Spectator Thread Free Parking

Xbro

Bags his own tea
At this point of the game the scum should always have an end game plan. If nothing else you should try to go out like a buster.
 
Sophia: Hm... if I bus you I can attempt to kill Nin tonight, but there's a likely chance he'll be protected. But if I vote Kalor, then Fandorin is the only kill in range for either of us, which would out me...

DCPat: The right play would be to lynch Kalor. And then no night kill. Lynch ketkat next day.

The lastest two scum chat posts.

Wonder how this will work out for them.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
The other option though is if kalor is lynched today they can opt not to kill anyone and instead make it look like the shot was blocked by nin.

DCPat would most likely be put up for a Lynch on the next day. Then Sophia can safely take out nin and depending on where the tokens are at that point she can use the preconceived notion of the range to her advantage and push the blame on to ketkat.

DCPat's current plan falls into this scenario.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Sophia: Hm... if I bus you I can attempt to kill Nin tonight, but there's a likely chance he'll be protected. But if I vote Kalor, then Fandorin is the only kill in range for either of us, which would out me...

DCPat: The right play would be to lynch Kalor. And then no night kill. Lynch ketkat next day.

The lastest two scum chat posts.

Wonder how this will work out for them.
......

Scum's best hope is for Town to mess up and lynch Ketkat. Lynch Kalor/DC tomorrow, push Ket right now!!!
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Sophia IS in the awful position of strongly Town reading Ket, it's not like she can suddenly back away from that to push her lynch without it being really suspect. But she could sit on Kalor and just not push him hard, let DC ride that Ket train and just don't fight against her mislynch.

They lynch DC now there is ZERO chance Ketkat gets mislynched for the rest of the game. The train on her started with him.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
I don't understand why claiming vanilla was as bad a play for kalor as they make it out to be.
 
Ketkat is getting lynched tonight...

hahahahahaha.

Oh man, what a rollercoaster. I'm still laughing as well over Kalor AGAIN being a prime target but he again, escapes without being lynched.
 
Stop being smart zipped let scum lynch Ketkat or kalor.... Or maybe go crazy and push for nin lynch, hehe.

Let's go scums, you got this!
 
Are we just going to ignore the hammer?
I'm getting the impression that obvious scum moves are NAI "because scum wouldn't do that". This really opens up the possibilities for plays I can go for when I roll scum again :P

And we've finally reached that unfortunate moment that always seems to repeat itself, in which a townie is basing their arguments on "there's no way gamerunner would do X" instead of focusing on rereading the thread and bringing up player interactions.
 

CrimsonFist

Neutral Vanilla
Hammer is yesterday's news. Today is all about dodgy yet 100% town role claims and nobody really considering Sophia as scum.
 
Spectating mafia is an exercise in staying hella salty and trying (but occasionally failing) to filter out mean comments about people you like.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
You can usually tell when people are being sincere. Or at least I can. I first adopted my thing of not responding to votes as a test of my theory that someone wasn't being sincere.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
I'll be the first to welcome muffin to the spec thread for being the only one who's thinking in there.
 

CrimsonFist

Neutral Vanilla
I think the problem a lot of players have is rationalising a lynch. Even if you correctly feel someone is scummy, if you don't have something to latch onto it's less likely to get followed up on.

So the mechanics stuff is easier to go after.
 
I think the problem a lot of players have is rationalising a lynch. Even if you correctly feel someone is scummy, if you don't have something to latch onto it's less likely to get followed up on.

So the mechanics stuff is easier to go after.

What I've learned from this:

Gut feelings seem to do better than 'weak' reasoning. The former doesn't get questioned as much as the latter because #feels or some such shit lol.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
Gut feelings are a good thing to get you started with. From there it's about going and getting evidence to back it up. Pat has had plenty to back it up.
 
I think the problem a lot of players have is rationalising a lynch. Even if you correctly feel someone is scummy, if you don't have something to latch onto it's less likely to get followed up on.

So the mechanics stuff is easier to go after.
It's a lot easier to rely on mechanics. If you're wrong, then it's not really your fault - you were just reading the mechanics wrong. I did that on my first game.

Even if you can never truly know the mechanics behind a game until it's actually over, it's just safer to follow your conceptions of what they are than to actually bet on a read, which is something that's entirely on you.

