Spectator Thread 999 and Mini Mafia V Spectator Thread
- Thread starter CaptainNuevo
- Start date
I left them enough clues about Claude. Maybe they find them. I don't think I could have been more obvious.
I could have claimed Cop, but odds are I was gonna get NK.
I thought about lying to save myself - claim some other role - but you vote off liars, so decided against that.
I just want to see some of the townies squirm like they did to me.
I could have claimed Cop, but odds are I was gonna get NK.
I thought about lying to save myself - claim some other role - but you vote off liars, so decided against that.
I just want to see some of the townies squirm like they did to me.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
I think not claiming is bad since you don't know if there is a doctor who could protect you and the mafia roleblocker is dead. Having said that, Cop is the easiest claim to fake in this set up since in the letter regime if CC is replaced with TT the cop is replaced with a vanilla town. So maybe one green check isn't going to be compelling evidence but you could explain why you checked a certain person to show why you were town.
You shouldn't want to see townies squirm. That is your team. They can be wrong about you but you need to do your best to give them all the info you have, explain your stances as clearly as you can. And if they still mislynch you can at least be happy you did your best.
Claiming might not have saved you long term but it would have probably have been enough to survive day 2 and get another check.
Welcome to my world. I've done that in a number of games myself :P
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Hi everyone, I subbed out.
You'll learn who I was eventually but spoiler for my in-game identity/role/alignment:
I haven't peeked at the identity spoilers in here, but this was my final list after D2:
You'll learn who I was eventually but spoiler for my in-game identity/role/alignment:
Trevor
Town Mason
Mason Partner:
My final scum reads were Asuka and Huang.
The current plan in Mason Chat is to mass claim and murder the shit out of Sorian... I mean... Asuka...
Town Mason
Mason Partner:
Catalina
My final scum reads were Asuka and Huang.
The current plan in Mason Chat is to mass claim and murder the shit out of Sorian... I mean... Asuka...
I haven't peeked at the identity spoilers in here, but this was my final list after D2:
[m] Vincent Alexander - TommyV
[m] Olinad - Michael
[m] WhySoDevious - Claude/Carl
[they] Aeleus - Carl/Claude
[m] Kyanrute - Catalina
[f] Dr. Monkey - Lance
[-] Sorian - Asuka
[m] Muffin - Ken
[m] Godfather - Franklin
[f] Kitsunelaine - Huang
[-] Swamped - Stan - Roman
[m] Lone_Prodigy - Niko
[m] Olinad - Michael
[m] WhySoDevious - Claude/Carl
[they] Aeleus - Carl/Claude
[m] Kyanrute - Catalina
[f] Dr. Monkey - Lance
[-] Sorian - Asuka
[m] Muffin - Ken
[m] Godfather - Franklin
[f] Kitsunelaine - Huang
[-] Swamped - Stan - Roman
[m] Lone_Prodigy - Niko
Would you like any confirmations? Or spoilers messaged to you? :P
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I don't want to get into a huge thing about this, but here's what I have to say about your play there:
That was the most Anti-Town route you could have possibly taken. What you should have done was told us right then and there that you were the Cop and gave us your info. Sure, some people might have wondered whether or not you were lying, but there's no way in hell we vote out a claimed Cop when we know that the RB is dead and there is possibly a Doctor.
I don't want to be a dick about it because I can tell you were really frustrated and I know how it feels to get really into these games and have negative emotional outbursts, it can be very cathartic. However, I think when you calm down you'll see that it might have felt good to you at the moment, but there's a good chance that the rest of the players on your team in there are feeling really let down by that move.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I'll take full spoilers in the form of a PM if you don't mind, yeah. I'm too curious lol.
done :) I know you're the curious type which is why I asked :)
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I just didn't have the Mafia-playing energy left to keep going with this one, too many weird things going on, I was confident in my reads and everything but didn't feel like I could keep up with my own pace anymore.
Oh hi there fanto, I was wondering who stu was pming.
o/
o/
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I'll never forgive that group that excluded you in 999 by the way. I shook my head solemnly when I saw that flip.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
If I was Scum, I would have killed you N1. If I was a Vig, I would have killed you N1. If I was a SK, I would have killed you N1.
