Maybe neither, I don't think they would have seen it as an intentional strategy, but they also can't be that annoyed by something that massively benefitted them.
Seconding this, it's a REALLY well put together argument.
<3
I became a mod-confirmed townie in Marvel Mafia after I did my “fake death” ability, yet people were still wary of me up until the end. I even had to post something calling out how ridiculous it was to suspect me when Word-Of-God essentially said that I couldn’t possibly do a night kill.
oh man, I remember Lifeline in Pineapple Pizza
Melon I don’t think anyone thinks that. Things certainly got out of hand in the thread, but we did tell players both publicly and privately to be more thoughtful with their words. You can’t blame people for thinking it was a bad play, but no one should (nor does, I hope) think any less of you. I’m sorry it got so rough. I really appreciate that you put in a lot of effort to try and talk people through your actions and to leave some valuable (and accurate) reads behind.
No, it's not that. Like the other's have said it's not about you as a person and is about the gambit.
Yeah but there's "quite annoyed" and then there's this.
But what options do they actually have?
Uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
lol
Wait, what do you know that I don’t? :<
Huh, I didn't even look at the title of the video, let alone click on it lol.
I believe the data has shown they’re traditionally worse in this community. I attribute that to too many of us being slackers and posting from work lol
it's weird for me, because I'm much better on weekends
I actually prefer weekends as well.
I would be interested what complete newcomers find easier to keep track of - the hecht rhythm and the set schedule or the consistent cadence of 48/24 or 72/48. Newcomers are the only reason we went with 72/48 in GOT, but I could see an argument where the set schedule is easier to remember.
Well, you course-corrected it rather quickly, so I don’t think any harm came of it.
Pedro put this in the gamerunner thread:
Pedro put this in the gamerunner thread:
I was going with the second row, but then people complained because we ended up getting a weekend only phase, so now I'm going with a 48 hr night to transition to the bottom row
I agree with this. Especially if you combine that with the posts/responses from previous day phases. I would classify those as over aggressive.
Faddy just needs to acknowledge Fanto's explanation and move on. I can see how it might look to Fantomas, but noone is actually attacking him for having a mentor or "playing too well", it was just an observation that it seems like he has some other outlet on the thread (which turns out to be true in an NAI kind of way).
Given how contentious this game has been I just would rather be cautious than let them go off again. Already people are starting to complain again.
I've certainly had my share of instances too. But do I think the issues that occurred in Love Boat 2 or Pineapple Pizza Mafia reflect positively for me? No, and in hindsight I wish someone had stepped in before things spiraled out of control.
about whether she shouldve been lynched or not.
Aw, so they're choosing to kill Vere? Shame since he apparently got a good hit with his tracking.
That was your first mistake.
There are obviously some disagreements and missteps here and there (along with the Stuart switcheroo throwing a wrench into the mix), but I think town is making the correct plays so far. Scum is really going to have to earn their win here since they have nothing but the standard ways of killing townspeople at this point. Scum needs to have like 3 or 4 more mislynches to even get to LYLO, and that's without any of them dying in the process.
yea, im worried after this day phase town will forget to look at why they needed to lynch melon in regards to gog.
Oh man, if Vere tracked the killer for real this time they're going to totally regret that.
Gog could just as easily have been protected though. I don't think melon's action should be enough to lynch her.
