Per Me Caeci Vident

[lokiduck]

I'd love for comments to happen just to give me a break from reading LOL.

 

[lokiduck]

These three i'm still suspicious of. i have a strong scum lean on Malus though I think he may be on a different team than swamped/vere.

Mao is a scum lean still (am i tunneling on him? Please tell me if I am because I did this with b-Dubs in SU because he was a vig like me, and Z-beat as well. XD)

Kalor is for sure scum considering that red check on him. He was certainly against Swamped being scum day 1-2 and never talked about it at all on 3 as to being wrong about it.

 

[lokiduck]

LP: Day 2- Analyzed day 1 votes first. Thought Vere voted OJ to save TP and that Swamped was just a noise train. He thought Swamped wasn’t scum and scum was on her train. Thought Aeleus was scum with TP voting on his train because he wasn’t in danger at the time. Thinks Fran and Neon, and maybe Brazil as the scum on swamped. Fran didn’t like being scum read by LP (sounding pretty judgmental about it) and LP explained it was based on him going over the votes for day 1, but D1 doesn’t mean much. Suspicious of Rush for Swamped then Rush for Aeleus. Found Aeleus train suspect based on weak reasoning and that Brazil was too quiet. voted Puns (consistent with previous posts). Thought VA was fine. Scum reading TP. Find it suspicious Sorian has been suspicious of Puns but no one has developed trains on him. Suspicious of Sorian. Feels Swamped would give more info about day 1 though swamped has done better defending herself unlike Aeleus. Would vote Swamped if not voting TP.

Day 3- Found Muffin a weird target for infection since he would be a NK target. Thinks TP is still scum after Swamped defended him lightly. Thinks scum voted Swamped and when she gained too much traction d1 Vere switched votes. Thinks Fanto or Faddy might have voted Swamped to save TP. Thought Kits was a scum cop. Feels better about TP after the Swamped flip and he was going to reread others to reassess his read. Doesn’t think Stu is scum.

Over all I think LP has mostly been tunneling on TP, using the day 1 votes as justification but he has already said he will reread others to see if his read changes. I’m feeling good about him right now, but i want to see what his reads on others are first. He has at least been consistent in his reasoning. interesting he didn’t vote though.

—

Neon: Day 1- Against voting Chuggs or I, early question to OJ. Town lean Malus (?), Wee, and Fanto. Vere and Sorian as well because of their activity. Null on Faddy, Muffin, and Stu. Reasoning for town reading Malus was because he was a lot calmer than in SU. Thought Scum might be more unwilling to do event 2 with the risk of a RB. Voted Swamped because Fanto voted for her because he didn’t have time to read thread. Said he was forced to vote via Fran asking everyone to.

Day 2- Early reads list.

Well a mafia died and pretty much noone else. That is kind of weird, but this is bastard. So...

Well, let's do a reads list: (Miss duck, I did copy your template just to save time, I hope you don't mind).

Lokiduck: Miss duck has so far been in her town play mode, as in asking questions regularly and keeping here ever trusty read list at the ready. Kind of a moot point to say this because of the mod confirm, but she is the towniest town that towned on this town.

Fantomas: Lean town. Just like Loki, Fanto has been very active in this game (maybe I should learn from you), and has been actively scumhunting.

Sorian: Lean town for now. Has been prodding constantly and their analysis of the dead mafia makes sense.

Stuart444: Based on his interactions with ver last day and the whole bandwagon on him, I'm willing to see him as lean town for now.

Fran: Very active so far. Although somewhat pushy in making sure eveyone voted on day one. Perhaps it was from a townie's point of view, wanting tthe rest of the players to be as active as possible. Null, slight lean town for now.

Faddy: Active and had he same idea i had about multiple mafia factions. Null, leaning town for now.

Cat: Relatively active with some good theories and posts. Relative lean town.

Muffin: Got his item stolen, but that is NAI. Null for now as I can't get a good read on him yet.

TheChuggernaut: Willing to believe he is lean town for now. Seeing as Ver was trying to coax more information out of him.

Apopheniac: Dunno. Null for now.

Kalor: Dunno what to think about you so far. Relatively active, but hasn't really stuck on my mind. His votes are weird though. Null for now.

Kitsunelaine: She has been relatively busy with IRL stuff so far so I can't form an opinion yet. Null for now.

weemadarthur: Given that Ver threw shade at wee last day phase, I see him leaning town.

Fandorin: Not enough information. Null for now.

Maolfunction: Null for now. I don't think his not voting for swamped indicates a connection.

Absolutbro: DUnno. Seeing that Ver was sorta pushing him as scum makes me htink he is not scum. Or at least not part of his team if there are indeed two teams. Null for now.

Brazil: Null for now. Don't have enough information on him.

Vincent Alexander: So far his posts have seemed reactive to me. COuld be a townie that waits and sees, but dunno. Null but keeping my eye on him.