<3
<3
Fanto
Confirmed Town
My alignment/role:
Y'all really want me to be Scum again, don't you? You just can't accept me as Town for more than one day when I put on my Town Leader hat. I will admit, the fact that I had extra info in that I knew that my Mason partner was also Town did make me play slightly differently to how I would play without extra info, same thing happened to me in MafiEra, but still, I'm as Town as I can be out there god dammit! Just face the facts!
Fanto
Confirmed Town
So, I feel bad about subbing out, but I still think it was the right call for me to make.
Just throughout D2 in general, I was feeling like I didn't have much to say (says the guy with 100 posts), and that I wasn't sure how to navigate through the game anymore. There were a lot of players I wanted to call out, or pressure, or something, but I just didn't have any idea how to go about it anymore.
I had a lot of energy on D1, and that just sort of went away on D2 for whatever reason, and by the end I just had very little motivation left in me. On N1 I was totally into going through and digging for clues, but when I went to go do the same now when N2 started, I found that I really just didn't care anymore, which was a bad feeling.
And that's what led me to asking for a replacement. My guess is it's a burnout thing, that's kind of what it feels like. I had my scum reads, and I just didn't give a fuck whether I was right or wrong, or what new evidence I could find, or who were my top Town reads, none of it felt like it mattered.
So yeah, big long post to basically say that I don't know if this was just because of this game and how things were going, or if in general I just need to stay away from Mafia for a while and actually want to care again. I don't know.
Knowing me, it'll be hard for me to stay away for very long, but now I'll have this thing in the back of my mind like "what if the game burns me out though" and that might not be good, so I'll probably want to make sure that thought goes away before I sign up again.
Just throughout D2 in general, I was feeling like I didn't have much to say (says the guy with 100 posts), and that I wasn't sure how to navigate through the game anymore. There were a lot of players I wanted to call out, or pressure, or something, but I just didn't have any idea how to go about it anymore.
I had a lot of energy on D1, and that just sort of went away on D2 for whatever reason, and by the end I just had very little motivation left in me. On N1 I was totally into going through and digging for clues, but when I went to go do the same now when N2 started, I found that I really just didn't care anymore, which was a bad feeling.
And that's what led me to asking for a replacement. My guess is it's a burnout thing, that's kind of what it feels like. I had my scum reads, and I just didn't give a fuck whether I was right or wrong, or what new evidence I could find, or who were my top Town reads, none of it felt like it mattered.
So yeah, big long post to basically say that I don't know if this was just because of this game and how things were going, or if in general I just need to stay away from Mafia for a while and actually want to care again. I don't know.
Knowing me, it'll be hard for me to stay away for very long, but now I'll have this thing in the back of my mind like "what if the game burns me out though" and that might not be good, so I'll probably want to make sure that thought goes away before I sign up again.
Costume games can be really hard and weird, so don't measure anything by that. <3 This is really nothing like a normal game and it's kind of a thing where it's easy to not get into it because the identities blend and it feels like there are no stakes.
I'm surprised about
I'm surprised about
your mason partner, tbh
Fanto
Confirmed Town
That might have been part of it too, I was having trouble remembering who said what outside of my firmest identity reads. I really love the concept of a costume game, but yeah, things just felt off to me after a while. I would probably have felt a lot more comfortable if the masks were off, the meta is real lol.
Really? I thought I made it obvious with how I was defending her, I even got called out for it. I had a kind of shitty breadcrumb on D1 that I dropped too.
I made both of us confirmed town gifs, and I really hope she uses hers lol.
I made both of us confirmed town gifs, and I really hope she uses hers lol.
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
So now you double hate me? Damn
I'll never forgive that group that excluded you in 999 by the way. I shook my head solemnly when I saw that flip.
It’s understandable. I’ve never actually been able to follow a costume game so far. It’s so hard for me to keep my thoughts straight with all the generic accounts. I’m glad people enjoy them, but I don’t think it’s for me.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
(Still can't get over that self vote though lmao that was so good)
Yeah, I think I might have had more fun just trying to guess who was who from in here and not having to put as much effort in as I normally try to, because it was a lot harder than normal for me to get there. I hope it was just the costume aspect.
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
You won’t be able to resist the next game so I suspect you’ll be back pretty soon :P I think half the fun is the interactions and the masks just make it harder. I’m sure you will get back into the groove no problem, though I know a lot of us have taken various breaks so if you do think you need some time by all means don’t feel like you have to play.
