Game Thread Invitational | Râlez, S'il Vous Plaît

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Kark staying alive would've outed the real mason

Would it? If everyone was scum reading him and his lynch would have revealed the lie rather than having to counter claim. I'm not sure I like the mod interference. Mod-kill for bad play is out of line imo.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I guess FEP is now the obvious lynch target.

And the possibility that Kark was right about monkey and Sorian is sort of on the table again.

And we need talk about potential bus players on the nin lynch
 

RetroMG

Bergentrukung
Staff member
ANNOUNCEMENT

I have been made aware that the search page for Outer Mafia has an option to search by thread prefixes. Please be aware that this list contains ALL of the prefixes that have been created for ANY game, (including games that have not run yet,) and will not actually provide any insight into ongoing games.

This post will also be posted in other open threads.
 
If nothing else we can look at the interactions with kark and try to determine who might have been taking advantage of his suspiciousness.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I don't even know how to react to this.

I guess he just wanted out?

Okay.

Ty, why did you wait until the last minute to vote? Terra, why Sorian for you? If he is town, who next? Who next if scum? Dusk, why did you think your role was designed for you?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I'm gonna

unvote

I don't know if scum Dusk would bring attention like that but nothing has been townie either so...

Regardless, I have to reassess.
 
I don't even know how to react to this.

I guess he just wanted out?

Okay.

Ty, why did you wait until the last minute to vote? Terra, why Sorian for you? If he is town, who next? Who next if scum? Dusk, why did you think your role was designed for you?
Sorian was just who I felt was the most scummy at the time. The Nin flip, while not clearing him of suspicion, is making me reconsider. If we assume Sorian is town, then FEP makes sense to me. If he is scum, then I would say Faddy.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
We don't gain a lynch. We gained a flip. We will probably misfire and lynch town today since there are so many uncertainties on the table and then we lose another town tonight. Bad fucking news for us. Majority is six, probably two scum left, gotta be careful.

Faddy is my top town right now. I would consider just about anyone else, depending on the case, but also pending questions on the table. Worm and Nomadic probably the others I am least likely to vote out.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Oh cool, responses while I typed.

I have not really suspected feps but feps v Sorian is slightly more worth considering now.

Topo, where are you thinking?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I hadn't really considered feps >> Faddy. I could see it, possibly.

Hmm.

I just feel really unsettled.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Well feps needs to come in and say why he switched off Sorian on day 2, that is bugging me.

This read list is a red flag as well
Would lynch:
8. Faddy [m] - arguing against town interest because why exactly?
16. Kevyt [m] (Seath) - even playing?
17. Sorian [m] - that goddamn reach, not honestly trying imo
3. Bronx-Man [m] - playing?
6. Dusk Soldier [m] - playing?

Don't care:
13. Kyanrute [m]
15. Nomadic Sparks [m]
2. Blargonaut [m]
7. El Topo [m]
1. BiscuitFreak69 [-] (Darryl)
11. Karkador [m]
12. Kawl [m]

Would not lynch:
4. cabot [m] - first time playing with cabot, don't want to end it too quick. Also, participation medal
5. CCS [m] - participating, even if it's just a shit cover for faddy.
18. Squidyj [m] - good people
9. flatearthpandas [m] - first time playing with cabot, don't want to end it too quick. Also, totally not shading squid
10. hey_monkey [f] - saw's town sister. Contributing.
14. Nin1000 [m] - seems usual nin which is good, plus i get good feelings from his posted feelings

Good feelings about nin and Kawl doesn't get the same "playing?" remark that the other inactives do.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
Okay, so after having gone through the entire thread I feel that I will start with:

VOTE: Sorian

I actually kinda agreed with his day 2 obsession over the killing of Kawl being dumb luck on an inactive, but his subsequent posts just did not sit right with me.


People I will keep my eyes on for various reasons:

El Topo
Faddy
Dusk

Sorian was just who I felt was the most scummy at the time. The Nin flip, while not clearing him of suspicion, is making me reconsider. If we assume Sorian is town, then FEP makes sense to me. If he is scum, then I would say Faddy.

