Pair Thread This Chat Is Made of Love

I'm reading over Neon after you posted that gif to try and see if I can spot anything closer, and this is what I'm seeing so far.

Neon is incredibly focused on Chuggernaut to the point that they've mostly tunneled on Chuggernaut for both Day 1 and 2. When Exodus claimed, their immediate reaction was to read the role as either town or as a jester role, and when told that a jester role isn't really something that we do, they felt better about Exodus but weren't ruling out Neutral still. But, they were certain that Exodus was not scum. They often were not even interacting with Chuggernaut and still placing votes, most notably though Neon jumped away from this tunnel vision on Chuggernaut when the trains were EzekalRage vs oreo and they placed a vote on oreo.

After EzekalRage flipped scum, they did change their mind on Chuggernaut and started to expand their reads lists and start asking questions from other people. This is their most recent read list :

(Links here because lots of quotes not showing up here : https://www.resetera.com/threads/st...well-always-save-the-day.123801/post-22226634 https://www.resetera.com/threads/st...well-always-save-the-day.123801/post-22227108 )

I do agree with other posters that this post in particular was weird and did paint you in a bad light. However, I don't think that this is conclusive evidence to you being scum (that comes later).





Yeah. In retrospective this wasn't a good move. Although in my eyes that gives more town reads in B-dubs favor. At the time I'm writing this, I read him as a townie that got too carried away with his power.




Was she defending Ezekel? At the time that theory sounded plausible. So I don't really put this against her.




Besides Exo, KetKat is one of the first to put some pressure against Zeke. Adding to that, Stan is the first one (this time I checked) to put the vote on Zeke. So I doubt he is scum (unless he planned early on in the day to buzz him, which is unlikely given that Zeke didn't stumble until later on in the day).




Slightly defending Zeke? He doesn't put himself in danger's way by saying he is null. But at the same time he putsforward the idea that he could be town based on meta.




Again, not voting for Zeke and insisting on voting Oreo while saying that he'd like to see how Chuggs flips.


Dunno. WSD is giving me scum vibes.






Then comes this weird exchange between nin and WSD. nin had already been pretty jumpy at the end of day, and trying to convince many people on jumping on the Chuggs wagon is highly suspect.


And in the end WSD decided to change votes to Chugg. Now I don't think two scums would vote for the same person at EOD. However, seeing as Zeke was the other leading wagon that day, maybe they were trying to save their buddy?




Slightly defending WSD while advocating for a Chugg lynch? There is also the fact that she only voted Zeke until the last minute. She has been a somewhat active player up until now however. That and her reasoning later on at the start of night 2 makes me read ehr as Null.


Okay. And that covers day 2. Now I only need to catch up on what has happened in the last 5 pages and I'm good to go.


(Playing catch up is not fun).

Yep. That is the effect of a lightning rod. Now the only question is if it was an item or was a one time thing that another player gave you.




OOC: Don't worry about it.


IC: Ok, now that the catching up is done I'll do a TLDR before my vote:


TLDR:

B-Dubs, Chuggs, Exo and Stan get slight town reads from me. I still can't trust you fully. But your actions so far seem like normal townies scumhunting.


Loki: So far, you classify as neutral to me. Apologies for thechoice of words, but most of the time you seem to be a duckling to Chuggs. Maybe is because you are new, and if you were mafia I don't think you would actually vote the same as Chuggs all the time.


Saw is Null leaning to town for the time being.


QK, KetKat and Reki are completely null reads for me. Queen Kong has passed by with mostly new player questions and hasn¿t left an impression on me. Her guessing of nin's "role" is weird, I wouldn't mind prodding further. KetKat has had a neutral game so far. And I can't pin Reki.


Z-Dubs is null leaning scum. He has been tunneling against exo for a while now and has relied mostly on flavor talk.


WSD, nin and oreo read as scum to me atm. nin's reactions come EOD2 were vey wishy washy. However I find it unlikely that all three of them are scum. I'm leaning slightly more in WSD direction cause of his weird "null" read on Zeke at the tail end of day 2, but that could be cause of his inactivity. I wouldn't be against an oreo vote tomorrow.


