Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

[Witch]

Credit how. Scum would totally point that out, free townie points.

It gave her exactly zero townie points, actually. No one batted an eye.

 

[Witch]

I wouldn't say that's the case, scum can want the neutral dead, they'd love it if town wasted a lynch on the neutral.

Scum wouldn't need to point it out to accomplish that, would they?

 

[Bob Ross]

Scum wouldn't need to point it out to accomplish that, would they?

They're not going to waste a kill on a suspected neutral unless it's something powerful, they let town do the work. So yeah they'd point it out 100%.

 

[Barney]

It gave her exactly zero townie points, actually. No one batted an eye.

Then why are you trying to frame it as something that desetves credit?

 

[Prisoner]

Scum wouldn't need to point it out to accomplish that, would they?

It can serve as a nice distraction if Town starts hunting Neutrals instead of Scum.

 

[Witch]

They're not going to waste a kill on a suspected neutral unless it's something powerful, they let town do the work. So yeah they'd point it out 100%.

Could scum have found a suspected neutral in half a day phase? Would they mention it before they'd done so?

Then why are you trying to frame it as something that desetves credit?

Like I said, I could be wrong, but my opinion is that it doesn't line up with the actions of scum. Folks should take that into consideration.

 

[Cereal Killer]

I really don't think anyone cares about anything but EoD1 votes and the most obvious read on them possible, as though scum wouldn't know the most obvious read on them.

 

[Bob Ross]

Could scum have found a suspected neutral in half a day phase? Would they mention it before they'd done so?

Maybe, maybe not, it's NAI imo.

 

[Bob Ross]

@Kool-Aid Man Thoughts, will you use the ability today?

 

[Witch]

Wish I had a shrug emoji, but okay. Guess it's just me.

 

[Cereal Killer]

Wish I had a shrug emoji, but okay. Guess it's just me.

This one works in a pinch

 

[Kool-Aid Man]

I really don't think anyone cares about anything but EoD1 votes and the most obvious read on them possible, as though scum wouldn't know the most obvious read on them.

Who you want dead ? I might shoot him

 

[Bob Ross]

Who you want dead ? I might shoot him

Wait, you're voting for her, why listen to her when she tells you who to shoot?

 

[Rey]

Who you want dead ? I might shoot him

Shoot daenaery pls

 

[Barney]

Who you want dead ? I might shoot him

You are not shooting anyone, lol.

 

[Witch]

Shoot daenaery pls

I think you should shoot Rey, coming out of the woodwork for this shit

 

[Rey]

Whatever Daenaery is saying is absolute bullshit just because she town read Drac

really what else do you need to know she's scum or scum adjacent

 

[Rey]

I think you should shoot Rey, coming out of the woodwork for this shit

oic maymay votes for the maymay god eh

 

[Rey]

I think you should shoot Rey, coming out of the woodwork for this shit

I HAZ A SAD? SAD!

 

[Rey]

Really though, claim psychic (town adjacent) and then tower read drac when they are clearly scum


Heady play

 

[Witch]

 

[Rey]

Big ole witch

what have you done for me lately?

I mean besides obfuscate everything to the point of having competiting busses

what have you done?

 

[Witch]

Big ole witch

what have you done for me lately?

I mean besides obfuscate everything to the point of having competiting busses

what have you done?

I would argue I have even done that for you

 

[Rey]

OH! THERE IT IS! I have rolled my eyes at lightspeed.

Wanna see it again?

I DID IT AGAIN~ I rolled my eyes at lightspeed AGAIN

Also if there's a vigilante you have got two choices witch or daenaery

either would do tbqh

 

[Cereal Killer]

Who you want dead ? I might shoot him

I posted a whole ass list, but this is on you, it's your shot, you know where I stand.

 

[Cereal Killer]

Whatever Daenaery is saying is absolute bullshit just because she town read Drac

really what else do you need to know she's scum or scum adjacent

Half the thread townread Drac, guess the game is over.

 

[Rey]

Half the thread townread Drac, guess the game is over.