Swamped: The whole day one votes for her apparently caused Ver to change votes? Did I get that right? I agree with the suspicions thrown so far.

Tearablepuns: As mentioned before by Sorian. His interactions with Ver do put a bit of a shade on him. Null but keeping an eye on him for the time being.

Malus: Dunno. He seemed more composed to me last day. But his vote switching from O to Stan could mean something. Null for now. But will keep an eye on.

Aeleus: Null given the fact that he hasn't posted at all since yesterday.

Ket:Somewhat active, but so far her posts have looked more reactive to me (might be because I'm tired perhaps), null for now.

Zipped: Null. With so little posts I don't have a solid read on hm. But he does make a good point in that the whole mafia could have been RB.

Voted swamped. Debated why Aeleus would make Chuggs so those posts if they are the one doing it. Seems like a neutral action. Felt Zipped, Ket, and Mao did bandwagoning votes. Thinks someone tried to frame Aeleus. Scum lean on Swamped, Mao, and Kitsune. Aeleus as null, and Chuggs, wee, and I as town. Ket is coasting.

Day 3: Shot at Sorian first. I thought he had focused on me, but now I realized that he was short of just shooting randomly at all the players with no real reason. Won the game. Wouldn’t vote Aeleus because they proved their claim. Debating between Ket and Kits due to being low activity, though TP is suspicious. Voted Kits. Unvoted after her claim. Voted Ket in the end.

After looking at this posts again, I’m still getting a null read from him. His reads haven’t been too bad, but they are a bit similar to my own and some others (most people are town leaning wee, or scum reading mao or Kits.) I’m less mad at him for killing me in the roulette game now that I realized I wasn’t his only target LOL.

 

[lokiduck]

I was going to look over some other peeps and I still might, but I think I'm done for the night. My main scum suspects are still Kalor, Mao, and Malus so I want to focus on them tomorrow anyways. In either case, I want to hear what you guys think so maybe it's good if I don't fill an entire page out myself. XD

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I’m just going to say, for when Vere and Swamped see this post: you guys suck lol

Idk if they pre planned making me look bad like that but it was genius and it made me have to defend myself more than I was prepared to this game. Going to the gym, and then before work hopefully I’ll have time to look back at stuff.

I will not be in the game thread for day start.

As you may have noticed already, while I’m busy at work or school or anywhere else, I will sometimes post in here but never in the game thread. I do this to avoid any chance of rushed posts or autocorrected posts. But at least now you guys will know if I die or not

 

[lokiduck]

Yep XD Thanks for letting us know who you are because that was actually kind of funny when Fanto and I thought you were Vere.

Also sorry he keep getting suspected like this, I had to somewhat deal with that in my first game near endgame because i had slept trough quite a few EoD's due to them being turboed without being able to put a vote down.

The only reason we weren't voted out on the last day was because I had been massively townread all game and because Ket and I managed to convince the remaining townies we were actually lovers and not scum trying some crazy ploy. XD

Mind you peeps are suspicious of me because of being confirmed town in a bastard game so I'm sure that'll come back to haunt me late if I live long enough :/ Basic tip I can tell you already though is that it sucks. XD

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Not gonna lie, D1 was hilarious watching you guys go in on me lol especially Fanto. He was super convinced I was scum.

I’m fine with it. It’s part of the game! And Town is well so far. 2 townies and 2 scum dead is great for 2 days. We can still pull through this.
I’m sure Ket not has a big target on her back though because of the mind stone reveal. So I worry about that.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Hey guys, sorry for the delay in joining you after EoD.

That Mind Stone reveal was fuck haha. But yeah, I guess the Infinity Stones are the common factor here then; I have the Reality Stone. Like TP it doesn’t really match my character flavor and all that, but I asked Geno at the beginning if it was an item that could be passed or stolen and he said it’s part of my role.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Now that we know that I feel more comfortable with the nature of the chat. Like TP said there are 6 stones tho and from flavor it looks like Thanos is collecting them. Maybe we have a neutral that needs to kill us all or something like that, but I don’t think they are in this chat.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

What's everyone's opinion on Malus? I'm currently looking over his posts (since he had the least out of my current suspects lol)

He was a scum lean at the start but so much shit happened that he kinda just fell off the list despite not improving much. I’d say I’m null about him at the moment. I don’t think I’ve played with him as scum before, but he’s usually a scum read player. Could try to ISO him to confirm my thoughts on him.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Now that we know that I feel more comfortable with the nature of the chat. Like TP said there are 6 stones tho and from flavor it looks like Thanos is collecting them. Maybe we have a neutral that needs to kill us all or something like that, but I don’t think they are in this chat.

Exactly what i was thinking. It sounds like a neutral and this chat was created to actually give us a chance at coordinating them not getting the 5 stones since they could win relatively easy if they get the right kills nightly/daily? Who knows when they can check us.
Which makes me think it might be a neutral team of at least 2. Having only one person with that kind of mission could end relatively quickly if they die.

