Gossip Thread "And this one time, at Vamp Camp...."
- Thread starter cabot
- Start date
Why have we sullied Willow’s reputation already?
Hi there
I come in peace
So I’m Town and made of magic and right now you’re probably the only player I’ve got a genuinely good feeling about
Me too.
Do you really think Scum and you picked Saw on the same night?
I’m only allowed to do this but once
*this bit once
And I feel like a lot of people are being really quick to claim and I don’t want to yet. I still have one thing I can use and I’m trying to make it worth it
Because I believed your claim and you seem to be working in town’s best interests and I’m pretty certain I’m going to get lynched tomorrow so I wanted to try to use this with someone who seems to be actively scumhunting
Sounded really dramatic though, right?
2 people working together from seasons 1-3? I dunno.
I’ve been townreading melon but if they are scum, could be Spike and Dru.
I hope not though because I was pretty sure on melon and I’ll be pissed if I’m wrong again
Town and I’m Willow
yes, v. shakespearean
See Fran had me unsure after the whole Sorian thing but it felt too intense to be fabricated so the melon thing made me feel better
Love it
So why would Splinter pull this? Does he do this stuff? Because it felt like it didn’t help anyone at all
Oh you won’t. Not ever.
He was bored, maybe? He didn't really put much effort into the game let alone hunting scum. It's been a bit similar in Berserk. I think he wanted to have some fun and go out with a bang :D
And honestly, I was entertained, even if it was a horrible play.
The first night I wasted another power.
Second night I was just an idiot and didn’t realise chat was a request I had to make during the day to use at night.
But today I felt that after the claim you sounded like a good person to talk to. I’d been holding off using the chat until I knew who to talk to and then you killed Ty today and I thought I could trust you.
Melon hadn’t been posting much of late and you’ve been asking a lot of questions so seemed like a sensible option
I think it’s just this night phase
Yah, but I want to know if we can talk after the deadline for the commands.
So basically, so far you’ve seemed like you’ve been seriously sniffing out scum so seemed like my best bet for some information I can actually use.
Did your shot at Ty use up any chance you have tonight at targeting someone?
Okay. Thanks for sharing. I’m Town. I don’t know how else I can say it.
I have one shots at the following: check alignment, chat, roleblock.
I’ve used 2 out of 3 now
I have one shots at the following: check alignment, chat, roleblock.
I’ve used 2 out of 3 now
And is it worth me asking to clarify if you’re Town or Neutral?
Yes because I’m a prize idiot and wanted to see if he was telling the truth or not and then he went and got killed
Sigh. Okay I withdraw that question.
I don’t know how the scum kills work yet. I don’t know who’s doing them and I don’t know how to look for breadcrumbs or clues or whatever yet. I don’t want to throw away my roleblock.
That’s why I’m reaching out here. You seem to be good at asking the kinds of questions to weed out scum. And yes, the Ty kill made me go “thats who to use my chat with”
That’s why I’m reaching out here. You seem to be good at asking the kinds of questions to weed out scum. And yes, the Ty kill made me go “thats who to use my chat with”
I didn’t know yet. I’ve been hiding my time. And trying not to get lynched
*biding
Okay, I'm dropping the play here. You asking for clarification on my claim sounded very much like scum asking for support from a potential neutral. Not that I have shown to be very supportive of scum.
And suddenly I thought of all kinds of mindgames and how I could pretend to be neutral and maybe get info out of you.
But I have a feeling you are town looking for support. I want to use that opportunity. I don't want to waste time pretending in case you aren't scum.
I am town. If you are scum, you can just go kill me. I've given my everything so far to hunt down scum. I will continue to do so :)
And suddenly I thought of all kinds of mindgames and how I could pretend to be neutral and maybe get info out of you.
But I have a feeling you are town looking for support. I want to use that opportunity. I don't want to waste time pretending in case you aren't scum.
I am town. If you are scum, you can just go kill me. I've given my everything so far to hunt down scum. I will continue to do so :)
I was scum in my last game so I still don’t have a bloody clue what I’m doing as Town. In Cluedo I had Monkey and Sawneeks to keep me right and right now I’m flying solo and I’m clearly shit at it because I’ve been up for the chop twice.