Yes after he dropped the accent how many people still town read DRAC

 

[Witch]

Who you want dead ? I might shoot him

Right here:

This is my PoE, made from the people I was looking back from the initial list of suspicion from my collated Drac posts who continued to be suspicious today. I would say this is an approximate order from least to most likely scum.

Cinderella
Barney
Prisoner
Minecraft Steve
Spider-Man

I would shoot Prisoner before Minecraft Steve, and Barney wouldn't anywhere in this list, but I agree that it's fine otherwise.

 

[Baby]

Yes after he dropped the accent how many people still town read DRAC

A lot of us? The accent didn't mean anything, and I still don't think it did

 

[Witch]

Yes after he dropped the accent how many people still town read DRAC

Pretty much everyone who did not vote for him? Which was what, like 12 people?

 

[Barney]

Yes after he dropped the accent how many people still town read DRAC

Like, almost everyone that didn't vote for him over zombie, me included.

 

[Rey]

Like, almost everyone that didn't vote for him over zombie, me included.

You're a lunch bomb hush you

 

[Kool-Aid Man]

You're a lunch bomb hush you

Who the fuck confirmed that btw ?

No one as far as I can tell.

 

[Kool-Aid Man]

Who the fuck confirmed that btw ?

No one as far as I can tell.

 

[Rey]

I still have my on BARNES AND NOBLES OVAH THUR

I know what lies in your heart


DEATH

 

[Bob Ross]

I'd be in for shooting Rey because it's gonna become a policy lynch later on but we'll lose a CK voter so I'd rather it be someone else.

 

[Rey]

Fart Button - Sound Button

Click here to play the sound!

www.myinstants.com

 

[Rey]

I'd be in for shooting Rey because it's gonna become a policy lynch later on but we'll lose a CK voter so I'd rather it be someone else.

Shoot a townie that could potential win a tie

Yah

Great galaxy brain play tho

 

[Barney]

You're a lunch bomb hush you

Shooting me should be safe, then, why not ask for me to be shot?

 

[Cereal Killer]

I'd be in for shooting Rey because it's gonna become a policy lynch later on but we'll lose a CK voter so I'd rather it be someone else.

I'm so on board with this that I'd be tempted to vote myself to replace the vote :-P

 

[Bob Ross]

Shoot a townie that could potential win a tie

Yah

Great galaxy brain play tho

Huh?

 

[Rey]

Shooting me should be safe, then, why not ask for me to be shot?

EXCELLENT QUESTION

Any objections?

 

[Rey]

Shoot: Barney
Lunch: Cereal Killer:
Investigate: Daenarys
Protect:Jack Sparrow

 

[Bob Ross]

Protect:Jack Sparrow

Explain this to me.

 

[Barney]

OH! THERE IT IS! I have rolled my eyes at lightspeed.

Wanna see it again?

I DID IT AGAIN~ I rolled my eyes at lightspeed AGAIN

Also if there's a vigilante you have got two choices witch or daenaery

either would do tbqh

Shoot: Barney
Lunch: Cereal Killer:
Investigate: Daenarys
Protect:Jack Sparrow

I wonder what happened with "two choices" there.

 

[Jack Sparrow]

EXCELLENT QUESTION

Any objections?

Yes I do. If you think they are a lunch bomb why waste the bullet on them?

 

[Rey]

Yes I do. If you think they are a lunch bomb why waste the bullet on them?

Less scummates

Explain this to me.

I couldn't think of another person contributing to the conversation

also my attention and memory span sucks

 

[Bob Ross]

I couldn't think of another person contributing to the conversation

also my attention and memory span sucks

I couldn't think of a person contributing LESS to the conversation except maybe MS and BO.

 

[Spider-Man]

If I were you I would shoot Witch @Kool-Aid Man . I've made a case for him but he's not credibly getting lunched today.

 

[Cereal Killer]

If I were you I would shoot Witch @Kool-Aid Man . I've made a case for him but he's not credibly getting lunched today.

You mean the case that went from "protect Witch" yesterday to "wait Witch is listening to CK, obvious scummates, oh and they don't like me, that's scummy?"