LP is really standing out to me in that regard. Maybe even Sorian.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Three things that reading your posts reminded me loki:
Mao is still coasting and not contributing at all. He made that big ass post with some safe reads with zero progression and lot of flavor and just vanished. That did nothing to change my mind regarding him.

Chuggs being forced to vote someone by the hypnotist is weird and I felt like he had more than one controlled post other than the vote post itself. It’s weird that scum would do that now after he already allowed to vote for Swamped on D2, if what they want is the item I mean.

I’m still very suspect of LP. Despite posting a bunch more he’s still coasting on others and doesn’t seem to try and progress his reads at all. He didn’t even vote this phase and I think that might be because he knew we had no scum on the top wagons. Plus, looking at your write up on his D3, there is a stark difference between his posts on TP and now I actually want to check this progression.

Day 3- Found Muffin a weird target for infection since he would be a NK target. Thinks TP is still scum after Swamped defended him lightly. Thinks scum voted Swamped and when she gained too much traction d1 Vere switched votes. Thinks Fanto or Faddy might have voted Swamped to save TP. Thought Kits was a scum cop. Feels better about TP after the Swamped flip and he was going to reread others to reassess his read. Doesn’t think Stu is scum.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I just realized these are the last two events and I would love to get my item...
I might have to find a way to post at work.
This is really going to suck lol

I’m still very suspect of LP.

im glad we’re on the same page lol time to pressure him this day phase

 

[Illuminati member 2]

But we have to be discrete about the LP pressure.

Remember, we all voted Kits last day phase, so we gotta tread softly this day phase

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Plus, I think I should leave my maybe paranoid take that Brazil could be scum with Sorian or Kalor here. He has the right amount of good scum hunting across the board and some good distancing between each other, which is the kind of scum play I think we’d get from him. He’s definitely not yet clear on my book.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

But we have to be discrete about the LP pressure.

Remember, we all voted Kits last day phase, so we gotta tread softly this day phase

I don’t think we are in much risk in this regard, but that might be wrong if this possible neutral hunter knows we are in cahoots lol.

But anyway, let’s hope Kalor gets shot this phase so we don’t lose an entire lynch on him.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I don’t think we are in much risk in this regard, but that might be wrong if this possible neutral hunter knows we are in cahoots lol.

But anyway, let’s hope Kalor gets shot this phase so we don’t lose an entire lynch on him.

Yeah, I just don’t want to underestimate people making these connections. Especially the one scanning anything they can find in the thread to find us lol

These night phases have been so unpredictable.

Btw, I wasted my space stone shot last day phase... I’m Tearable at this game.
It’s a switch and I used it on Cat and Stu. Nothing seemed to have happened?
So regarding the other switch people have been talking about, there must be another switcher

 

[Illuminati member 2]

*last night phase

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Yeah, I just don’t want to underestimate people making these connections. Especially the one scanning anything they can find in the thread to find us lol

These night phases have been so unpredictable.

Btw, I wasted my space stone shot last day phase... I’m Tearable at this game.
It’s a switch and I used it on Cat and Stu. Nothing seemed to have happened?
So regarding the other switch people have been talking about, there must be another switcher

That’s a weird switch lol. It doesn’t look like it did yeah, but we could find something out later.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

That’s a weird switch lol. It doesn’t look like it did yeah, but we could find something out later.

I know... my regret is targeting Cat. Idk why but i tried to pick one person I town read at the time and one person I scum read at the time... but i should have realized there was no action around Cat so why tf did I even target her lmao.

Btw, so if Swamped poisoned somebody, they will die N4 and flip D5 right?
Working theory: Swamped targeted me. Hence her and vere saying that they didn’t find me scummy.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Sorian pulling back his vote on me after grilling me all day phase was really shocking... he even mentions that he’s happy he caught himself tunneling and that I wasn’t going to be lunched.

Working theory: Sorian is a member of FoL

 

[Illuminati member 2]

He knows the poison will work on me and he’s trying to distance himself from me before it takes hold

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Sorian pulling back his vote on me after grilling me all day phase was really shocking... he even mentions that he’s happy he caught himself tunneling and that I wasn’t going to be lunched.

Working theory: Sorian is a member of FoL

He knows the poison will work on me and he’s trying to distance himself from me before it takes hold

Sorian could be that, though I’m thnking he might be FoDarkness instead and just figured out you were town along D3 or something like that.

Oh, and @lokiduck I think the ITA command can be anything really, so Kalor could’ve just said “pew pew: Sorian”. It worked like that in Marvel Mafia and it gave us some very cool ITA shots lol.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Yeah, after reading Fandorin and Loki's posts, i'm going to look a lot into: Malus, Sorian, LP and Brazil.
LP's will be easy because most of it is about me.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Ughhh. I’m not even halfway with investigating Sorian, and I already have to get ready for work.
What a pain.
I’m going to do my best to participate in the event.