How do you currently feel about Dusk Soldier and El Topo?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Real talk - does no one else think this is something that may be of note somehow? It's okay if it's just me; just let me know and I'll stop bringing it up.

Slight issue is that if he was scum wouldn't Dusk have posted that in the scum thread.
 
How do you currently feel about Dusk Soldier and El Topo?
Dusk... Is just kinda there. Nothing really sticks out too much about him, which can mean a whole slew of things depending on what one thinks his alignment is.

El Topo... It doesn't make sense for Scum Topo to bus nin, but at the same time if he were to bus, he placed his vote at the usual bussing spot. Still kinda on the fence about him.

Not really suspicious enough of either of them to try and Lynch them today, but I don't want to forget about them either.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
@RetroMG @Ourobolus out of game but
9ZUfByjOAGwnfLmP0O7JD67RJrqUI9Pv3iquo98IDalEHN-1WjYcWPRqNwKj1uXdhkLEsbdUNbBjQXE06j0syMjaGYgLC4EbBMI9D6q8114VkJUjYQ1r7hyO4IXpLuN3gmB0FRveORVEf7hmjtD3SC0oHadTyfSziOAtBXGsb-qFVzrasJ81LIV8QV7Fq4TiTfsHV2Mhlad1DfcsrBH3qK8ZMYgaU7D7JQ3SriyEDrP_xUXmz8ef3XeNQ6fCENfxWL-M7SAw2QCq4Mxvlxi85D5MlyucLYrZX04CVXBYsA_oHpqtZ3oi7VXFk9L8xImu1vU6QY2itPunEqDbA6nFpq-uDeuai3IlSWdf5KtB85XEPPLhsrjdS76bFVUfjAYO7ULralnj5TUDdK3ae83P55U-E52AXSzkhb3MBTmlI3N4-YrTSRtwQh9NlZvI-5X7UPMG0IJDjToh7BuPUPK9GGrz5g6rT2-r6J0rlHx8EYRXkrKUL-BD4rV0_ISMv3Jb_nawHvPvj2KLbYJY_G7EdPu_to8oZGYtryUEAcgNjzGGLWwVhgclbvzfG-kmGgCEumS5DZ2b5FpSvK_ZnGUDahq-k4xFWflPdyAE6-14_w=w373-h662-no
DQDDY-zPsPNZ9a4nBtJIO48n3wkwY217tLQLSBvF5B3jjBspSfjX0npqexhL2Bea4zvL70GeqtBY3LR_JKVGdkGTi9ClgtMtwYZstrwDrN_0h9UA4SN7_gPabZgEXmmLslUL2Pnc8-2DOQDDPNmz32U5RhhmcryrzhyXCdDymUw15weut3hcnPwxhhyfa-06AVPvQgghv4XLZzL9S0FqDED2xkVI7RP-9vu0BPybFnDYMP2kYvF86s_vDVLmDuXYknmu_C8w4MXiPb1P2rssXqUl7Y6RO59Zuy0NyVwhsBpZrZq7WuttWG8Z1Bovx9lxqUKVP9pMZFzIMdBOfT_setOMFFDnCBT-jM79VjQDDkQUuDvGCtZVYrSZl0-omvr2EpKCGug1tlgEOdYAnlVLKh-kr-US1xNoMpFsdufyh3EpJ21bfxGAG9p9i2ns9IPX__mH8WV6rNpORpBXFG5rNLuK0UE7pElEugh0at1nmjxEAopGv6l9GI6hz7R0JFTsxw5hVuwWYMpmD8VvOa-oR9sBPLBAVf9JU9Gm78y_0-qS5iFHipeC2MKRUgC83BL-5hZ9OTo-XD4oNFiG0XySdq6yG-4hNYx2a16uE5QyTg=w373-h662-no

can you not do this to the people using light theme? thanks
 

Dusk Soldier

Not contagious
1. Dr. Worm [m]
3. Ty4on [m]
6. Dusk Soldier [m]
8. Faddy [m]
9. flatearthpandas [m]
10. hey_monkey [f]
11. Karkador [m]
15. Nomadic Sparks [m]
16. Terrabyte20xx [m]
17. Sorian [m]

This who we have left? With 2 scum I'm guessing?