Witch shouldn't get killed for reconsidering a position in a transparent way, especially when it's not to their benefit to do so. That bleeds town.

 

[Cereal Killer]

scum!Witch would have just stayed on me. It was perfectly safe to do so unless the whole scum team was already there. Otherwise, there's no need to kill Witch here if you're going to kill me today. See my flip and then evaluate Witch.

 

[Cinderella]

Just treat the vig shot as an extra lunch and aim it at one of the 2 wagons

 

[Bob Ross]

No, don't shoot Witch before we flip CK, bad plan.

 

[Spider-Man]

You mean the case that went from "protect Witch" yesterday to "wait Witch is listening to CK, obvious scummates, oh and they don't like me, that's scummy?"

Witch shouldn't get killed for reconsidering a position in a transparent way, especially when it's not to their benefit to do so. That bleeds town.

It's actually not about witch listening to CK. It's about witch in general being skittish about putting down votes without consensus from other players. And the big reason in my mind is that weird poking at you and then unvoting quickly. It didn't feel like a natural progression.

 

[Witch]

Just treat the vig shot as an extra lunch and aim it at one of the 2 wagons

This is a really bad idea. There is almost certainly one town between the two of these folks.

 

[Daenerys Targaryen]

If I were you I would shoot Witch @Kool-Aid Man . I've made a case for him but he's not credibly getting lunched today.

Yo Spidy, quicky question, same I asked Cereal: You're scum, it's D1, what do you do, try to do, doesn't have to be long.

 

[Cereal Killer]

No, don't shoot Witch before we flip CK, bad plan.

I already said this. :-P

 

[Cereal Killer]

It's actually not about witch listening to CK. It's about witch in general being skittish about putting down votes without consensus from other players. And the big reason in my mind is that weird poking at you and then unvoting quickly. It didn't feel like a natural progression.

You leave out the context of multiple posts in that. And in those posts, I think, is the answer to why Witch has been behaving as he has.

 

[Cinderella]

This is a really bad idea. There is almost certainly one town between the two of these folks.

Lmao. Might as well never lunch then with that kind of reasoning

 

[Cereal Killer]

This is a really bad idea. There is almost certainly one town between the two of these folks.

There's potentially even two towns, but I doubt it. Still, I'm fine with eating a bullet and letting some actual investigation happen in the last hour.

 

[Natiko]

Vote Count:

Cereal Killer - 7
Bob Ross - Post #758
Spider-Man - Post #778
Minecraft Steve - Post #884
Witch - Post #886 Post #917
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,116
Barney - Post #1,138
Rey - Post #1,189
Prisoner - Post #1,280

Spider-Man - 7
Cereal Killer - Post #787 Post #862
Zombie - Post #821
Cereal Killer - Post #1,082
Witch - Post #1,105
Banana - Post #1,110
Baby - Post #1,210
Cinderella - Post #1,244
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,273

Prisoner - 1
Barack Obama - Post #1,168

Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Baby - Post #786 Post #1,139
Cinderella - Post #1,026 Post #1,244

Barack Obama - 0
Jack Sparrow - Post #979 Post #1,134

Jack Sparrow - 0
Cereal Killer - Post #862 Post #1,082

Rey - 0
Kool-Aid Man - Post #870 Post #1,116

Barney - 0
Baby - Post #1,139 Post #1,210
Prisoner - Post #1,179 Post #1,280

Day end is in ~62 minutes.

 

[Daenerys Targaryen]

I agree with Witch. I too don't like killing town and these wagons have very little friction.

 

[Bob Ross]

I already said this. :-P

Yeah saw after I posted.

 

[Cereal Killer]

I'l even claim. I'm just vanilla town. All you lose is posts you don't read anyway. Shoot me.

 

[Cereal Killer]

Yeah saw after I posted.

Just thought it was funny since it's the second time, only with the roles flipped.

 

[Bob Ross]

I'l even claim. I'm just vanilla town. All you lose is posts you don't read anyway. Shoot me.