But something to think about before I post my entire read of Sorian: he posted about continuing to pressure nin because he doesn’t want a late game scum coasting win and a minute after, Geno posted that nin was replaced. Right after, Sorian switched his vote to Brazil..
I looked back at last games scum thread and Geno would post A LOT there. Geno could have told scum chat that he was looking for a replacement for nin, so Sorian got to typing a reason why he “should” keep pressuring nin, and then when the replacement was announced, he could easily dismiss voting there. I could be way off but something to thing about

 

[Illuminati member 2]

If Geno doesn’t post Megalovania to set the tone for this next event. For shame lol :P

 

[Illuminati member 3]

If Geno doesn’t post Megalovania to set the tone for this next event. For shame lol :P

Yeah, Megalovania is the least I expect. Give me "Battle Against a True Hero" for maximum points tho.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Ughhh. I’m not even halfway with investigating Sorian, and I already have to get ready for work.
What a pain.
I’m going to do my best to participate in the event.

But something to think about before I post my entire read of Sorian: he posted about continuing to pressure nin because he doesn’t want a late game scum coasting win and a minute after, Geno posted that nin was replaced. Right after, Sorian switched his vote to Brazil..
I looked back at last games scum thread and Geno would post A LOT there. Geno could have told scum chat that he was looking for a replacement for nin, so Sorian got to typing a reason why he “should” keep pressuring nin, and then when the replacement was announced, he could easily dismiss voting there. I could be way off but something to thing about

Hummm.. Sorian loves dissing low count posters, and pushing a bit against nin / LP at the start is a safe way to get some bus points. Not sure he knew nin had already asked for a replacement, but it is interesting that he mostly subdued that line of thought following the nin's sub out.

 

[Illuminati member 4]

Honestly, mafia should not kill me tonight, but if I do die, then seriously consider that someone is looking for those stones. There are 5 of us in here, each with a stone, so someone has 1 more on their own out there, which does match up to how I would expect a Thanos situation.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Honestly, mafia should not kill me tonight, but if I do die, then seriously consider that someone is looking for those stones. There are 5 of us in here, each with a stone, so someone has 1 more on their own out there, which does match up to how I would expect a Thanos situation.

anyone you’d like us to look into just in case you’re not here next day phase?
I saw you found Fran suspicious with his votes before day end.

 

[Illuminati member 4]

anyone you’d like us to look into just in case you’re not here next day phase?
I saw you found Fran suspicious with his votes before day end.

Honestly, I've been thinking about the thunderdome a lot and who I should have aimed for, and I think people should look a bit closer at both Aeleus and Brazil. Brazil has been widely town read the whole time to the point that I don't recall much pressure going his way. I don't think he's necessarily on the same team as Verelios and Swamped, but he could be a neutral or on that elusive 2nd scum team. Aeleus is someone who people are going to largely consider town for creating the thunderdome, but I think we need to consider that they were able to put 5 people into it. While the item likely gave them that increase in power, the odds of Aeleus dying in that moment aren't super high and can be used as a cover for teammates or directing the conversation away from other people for a little bit.

Wee and Loki are confirmed town at this point, so that's the only place I wouldn't look. Also, I want to say, don't believe Sorian's claim. I can't count the number of times I've read a game that he's in and he makes up some serious lies that are just crazy enough that people believe it must be real. He claimed that he could live through ITA's and events, but that's awfully convenient timing to reveal after Kalor's claim. Watch how he signs up for these last two in particular

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Thanks for that Ket. I too believe Aeleus gave people too much of a pass because of the TD creation. And Brazil during the last hour of last phase has me questioning him a lot more now, and that’s why I chose to look into him today.

And great insight on Sorian’d play style. I’m not going to give him a pass at all because of his claim, that’s why he’s the first person I’m looking into today.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

*people gave Aeleus a pass

 

[lokiduck]

Exactly what i was thinking. It sounds like a neutral and this chat was created to actually give us a chance at coordinating them not getting the 5 stones since they could win relatively easy if they get the right kills nightly/daily? Who knows when they can check us.
Which makes me think it might be a neutral team of at least 2. Having only one person with that kind of mission could end relatively quickly if they die.

LP is really standing out to me in that regard. Maybe even Sorian.

Honestly, mafia should not kill me tonight, but if I do die, then seriously consider that someone is looking for those stones. There are 5 of us in here, each with a stone, so someone has 1 more on their own out there, which does match up to how I would expect a Thanos situation.

I feel it'd be too easy if the neutral hunting us could kill us as well (I would know from trying to make games) so I wonder if they are more of a lyncher where they need all of us to die, so they will try and get us killed via lunching or convincing those with Nk's to kill us. We'll find out though if Ket or I die tonight though.

