Puppet Mafia | Everyone's wearing socks

puppet-mafia-banner.png


The most famous puppets in all the land received invitations in the mail to an extravagant show at the Grand Puppet Theatre. 'Twas an incredible honour to merely attend a show at this theatre, let alone star in a production there. The invitations promised that a contest would be held, with the winners offered a chance to debut a show of their choosing. None of the invitees could resist the allure of such a promise.

Twenty guests slowly streamed into the auditorium on the chosen day. Excited murmurs echoed through the crowd. Finally, the lights grew dim, and the doors locked. The Master of Ceremonies, Geno, stepped on stage, illuminated by the stage lights. As he walked up to the microphone and began to speak, the lights and sound cut out. Panicked screams from the audience pierced the silence. The lights returned quickly, but Geno was now lying on the ground. His strings were cut and his pieces lay scattered. He was dead.

Geno has died!

Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Geno. You are aligned with the Good Puppets (that is, TOWN).

The literal star of the show in Super Mario RPG. After saving the world, you retired to a prestigious position as the Master of Ceremonies of the Grand Puppet Theatre.

You are the Sample Flip. Thoughts and prayers for your loss.

You have the ability to vote.

You win when all threats to the Good Puppets are eliminated.

Costume Name: Sorry
Costume Password: Nope
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.

Gamerunner: Randomless
Gamewatchers: [REDACTED]
Reviewer: Faddy
Complexity: Normal
Key Mechanics: Unusual, Costume
Players: 10
Day/Night Cycle: 48/24
Day Start/End Time: 23:00 UTC

!player_list
[They/Them] Pinocchio - UTC+10
[He/Him] Bert - UTC-7
[He/Him] Abby Cadabby - UTC-5
[He/Him] Lamb Chop - UTC
[They/Them] Howdy Doody - UTC-6
[They/Them] Fozzie Bear - UTC-5
[She/Her] Miss Piggy - UTC-5
[He/Him] Mr. Mew - UTC-4
[She/Her] Shang Bu Huan - UTC-8
[He/Him] Grogu - UTC-5
[He/Him] Dynamite Headdy - UTC-5
[He/Him] Kutaro - UTC-5
[She/Her] Oscar the Grouch - UTC-6
[He/Him] Kermit the Frog - UTC
[She/Her] Elmo - UTC+1
[He/They] Ernie - UTC-24
[He/Him] Charlie McCarthy - UTC+2
[They/Them] Topo Gigio - UTC-6
[He/Him] Jeff Tracy - UTC
[She/Her] Triumph the Comic Dog - UTC-5
!player_list

Replacements
[REDACTED]

Mentorship program
For new and returning players who would like some assistance, we offer a mentorship program where a volunteer veteran player can assist you. If you are interested in having a mentor for this game, please contact your gamerunner. For more info, please check the main MafiERA OT.

We also have a collection of resources for players you can find HERE.
 
Last edited:
What Is Mafia?
Mafia, also known as Werewolf, is a famous social deduction game that puts two teams against each other: Town and Mafia. Mafia players know who everyone in their team is, while Town players only know their own alignment. Cut into two 'Phases', Day and Night, the game entails Town trying to eliminate the Mafia via discussion and voting while the Mafia are trying to not get caught in order to match or outnumber the Town in order to win.

Interested in joining or learning more? Check out our MafiERA OT!

Fundamentals:
1. All site-wide rules apply here.
2. Do not use slurs or bigoted language.
3. Please do not put active players on an ignore list during a game.
4. Unless explicitly told otherwise, players may not discuss this game outside of this thread.
5. Unless the gamerunner explicitly states otherwise, players may not quote or repost conversations or posts from outside of this thread. Players may NOT quote a majority of their role PMs.
6. Players are allowed to lie, within reason, about any game-related material such as the content of a role PM.
7. Please do not refer to, or discuss, player activity outside of this thread, for the sake of the game's integrity. This includes discussing circumstances around player replacement. Players (including the replacing player) should not refer to reasons for or behavior around replacements.
8. Please respect all of your fellow community members in terms of personhood and accessibility. In this community we require that you respect person's pronouns and be aware of accessibility when using non-default text (do not change text color unnecessarily and be mindful of small and large fonts' impact on readability).
9. Failure to adhere to a player's personal pronoun will result in a private warning. On the second offense that player will be removed from the game.