I've read all those posts, in the unlikely event you do flip town these posts will become very valuable.

 

[Daenerys Targaryen]

I'l even claim. I'm just vanilla town. All you lose is posts you don't read anyway. Shoot me.

I like your posts :'(

 

[Cereal Killer]

I've read all those posts, in the unlikely event you do flip town these posts will become very valuable.

They're valuable now, you're just hung up on a set of votes scum wouldn't cast.

 

[Bob Ross]

They're valuable now, you're just hung up on a set of votes scum wouldn't cast.

Maybe, I'm a very stubborn person, if I say to myself you're scum then it's very tough for me to change mind. I realize I might be up for a lynch tomorrow if you flip town and I'll fully accept the blame.

 

[Cereal Killer]

Nightmare is a good example of where the scum panic happens. It's not in the game thread. It's in the scumthread where they say oh no, I'm locked in, now I have to vote you, I have to suggest you for this shot - that's where those discussions and the planning happens. It doesn't happen in the game thread.

 

[Cereal Killer]

Maybe, I'm a very stubborn person, if I say to myself you're scum then it's very tough for me to change mind. I realize I might be up for a lynch tomorrow if you flip town and I'll fully accept the blame.

Yes, I know you're stubborn and you rarely re-evaluate. But honestly, you look at Spider-Man, you look at me, who's trying to solve the game?

 

[Cereal Killer]

Maybe, I'm a very stubborn person, if I say to myself you're scum then it's very tough for me to change mind. I realize I might be up for a lynch tomorrow if you flip town and I'll fully accept the blame.

And you should not be up for the vote tomorrow. Cascading votes like that is ignorant. That's how town loses.

 

[Barack Obama]

pls make a shot koolaid. i believe in youuuu

 

[Bob Ross]

Yes, I know you're stubborn and you rarely re-evaluate. But honestly, you look at Spider-Man, you look at me, who's trying to solve the game?

You, without a doubt, however you know I can't know if it's true solving or fake solving. By the same logic I'd say most players aren't trying to solve anything, but they can't all be scum, only 3 of them can.

 

[Witch]

Maybe, I'm a very stubborn person, if I say to myself you're scum then it's very tough for me to change mind. I realize I might be up for a lynch tomorrow if you flip town and I'll fully accept the blame.

I'm not going to vote for you if CK flips town fwiw. I don't think you getting it wrong makes you scum. Of anyone else here, you've been super transparent with your thinking.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

@Minecraft Steve Any thoughts?

I'll be honest, My mind hasn't changed much from my initial vote on Cereal killer yesterday. I have been incredibly busy with work the past two days and haven't given enough to the game. I promise I will have more tomorrow.

I liked my vote yesterday, and after seeing others get behind it today I am even more convinced. I still think Prisoner is a good scum read. My investigate is on Banana right now, I need to re-read all of Banana's posts to see where my head is now.

 

[Baby]

I'l even claim. I'm just vanilla town. All you lose is posts you don't read anyway. Shoot me.

FWIW, I've read all of your posts. That's a large part of why I moved from scum reading you for the votes at end of Day 1 to putting you in my lean town pile. They're good posts!

 

[Minecraft Steve]

Would you vote prisoner today?

I would vote prisoner today, but either CK or Prisoner I am good with those two.

 

[Cereal Killer]

You, without a doubt, however you know I can't know if it's true solving or fake solving. By the same logic I'd say most players aren't trying to solve anything, but they can't all be scum, only 3 of them can.

No, most are along for the ride. But who has Spider-Man pushed?

First, you.

Now? Me and Witch.

Take me out of the equation. Do you think Witch is scum?

 

[Spider-Man]

Yo Spidy, quicky question, same I asked Cereal: You're scum, it's D1, what do you do, try to do, doesn't have to be long.

This has actually happened to me twice in the past, when a scummate was on the line D1. I held out hope that a competing wagon would win - out was close. Both times they didn't and I really messed up by panick voting at the last minute. So I'd like to say I learned from that experience and would bus earlier. Or I might even vote off wagon like I did this time lol...

