We have people like rac here attempting to change their vote at the last second in the previous day phase to me instead of turmoil. Thankfully, votes were locked, but that kinda stuff could have gotten me lynched instead of turmoil if they saw there was some momentum going. And then today would have been way less clear than it has been.
So I'd kinda like to avoid last minute messes when we have a slightly clear perspective on where things should be heading.
It kind of makes sense if there is an extra kill power, either for Scum or for a Neutral, out there. It would make sense that Scum ran into Ketkat's two targets there back to back and that's how Faddy knew who she targeted when he fake claimed.i actually don't understand what the bp role is for at all if we have a doctor
I can put together a formal role claim list in here for us. I was also thinking of getting a vote spreadsheet down now that we have a number of flips out there, 2 Scummies, and me and Fran as Confirmed Town, so we might be able to look at those and do some analysis.this game is so hard to follow actually
just a massive amount of claims and it was only d3
i mean i guess but scum actually targeting pirate bae, i agree with a lot of the people in the threadIt kind of makes sense if there is an extra kill power, either for Scum or for a Neutral, out there. It would make sense that Scum ran into Ketkat's two targets there back to back and that's how Faddy knew who she targeted when he fake claimed.
That would mean that the Neutral is the one who has got the two kills so far. Geno makes sense as a random target for a Serial Killer, or if Geno was on to the SK at some point on D1. If the SK caught on to Cabot's D2 bread crumb (the Don't Shoot Fanto one), they might have wanted the 2-for-1 shot since they might need to survive to end game for their win con, so getting a 2-for-1 gets them that much closer.
That's kind of my working theory right now, but it is based on a lot of assumptions. If we have a double kill night now, with Ket being one of them and some rando target being another, I would entertain the theory a lot more for sure.
this has to be one of the worst scum plays of all, what are the odds of faddy telling us what actually happened that night?She basically claimed cop so mafia not having a strong kill I can see a world where they both roleblock and try to kill her.
Definitely. I think some of those anti-Chugg posts are the most suspect ones post-claim from Ketkat actually. It is true that his claim would look suspect, I said as much in here too, but I don't think I'd have advocated for his lynch over it.also would scum throw shade on chug here? not like they new he was going to die
this has to be one of the worst scum plays of all, what are the odds of faddy telling us what actually happened that night?
what would he gain from that?
It would depend on what other powers they have I suppose. If they do have some way to pull off extra kills, and a possible Neutral around isn't a killer, that could also make sense I think. That way they can afford to Kill and RB Bae in case of protection and send their other kill Cabot's way.something's just not adding up
tell me if you were scum would you rb and shoot bae?
i agreeCabot had made a note after D2 that there is a good chance that there could be some very good Scum Roles in this game because we are OP as Town with all these PRs,
TheChuggernaut said:There is something I did notice though. Malus/Faddy/Fandorin all seemed pretty hesitant to scum read each other today which I took note of. Faddy mentioned one of them in a post, but he didn’t seem to lean hard into it at all, and Malus and Fandorin didn’t seem to want to scum read each other till a couple of hours ago where it seemed obvious that one of them was getting lynched. I’m not going back to look right now, but I remember either Malus or Fandorin (Both?) coming into the day phase saying they were lost, and I just don’t really know how your takeaway from that Turmoil lynch is that you aren’t sure about the game anymore. The votes on each other today just feel like they’re trying to get some early bussing in and I don’t buy it.
sorry i was a little too drunk tonight a need to read over d3 faddyChugg had made a note in the thread before he died, which is something I also agreed with. What do you think of this?
Yeah, if they were tracking her they would have just taken her out by now probably.no idea but if they were tracking ketkat why wouldn't they have just killed her n2?
back to defending malus a bitI don't think Brazil deserves town cred for the shot, particularly due to the way he handled it.
I was going to push on Rac but reading through his posts he was the person who was most against Brazil. Although he was very dramatic about it.
I think there are lots of people in this game that are coasting by doing very little. KetKat is still in that bunch. Zubz, kyan, malus, AB.
I have stronginsh town reads in FRan, Chugs CeeCee for the claims and how they happened. Cabot is my top pure town read, I still like Fandorin. Add Sorian and Natiko to round it out. I would have said Blarg but he is on a nonsense spree today.
Scum are in the coasting group. Then Fluxwavez is my top scum read. I like Sorian's pint that he has been sheeping reads. He also has a weird tone in a lot of his posts that feel defensive but also sort of mocking.
I think that's something we can ask @Grizzly to clarify for us, yeah.you think we'll still be able to look at this chat after the night is over?