Game Behavior:
10. While mafia can be an intense and stressful game, with play becoming heated at times, please try to keep discussion as respectful and congenial as possible. Take a break if you feel heated. If someone is breaking a rule you are encouraged to alert your gamerunner and game watchers. Reports about in-game action and behavior will be handled by them, and the gamerunner will issue final rulings in the event of disagreements. If you need any support or assistance, reach out to a gamerunner or watcher.
11. Being overly hostile towards your fellow players is not allowed. If the gamerunner and game watchers find a player has been overly aggressive, action will be taken. First a private warning via PM will be given. Failure to stop the behavior will then result in another private warning and the offender will be given a priority penalty. If these behaviors still continue then that player will be removed from the game.
12. Treat players, gamerunners, and game watchers with respect. Players who are bothered by behavior they perceive as uncomfortable or as targeted aggression should make their positions clear in game as everyone has a different threshold. If a player feels someone has crossed a line they should contact the gamerunner and game watchers, listed in the first post, about the issue.
13. Players should not perform moderator actions in game, including using highlight text outside of voting, using highlight text to submit false or restricted commands, issuing day-end/start commands, or calling for the modkill or replacement of another player. Encouraging others to break these rules is also not allowed. While we understand mafia can be an intense experience, and players may wish to discuss in-game moderation decisions with the gamerunner, once a gamerunner makes a decision, please respect it as final.

Activity:
14. Players are required to post a minimum of 10 posts per day phase. Failure to adhere to this will result in a private warning. On the second offense that player will be removed from the game.
15. If a player posts fewer than 5 posts in a day phase without alerting the gamerunner to their absence, they will be removed from the game without a warning.
16. If you are unable to continue playing for whatever reason, please contact your gamerunner.
17. If a replacement is added to the game, they may request the current/upcoming night phase to be extended up-to 48 hours to allow time to catch up.
18. Please do not theorize or discuss the reasons behind a player's replacement during a game.
19. Do not talk about replacing out of the game. Please contact the gamerunner.

Voting:
20. In order to vote for another player to be voted out, you must present it on its own line and in the following format with no spaces: [ HIGHLIGHT ]VOTE: playername[ /HIGHLIGHT ]. Any other format will not be accepted.
21. To remove a vote from a player, you may simply vote for another player, or you may present it on its own line and in the following format with no spaces: [ HIGHLIGHT ]UNVOTE[ /HIGHLIGHT ].
22. Players may vote for a "No Vote" to end the day phase without a player being voted out. This is done by using the formatting above and typing: [ HIGHLIGHT ]VOTE: No Vote[ /HIGHLIGHT ].
23. When a player has received a strict majority of available votes (>50%), the day phase ends with the removal of that player. Once a day phase has ended any in-game discussion stops and votes cast after that will not be counted.

Death and the Spectator Thread:
24. Once you are dead, you may no longer discuss the game in any manner with any of the remaining players.

Other:
25. Do not edit your posts or hide content in the formatting. Repeat offenders will be removed from the game.
26. If a player is replaced or modkilled due to any rule-breaking or being under the minimum post count limit, they will have end-game priority when signing up for a spot in their next game.
27. Gamerunners reserve the right to add, remove, or modify existing any rules at any point, and enforcement may be applied retrospectively. However, all players will be informed of changes beforehand.
28. Players may not be replaced during the last third of an ongoing phase; replacements at that point may be held until end-of-phase. This will be up to the gamerunner and the player's discretion. (This rule is in testing phase.)

Game Specific Rules:
29. Do not reveal who your alt-account is, or what your true ResetEra/OuterMafia identity is. If you reveal your alt-account or your true identity, you will be Modkilled. If you get too close to revealing your alt-account or true identity you will receive a Warning, upon which you will be modkilled if you do it again or reveal you were warned.
Specifics about this rule:
A. No confirming or denying someone as your alt-account or true identity.
B. No hints about your alt-account or true identity.
C. No revealing who your alt-account was after they have died.
D. Speculating on other players’ alt-accounts and true identities is allowed, but you cannot comment on others’ speculation of yourself.
E. Examples of violations include:
“My Era avatar has a duck in it”
“I don’t post much on Era, only in the WeebEra OT”
“One of my accounts is Vanilla”
“I’ve never voted for my alt”
“Oops wrong account”

30. All replacements will be silent. If you need to replace out, please do so quietly by privately messaging the gamerunner so as to avoid giving away which accounts are linked. If you loudly replace out you may be Modkilled depending on the severity of the infraction.

31. All prior rules apply to both user accounts, including the respecting of pronouns and the 10 posts per day minimum.

32. If one account dies, the other continues on as normal. You will only be entered into spec chat once both accounts have died.
 
Last edited:
Recommendations for How To Play this Game:

As this game will involve switching back and forth between two separate costume accounts, here are some recommendations to play this game as smoothly as possible and minimize the friction of posting with the wrong account.

