Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Just did a quick reread of Faircure, the person I gave the antidote to yesterday event. I didnt really have a really good reason to choose her over Apollo, Geno or Kawl, but I decided to give it to her to see what she'd do with it. Gave it to Geno.

I think it's at least interesting that there is this post day one where she says she doesn't like the lynch candidates. Doesn't like to lynch either Rynam (scum), Vere (scum) or Geno (because he is always a candidate up for lynch d1). She says she'd maybe like to vote Apollo or Grizzly (both scum and under discussion), but she ends up voting Zipped. No mention of Apollo and now likes Grizzly more. Only after the claim votes for Grizzly. After the lynch already was decided.

Her reads list next day is half-decent. All thought it nicely balanced scum in scumread (apollo) and townreads (vere).
First ITA is an easy shot at an inactive.

Then comes the event, where I gave her the antidote. She had the option to give it to either Kawl, Apollo or Geno. She didn't give the antidote to scum Apollo, but I don't think she could. She had a townread of Geno and I guess a scumread on Apollo earlier which I didn't see changing. So no way she can give him the antidote. Then after Apollo died and had to kill somebody she did this weird claim thing while she was vanilla and townread Geno, weird move.

She also later left the Mazre vote for a Lux vote making it I believe 10-3. Leaving the mislynch.

Not feeling good and will leave my vote here. Not sure enough to ITA now and will keep my shot untill ITA3.

VOTE: Faircure
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I don't think it's bad to hold on for your shot a little longer. But at least use it.
No need to all fire away directly.
It's curious in this case since he was around and had opinions re: today's claims. But I'd also like to hear his reason. Not yours. No offense.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
An event is starting

This event will have a hard cap of 16 players but I'm only taking multiples of 4. So if only 15 sign up, for example, the last three will not make it in. Sign-ups will be for about a half hour. Activity level for this event is low-medium (a game will be played but not much discussion required, just need to be available to make choices). Please use the JOIN command to join the game.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Ah, it's an event. Sorry I can't join, it's time I was turning in for the night. Have fun with whatever Sorian's got planned, and I'll see you fine folks in the morning.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Of course we get an event when I'm still catching up. I want to try it out but I don't want to disadvantage anyone with my limited game knowledge right now.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I don't understand your previous post tbh. When did Natiko claim? There is a chance I missed something here.

Then that doesn't change anything in my theory. It's still plausible.
I'm not even saying he's necessarily scum here. Just saying he's not cleared.
But what about the linked claims to others? They're all scum/neutral? That seems extra risky when so many scum have died. Neutral I could see.

I love this Damn game
are you reading it, though?
Anyways Geno seems to have scent of town so for now:

Vote: Natiko

From my skimming his reasoning did seem iffy and others are starting to question him. Consider this not a vote to kill, though his behavior makes me think we may get answer from that, but just a prod.
because skimming is not reading and this is some shady shit

Looking at the ITAs of course @hom3land looks really bad. He comes in and shoots confirmed town Kawl. Wifom. We can deal with a mislynch because of that.

Geno shooting Natiko seems to follow his logic he described before. But it also looks like he never bothered to look at how Include continued to defend herself.

And @NeckToChicken first post of the day was concerning Lone Stranger, then he only appears for the ITA. Getting scummy vibes.
Geno is following older logic and that bothers me but I have mostly townread him this game. hom3land looks super scummy there and I always struggle to read Kalor so that's gonna be a time. (@rac was it you who asked about that? I had no reason to scumread Xbro; will go into it after event).

NtC has been kinda like this the whole time. I have to go back and look because something had moved him out of major scum contention for me but now I don't remember what.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
"lol, what're you gonna do? ITA me?" : Blargonaut
interesting saw

SNAP: Blargonaut
Izd1e4x.gif
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Need two more people to join or I'm kicking Fandorin and Brazil to the curb.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I'll volunteer to get kicked so Fando can stay in if it comes down to it, and if Sorian will let me.

(before someone asks, same reasons I passed to Brazil in the poison event)
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
lol it's not because I love you (I do)
I just wanna see some action out of you
(not a euphemism)
(or is it)
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Going to extend time by 5 minutes since stragglers seem to like to join just as I close sign ups. We're looking for two more brave souls.

I'll volunteer to get kicked so Fando can stay in if it comes down to it, and if Sorian will let me.

(before someone asks, same reasons I passed to Brazil in the poison event)

samsies for me and Brazil if it comes down to it.

I'll allow both of these swaps if it doesnt fill.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Well, now that I'm present for this next ITA phase, I'm having trouble deciding who to shoot.

Maybe just one of the inactives like briefs_cat or oreomunsta? They are low-info kills, though. Maybe Natiko to confirm if Include was trying to bus him? Hm... <_>
...and you never ended up shooting, did you? Why not?

something something i like to nitpick monkey
ugh, I hate that quotes don't grab quoted posts.
Sneeks, if you're here, I don't have to go grab it again; what did you want to ask me about and nitpick at?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
briefs_cat has never voted in this game

other notables:
oreomunsta has not voted since day/thunderdome
same for ferg(rac) (but rac has voted since joining)
Stan has not voted since the thunderdome, either

there's too many. I gotta spreadsheet this or I will be here all day. I get that this isn't a normal game but goddamn, vote.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
The Sorian's Big Blast Event has ended and is now publicly viewable. Rewards will be sent out in about an hour.
 