I’m honestly here in good faith.
I’m honestly here in good faith.
I’m Town. I promise you.
its the fact that I’ve been there twice.
So basically I want to spend tomorrow working out where to use my roleblock
So basically I want to spend tomorrow working out where to use my roleblock
Splinter flipping Town has thrown me in a tizz now because most of my shifty feelings about Kyan were based on his votes coinciding with Splinter’s
I can only use one action per night.
Monkey, cabot, is that right???
Monkey, cabot, is that right???
Ah shit. Right.
See when Ty and Sorian both said that scum could have been AFK on the day of the hom3land vote (when Sawneeks suggested that surely any possible scummates would have jumped in on that to save him), that was the day when Kyan didn’t vote, yeah?
They wouldn’t be that obvious though, right?
See when Ty and Sorian both said that scum could have been AFK on the day of the hom3land vote (when Sawneeks suggested that surely any possible scummates would have jumped in on that to save him), that was the day when Kyan didn’t vote, yeah?
They wouldn’t be that obvious though, right?
I don’t know. I mostly feel yes but that last minute Sorian thing was weird. Like for him to claim partner with someone who already has a partner was really odd luck. We obvs know that Splinter was lying but it was insane that it outed melon and Fran in the process. And I still don’t know why Fran was still alive after the bet thing with Sorian. I get that Nicole’s claim was that she was bulletproof or immune or something so that would be why she’s alive (if scum were apprehensive about targeting her) but Fran’s was super vague.
I mean if he is Town that’s because he’s masons with melon so had to be vague to protect her too.
I mean if he is Town that’s because he’s masons with melon so had to be vague to protect her too.
Does it feel to you that this is a scumteam that aren’t communicating much??
Sorian and Ty definitely avoided talking to one another in the thread, but I think it was more subconsciously.
There was a post from Kyan in which he explained how Fran made a none-claim. Kyan brought up the issue a few times I think?
Anyway, the line of thought was that Fran never committed to a claim and let others build a story. Fran himself said it was a bluff. He couldn't react to Swamped asking for clarification for example.
I think scum figured Fran didnt have a role.
There was a post from Kyan in which he explained how Fran made a none-claim. Kyan brought up the issue a few times I think?
Anyway, the line of thought was that Fran never committed to a claim and let others build a story. Fran himself said it was a bluff. He couldn't react to Swamped asking for clarification for example.
I think scum figured Fran didnt have a role.
Like some people seemed to accept it was just an attempt at goading Sorian
The could be Cordelia and Harmony.
Fluff-wise.
I’m trying to think of other Town-friendly pairs.
Also because the fluff seems to actually reflect what people can do.
Fluff-wise.
I’m trying to think of other Town-friendly pairs.
Also because the fluff seems to actually reflect what people can do.
It was Kyan who made a list of people who didn’t respond to Fran’s claim and then said it wasn’t really for anything. Just a list in case he wanted to come back to it
Sorry I’m bouncing back and forth between ideas here
Sorry I’m bouncing back and forth between ideas here
Like my Willow alignment check command was RESEARCH. Lol
So if Fran and melon are masons are they just generally able to know how each other is aligned then?
That would make sense that Fran said that he could confirm his alignment. He was going on the idea that melon could confirm him whenever it came down to it
That would make sense that Fran said that he could confirm his alignment. He was going on the idea that melon could confirm him whenever it came down to it
Lol yeah I’m really impressed
Also it’s getting late here so I may have to pick this up in the morning.
I don't see a reason why melon/fran would act like they did at the end of the day as scum. If scum, why not let Splinter survive and use him as a mislynch tomorrow?
but instead they clarified and tied themselves together. It's a townie move, for me they are confirmed town.
If I take our townieness as given, we end up with this vote count:
Looking at D1 the distribution is really odd. And at least one of Kyan / Turmoil(Terra) must be scum, possibly both.
