning them with Howdy, which leads me to believe they are a real Weak Hider. If they hid with you, they'd be dead. So they got nuthin as far as I'm concerned. This is just recency bias because Kutaro called you out before death, but for what? You wanting to vote Grogu who has been on other people's lists as possible scum? They're case is weak, so you have room to defend yourself just fine. I'm not very worried.All good, personal and family stuff always come before this silly little game!
Seems to have worked out ok so far.
Triumph might have tracked Pinocchio and got no movement, I don't see how they go to that vanilla comment otherwise.
Oscar could be a cop with 3 shots with a red check on me which would really suck but for now just gonna deny deny deny until they come out with it. :/
Probably won't be around too much as I said in the main thread
I just don't like how short and pointed Oscar is being, kinda reads like they have something and are watching reactions since they ignored me asking for justification on their read.I didn’t hide last night.
I genuinely think they got jack shit.Maybe 2 shots of weak hider and a 1 shot police badge they found in their trash can or something. Anyway I'll still throw some reads out there in case this is a gambit
Fingers crossed :)
The funny thing is I think the person making the posts is thinking about the activity lining up a lot more than anyone reading them.This is really fun and hard to juggle two accounts. You can't have both show up at once and make it obvious who is paired. I just have to show up, talk a lot with one, vanish. Come back later, talk a lot with the other, vanish.
![]()
Mew's turn.