It's the same reason why people are more likely to rely on second-hand reads than bet on their own. As an example, I don't think the townies who are still in there right now even remember why Kalor was first accused of being scummy (because he unvoted off of Stuart). They certainly haven't mentioned that once during this phase, much less tried to look deeper into it. They haven't looked back on anything about the three lynch candidates other than the board pictures.

It's a lot less risky to look at the board and say "Ketkat is the only possible killer" than actually betting on your own reads and saying, "No, I've been consistently reading Ketkat as town", or even looking at something like DCPat cutting the conversation short in the last phase when people were starting to turn around on Kyan and making a judgment.

Funnily enough, the fact that I was willing to take chances on dumb theories and gambits is the only reason why people were townreading me. It certainly wasn't because I was right all the time :P
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Though this clears Ket for the rest of the game. Either way this may still end with Sophia going up against Masons, a Doctor, a very Town Read Ket, and Mr. I'm-Always-A-Lynch-Target Kalor.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Zipped is the hero Town deserves. This could have so easily gone Scum's way and almost given them the game.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
Remember from the discussions me and Brazil had last night though. Pat lynch can still very well go in scum's favor.
 
I suppose the real question now is. Can Sophia carry us to victory against masons + town read Ketkat (assuming Ketkat doesn't get NK'd)
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Remember from the discussions me and Brazil had last night though. Pat lynch can still very well go in scum's favor.
Possibly, but since it looks like Zipped is going straight for a Nin connection if they lynch him and he flips Town Sophia will be in trouble. She and Nin are the only two people who didn't vote for Scum today....

Say Muffin wins tonight, that leaves us with:
Sophia, Ket, Zipped, Fandorin, Kalor, and Nin.

Say Sophia kills Kalor. The next Phase they lynch Nin. That leaves it at 1 Scum v 3 Town. She'd being going up against two Masons and a Town Read Ket. Sophia loses.

Her best bet is to keep Kalor alive to the final group, it's her only chance at a mislynch after what just happened. However, unless she now wants to give up a Nin mislynch tomorrow she can't kill anyone tonight.

She could still win....but it's a longshot. Any big chance they had all died here with that Ket train derailing.
 
Remember from the discussions me and Brazil had last night though. Pat lynch can still very well go in scum's favor.
Definitely. But those discussions were before what went down during this phase, hahaha. Now they have one more chance to miss, at least. It's a better position to be in considering how the vote went.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Yikes, no vote on DCpat despite saying she would vote for him AND the slight change against Ket there before she had to leave....

Sophia is done.
 
Yeah, never assume this town will look back on things that they probably should.

Or if they do, it will be in passing and then ignored some hours later.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
Okay so the problem is that DC made it a 'Me vs You' situation against ket, when he was acting scummy and ket was acting townie.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Also DC if you come in here, welcome! Turning that around on Ket almost worked out and was really well done, if they had lynched her that would have set you guys up really well.
 
DCPat, I legitimately thought the day would start with 3 straight votes on you in the first three posts.

Instead, you went out there and actually made town spin round and round and round in your fingers. Damn well played.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I’m kind of in a stupor that town is going to win this when most of them never even showed up if we’re being honest. That shot on Grizzly changed everything. Shows how one action can sometimes make or break a team.
 
I’m kind of in a stupor that town is going to win this when most of them never even showed up if we’re being honest. That shot on Grizzly changed everything. Shows how one action can sometimes make or break a team.
Muffin's last minute vote on DCPat changed everything as well, even though in the grand scale it'd be just one small thing and we probably won't remember it.

And he actually guaranteed that he won't get shot tonight by helping town lynch scum.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I’m kind of in a stupor that town is going to win this when most of them never even showed up if we’re being honest. That shot on Grizzly changed everything. Shows how one action can sometimes make or break a team.
This game has had some very interesting main plays from Town that have shaped the rest of it. Xbro shooting Grizzly is one of them, Zipped turning heel here and lynching DC is another. If neither of these things happened Scum would be in an excellent spot.

However, there's been a lot of small things too here and there that could've been changed to help out. Town being more active and engaged is one, Scum holding on to the longshot kill, Scum killing Nin, etc.

If anything I think this game shows we gotta step up in some areas.
 
Laughed at this so posting it here:

"Captain's log. Star date: 42053718

I am all alone now. My crew has been brutally murdered by the Proletariat mob. All it took was a few moments away from them, and they were gone. I am uncertain as to what to do next, but I must plan carefully. For the slightest mistake could cost me my life..."
 