For now: Vote: nin

They were pushing for a nin flip on Day 3, but that isn't really unusual. There aren't a ton of posts from Neon throughout the thread, and the first 2 days don't look great. But, I do feel that Day 3 is better even if they didn't hit scum. Honestly, looking at their history during all of this, I didn't see any other gifs or much joking around outside of the extreme early game so I am honestly learning towards Neon being the Party role. Their Day 2 is weird, and I'm going to keep an eye on them and hopefully get some answers tomorrow, but I think they're okay for now.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Okay that's a good read on neon and aligns with what I feel about him. I've been townreading him because what he has been contributing is decent, but day 3 and his summary is what made feel better about him despite him getting somethings wrong (exo voted first on Zeke, I should know I have a spreadsheet keeping track of when votes are made).
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Don't worry, you've been doing more than enough already. You're making a very convincing argument here for Z-beat and honestly you should bring these up once the day starts tomorrow. Just that list right there + a callout towards him could get a train going, or at the very least lead to some answers. I'll absolutely support voting there, although I might not put it down immediately to see where other people are falling

Thanks so much! I'm happy to hear that ;-; I'm really feeling good about suspecting Z-Beat so I will def make an argument if we aren't NK'd I'll work on the draft for it so I can make the post once we see the NK'd results and day 4 starts (if we are alive).

I really hope I get to make this argument now or the very least get my shot so I can hit Z-Beat. I really do feel like hitting him might answer some questions on exodus, and B-Dubs (Speaking of B-Dubs if you do have more smashes please don't steal my kill ;-;).
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Also good news is I made a spreadsheet of all the quotes I'll need for my evidence with links to said quotes so that'll hope. ^^
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Okay good news is that I did it. I made a draft on the thread and saved the draft so it's already to go.

The game plan is that at 10 am my time when it is confirmed whether we are dying or not, I'll go through it again and edit it to make sure it has all the final touches. I don't want to put too much effort into a post I may not get to make after all... though I will say.

If I got NK'd, then I am absolutely posting this in spec. chat because I may be really annoyed. Please game, just give me my shot or let me live TT_TT
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
So good news I guess is that Sawneeks has been suspicious of Z-beat for tunneling all game, so she might believe my argument (here's hoping she doesn't make a post against him before i can post mine).

That also means that if we die without the shot, there's hope for us yet that they'll catch Z if he's scum :_ )
 
It'll be okay! Hopefully they don't shoot one of us or Z-beat though, because that's going to be awkward if they do
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Though I doubt that since Z's tunnel has pretty much prevented him from being much of a threat, especially since a NK against him would make his two main suspects exo and Dubs more suspect.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Okay Pedro mentioned the night actions being locked so maybe I'll get the message from him? If I don't here by 10:30 I'm editing my post to make sure it's perfect and hoping for the best.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Question am I allowed to post my post in here so Ket can see it ahead of time? I know there's a whole rule about not quoting from OM which is why I have been making my posts differently worded then how I have them on here.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Sorry, I was at the dentist, which is why it was late.

But you're not allowed to put something in here and then post it in Era. Sorry. :( You can summarize, but that's all.
 
Oh, I thought this chat closed when night actions locked, so I didn't check it! Good to know we're not dead yet!

And don't worry too much about having your post perfect or anything like that. You've read over Z-beat and have some good things to question him with, and people will definitely understand
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Sorry, I was at the dentist, which is why it was late.

But you're not allowed to put something in here and then post it in Era. Sorry. :( You can summarize, but that's all.

Thanks for the info, I was wondering about that XD (It's why I've been making my posts as drafts in the mentor thread but never actually posting them.)

Oh, I thought this chat closed when night actions locked, so I didn't check it! Good to know we're not dead yet!

And don't worry too much about having your post perfect or anything like that. You've read over Z-beat and have some good things to question him with, and people will definitely understand

Yeah that's what I'm hoping. Here's a basic summary of how the post is going down.

Basic intro:
-I still suspect oreo, but after nin I decided to focus on another suspect (Z-Beat) while I figure things out.
- Basic read about Z-Beat: He is tunneling to China and this is annoying becuase we can't get reads off him.

-Summary of all the times he has mentioned players other than B-Dubs or Exodus using the actual quotes and me pointing when they connect to exo.

-Summary of the similarities between him and Zeke.

Conclusion:
-I don't know what this means about Z-Beat and Zeke so let's discuss it. C:
-I think Z-Beat's flip will give us a lot of info. I think Z and Dubs are scummates bussing eachother but Z could be not focusing as much on Dubs now because of exo.
-If Z-Beat is scum, I think Exodus is town and vice versa.
-Everyone tell me your opinions on all this.
-Z-Beat please just give us an actual reads list to work with. :<
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I'm going to keep Z's possible breadcrumbing to just this chat for now, because it might out Z's role and if he is town that's bad, but we can bring it up if it seems relevant.
 