(Still can't get over that self vote though lmao that was so good)
Yeah, I think I might have had more fun just trying to guess who was who from in here and not having to put as much effort in as I normally try to, because it was a lot harder than normal for me to get there. I hope it was just the costume aspect.
I can understand somewhat since I vaguely remember struggling a bit in power rangers trying to figure out who was who and everything. Not that mafia gave me much of a chance lol.
It's okay to take a break. I know I've cut it back a bit! Season 11 (my first season here) I did 4 games, season 12 only 2, one of those I subbed out and obviously for season 13 so far only 1.
It's okay to take a break. I know I've cut it back a bit! Season 11 (my first season here) I did 4 games, season 12 only 2, one of those I subbed out and obviously for season 13 so far only 1.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
Sooooooooo everyone was wrong about who Niko was.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
My OOG scumlist:
TommyV
Roman
How close am I? Just tell me if I'm wrong or right. Maybe. Idk.
TommyV
Roman
How close am I? Just tell me if I'm wrong or right. Maybe. Idk.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
Aaaah, I'm nailbiting now. I wonder if I had my sights pointed at the right target since D1.
And thanks, lol. I'm still tempted to write up a massive will.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
i'm screaming if he is. he's played pretty well to get out of the hole he dug himself
Zzzzz, You two took too long to give me spec access so I did it myself.
Without reading anything here: one of (or both) Catalina and Trevor are mafia, add in Tommy and that group of three should have all the mafia. Ken roleblocked me N1. Carl got a town read on either Claude or Nico, I think it was Claude personally.
Any good guesses in there?
Without reading anything here: one of (or both) Catalina and Trevor are mafia, add in Tommy and that group of three should have all the mafia. Ken roleblocked me N1. Carl got a town read on either Claude or Nico, I think it was Claude personally.
Any good guesses in there?
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I asked in the mod chat as soon as I saw your message >.>
Ok, read through now, I was right on 2 of 3! Maybe, I guess I don't know if Ken roleblocked me but I don't see any other way Lance died.
Franklin had me completely fooled, I even protected him last night, props to whoever that is
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
You got the Claude thing correct.
It actually isn't too bad a guess apart from being completely wrong on alignments.
You weren't roleblocked
It actually isn't too bad a guess apart from being completely wrong on alignments.
You weren't roleblocked
He got shot by both Scum and SK. You only protect from one shot per night as it says in the role description
How many killing roles are in the game? Two people really targeted Lance?
Edit: Nevermind, I was late. That's some shit then. What is that SK doing with these bad picks? lol
Absolutely
Also side note, wasn't Franklin the one that was saying the C++ set up stuff was too complicated yesterday? Now he's a pro? lol
I was actually wondering the same thing myself haha.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
c'mon town you can do it
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
huang said:
this is so weeeeeeeeeird
edit: ok i think i've figured out who catalina is behind the mask
Last edited:
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Crossing my fingers for the 1-1-1 end game where Town has to not vote and hope the Mafia and SK shoot each other, except they can't do that because they know that situation will result in their own loss, so they must shoot the townie, but then the other killer will know that they know that, meaning they could shoot them instead and win, but since they know they know they know that, then they would want to shoot each other, but this would result in a town win, and that would be playing to lose, so instead they would try to shoot the townie...Catalina said:
I'm too lazy to check the set-up. I assume this game goes by standard rules where a 1v1 scum vs. SK is automatically the SK win?
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Could be, I just like the WIFOM lol.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
That makes so much sense. I never bothered looking back at the original list so I was never even completely clear on who made it into the game to begin with. I only suspected her based on me thinking I was roleblocked by the way. The only two people who would have roleblocked me were you or her (I knew who you were).
Damn, now I inadvertently complimented you. I have to go.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Masons being a Scum gambit would be an awesome thing, and I would totally have approved of it, but man, if they go for one of them today that will be amazing.
I will say though, the gifs were really meant for after one of them flipped, I probably should have made that more clear in the chat lol.
I will say though, the gifs were really meant for after one of them flipped, I probably should have made that more clear in the chat lol.
Who do you think?
Also I went away for literally half an hour, come back and I have to warn people.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Is it Z-Beat?