So to update on this thought.

First I'll cross out the players that voted out Kawl. If he was bussed it would have had to happen sometime after the 5th vote (Dr. Worm/Darryl/Biscuit) up until that point it was perfectly plausible for CCS to get lynched. The stragglers on the Kawl vote have already been lynched however.

1. Dr. Worm [m]
3. Ty4on [m]
6. Dusk Soldier [m]
8. Faddy [m]
9. flatearthpandas [m]
10. hey_monkey [f]
11. Karkador [m]
15. Nomadic Sparks [m]
16. Terrabyte20xx [m]
17. Sorian [m]

From there I think we can also safely remove the first 5 Nin voters. Again if scum was trying to bus for townie points it would have been late, since Sorian was a very viable counter-lynch up until that point.


1. Dr. Worm [m]
3. Ty4on [m]
6. Dusk Soldier [m]
8. Faddy [m]

9. flatearthpandas [m]
10. hey_monkey [f]
11. Karkador [m]
15. Nomadic Sparks [m]
16. Terrabyte20xx [m]
17. Sorian [m]

That leaves us with:

Ty4on
Nomadic Sparks
Terabyte20xx
Karkador

Karkador of course suicided so we don't need to worry about him.

I think scum is hiding in the other 3.

Ty posted the hammer vote on Nin, which could be scum trying to lap up townie points after a lost cause.

There was likely a scum on the Sorian vote, which Terrabyte20xx fits in nicely.

Nomadic is a wild card but if both Ty and Terra turn out to be town I would consider looking at him more closely.

vote: Ty4on
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I'm certainly more suspicious of Worm not doing more critical thinking on keeping quiet on the mason claim.
 

RetroMG

Bergentrukung
Staff member
tut tut @RetroMG after admonishing people in the Beserk game for not properly using text colours...

I am reminded of a similar situation from Animal Crossing, and the appropriate response from Crab.

"I am a moderator. You are a corpse."

"But I'm not a corpse," I hear you say.

KEEP PUSHING ME.

;)

(I'm going to stop derailing Ouro's game now.)
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
You and I both know I'm not scum. I don't even know why you'd ask me that....

I know that above is the first analysis you've really done in this game. I don't know anything else about you. I certainly don't know that you're not scum.

As for the mason, I have a strong suspicion that's one of two remaining players, and I lean more strongly on one than the other. But I'm also guessing town has more roles than that, though I won't speculate on investigative or not since Ouro hates us. I'm just guessing there's more and I wonder if/when we will see them.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Dammit Kark. Didn't I fucking warm everyone he was probably town though. What a waste.

Dusk, glad to see you showed up. Solid reads.

Faddy, wish I could say the same. I was bullish on Sorian D2 as well, I just preferred crimson. From the d1 votes, i figured there might be another inactive scum. I thought it might be Crimson.

What a weird shift. Kark is scum for always voting sorian! (wrong)
Feps must be scum for not voting sorian once! (wrong)

Tell me, if Sorian is town, how am I scum for not being on that lynch? I should have somehow knew he would win that day even though my vote was on the neck and neck train?

I wasn't sure about him but I doubled down d3 when he was saved by override, kept giving shit reads, wasn't paying attention to the game, etc.

I think it's good to find town but you've invested deep into him for the wrong reasons and you're making bold claims against other players that are turning out wrong based on it. Sorian's best ability in mafia imo is crowd pleasing. He seems townie, even when he's outed scum. Keep some healthy suspicion and try not to ml too many things because of shit you "know" on shaky suspicion.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Anywho, if Sorian is town then I do believe that there was scum on his lynch d1. CCS and Sorian trains started within minutes of each other, previously scum Kawl was leading. If both CCS and Sorian were scum, I think scum would have wanted either or both to succeed and put their weight there if they had the numbers. There should have been three of them active since kawl wasn't. Even if their other vote was also inactive, they had enough people to jump on both trains.

