so yeah about my soul-read...
ehh
This is tough
I don't think it's Sorian.
I don't think it's darkside.
bo's Co To so no
They seem to be all revolving around that pool I was staring at since D2:
Hedin&
Wizard&
Maol
I haven't reassessed Terra fully, but my guts until now say not scum...?
I'm really torn about Geno... Geno as a claimed Item Thief, counterbalances The Wizard... but he only stole a loaf of bread... Prisoner 24601... which one is scum...
I could see melon being scum, I opined about that b4 I died
Salva et Wiz, I kinda see in a same light; although Salva's claim isn't corroborated at all like Wiz's is (Wiz claims to be item gifter, hasn't been countered, has an apparent mechanical counter in Geno), both got that scummy kind of interference-causing potentially saboteur-y Power (item-giving... graverobbing...) ellipses
I would say look back at the timing of Geno's Role-claim; did he claim to be a Thief AFTER Wiz's claim as Item-gifter? Maybe Wiz doesn't actually have an in-game counter, maybe scum!Geno saw an opportunity to fill that mechanical void riskily and so get elected to Town Council off the laurels of his claimed unique skillset that oh so complements Wiz's hmm
Did anyone corroborate Geno's Thieving? Can't remember. Didn't he say he stole off melon? Did melon ever mention if she got a message/PM confirmation about her held item being stolen...?
...also considering that during this game I was the best Miller this community ever had; this game itself seems to harbour the antihero-type Town Roles (I lost my draft of the list of all flips & claims so no receipts for this statement except what little is left in my head) so actually... I think I'm inclined to believe that Wizard is Town. Town-aligned Negative-utilities seems to be this game's gimmick? innit? iirc iirc iirc so Wiz is Town ok solved next whatever
but then... if Geno is scum in that reality; that means... he was created for the sole purpose of giving scum food poisoning?? Stealing shitty Happy Meals for scum to eat?? His scum!job was to sabotage his own faction by dumpster-diving at Night??? Would that really be a scum player slot? I don't think so? So Geno is... Town?
no wait, unless the Happy Meals effects CHANGE if they're stolen by scum? To be something useful/good instead??
...nah
ok so Geno is Town
That leaves:
melon
Salva
Hedin
Maol
ummm