But yeah feeling better about the chat because that definitely seems to be our purpose is to protect the stones. In that case the remaining three of you need to keep quiet about yours and maybe even avoid using them if possible (Zeke's is public so definitely risky).

Lol maybe I should have just said the cop shot was one of my abilities instead of bringing up this mcGuffin business .-.

I just realized these are the last two events and I would love to get my item...

LOL hope your item wasn't the Chaos Emerald this time. XD

Yeah, I just don’t want to underestimate people making these connections. Especially the one scanning anything they can find in the thread to find us lol

These night phases have been so unpredictable.

Btw, I wasted my space stone shot last day phase... I’m Tearable at this game.
It’s a switch and I used it on Cat and Stu. Nothing seemed to have happened?
So regarding the other switch people have been talking about, there must be another switcher

There definitely seems to be a few switching abilities which makes sense because one of my passive abilities is a counter to it.

Oh, and @lokiduck I think the ITA command can be anything really, so Kalor could’ve just said “pew pew: Sorian”. It worked like that in Marvel Mafia and it gave us some very cool ITA shots lol.

Ahhhhhhhhh I was hoping it'd be a hint. I have a cool command for my other ability.

 

[lokiduck]

Speaking of. I can't happily talk about my powers now because i'm just a regular Innocent child now. lol Because last night i did this:

 

[lokiduck]

Welp seems our neutral can kill maybe? Also Ket no!!!!!

Also no mention of us or the stone so yay???

 

[lokiduck]

So i was right Thanos is going to want to collect us. So DO NOT MENTION YOU HAVE THE STONES GUYS.

I'm probably next.

 

[lokiduck]

There is a chance that scum just took out Ket instead of it being Thanos, but this is legit bad. I really should have claimed the shot was one of my powers.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Interesting that our stone abilities aren’t in our flip. Loki, no more mcguffin talk if you can help it. I’m paranoid now. But I unfortunately had a feeling that once she publicly revealed that she had the mind stone that she would be gone overnight

 

[lokiduck]

Interesting that our stone abilities aren’t in our flip. Loki, no more mcguffin talk if you can help it. I’m paranoid now. But I unfortunately had a feeling that once she publicly revealed that she had the mind stone that she would be gone overnight

Yeah I'm going to avoid discussing why her "item" didn't show up on her pm. If people connect the dots, they'll realize what mine is.

It would ahve been believable for me to have a cop check, I should have just claimed it was an ability ><

 

[lokiduck]

Welp Kalor's claim was real and he just did an anti-town move by not claiming earlier... I wasted my shot and Kits did too then.

 

[lokiduck]

Well shit I was wrong about Malus too.

 

[lokiduck]

I'm honestly unsure where to focus now :/

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Sorian, LP, Malus and Brazil are good starting points. Sorian is way too curious about the infinity stones after Ket’s flip. I don’t like it.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Omg I didn’t see the malus flip wtfff

 

[lokiduck]

Well shit though, I did those reads on malus and Kalor only for them to be completely useless :/ This is really throwing me off.

 

[lokiduck]

Also just realized I wasted both of my abilities ><

So full claim time.

I'm a mod confirmed town with 1 roleblock (called a shield bash) and a cop check.

I checked Kalor two nights ago and he turned out to be a miller so good job me for getting foiled by the role that's supposed to balance my role out.

Last night I Shield Bash Malus... and welp that was a waste as well.

I'm pretty mad at myself right now.

 

[lokiduck]

Point brought up by Brazil is that Ket didn't have an item. I'm assuming now that none of us do because we have the stones.

 

[lokiduck]

never mind LOL

 

[lokiduck]

Lol Stu trying to throw shade at me.

 

[lokiduck]

Whatever Fran.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

It’s all good Loki. I didn’t no better with my stone lol
And Cat playing dumb about the mind stone?
NOT BUYING IT

 

[lokiduck]

i'm really mad at Stu right now lol

 

[lokiduck]

ANyways I'm putting together an excel sheet like I did for day 3 for the first two days, just so i can keep track of alignments ad all that and see if it tells me anything.

 

[lokiduck]

I'm going to go eat something, do some errands and reevaluate my options. This is the day I can really participate (since I'm off Monday, Friday and the weekends) so I will definitely put in some effort when I get back.

 

[Illuminati Member 5]

Seems like Fran is going in all directions again. No real focus.

 

[Illuminati Member 5]

 

[lokiduck]

I wish there was a way we could trick the Thanos player into revealing themself. XD I assume they are our main threat in this group so getting rid of them would be lovely, but the good news is that unlike them and town, no one knows how many stones they have so we have that advantage.