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Well, I knew he signed up but didn't get in, but also, this is the most Z-Beat thing to say ever lol:
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
You can do it Claude!
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
well i'm glad i died last night because i'd have to have gotten a replacement today thanks to my city being a target of terrorism right now and me being kinda shook
Well shit, stay safe
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
yeah i live in christchurch. i'm like a 30 minute walk away from where everything happened.
Oh man, so sorry to hear that. I wasn't even looking at the news or anything (not off topic era, twitter or anything) so i just found out this is going on.
Stay safe <3
Sorry to hear it. I've been near two similar incidents and they're awful.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
the thing that's heartbreaking is that it just doesn't happen over here. mass shootings aren't a thing in new zealand.
Yeah. And from the news, this seems particularly... egregious. I won't lie. It will take time before shit feels normal again, especially for y'all.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
So, 7 players left: 4 Town, 1 SK, 2 Mafia.
Kill SK, it's a 3-2 LyLo tomorrow, which is manageable but rough.
Kill Mafia...
Kill SK, it's a 3-2 LyLo tomorrow, which is manageable but rough.
Kill Mafia...
- If SK shoots Mafia and Mafia shoots SK (assuming SK is not BP), it's 4-0-0 and Town wins. Kind of unlikely though.
- If SK shoots Mafia and Mafia shoots Town, it's 3-1 with just the SK and Town left.
- If SK shoots Town and Mafia shoots SK, it's 3-1 with just one Mafia left.
- If both shoot Town, it's 2-1-1, which probably leads to a Town loss?
- If SK shoots Mafia and Mafia shoots SK, it's a 2-1 LyLo.
- If SK shoots Mafia and Mafia shoots Town, it's a 2-1-1.
- If SK shoots Town and Mafia shoots SK, it's 2-2, Mafia wins.
- If both shoot Town, it's 1-1-2, which is... a Mafia win? I think?
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
Awww, did you try to protect me?
<3
youtried.png
(Still logged into the costume on my phone and I’m far too lazy to switch)
Also same.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I'll address this in here:Huang said:
It did make me feel uncomfortable, mainly because it felt like I was being personally targeted by someone, and I wasn't sure who they were or why they were doing it. After finding out who you are, I'm still not sure why you singled me out like that, because I've never played with you before, so I can only guess as to why you decided to do that.
I also think it's unfair to compare that to how Niko was playing, because Niko was simply adding some flavor to his posts. You were purposefully trying to impersonate another player on the roster, which is not at all similar in my mind.
All that being said, I don't think there was anything wrong with the play necessarily since it was a costume game after all, and I accept the apology, but I do think that was a bit of a grey area that you were in there and isn't really comparable to what Niko was doing.
Kitsunelaine
hi i'm a backpack
Just an FYI, you can refer to me as she out of game. <3
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Sorry, my bad. <3
Also, I think I forgot to mention it before, but your will was great lol. Poor lil Niko!
In PR, we had a player pretend to be a different player each day. It was hilarious tbh.
But yeah, I don't think they were personally targeting you, they were just having a bit of fun. And they really like your gifs. I'd say it's a compliment.
That said when they get here (or after the game if they survive until the end), feel free to discuss it with them but I'm sure they meant no harm.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I guess it's just a strange feeling to have someone I've never played with before go digging through old games I've played so they can find gifs I've made and make references to those games in an attempt to impersonate me, and try to do it for more than one day as well. That's what I meant by "personally targeting."
Bleh, just a lot of stuff about this game got to me in some way. I hope it was just the costume stuff, because I do really want to play in Monkey's Twilight Zone game, but I also think I want to take a break soon and just try to not think about Mafia so much. I've played in or spectated every game since GoT, I could probably use a few weeks to just think about anything else instead.
sorry to hear that :(
I feel the same way. The game broke me in some weird way.
I had come up with a great gambit, but the continuous accusations just made me say, fuck it.
I even tried to breadcrumb... there was a gif that called me Sherlock... I responded with “your gif game is on point”.
Can’t believe they’re not even thinking I green-checked Claude. It’s so obvious.
I had come up with a great gambit, but the continuous accusations just made me say, fuck it.
I even tried to breadcrumb... there was a gif that called me Sherlock... I responded with “your gif game is on point”.
Can’t believe they’re not even thinking I green-checked Claude. It’s so obvious.