I do not think there was scum bussing kawl. As soon as CCS and Sorian gained votes, Dusk jumped onto Kawl, keeping him viable. That is an invested scum bus and i don't buy it. Dusk is also looking at the game critically.

If there is no scum on Sorian, I believe either he is scum or that the whole scum team was basically inactive. We have a few days we can burn. We probably have no protection and no cop. Scum will be killing town every night. So we can measure our time accordingly.

10p 8t 2s
D5: 6t 2s
D6: 4t 2s mylo
D7: 3 t 2s lylo

I propose we clear the air a bit.

Vote: Nomad Sparkster

Let's check Sorian's train. With Kark flipped, we will know Sorian's train by tomorrow by D5 if we lynch nomad. Guaranteed.

If the train is pure, I heavily suggest we lynch Sorian. If Sorian is scum that means we're looking at

D6: 5t 1s
Turbo monkey at that point and go from there

If Sorian train is pure but Sorian flips town we're looking at something a bit trickier.

D6: 4t 2s

Scum kills will affect, but inactives or CCS train. Hard to predict that far, but I think it's a good short term roadmap. Scum NKs will be giving us information beyond just flips as well.

Town, we have a real shot still, we're in a good place. I think methodical will win it.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Ok, I woke up an hour ago but went out for good and while doing my multi quoting saw the whole Kark thing and called it all stupid and finished eating in peace. Home now. I'm legitimately annoyed but I'll save that for after the game. Continuing on with trying to figure out who the hell is scum. Kark being town and not actually having to be lynched to see the flip is super helpful. It lets me narrow in on FEP more. I don't vote outside of FEP, Dusk, or Topo today. Terra and Nomad lag slightly behind but those are my top 3. To be a cheeky shit

VOTE: flatearthpandas

because yes, there was scum on my vote.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
I still have most of a day. This is still no surprise and you can easily pull this out of my play book. We both know the liklihood of you getting lynched is just too low. This day ends in a Dusk or Terra vote if I had to guess based on people's rumblings. I'm voting you because I want more people to look at you.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
can you two just like bone already or what
As soon as CCS and Sorian gained votes, Dusk jumped onto Kawl, keeping him viable. That is an invested scum bus and i don't buy it. Dusk is also looking at the game critically.
Your point on timing is good but Dusk has made ONE solid post. I'm not writing him off yet. Nomadic feels simultaneously like an okay but also wasted lynch. I'm pretty sure he's town. Maybe we can get some reads out of him now that we're narrowing the field.

FEP, Dusk, or Topo today. Terra and Nomad lag slightly behind but those are my top 3.
Topo, too, feels kinda wasted. Why do you think Dusk decided today to suddenly participate?
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Nomadic is the best lynch.

He's been active the whole game but not contributing. Flips tell us nothing about him as long as Topo lives so he's free to continue not contributing while town eats itself.

More important, If there was scum on Sorian, it has to be nomadic. If there's not, Sorian is extremely likely scum.

Lynch nomadic today. If he's town, lynch me tomorrow. When I'm town, lynch Sorian.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
So this whole narrative has been brewing all day. Why does town or scum being on me matter with whether I'm scum or not? CCS was the prime other lynch day 1. Yeah, I still think scum was on me but even if you were all town, how does that flip on me somehow?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Nomadic often plays this way. While it's possible he is scum, I find it very unlikely and I don't know if I can get behind the idea of a possible town-lynch chain based on Nomadic. That seems like a risky move.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
And if we take down three townies because we took a risk on Nomadic, that puts us at endgame with possibly nothing - if feps, Sorian, and Nomadic all flip town, then it gets really easy for scum left to say LET'S LYNCH MONKEY SURELY THAT'S A SCUM OVERRIDE or whatever weird narrative brews by then and that's game over, goodnight, thanks for playing, we just threw a game that at this point should be easily solvable.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
To Sorian, you were the first train. We know scum jumped on the second, that was nin.

Why would scum only wait for a second train and not take advantage of the first?

If you're town, there's definitely scum. If there's scum, it's definitely nomad.