If we could get rid of them, then we'd only have to worry about the las plagas infector, any neutrals, and of course the remaining mafia members. :/

 

[lokiduck]

I should have checked Fran. I'm going to definitely go over him during the night phase because his behavior has been really weird, I just haven't had a reason to justify my voting for him or voicing those suspicions.

 

[lokiduck]

Apop's role is connected to the infinity stones??? Also weird posts still i see.

 

[lokiduck]

Also we know the stones are in the game because of the flavor at the beginning so ???

 

[lokiduck]

I mean obviously it was a bait post because he's claiming Ket wasn't town when she was.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

Apop's role is connected to the infinity stones??? Also weird posts still i see.

If Apop reveals that he has a stone, this could be big for us. He doesn't know we have a chat full of people with the rest of the stones. He'd be the odd one out O.O

 

[lokiduck]

If Apop reveals that he has a stone, this could be big for us. He doesn't know we have a chat full of people with the rest of the stones. He'd be the odd one out O.O

Yeah that'd be a bit weird and makes him suspicious as well, in fact it's something we can use to our advantage if he is the neutral we need to take out because obviously we can coordinate and make sure we don't all engage him about it (in fact I think we should avoid the conversation altogether unless we are asked our opinion on it.

However, the part that stuck out to me, is that Apop thinks the stones are connected with our roles... which they fucking are.

 

[lokiduck]

So it's good that our Illuminati membership doesn't get revealed with our death (because that'd probably end up causing more issues as Town would freak), but I'm still wondering out we get revealed to the rest of the game.

At this point I'm wondering if we ever will and when we all die/the game ends Geno and Gorlak will just mentioned "All of the members of the illuminati are dead!/Winners (fill in the name) won and were part of the Ilum and everyone will go "there was an illuminati????"

I feel like we may be a counter to the neutral as said above as we can try to work together to find them, but how do we proceed with that? Do we pursue and try and get out Apop, do we leave him alone in case he's baiting the other stone owners out?

 

[lokiduck]

I would like to point out that Mao made the "I want to see how they flip to see who was on their case" argument again when talking about Faddy =-=

Like I get flipping is important so yes Mao I know how to fucking play Mafia but "We'll see how they flip so I can analyze" is an extremely weak argument for wanting to vote someone if that's all you have.

Either way I'm not bringing it up with him again but if someone else wants to go right ahead.

 

[Illuminati Member 5]

Note to self: start reading along with the thread when put on replacement list.


I think I’m used to playing in smaller games which didn’t require much time to catch up/reread.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I feel like we may be a counter to the neutral as said above as we can try to work together to find them, but how do we proceed with that? Do we pursue and try and get out Apop, do we leave him alone in case he's baiting the other stone owners out?

this is why i proposed the idea that there is a neutral faction, not just one person, looking for the stones. i think we should just chill and see what Apop has to say on his own. he's put it on people's radar so im sure it wont be forgotten.
and Mao's trust in Neon is offputting. yes he voted swamped, but he also votes kits too

 

[Illuminati Member 5]

I would like to point out that Mao made the "I want to see how they flip to see who was on their case" argument again when talking about Faddy =-=

Like I get flipping is important so yes Mao I know how to fucking play Mafia but "We'll see how they flip so I can analyze" is an extremely weak argument for wanting to vote someone if that's all you have.

Either way I'm not bringing it up with him again but if someone else wants to go right ahead.

Meh I’ve used it before. Usually because I have a working theory based on that flip.

I am usually wrong though

 

[Illuminati Member 5]

Was multiple scum teams brought up b4 I joined?

 

[lokiduck]

Note to self: start reading along with the thread when put on replacement list.


I think I’m used to playing in smaller games which didn’t require much time to catch up/reread.

I actually kept up with LB3 when I was a replacement just to make sure i'd be able to do my job properly if I swapped in. I ended up being crazy busy when I was asked though.

this is why i proposed the idea that there is a neutral faction, not just one person, looking for the stones. i think we should just chill and see what Apop has to say on his own. he's put it on people's radar so im sure it wont be forgotten.
and Mao's trust in Neon is offputting. yes he voted swamped, but he also votes kits too

Agree about Mao townreading Neon I'll even brought it up in my post on him. And yeah I like your idea of waiting on Apop, maybe he'll get himself killed instead LOL.

Meh I’ve used it before. Usually because I have a working theory based on that flip.

I am usually wrong though

I'm fine with that as an argument as long as you say "Because I have a theory" or at the very least include something else besides it.

Was multiple scum teams brought up b4 I joined?

Yes it was by Faddy actually. I think it was D2. I'm also sideyeing Stu for saying I must be scum if there is more than one scum faction.

Also if you have problems with Mao can you please bring them up so i'm not the only one lol. XD

 

[lokiduck]

lol thanks for using the gif every post Zeke, I still didn't notice that one post was Puns though. XD

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I'm also sideyeing Stu for saying I must be scum if there is more than one scum faction.

