I'm reading over Neon after you posted that gif to try and see if I can spot anything closer, and this is what I'm seeing so far.
Neon is incredibly focused on Chuggernaut to the point that they've mostly tunneled on Chuggernaut for both Day 1 and 2. When Exodus claimed, their immediate reaction was to read the role as either town or as a jester role, and when told that a jester role isn't really something that we do, they felt better about Exodus but weren't ruling out Neutral still. But, they were certain that Exodus was not scum. They often were not even interacting with Chuggernaut and still placing votes, most notably though Neon jumped away from this tunnel vision on Chuggernaut when the trains were EzekalRage vs oreo and they placed a vote on oreo.
After EzekalRage flipped scum, they did change their mind on Chuggernaut and started to expand their reads lists and start asking questions from other people. This is their most recent read list :
(Links here because lots of quotes not showing up here : https://www.resetera.com/threads/st...well-always-save-the-day.123801/post-22226634 https://www.resetera.com/threads/st...well-always-save-the-day.123801/post-22227108 )
They were pushing for a nin flip on Day 3, but that isn't really unusual. There aren't a ton of posts from Neon throughout the thread, and the first 2 days don't look great. But, I do feel that Day 3 is better even if they didn't hit scum. Honestly, looking at their history during all of this, I didn't see any other gifs or much joking around outside of the extreme early game so I am honestly learning towards Neon being the Party role. Their Day 2 is weird, and I'm going to keep an eye on them and hopefully get some answers tomorrow, but I think they're okay for now.
Neon is incredibly focused on Chuggernaut to the point that they've mostly tunneled on Chuggernaut for both Day 1 and 2. When Exodus claimed, their immediate reaction was to read the role as either town or as a jester role, and when told that a jester role isn't really something that we do, they felt better about Exodus but weren't ruling out Neutral still. But, they were certain that Exodus was not scum. They often were not even interacting with Chuggernaut and still placing votes, most notably though Neon jumped away from this tunnel vision on Chuggernaut when the trains were EzekalRage vs oreo and they placed a vote on oreo.
After EzekalRage flipped scum, they did change their mind on Chuggernaut and started to expand their reads lists and start asking questions from other people. This is their most recent read list :
(Links here because lots of quotes not showing up here : https://www.resetera.com/threads/st...well-always-save-the-day.123801/post-22226634 https://www.resetera.com/threads/st...well-always-save-the-day.123801/post-22227108 )
I do agree with other posters that this post in particular was weird and did paint you in a bad light. However, I don't think that this is conclusive evidence to you being scum (that comes later).
Yeah. In retrospective this wasn't a good move. Although in my eyes that gives more town reads in B-dubs favor. At the time I'm writing this, I read him as a townie that got too carried away with his power.
Was she defending Ezekel? At the time that theory sounded plausible. So I don't really put this against her.
Besides Exo, KetKat is one of the first to put some pressure against Zeke. Adding to that, Stan is the first one (this time I checked) to put the vote on Zeke. So I doubt he is scum (unless he planned early on in the day to buzz him, which is unlikely given that Zeke didn't stumble until later on in the day).
Slightly defending Zeke? He doesn't put himself in danger's way by saying he is null. But at the same time he putsforward the idea that he could be town based on meta.
Again, not voting for Zeke and insisting on voting Oreo while saying that he'd like to see how Chuggs flips.
Dunno. WSD is giving me scum vibes.
Then comes this weird exchange between nin and WSD. nin had already been pretty jumpy at the end of day, and trying to convince many people on jumping on the Chuggs wagon is highly suspect.
And in the end WSD decided to change votes to Chugg. Now I don't think two scums would vote for the same person at EOD. However, seeing as Zeke was the other leading wagon that day, maybe they were trying to save their buddy?
Slightly defending WSD while advocating for a Chugg lynch? There is also the fact that she only voted Zeke until the last minute. She has been a somewhat active player up until now however. That and her reasoning later on at the start of night 2 makes me read ehr as Null.
Okay. And that covers day 2. Now I only need to catch up on what has happened in the last 5 pages and I'm good to go.
(Playing catch up is not fun).
Yep. That is the effect of a lightning rod. Now the only question is if it was an item or was a one time thing that another player gave you.
OOC: Don't worry about it.
IC: Ok, now that the catching up is done I'll do a TLDR before my vote:
TLDR:
B-Dubs, Chuggs, Exo and Stan get slight town reads from me. I still can't trust you fully. But your actions so far seem like normal townies scumhunting.
Loki: So far, you classify as neutral to me. Apologies for thechoice of words, but most of the time you seem to be a duckling to Chuggs. Maybe is because you are new, and if you were mafia I don't think you would actually vote the same as Chuggs all the time.
Saw is Null leaning to town for the time being.
QK, KetKat and Reki are completely null reads for me. Queen Kong has passed by with mostly new player questions and hasn¿t left an impression on me. Her guessing of nin's "role" is weird, I wouldn't mind prodding further. KetKat has had a neutral game so far. And I can't pin Reki.
Z-Dubs is null leaning scum. He has been tunneling against exo for a while now and has relied mostly on flavor talk.
WSD, nin and oreo read as scum to me atm. nin's reactions come EOD2 were vey wishy washy. However I find it unlikely that all three of them are scum. I'm leaning slightly more in WSD direction cause of his weird "null" read on Zeke at the tail end of day 2, but that could be cause of his inactivity. I wouldn't be against an oreo vote tomorrow.
For now: Vote: nin
They were pushing for a nin flip on Day 3, but that isn't really unusual. There aren't a ton of posts from Neon throughout the thread, and the first 2 days don't look great. But, I do feel that Day 3 is better even if they didn't hit scum. Honestly, looking at their history during all of this, I didn't see any other gifs or much joking around outside of the extreme early game so I am honestly learning towards Neon being the Party role. Their Day 2 is weird, and I'm going to keep an eye on them and hopefully get some answers tomorrow, but I think they're okay for now.