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Care to prove what you're saying or nah?

Granted I only have day 1 and a little bit of today to go off but I have seen you make posts today that are basically the same as day 1 and in those instances, don't really say anything new. I'd provide quotes if I wasn't on mobile. Maybe your day 2 game is way better but right now, I'm surprised you've made it this far. Though maybe that's just because you got lucky with the ITAs like you did earlier.
 

Nomad Sparkster

This is some wild shit maynard
and provided she can get people to gather around (scummy hey monkey) she can probably get it done too

don't be surprised if i get NK'd tonite D:
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
ugh, I hate that quotes don't grab quoted posts.
Sneeks, if you're here, I don't have to go grab it again; what did you want to ask me about and nitpick at?

More or less what I said there, I dislike how you were willing to give Include the pass despite the fact she was trickling out info and being really cagey with everything. Just trying to decide if I scum read that or not and wanted your reaction on it.

briefs_cat has never voted in this game

other notables:
oreomunsta has not voted since day/thunderdome
same for ferg(rac) (but rac has voted since joining)
Stan has not voted since the thunderdome, either

there's too many. I gotta spreadsheet this or I will be here all day. I get that this isn't a normal game but goddamn, vote.

wait, STAN hasnb't voted since the Thunderdome? Really??

Ewwwww whyyyyy did that happen stupid mobile

Uhhh, think it had something to do with a vote of yours but I can't remember why. Will try and look it up but no promises.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
More or less what I said there, I dislike how you were willing to give Include the pass despite the fact she was trickling out info and being really cagey with everything. Just trying to decide if I scum read that or not and wanted your reaction on it.
My reaction is pretty much the same as it was then - I figured there was a chance she was neutral and her claim seemed not terrible, and she did have a breadcrumb that was kinda ridiculous, but then I started thinking about the switcher stuff in HvV and figured, well, we should probably shoot her just in case. Town's ahead enough and she at least had some good connections to people. that could be traced. I also figured giving BP out wasn't that helpful, considering the numbers, so if we lost it, no big. Seemed worth seeing what happened if we flipped her. I do hold there's probably at least one vet left on the scum team helping. I think a newbie scum fake claiming like that probably has a calm voice behind them.

I didn't like some of the things people were saying, which gave me some pause, like melon saying Include wasn't as "fiery" as usual. I also have a long and unfortunate history of responding "seems legit maybe" to claims, so there's that. Anyway, the big thing for me was Natiko's claim, I think. His just has too many dependent pieces so I figured if it was gonna be one of them, Include was the one to test. Stuart getting shot helped, too. RIP Stu.

as for Stan-

look at the vote tool and see if you see a vote from him since the thunderdome
I don't
also fun fact: we only have like 80-some votes in the last two phases with this many players.
 
Just did a quick reread of Faircure, the person I gave the antidote to yesterday event. I didnt really have a really good reason to choose her over Apollo, Geno or Kawl, but I decided to give it to her to see what she'd do with it. Gave it to Geno.

I think it's at least interesting that there is this post day one where she says she doesn't like the lynch candidates. Doesn't like to lynch either Rynam (scum), Vere (scum) or Geno (because he is always a candidate up for lynch d1). She says she'd maybe like to vote Apollo or Grizzly (both scum and under discussion), but she ends up voting Zipped. No mention of Apollo and now likes Grizzly more. Only after the claim votes for Grizzly. After the lynch already was decided.

Her reads list next day is half-decent. All thought it nicely balanced scum in scumread (apollo) and townreads (vere).
First ITA is an easy shot at an inactive.

Then comes the event, where I gave her the antidote. She had the option to give it to either Kawl, Apollo or Geno. She didn't give the antidote to scum Apollo, but I don't think she could. She had a townread of Geno and I guess a scumread on Apollo earlier which I didn't see changing. So no way she can give him the antidote. Then after Apollo died and had to kill somebody she did this weird claim thing while she was vanilla and townread Geno, weird move.

She also later left the Mazre vote for a Lux vote making it I believe 10-3. Leaving the mislynch.

Not feeling good and will leave my vote here. Not sure enough to ITA now and will keep my shot untill ITA3.

VOTE: Faircure
My voting D1 was terrible and there's really no defending it besides I was really off-base. All I can say is that with three scum trains, there was plenty of bus targets and I feel like if I was scum I wouldn't have gone for the literal only town train since it would obviously look terrible later.

My suspicions of Apollo were kinda a quiet thing, I had like two posts where I addressed it. I feel like I easily could've come into the event without mentioning them if I was concerned about his survival. Also Geno hadn't posted any list of who he wanted dead and had been a bit irritable all day, I feel like he was a bit of a wildcard of who he was going to pick and idk if I'd gamble my teammate's life with him if I was scum.

Claim post was indeed weird and badly thought out. Can I pull the newbie card still?

And meh about my vote yesterday. I don't think anyone is giving me super townie points for not being on Mazre. It was very quiet and usually that's a town lynch, I was going to move my vote off it at least to show where I was at.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
heymonkey is going to have my ass in a sling if she gets her way
No, I just think you're a moron and I'm pretty salty at all the people who seem to not be reading the thread and yet are happy to throw votes and shots around, which is the most anti-town thing y'all can do. We might be ahead but don't get sloppy and lazy.
 
Top Bottom