Also if you have problems with Mao can you please bring them up so i'm not the only one lol. XD

Stu is coasting through this game. with Fran, Faddy and Sorian all saying he's a bad vote, he's pretty much untouchable.

I don't get scum vibes from zipped just yet even though he's super mellow as always.
I wouldn't mind voting Mao or maybe even Brazil, if i cant propose a decent argument against him.
My gut wants Sorian gone. Something about his claim just seems off and the way he unvoted me yesterday seemed fake.

I truly believe Swamped poisoned somebody, and i have a feeling it was me. so we'll see what happens this upcoming night.

 

[lokiduck]

If too many people are protecting Stu, I wonder if we should look elsewhere for now until we can build up a decent case against him, kind of like I'm doing with my gut scum reads. I'm pretty set on voting Mao during this day phase, but I want to see what other arguments are pushing and look over others first. Again if there is a way we can get out Apop without him realizing we are the ones that have the stones, that'd be great LOL.

 

[lokiduck]

Since Zipped has 39 posts, I'll look over him real fast before looking at Apop.

 

[lokiduck]

Assessment on Zipped, he seems like he was as town in LB3. He was fine with not getting the item which is why some people were positively reading him, when that really doesn't mean much. He's only voted for Ket and Aeleus. He's a big ole null read.

 

[lokiduck]

Fran: Asks me to explain why I'm town reading Fando and Puns.

Me: >>; *Tries to not instantly say we are members of a secret global organization and I trust them*

---

To be honest I downplayed my reads on you in the hope you wouldn't stand out. XD

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Shit I’m late to comment here, but damn Ketkat got dead. I’m glad you managed to use your stone first! But yeah, at least our stones didn't get mentioned there so it’s real that Thanos is hunting us.

Quick takes. I’m really surprised Kalor flipped town. That’s pretty bad for us, two wasted checks on a miller because he didn’t claim that first. At least he managed to ITA himself first.

Apop was clearly forced to post that soft claim of his. He even came back to complement the post with another sentence lol. I think the hypnotist is just causing chaos, don’t think he actually has another stone or something like that, he played that too casually for that

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Stu is coasting through this game. with Fran, Faddy and Sorian all saying he's a bad vote, he's pretty much untouchable.

I don't get scum vibes from zipped just yet even though he's super mellow as always.
I wouldn't mind voting Mao or maybe even Brazil, if i cant propose a decent argument against him.
My gut wants Sorian gone. Something about his claim just seems off and the way he unvoted me yesterday seemed fake.

I truly believe Swamped poisoned somebody, and i have a feeling it was me. so we'll see what happens this upcoming night.

I’ll try to go in on Sorian. I get the snarky suspicion that both him and Brazil are a team. That would be horrible, but I’m actually considering it.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Fran: Asks me to explain why I'm town reading Fando and Puns.

Me: >>; *Tries to not instantly say we are members of a secret global organization and I trust them*

---

To be honest I downplayed my reads on you in the hope you wouldn't stand out. XD

lol just don’t get modkilled explaining that read. I’ll post in the thread now that I’m catch up

 

[lokiduck]

Shit I’m late to comment here, but damn Ketkat got dead. I’m glad you managed to use your stone first! But yeah, at least our stones didn't get mentioned there so it’s real that Thanos is hunting us.

Quick takes. I’m really surprised Kalor flipped town. That’s pretty bad for us, two wasted checks on a miller because he didn’t claim that first. At least he managed to ITA himself first.

Apop was clearly forced to post that soft claim of his. He even came back to complement the post with another sentence lol. I think the hypnotist is just causing chaos, don’t think he actually has another stone or something like that, he played that too casually for that

Yeah Kalor really hurt town by not telling us he was a miller. It's a bit hilarious that both cops hit the role that was their foil, but it could have been avoided and I wouldn't be in a funk right now >:(

Also hadn't considered that Apop was being controlled actually. That post was just hella weird and felt like bait to me.

 

[lokiduck]

I’ll try to go in on Sorian. I get the snarky suspicion that both him and Brazil are a team. That would be horrible, but I’m actually considering it.

It'd be kind of amazing if Brazil and Sorian were a team again for the sequel XD I think people would assume it was fixed from the start somehow. XD But yeah good idea to maybe focus there.

lol just don’t get modkilled explaining that read. I’ll post in the thread now that I’m catch up

Don't worry about it XD I basically said I liked your analysis but hated your voting history, and Puns i like for the most part but don't always agree with and that basically for me right now there are bigger fish to fry and you both seem townie enough to be a town lean for me. XD

 

[lokiduck]

I'm waiting for people to as why I gave Zeke such a high rating just because my response will basically be "Fanto was a major town read for me, and Zeke hasn't given me a reason to doubt that lol

 

[lokiduck]

Aeleus has largely been focused on Fran, Zipped, Kits, and Kalor latter two being town. Picked TD targets based on tallying up everyone's lists and picking the most repeat offenders.