I'm unsure about hom3land. I don't know if he's acting everything. He seems at times to a bit confused and without a clear path. His reactions seem genuine to me. I don't know if Sorian would hound him if it were his teammate.
but instead they clarified and tied themselves together. It's a townie move, for me they are confirmed town.
If I take our townieness as given, we end up with this vote count:
(I hope the pic is not too big)
Looking at D1 the distribution is really odd. And at least one of Kyan / Turmoil(Terra) must be scum, possibly both.
I'm unsure about hom3land. I don't know if he's acting everything. He seems at times to a bit confused and without a clear path. His reactions seem genuine to me. I don't know if Sorian would hound him if it were his teammate.
Oh, you're in a similar timezone, nice. Yes, we can continue tomorrow :)
Do you want to set a time, so we can throw ideas at each other at the same time?
Kyan has seemed just iffy. Like there’s been no smoking gun or anything but he’s not looking great.
And I agree with your thoughts on turmoil. I think he’s handling things with a little more finesse than Terraforce but looking at him today, he barely spoke when spoken to and seemed to just go for things that suited him.
Plus Ty’s response to me is the one that has me thinking that maybe Scum isn’t communicating much. Like turmoil threw out a read and a vote on Ty as if to make a show that he’s here and reading things and being all Townie but then people went “oh yeah” and agreed with him and Ty seemed to panic and question the people who agreed with it.
It did feel like a showy start that maybe backfired and Ty tried to pull it back a bit
And I agree with your thoughts on turmoil. I think he’s handling things with a little more finesse than Terraforce but looking at him today, he barely spoke when spoken to and seemed to just go for things that suited him.
Plus Ty’s response to me is the one that has me thinking that maybe Scum isn’t communicating much. Like turmoil threw out a read and a vote on Ty as if to make a show that he’s here and reading things and being all Townie but then people went “oh yeah” and agreed with him and Ty seemed to panic and question the people who agreed with it.
It did feel like a showy start that maybe backfired and Ty tried to pull it back a bit
Setting a time sounds good. I have a fairly crazy day tomorrow so could either chat after work or if I manage to scrap together enough time for a lunch break
There are a couple of things I'd like to discuss this evening, just throwing it in here for now:
How many scum do you expect to be left alive?
What are your thoughts on Ty's interaction with Inlcude? They discussed during D1 and in this last phase Ty put out a read. What was his intention?
Turmoil ignored basically everything anyone asked him. He came in and only said votes look like this, so I vote x. Have you seen Beserk or Ted and Bill mafia? Do you see any reason for his behaviour?
What do you think of Blarg?
Basically I need your current thoughts on everyone alive minus these four: melon, Fran, GoG, Gorlak
---
Include
hom3
Swamped
turmoil
Flush
Stan
Blarg
Kyan
Nicole
Brazil
Splinter lynch was far too easy and it was too quiet at the day end (before the claim).
How many scum do you expect to be left alive?
What are your thoughts on Ty's interaction with Inlcude? They discussed during D1 and in this last phase Ty put out a read. What was his intention?
Turmoil ignored basically everything anyone asked him. He came in and only said votes look like this, so I vote x. Have you seen Beserk or Ted and Bill mafia? Do you see any reason for his behaviour?
What do you think of Blarg?
Basically I need your current thoughts on everyone alive minus these four: melon, Fran, GoG, Gorlak
---
Include
hom3
Swamped
turmoil
Flush
Stan
Blarg
Kyan
Nicole
Brazil
Splinter lynch was far too easy and it was too quiet at the day end (before the claim).
Masons usually know each others alignment, character and share a chat, but they both claimed to be chatless. Something about neighbours, which I remember to have read somewhere. I'll go and look at the crumbs, but I'm fairly certain about them anyway. So chatless is just a weaker variant of normal Masons.
Can you link Ty's response (just if I don't find it soon)? I can't really assess if this scum team communicates or not.
This applies to Ty4on and Sorian as well.
Ugh, Harmony was turned at the end of season 3, right?
One and done, pretty neat execution.