  1. Use two separate internet browsers, one for each account. If you normally use Google Chrome, you can remain signed in to Outer Mafia for one account on Google Chrome, and use another browser, like Firefox, Microsoft Edge, or Safari, to remain signed in as your other account.
  2. Alternatively, you may use the same browser as normal, but utilize Incognito (Private Browsing) window (or tab) functionality to sign in as your alternate account in the Incognito window. In Google Chrome for example, the Incognito window uses visible imagery that makes it very obvious you are now Incognito. That should help remind you which account is signed in to the Incognito window, and which is signed in to your normal window. The caveat for using a Private Browsing mode is that you will need to re-sign-in to your alt-account each time you close and reopen the Incognito window.
  3. Screen split your different windows so that each one is on a separate side of your screen. This will primarily work if you are playing the game on a PC or Mac, though some phones and tablets also have window splitting functionality. If you make it so that the left side of your screen is always a window signed into one account and the right side of your screen is a window signed into the other account, there is less opportunity for confusion.
  4. Use a password manager to store your costume account passwords. This will make signing into the accounts, as well as switching between them, easier. I recommend BitWarden. It is free and open source. It works with multiple browsers and mobile devices. There is even an offline version if you are paranoid about uploading your passwords to the cloud.
 
Last edited:
The doors remained locked. Even the strongest of the puppets could not get them to open. The trap had been sprung. Something sinister was afoot.

Thankfully, as everyone present was a puppet, they did not need to eat or drink, so the only threat was whoever murdered the Master of Ceremonies. Great news, indeed.

Day 1 Begins

Day 1 Ends in:
xfbu0s1sz6


Vote tool: https://vote.fireblend.com/om/968/
 
I figured I would come back to more content after being so late.

Oscar opening with an RNG vote is interesting but really doesn't tell me much.

Howdy Doody comes out of that mildly worse trying to pick a fight over nothing but its early enough that I guess that's fine.

Miss Piggy's random vote is at least more pure since she didn't hide behind actually calling it random.
 

Lamb Chop

Costume
I figured I would come back to more content after being so late.

Oscar opening with an RNG vote is interesting but really doesn't tell me much.

Howdy Doody comes out of that mildly worse trying to pick a fight over nothing but its early enough that I guess that's fine.

Miss Piggy's random vote is at least more pure since she didn't hide behind actually calling it random.
Most people were probably too bored to switch accounts.
 

Topo Gigio

Costume
I mean what are you as in, where are you famous? I was famous in Italy, but also had a run in South America, Japan and late night talk shows (specifically the Ed Sullivan show)
 
I mean what are you as in, where are you famous? I was famous in Italy, but also had a run in South America, Japan and late night talk shows (specifically the Ed Sullivan show)
I didn't know mine either but I didn't know a few of these. Apparently I'm out of a japanese-taiwan production. But that's really all I looked at.

I should be around most of today so I'll probably be faster to respond. I'm not mad at Fozzie copying a vote if nothing else because maybe it'll get Dynamite in here and generate some content.
 

Jeff Tracy

Costume
VOTE: Oscar the Grouch

Blaming your vote on "ooo rng" feels like a scum move
The random votes don't really move the needle for me but the way you jumped on this feels a tad forced?
It could be that cursed avatar giving me the heebie jeebies.
Topo gigio is a deep cut.
Is it? I have one in my fridge. Fake edit: On further inspection, that's a Topo Chico.
Abby Cadabby sounds like the name of a Lord Voldemort child in a silly fan fiction.
I myself am a big fan of the works of Ms. Scribe.
 
Hello folks! I don't like how Headdy has 2 D's I wish it only had one. I don't really have anything to contribute besides explosive puns so let's blow this game wide open! But more on topic, as much as Day 1 is NAI (especially in costume game shenanagins like this), it's interesting to see people coming out of the gate trying to solve and other people just going full meme (which is totally fine!) might just be interesting to look at later.
 

Grogu

Costume
It's not real Sesame Street representation unless that damn rock is here. Evening, all. It seems like most people have poked their heads in here, but not everyone. I'm sure that'll change as we get used to this.
 
The random votes don't really move the needle for me but the way you jumped on this feels a tad forced?
It could be that cursed avatar giving me the heebie jeebies.

Is it? I have one in my fridge. Fake edit: On further inspection, that's a Topo Chico.

I myself am a big fan of the works of Ms. Scribe.
Basically what I said last night too. Maybe there is some scheming already but a lot of the votes so far are likely just blind guesses and a bit of copying others (The headdey votes) but that one in particular reads like a forced reaction.
 