That seems good to me, the only thing to consider is if you're going to put a vote on Zeke for this or not. I probably would just to add a little more pressure with it so that Zeke will respond to everything, but you've got this for sure!
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Though naturally, I'm willing to swap my vote to a better candidate, if someone makes a good argument for them/scum really fucks up and lets something slip.
 
What a bizarre day. I'm not sure why Malus decided to come in with that kind of claim, because while it was technically true, it was just going to have us look super close at him after. But, we got one!
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I wish i had gotten to vote malus, now I feel weird for being the only one on Z-Beat but at least I have an excuse because I was sleeping.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Anyways i guess this works... out because I have a family thing this weekend, so I can chat with your now, but i won't be on as much later today. Only issue is new day will start when I'm on the road and hell we'll be notified if we are NK'd while I'm on the road. :/ But at least I have mobile.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Mind you I'm not sure we will get NK'd since exo and Reki will now have targets on their heads for being basically confirmed town. Though it is possible exo is scum and that whole fight was a weird scum ploy... I doubt Reki's was tho unless they were really banking on them getting town points for the rest of the game, in that case Reki could have faked the fact check.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Anyways, it took forever but I finally got Z-Beat to answer questions and the answers weren't too bad. I'm still not sure on him though, as no one really discussed my post with me except for him and Reki. People were just voting Z-Beat. Who should I shoot in that case though?
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Now most people vetoed the role claim, but we are going to get to point when it will happen, so I think we need to plan what we are doing. Here are my proposals. In all case I'm going to put forth the theory that there are similar roles in the game to potentially throw us off scum and town. It'll explain our role.
1. We claim to just being potential lovers and that's it. There's a risk of a role cop (Neek's prize was just alignment based so no worry there.) catching me lying but *shrugs*
2. We claim to be potential lovers and a potential vig. Won't say who is who because don't want to risk not getting our vig shot. We take risk of a role cop again and scum hitting me.
3. You claim to be Ruby (full role claim) and I claim to be Sapphire hoping to bait the kill so that when they take us out they hit you. Risk of Role cop, but if I can get the shot it's worth a risk.

Anyways those are the three possible routes I see. Any ideas?
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Oh and in all cases we never mention what the condition for me getting the shot is. Just say I only get it if the right conditions are met.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I wonder if it's worth pointing out that I can't make my shot publicly while B-Dubs has to.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Had a shower thinking about the game. Exodus' power is perfect in being a counter to malus, so that does make him seem way more towny. If Reki is scum I give them props because this whole malus thing was a perfect way to get town cred. I'm still willing to consider them town tho.
 
I feel safe with saying that exodus is town at this point. And Reki could have chosen a random town member if they were scum as well. I think we're really narrowing down who could possibly be scum at this point
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
yeah I agree with you there. i won't complete town read them, but the only person I am is you and that's because I know it. Question is who to shoot.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I think I'm safe for a NK because even with my big master post that only two people commented on, other people were suspecting Z-Beat.
 
I think we can point back to your master post tomorrow, just a lot of weird stuff surrounding Sawneeks and Malus happened today. It'll definitely come in handy!
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
That’s true. Maybe tonight if I get the chance I’ll be able to look over Neek’s posts and what WSD/Mali’s.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I think I still plan on shooting Z-beat for now, but what is your opinion on the role claim thing?
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Just a heads up Ket and monkey. I’m going to a family breakfast thing tomorrow at 9:30 which is 30 minutes before night actions lock. In theory I should be able to check my phone before 12 my time because I had reception today, but there is a slight chance I may not make it in time.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Also Ket I had like three glasses of wine so I heavily doubt I’ll be able to do any reads tonight, but when I’m drunk/tipsy is when I’m super good at fact checking which is why I’m such a pro at papers, please when drunk so maybe I’ll be amazing at it. Anyways, we’ll see. C:
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Fun fact: I once edited my master’s thesis after four glasses of wine (though it wasn’t the final draft)
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
So tonight my family and I are staying at this AirBnB place, which is this super fancy house in the middle of fucking nowhere. The woods are creepy as fuck (honestly typical for Washington) and this really feels like the set up for a horror film. If you don't hear from me by tomorrow you know what happened. XD
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
So guess what partner, I did end up deciding to do some reads and there is one interesting point I have already noticed.