Hope you got what you wanted from this answer lol

 

[Cereal Killer]

I would vote prisoner today, but either CK or Prisoner I am good with those two.

oh shit he lives

 

[Kool-Aid Man]

 

[Cereal Killer]

FWIW, I've read all of your posts. That's a large part of why I moved from scum reading you for the votes at end of Day 1 to putting you in my lean town pile. They're good posts!

I'm glad people are apparently reading them but it sure has hell hasn't felt like it.

 

[Barack Obama]

I would vote prisoner today, but either CK or Prisoner I am good with those two.

should hop on the prisoner train, choo choo

 

[Cereal Killer]

I'll be honest, My mind hasn't changed much from my initial vote on Cereal killer yesterday. I have been incredibly busy with work the past two days and haven't given enough to the game. I promise I will have more tomorrow.

I liked my vote yesterday, and after seeing others get behind it today I am even more convinced. I still think Prisoner is a good scum read. My investigate is on Banana right now, I need to re-read all of Banana's posts to see where my head is now.

Steve, how do you have scumreads at all if you haven't been able to keep up with the game?

 

[Barack Obama]

oh dang

 

[Minecraft Steve]

Steve, how do you have scumreads at all if you haven't been able to keep up with the game?

because yesterday I followed the game and developed a read on Prisoner, and then earlier in today when I had more time I developed one on you and voted.

 

[Bob Ross]

No, most are along for the ride. But who has Spider-Man pushed?

First, you.

Now? Me and Witch.

Take me out of the equation. Do you think Witch is scum?

Hmm, it's a tough call, I can't say I'm very sure, I'd say I'm null to a slight town lean. I'll reevaluate if I see a flip either from the shot or if you are lynched.

 

[Daenerys Targaryen]

This has actually happened to me twice in the past, when a scummate was on the line D1. I held out hope that a competing wagon would win - out was close. Both times they didn't and I really messed up by panick voting at the last minute. So I'd like to say I learned from that experience and would bus earlier. Or I might even vote off wagon like I did this time lol...

Hope you got what you wanted from this answer lol

You should believe in yourself and save that teammate! Thanks for your answer.

 

[Bob Ross]

Please don't wait last second to fire your shot, try to do it with at least 30 mins remaining.

 

[Cereal Killer]

because yesterday I followed the game and developed a read on Prisoner, and then earlier in today when I had more time I developed one on you and voted.

You think Prisoner and I could be teammates?

 

[Rey]

Not prisoner per say, but I believe @Cereal Killer and @Daenerys Targaryen having something brewin

 

[Bob Ross]

Starting to become convinced KM is bullshitting us, if you don't fire today I'll promise you I'll push you so hard tomorrow you'll be forced to fire.

 

[Barack Obama]

VOTE: Kool-Aid Man
Shoot shoot shooooooot!

 

[Cereal Killer]

Super glad BO and MS could show up here to do a lot of nothing, but just enough to avoid replacements.

 

[Bob Ross]

VOTE: Kool-Aid Man
Shoot shoot shooooooot!

It's too late for that unfortunately.

 

[Cinderella]

Starting to become convinced KM is bullshitting us, if you don't fire today I'll promise you I'll push you so hard tomorrow you'll be forced to fire.

You know he’s mostlikely trolling right now right?

Spoiler: Spoiler

Pls dont shoot me KAM

 

[Barack Obama]

Super glad BO and MS could show up here to do a lot of nothing, but just enough to avoid replacements.

well i would have moved my vote on you sooner if the whole bullet thing wasn't in play, so that's something. But thanks

 

[Cereal Killer]

well i would have moved my vote on you sooner if the whole bullet thing wasn't in play, so that's something. But thanks

I've suggested that I be killed by KAM or the thread multiple times, so this is not much of a stick or a carrot.

 

[Bob Ross]

You know he’s mostlikely trolling right now right?

Spoiler: Spoiler

Pls dont shoot me KAM

If so what does town gain from it? I'd be really interesting to hear that.