Monkey, you guys probably won't lynch me so it isn't as dangerous as it sounds. At absolute worst we lose two town and clear the air a ton. No one is going to believe scum used their override to protect town Sorian lol. If he's scum you're in trouble though
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
So this whole narrative has been brewing all day. Why does town or scum being on me matter with whether I'm scum or not? CCS was the prime other lynch day 1. Yeah, I still think scum was on me but even if you were all town, how does that flip on me somehow?
yeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaahhhh, I really don't see where fep is going with this

I think any scum would've probably jumped to CCS from you
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
yeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaahhhh, I really don't see where fep is going with this

I think any scum would've probably jumped to CCS from you
The Sorian train was full before the CCS train even started.

Why would scum not get on board? Why would they wait for a CCS train if there was already a town train to board?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
If I'm scum and faced with a town CCS and a town Sorian, I probably prefer to keep Sorian around because he is Sorian and no one trusts a town hooker.

Sorry, CeeCee. RIP

(and it could also be that inactivity issue for scum. we just dunno.)
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
But CCS was not yet a choice. It was Sorian Kawl tied before CCS started. If you're scum, why do you not jump on Sorian? Why do you wait for a third option and then jump on?

When Nin votes CCS, it is 3-3-2 Kawl Sorian CCS. Nin ties it. Why? There's scum already on Sorian or there's scum in Sorian.

Believe Sorian is town, that's fine. But believe Sorian is so scary scum don't want to vote him?? When though we already know nin did jump on Sorian d2??

Nin went CCS because there was scum already on Sorian and they could shift to either target if need be I think.

There not being scum on town Sorian doesn't make sense. Especially when scum is on the books causing a 3 way tie with one of their own in the mix
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
because he is Sorian and no one trusts a town hooker.
Except everyone does. Right now, people are bending over backwards to argue not only that he's town, but he's so town scum are afraid to vote him. They're so afraid they engineer a third train when town have tied Sorian with scum Kawl for vote leader all by themselves...

Please.

Scum was on him. Nomad gotta go.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I don't think scum thinks he's scary. I think if he's town, scum finds him useful as a distraction. IF Sorian is town, we will always be discussing whether or not he's scum. It would perhaps be more useful to vote him at this stage.

Nomadic is an unpredictable issue, I'll grant that. But so are several others. I admit I'm torn in several directions just now, so I'm gonna listen and weigh options.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
I don't follow...

With scum kawl at three votes, town fep and kark get a competing train rolling on town sorian, scum nomad boarding isn't deviously engineering anything... Quite the opposite. There ought to be scum on board.
 

Dusk Soldier

Not contagious
I'm not following the logic here...

Why would scum-Nomadic vote out Sorian D1, when he could have saved Kawl by switching his vote to CCS?
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
To Sorian, you were the first train. We know scum jumped on the second, that was nin.

Why would scum only wait for a second train and not take advantage of the first?

If you're town, there's definitely scum. If there's scum, it's definitely nomad.


Monkey, you guys probably won't lynch me so it isn't as dangerous as it sounds. At absolute worst we lose two town and clear the air a ton. No one is going to believe scum used their override to protect town Sorian lol. If he's scum you're in trouble though

Why would scum not get on a leading town train when a teammate is on the line?

Both of these are kind of the same quote. This assumes every scum player being active at the same time. We've had a game with tons of very gratuitous inactivity. There's an issue where if a number or two are missing during a specific train gaining ground then they would need to get on the next one. There's something disingenuous here because you're having us look at the day end vote when I'm no longer the counter wagon and also ignoring the inactive lynch bomb being a bus.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Not... at... all. Confirmed scum is active at a recorded spot. Confirmed scum jumps in to tie CCS. Not to add votes to you for lead.

Why??

Sorian though

Sorian though

I beg you

I fucking beg you


Ignore how many times I've told you that i won't be lynched


Ignore it. Keep digging. Keep tunneling. Keep at it, champ. Keep pushing.