Naturally there wasn't much to get from malus since he was only in the game for a day, but we can get some interesting info from him if we compare him with who he replaced, WSD. And guess what they have in common.

BOTH think we should ignore B-Dubs.

malus comment for his day:
I feel like it's a waste of time to investigate B-Dubs. I have actually never seen a scum day vig (and even mafia scum wiki lists it as a town role). Also why would he shoot the top wagon of the day? There were lots of people suspicious of meatwad and not much competition so he could have shot someone else and let the lovers be lunched.

and WSD: comment on day 2
Okay, I'm town-leaning on B-Dubs.

In the games I've played, the role has been town, so that's where I was coming from.

Both of them town read B-Dubs because dayvig is always town in the games they have been in.

This is an interesting common point between them. Also what they didn't know is that there is another vig that is town, me.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
WSD says to investigate Zeke (Scum), Z-Beat (i think scum???), LP (Town), Nin (Town), and Weemad (Town.)
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
The only reads list we have for the both of them.

My current reads so far...

Town
- B-Dubs - no explanation needed

Town-leaning
- Exodus - people say his role is NAI, but I'll take it as him being town
- lokiduck - I appreciate his start-of-day analysis and I think he's got a god read of what's going on.

Null
- EzekelRAGE - Gonna give him the benefit of the doubt for now. His playing style may seem pushy, but that's how he played in Maple Street Mafia, and he turned out to be town in that one.
- Everyone else not on this list - I'm just not picking up on anything right now.

Scum-leaning
- Stantastic - Not getting any particular vibe from him, but someone to keep an eye on because
- TheChuggernaut - His vote on weemad and his vote on MeatWad are highly suspect to me.

Again B-Dubs is the only one he completely town read. Zeke was null. It checks out that Stan and Chuggs was on his scum list since be voted for both. Exodus was town which was his main difference from malus, but maybe that's because he knows Exo is town and because the double vote was put in place to help get him killed.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
And that's all I got from those two. Hope this townreading B-Dubs from both of them proves useful.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Also if you think this B-Dubs thing is interesting enough to bring up, why don't you do that since I'll be gone anyways and I can keep focus on Z-beat. xD
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I'm getting nothing on Sawneeks that would help explain why they killed her except that she was being a town leader.

However, she was suspicious of Z-Beat and WSD. She was townreading Reki, Stan, and exo. Two of those are basically town at this point and I'm feeling good on Stan.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Nin told everyone not to go after Neeks for killing him so maybe Scum considered her too much of a thread and felt they couldn't make a solid argument against her anymore.
 
Hm. While they're both townreading B-dubs I'm not sure that he is scum just yet. It was extremely early to use that shot on Meatwad of all people, and presumably they didn't know that it would pan out into 2 town members dead, so that honestly matches up with how I would expect a DayVig to act. They'll want to make sure they get to use their power just in case they get NK'd. I'll definitely bring it up and gauge other reactions though.

I'm still unsure of how I feel about Stan. You don't have to give a huge reads list right now, but who are you most suspicious of right now?
 
Personally, I feel that scum has to be among these :

Stantastic - Oreomunsta - Z-beat - Chuggernaut

I feel pretty town leaning on everyone else in the game, although I might need to read a bit closer on some of them in case I'm getting tricked somewhere
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I’m mainly scum reading Z-Beat and Oreo. While you have valid points on B-Dubs actions seem like something a town vig might make I’m still unsure about him.

Maybe wsd and malus town read him because they didn’t want him smashing them XD.

Stan hasn’t always been around but for the most part I’ve liked what he has done and he seems like how he was in LB3 where he was town.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I really have been townreading Chuggs all game but all of our scum suspects have been suspicious of him at least once so that’s it’s weird and something to wonder about.

So what’s the plan for role claiming?
 
Now most people vetoed the role claim, but we are going to get to point when it will happen, so I think we need to plan what we are doing. Here are my proposals. In all case I'm going to put forth the theory that there are similar roles in the game to potentially throw us off scum and town. It'll explain our role.
1. We claim to just being potential lovers and that's it. There's a risk of a role cop (Neek's prize was just alignment based so no worry there.) catching me lying but *shrugs*
2. We claim to be potential lovers and a potential vig. Won't say who is who because don't want to risk not getting our vig shot. We take risk of a role cop again and scum hitting me.
3. You claim to be Ruby (full role claim) and I claim to be Sapphire hoping to bait the kill so that when they take us out they hit you. Risk of Role cop, but if I can get the shot it's worth a risk.