DCPat, I legitimately thought the day would start with 3 straight votes on you in the first three posts.

Instead, you went out there and actually made town spin round and round and round in your fingers. Damn well played.

I started the day sad without giving me much chance. Then it kept getting better. And now I'm fuming.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
For big things going right or wrong town have had most of the breaks.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
Why did I get killed by that Zipped theory?

Where does it make sense?
It was multiple things. One was ketkat clearly being sincere in being town(as pointed out by fandorin), the other was muffin's post. Zipped was the final nail on the coffin.
 
It was multiple things. One was ketkat clearly being sincere in being town(as pointed out by fandorin), the other was muffin's post. Zipped was the final nail on the coffin.

I thought about reacting to that post by Fandorin, but tbh, Ketkat was so town during the whole game I couldn't even do it.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I thought about reacting to that post by Fandorin, but tbh, Ketkat was so town during the whole game I couldn't even do it.

During times like that when it comes down to you or a Townie you gotta try and look honest enough to make people doubt your lynch. Town is so fickle when it comes to that stuff that even the slightest thing, like Ket's townie post, can determine the lynch for the Day.

Alright man, this isn't going to cut it. One of us needs an avatar.

Please, there are times when I'm certain you are both the same person.
 
Zipped is playing Monopoly right now. Muffin's vote pushed him to look at you, and he came up with a theory that fit.

But I honestly don't understand it. Does he think Nin is my scum buddy? Or did I want to move Nin to put him in Kalor range?
 
During times like that when it comes down to you or a Townie you gotta try and look honest enough to make people doubt your lynch. Town is so fickle when it comes to that stuff that even the slightest thing, like Ket's townie post, can determine the lynch for the Day.



Please, there are times when I'm certain you are both the same person.

I was hoping it would swing to a Kalor lynch.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I was hoping it would swing to a Kalor lynch.
The conversation around him dying off like how it did towards Day End kinda killed that. Town forgets lynch targets real easily...

And the way that you structured your case against Ket meant it almost HAD to be you or her. Lynching outside of that wouldn't have made sense given the arguments being presented. If they had lynched Ket today that meant you would've been lynched tomorrow but that could've set up Sophia to be in a better spot than she is now.
 
I kinda gave up on myself at the start of the day anyways. I had an awful, just awful day 5, due to availability. Hammer on top of that made it worse.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
A ketkat lynch would have been game of you didn't frame it as you vs her
Really not sure how else he could have framed it though. The whole argument against Ket was that because DC blocked Purse and he was the Dog, the only person in range to kill Brazil was the Cat. Either he had to be lying or he was telling the truth and Ket was the killer.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I kinda gave up on myself at the start of the day anyways. I had an awful, just awful day 5, due to availability. Hammer on top of that made it worse.
No worries DC, it happens. You really made the best out of this situation and had Town eating out of your hand with that Ket theory, it was just Zipped's flip that ended up getting you in the end.

Just another case of everything seeming worse when you're Scum than it actually is. That hammer wasn't great but it isn't even what did you in. :p
 
Really not sure how else he could have framed it though. The whole argument against Ket was that because DC blocked Purse and he was the Dog, the only person in range to kill Brazil was the Cat. Either he had to be lying or he was telling the truth and Ket was the killer.
Yeah, I don't think there was any way for them to lynch Ketkat at that point without creating a thunderdome. It was risky, but it came literally minutes away from making scum (probably) win the game.
 
:(

Now let's all hope I can finally get some town experience in when I play my next game.

Hardest part atm is scumreading people I know are town. I think the only real reads I gave this game were townreads.
 
:(

Now let's all hope I can finally get some town experience in when I play my next game.

Hardest part atm is scumreading people I know are town. I think the only real reads I gave this game were townreads.
You've been scum three times in a row, haven't you?

Jesus :(
 
I just had trouble giving reads on people in general. Not knowing what is or isn't a town/scum move. I was just guessing.

Might be easier when I'm Town because I won't be pretending that people I know are Scum are actually Town lol.
 

Xbro

Bags his own tea
I have an issue with throwing in unless I'm sure on something. The good thing is I can usually figure things out. It just leads me to be quiet early game and loud late game.
 
Top Bottom