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Dynamite Headdy (1 votes)
Miss Piggy - #25

Jeff Tracy (1 votes)
Oscar the Grouch - #21

Not voting: Kutaro, Mr. Mew, Jeff Tracy, Kermit the Frog, Topo Gigio, Ernie, Lamb Chop, Shang Bu Huan, Abby Cadabby, Howdy Doody, Dynamite Headdy, Fozzie Bear, Pinocchio, Charlie McCarthy, Elmo, Bert, Triumph the Comic Dog, Grogu

Post Counts:
Abby Cadabby: 8 Charlie McCarthy: 4 Topo Gigio: 4 Shang Bu Huan: 4 Pinocchio: 3 Fozzie Bear: 2 Mr. Mew: 2 Kermit the Frog: 2 Bert: 2 Howdy Doody: 2 Dynamite Headdy: 1 Oscar the Grouch: 1 Elmo: 1 Triumph the Comic Dog: 1 Jeff Tracy: 1 Miss Piggy: 1 Ernie: 1 Lamb Chop: 1 Grogu: 1

Current Countdown:
xfbu0s1sz6



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 

Ernie

Costume
The random votes don't really move the needle for me but the way you jumped on this feels a tad forced?
It could be that cursed avatar giving me the heebie jeebies.

Is it? I have one in my fridge. Fake edit: On further inspection, that's a Topo Chico.

I myself am a big fan of the works of Ms. Scribe.
That's a fine mineral water. At least my duckie seems to love it.

images


So far I agree that the way howdy latched on the vote seems opportunistic.

Abby Cadabby sounds like the name of a Lord Voldemort child in a silly fan fiction.
That's a good one Bert! If you read it as Addy Cababby it's like you are asking for more vegetables in your meal!
 

Bert

Costume
That's a fine mineral water. At least my duckie seems to love it.

images


So far I agree that the way howdy latched on the vote seems opportunistic.


That's a good one Bert! If you read it as Addy Cababby it's like you are asking for more vegetables in your meal!
Thanks Ernie, your duck is very cool too. Now stay in your side of the room.

Oh nevermind, both people did the same misspelling lol I feel like that tells me a lot.
What are the odds.
 
To be fair, I realized I also spelled the name wrong too when I was re-reading so probably doesn’t mean much in retrospect.
 
I wanted to be cute and try to find a puppet pair but yes, I am literally backpedaling when I realized the case was weaker than I thought.
 

Bert

Costume
I wanted to be cute and try to find a puppet pair but yes, I am literally backpedaling when I realized the case was weaker than I thought.
Why care about how weak the case is, any morsel of case is good enough this early in the game.
 
Fair. But you don't seem that interested of pursuing any leads to find a bad team either.
It's not like I have much more to work on. I like the dynamite votes because it's at least applying pressure and he didn't seem very concerned about the votes on him. And I've already said that Howdy Doody is really the only one that smells mildly bad at the moment with the forced vote but that's barely anything.

I at least appreciate that you are trying to shade me now at least. It's a new thing to read and I like that you are trying to shift the game state.
 

Bert

Costume
It's not like I have much more to work on. I like the dynamite votes because it's at least applying pressure and he didn't seem very concerned about the votes on him. And I've already said that Howdy Doody is really the only one that smells mildly bad at the moment with the forced vote but that's barely anything.

I at least appreciate that you are trying to shade me now at least. It's a new thing to read and I like that you are trying to shift the game state.
Then you seem to be getting ready to vote howdy so far, right?
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
If we find Scum and know the pair, we have found two Scum.
Assuming everyone has a pair and we don't have any singles out there (neutrals?). PURELY SPECULATION.

I like the idea though. Until we vote out someone townie because we think they were part of a scum pair and goof. But we can worry about that later. We haven't spilled a drop of stuffing yet.
 

Grogu

Costume
Assuming everyone has a pair and we don't have any singles out there (neutrals?). PURELY SPECULATION.

I like the idea though. Until we vote out someone townie because we think they were part of a scum pair and goof. But we can worry about that later. We haven't spilled a drop of stuffing yet.
It is a normal complexity game, so while I do think we might have a neutral single or pair running around, I suspect it won't end up too confusing on that front. I feel less like pair-hunting will provide as much value, though, as it would really just be conjecture unless someone has a pair related invest role
 
For the record, partners, I think Bert and Ernie being pairs would be far too obvious, and would spoil the fun. But maybe it's all for memes anyway and they could be pairs. I don't think any two people stand out as paired to me yet.
 

Abby Cadabby

Costume
For the record, partners, I think Bert and Ernie being pairs would be far too obvious, and would spoil the fun. But maybe it's all for memes anyway and they could be pairs. I don't think any two people stand out as paired to me yet.
I could go back-and-forth a million times on why they could or could not be the same. But seeing how well they're playing off one another for the sillies, I do kind of hope one is scum and one is town. The ultimate betrayal.
 
But seriously, what if all the sesame street characters were scum. Scum can totally be a team of 8 right?

Having said that, I like Abby so far, engaging the game in a good way.
 
Top Bottom