Anyways those are the three possible routes I see. Any ideas?

I'm really unsure here to be honest. If it comes down to a mass claim, we'll have to tell people at minimum that we're potential lovers for sure. But, if we go with #3, we could act like we haven't found each other yet and talk about how we can use this as a way to investigate each other a little closer, and possibly clearing us. At the same time, I'm not sure that would change the fact that they have no idea which of us to aim for to just put a squash on that. I think #2 is the best option that would allow town to think about B-dubs a little clearer while also really making scum think about whether we have that power or not. I don't think a role cop is going to look at us over one night and then shoot us the next if we confirm that we're lovers though, as they'll be knocking out 2 town quickly as it is.

#1 comes with the risk of people not believing it because there was already a standard set of lovers in the game, and there would have to be some kind of trade-off for it to make sense.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Thanks Monkey!

My only concern about pretending to not have found each other yet is that if neeks gave that “remember what happened last night power” they may get “Loki and Ket talked together long into the night or something like that. Same if there is like a motion detector or something
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
You are probably right about scum not being sure who to hit even if he try option 3 so maybe 2 is the vest one.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Saying we are potential lovers and one of us is a vig with the right conditions might make people suspect us less whole also putting a target on us from scum but if we can protect town by taking the hit then it’s cool.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Of course we could do all this planning and what monkey means us not getting a vig shot is that I got NKed. If that happens they better look into my top too suspects oreo and Z-Beat Dx
 
Yeah, I think something along those lines is the right call. Be somewhat vague about the vig shot, but just say that we'd rather not reveal that yet. We'll definitely be okay though, we're close to winning this!
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Yep if they inquire about the big shot just say we don’t want scum knowing too much about it so please just trust us.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I was half tempted to say something to him with the word hammer to see if he’d react
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Are you sure? XD this is Monkey are talking about. The last few days she has told us we are safe, but today she said we don’t have a vig shot
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Like holy crap I'm super worried for us now though. I think there's only 1 maybe 2 scum left but we really did get some targets put on us today.

You lead the Oreo train and were basically confirmed as town by neon. I questioned oreo's flavor claim and helped in keeping doubt in on him.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
So oreo really was scum that was saved by a townie (nin) with the help of WSD. I really shouldn't have let nin being town throw me off Oreo but I was always suspicious of him so excuse me while I'm still excited about that because holy shit I was right.
 
I believe this is the updated list, let me know if I missed something from those 4 unclaimed in particular.

Us
[she/her] KetKat - EST
[she/her] lokiduck - PST

Claims
[he/him] exodus - EST - Double Voter that's gone once either Steven or Connie die - Stevonnie
[she/her] Queen Kong - GMT+9 - Unknown role - Pearl
[he/him] B-Dubs - EST - DayVig - Sugilite
[he/him] Z-Beat - PST - Unknown Role - Greg

Unclaimed
Protector role - Steven (Presumably, he has a big shield/healing tears and can be tied to Exodus that way)
Party - Unknown flavor

[he/him] Stantastic - GMT+12
[he/him] NeonBorealis - CST
[they/them] Reki - UTC-4
[he/him] TheChuggernaut - CST

Dead
[they/them] saenima - Lover #1 - Sadie
[he/him] Meatwad - Lover #2 - Lars
[he/him] Lone_Prodigy - Thunderdome - Amethyst
[he/him] nin - Deflector - Peridot
[they/them] weemadarthur - Commuter - Connie
[she/her] Sawneeks - PST - Mr Smiley - Vending Machine
[he/him] oreomunsta - MST - Goon - Holly Blue Agate
[he/him] WhySoDevious - UTC-6 - Replaced by Malus - Loved - Blue Diamond
[he/him] EzekelRAGE - Scum Roleblocker - Jasper
 
When I take a look at this list of claims and unclaimed laid out like this, as well as the events surrounding Neon and Reki in particular, I feel that scum has to be between Stantastic and Chuggernaut, and I'm leaning more towards Stan right now. Chances are pretty decent that scum will shoot me, but it seems like they're pretty annoyed at Steven and they were trying to root him out at the end there.
 

lokiduck

Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I was kind of wondering if that was what Oreo was doing, hoping that the real bodyguard would out themself to prove he's scum.
 
Top Bottom