Why?
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Also, weirdly, because i think nomad is scum, but weirdly, Sorian is quoting time periods incorrectly.
There's something disingenuous here because you're having us look at the day end vote when I'm no longer the counter wagon and also ignoring the inactive lynch bomb being a bus.

Nin voted when ccs was not in the lead. I'm having you look at the actual vote.

Now. Twice now. Sorian not knowing the situation he's talking about. Both times to attack me. Does he care more about gamestate or about trying, stupidly, to mislynch me against warnings
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
The question was continuously over and over again. Is there scum within Kark, Nomad, or you. That is a very specific time period, the end of the day. Yes, this morning you talked about the timing of nin's vote. I get that but I'm also wel aware of who nin is. You aren't taking into account how he consistently does not play logically.

You're running a script. You're setting it up as if you expect a town flip on Nomad and then I can go next. Except the one time where you said "lynch nomad, then lynch me, then lynch Sorian," the rest has been that we have no chance of lynching you, which feels like scaring us off the idea ahead of time.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Why motherfucker? Because I'm scum setting you up??? You know i can prove I'm town now and this is the weakest shit you can present??????

You say I want to talk about a specific period. Exactly. I really want to talk about when we can read people's movement. I want to talk about measurable shit. You wanted to paint Kark as scum. Fucking wrong. You want to paint me as scum. Guarantee you're wrong. Scum, town, you're fucking awful at finding town.

Kark nomad and i all voted before the CCS train ever started.

Why do you want to rewrite history?

Why is Sorian so town?

Why is he impossible to prove anyi-town... for reasons....

Who is dumb town... who is scum?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I am going to vote fep because I think he is scum. He is also half dangling an important role claim like CCS did which will probably get him killed tonight anyway if he is town.

If you are going to claim just do it, don't hide behind coded language because scum can break those codes as well.

Vote:flatearthpandas
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
I'm not pushing you off, push it now and I'll claim and eat the nk.

I'm not scaring people off my lynch, I'm assuring the future. Not you can't lynch me... you won't do it.

Why?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I'm not pushing you off, push it now and I'll claim and eat the nk.

I'm not scaring people off my lynch, I'm assuring the future. Not you can't lynch me... you won't do it.

Why?

You are already going to eat a kill if you don't claim.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
scum, I'm loving how bad your are.

Town, you can't surprise me because i have no expectations


Faddy, you're either scum or the worst town I've ever seen
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
This is dumb. You said the same yesterday and it's clear why. I'm done.

VOTE: Dusk Soldier

Dusk is next.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
scum, I'm loving how bad your are.

Town, you can't surprise me because i have no expectations


Faddy, you're either scum or the worst town I've ever seen

Look if you are claiming neutral then fuck it, we are up 2 lynches to 1.

I will gladly get rid of rid of you.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Who the fuck thinks there a neutral in play?

Literally, faddy, worm, what the hell are you doing?

You're like sorian but without the seasons of built in admiration.

Worm, u thought kark was the mason. If you are town, evaluate your reads. They're bad
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Who the fuck thinks there a neutral in play?

Literally, faddy, worm, what the hell are you doing?

You're like sorian but without the seasons of built in admiration.

Worm, u thought kark was the mason. If you are town, evaluate your reads. They're bad

18 players, 4 scum, 1 neutral is a perfectly valid set up.

I'm going to look closely at your posts right now but I wouldn't call what you are doing good town play.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Vote: nomad sparks

People love Sorian. I get it.

But to believe scum would ignore his train versus kawl??? To really believe scum wouldn't take a town train??? Kawl was the third train! You think no one was on number two?


Everyone thought kawl was scum. Your reads are off. Evaluate your shit. Your reads are off.
Town, we can win. Be careful. Be mindful.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
what has the neutral been doing, asshole?

surviving?

or any number of neutral roles that people could come up with.

I read your posts and you do seem to concentrate a lot on a cop but IDK. Because if you were a cop you would have checked Kark and you could have saved him today. Now I am wondering why dangle the claim to save yourself if you weren't actually willing to full claim and give your reads.