I believe Aeleus' claim, and I believe he is town based on that power for now. His TD targets are NAI though.

 

[lokiduck]

Well FML that grinding event i mentioned in my game is starting on the 29th. So if I could die sometime soon that'd be great ;D

 

[lokiduck]

If we want to do some crazy gambit to lure out the neutral after our stones, I'm your cap ;)

 

[lokiduck]

Fando... he was roleblocked last night .-.

 

[lokiduck]

Apo is suggesting Chuggs isn't being controlled today and I wonder if this is his hint that he is like you suggested Fando?

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Fando... he was roleblocked last night .-.

Wait, who was roleblocked? malus? I went lazy and just trusted Sorian with this post.

No and by the time I finish this, someone will have probably beat me to it but let's see.


Day 1: Roleblocks on Sorian, loki, wee, Faddy, Fantomas, Stu, Kalor


Day 2: Roleblocks on Fantomas, Brazil, and Ketkat. No votes for Sorian and malus


Day 3: Roleblocks on Sorian, Kalor, Cat. No votes for Aeleus, Stu, and loki


I think that's right?

 

[lokiduck]

Wait, who was roleblocked? malus? I went lazy and just trusted Sorian with this post.

No I meant I roleblocked him with my last ability. He wasn't one of the RB targets last night. But either way i may have interfered with him being able to use that track ><

 

[lokiduck]

Should I comment that I agree with Brazil's point about Stu's only main game posts being scumreading me and that being weird lol XD I always feel weird talking about me lol.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

No I meant I roleblocked him with my last ability. He wasn't one of the RB targets last night. But either way i may have interfered with him being able to use that track ><

Oh yeah, I totally forgot about your RB lol.

Oh well, he didn’t seem to breadcrumb anything last phase either way so I guess he didn’t get anything worthwhile.

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Should I comment that I agree with Brazil's point about Stu's only main game posts being scumreading me and that being weird lol XD I always feel weird talking about me lol.

Stu is so weird this game. I’m just glad D1 mess sorta kinda cleared him at the end.

Well FML that grinding event i mentioned in my game is starting on the 29th. So if I could die sometime soon that'd be great ;D

What game is this? Really curious now lol

If we want to do some crazy gambit to lure out the neutral after our stones, I'm your cap ;)

What don’t do that. Pretty sure it ain’t worth it, especially now that Ket is dead. She was our offensive in the end since she could just override Thanos no question asked.

 

[lokiduck]

What game is this? Really curious now lol

Fate/Grand Order it's part of the fate series and we have two yearly events where you get to grind lottery boxes to your hearts desire for mats and resources. During Christmas last year (the other grindy event) I farmed 78 boxes lol so I want to use most of my free time farming.

What don’t do that. Pretty sure it ain’t worth it, especially now that Ket is dead. She was our offensive in the end since she could just override Thanos no question asked.

Lol don't worry I won't do anything crazy, it would have been cool if we could have planned something though :o

 

[lokiduck]

Additionally Vere and I are making a game based around the fate series so totally check that out when it's out :p

 

[lokiduck]

Stu is so weird this game. I’m just glad D1 mess sorta kinda cleared him at the end.

Stu has definitely been very weird this game, though I kind of wonder if he's town scumreading me because scum is keeping me alive... XD

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Fate/Grand Order it's part of the fate series and we have two yearly events where you get to grind lottery boxes to your hearts desire for mats and resources. During Christmas last year (the other grindy event) I farmed 78 boxes lol so I want to use most of my free time farming.



Lol don't worry I won't do anything crazy, it would have been cool if we could have planned something though :o

Ohh, Fate/Grand Order! I really like the series so I’m hyped to know a game is under works! Fortunately I can only be addicted to a single gacha game per decade so Grand Order won’t do much for me lol

 

[lokiduck]

Ohh, Fate/Grand Order! I really like the series so I’m hyped to know a game is under works! Fortunately I can only be addicted to a single gacha game per decade so Grand Order won’t do much for me lol

Oh neat XD I'll definitely message you when we are ready to release it XD

And yeah I get the gacha game thing. Which gacha game has your favor then? XD

 

[Illuminati member 3]

Oh neat XD I'll definitely message you when we are ready to release it XD

And yeah I get the gacha game thing. Which gacha game has your favor then? XD

Dragalia Lost! I’m a real sucker for it.

 

[Illuminati member 2]

I’ll try to go in on Sorian. I get the snarky suspicion that both him and Brazil are a team. That would be horrible, but I’m actually considering it.

Me too.. like i said, I’ll never forgive Geno if that’s the case. Lol
I wish he had more pressure on him so he would tell us more about his lame ITA ability that seems to only work on this last event and the one upcoming.
So pretty much, it’s only to increase his odds in getting an item.. I don’t buy it