But now you aren't voting Sorian. Does Nomad have a red check. I don't know, your play is just too high level for me.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I specifically said i don't think ther's a cop today. Faddy, if you are town, READ THE FUCKING GAME

I don't get the need to be cryptic. If you are using a code and expect town to crack it, don't you think scum can also crack it? And at that point why even be cryptic in the first place. All you are doing is denying dumb townies like me proper information and potentially allowing your posts to be twisted later if you die.
 
Man I am so torn on Feps right now. His posts are clearly full of frustration but I can't tell if it's frustration of being pinned down or frustration of no one listening...
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I don't think feps is scum. I'm questioning Dusk at the moment for that early question about roles. I'm good with Terra and I expect I will stay there. But I've been in meetings all day and will reread all this stuff to make sure I'm not missing anything.

feps feels like a townie in a tunnel. He gets convinced. We all do sometimes. But I don't see it as scummy at this time. I think we have more suspicious fish to fry.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
I have doubts there is a cop

I don't get the need to be cryptic. If you are using a code and expect town to crack it, don't you think scum can also crack it? And at that point why even be cryptic in the first place. All you are doing is denying dumb townies like me proper information and potentially allowing your posts to be twisted later if you die.

Faddy fishing for claims
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
(Expect I will stay doesn't mean I will. Ty's vote was ALSO questionable and there is some merit to voting Nomad or even Topo).
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Guys, think.

Lynch nomad.

Scum will kill me tomorrow or tonight. You won't. Better they do it tomorrow, imo. Really think though. Why would scum not vote Sorian d1. He was the first competing train with kawl. Why no scum? It's either nomad or no one. Why????
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
fep you are acting like you have massive amounts of town credit. Yesterday we lynched scum, you were on the opposite train. Why should we listen to you?

So are Nomad and Sorian both scum? Because that is 4 and the game would be over imo.

It makes all your need to be cryptic complete nonsense. If there is any problem with towns in our circle it is the inability to be straight forward and open.
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
Faddy, my argument is not monsters. Explain why scum doesn't jump on town Sorian d1. You can't. Because of course they do. Vote Nomad.

Faddy, I'm not claiming town credit. I'm saying town vote me. I can claim conclusively. If we we want to to clear Sorian, we can do it now. It involves lynching scum nomad tonight or lynching scum Sorian tomorrow. If i get killed tonight it's okay, but only if nomad is lynched before me. I'm telling you i can prove alignment. Nomad can't. Why did for my claim? Why guarantee my nk? Why really try and lynch me? I know it's cryptic but I've said for days i won't be lynched. Explain why Sorian wouldn't have votes or explain why you need my claim. You sounds scum as hell
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Faddy, my argument is not monsters. Explain why scum doesn't jump on town Sorian d1. You can't. Because of course they do. Vote Nomad.

Faddy, I'm not claiming town credit. I'm saying town vote me. I can claim conclusively. If we we want to to clear Sorian, we can do it now. It involves lynching scum nomad tonight or lynching scum Sorian tomorrow. If i get killed tonight it's okay, but only if nomad is lynched before me. I'm telling you i can prove alignment. Nomad can't. Why did for my claim? Why guarantee my nk? Why really try and lynch me? I know it's cryptic but I've said for days i won't be lynched. Explain why Sorian wouldn't have votes or explain why you need my claim. You sounds scum as hell

Ok tell me why a scum team of nin, Dusk, Terra/Ty and Kawl doesn't work?

I would like your claim because you dangled it with the indication that you had greater knowledge with "read the thread" which says to me, the worst town player, that you have breadcrumbed something and I should be onto it.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
fep if your whole case is scum must be on sorian, why were you on Sorian, why was Kark on Sorian. Why couldn't a 3rd town player be on sorian?
 

flatearthpandas

Round Moon Bears
fep if your whole case is scum must be on sorian, why were you on Sorian, why was Kark on Sorian. Why couldn't a 3rd town player be on sorian?
Thanks for playing. A third could. But the more town on Sorian, the less reason for scum to engineer another train.

The question isn't why are there town on the train. There question is why wouldn't there by scum? This train tired scum before CCS train even started
 
Top Bottom