Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Since its EoD.
5elwbaphur941.jpg
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
I noticed that you didn't claim at the end of day while you were a leading wagon and tied for contention. That tie wasn't broke until the last little bit of the day either. Why didn't you?
[/QUOTE]
That may have been my mistake I was asked near EOD if I would change my vote and I said I would change to CK to prevent ties.

regarding Barney's claim, could he be a scum JOAT, with one of the powers a gossip chat?
 
Minecraft Steve

Minecraft Steve

Costume Account
It's really hard to tell, DT.

I'm thinking it's either you, Spider-man OR Witch, very unlikely all three of you (or any combination of you three) are on scum team. Lynching one of these will likely help clear up the other two handily

Add in Prisoner, and maybe someone like Jack Sparrow or Cinderella but that's not really out of a scum read more of a lack of a town read on my part there..

Much more town read would be Bob Ross ( which is why I find the Jack sparrow vote so crazy) and Rey

Slight town reads on Zombie and baby,

KAM has his own write up above same with Barney.
 
Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
it seems that the fun train just passed town.

no fun allowed it seems, okay lets make it more interesting then.

In all fairness i dont buy Barneys claim,

Vote: Barney
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
reads:
town
baby
Bob Ross said:
Right on time.
Click to expand...
you seem to be meeting your quota reflecting on my post habits, in between setting up 'policy lynches' for later phases.

at what point did you decide to bus Dracula? Was it the slip, was it the fact he wasn't chatty enough in scum chat for you, making it hard to coordinate your plays? Was it the fact that he could have saved himself but didn't?
 
Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Barack Obama said:
reads:
town
baby

you seem to be meeting your quota reflecting on my post habits, in between setting up 'policy lynches' for later phases.

at what point did you decide to bus Dracula? Was it the slip, was it the fact he wasn't chatty enough in scum chat for you, making it hard to coordinate your plays? Was it the fact that he could have saved himself but didn't?
Click to expand...

Mr. President , what makes you believe that Mr Ross himself is scum ?
 
Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
it can go either way, either i believe that Barneys claim is true and go for DT
Dont believe him and vote him
Or believe the president and go for BR himself
 
Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Barack Obama said:
His read on the game hasn't evolved from his reads on day 2, dispite being involved in mislyncing a townie
Click to expand...

thats what makes me suspicious aswell, heck even i get scum read even though i lynched scum.
One could ofc argue that the vote was late and it was a bus.

I go for those votes on EoD1.
Facts matter.
Feelings dont.

Get out of here with that bs that you feel attacked just because i had some fun.
Grow up.
 
Daenerys Targaryen

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
This post is relevant to the discussions at hand
Dracula said:
Alright, hey there. My bad about the sporadic activity, finally have a few hours to myself.



Between Zombie, Bob, and Prisoner I'm leaning towards Zombie being on the town end. His posts look the most insightful and it looks like he's more genuine in trying to ascertain people's intentions. I agree with the vast majority of the insights he's dropped, and melding like that is always a good sign. The progression towards his vote on me today looks town-natural, I'm not surprised that his wagon has been the one to gain traction the easiest. I think the wagons being on him and I at the moment is town playing right into scum's hands.

My personal vote?

VOTE: Bob Ross

It looks like Bob has spent the day using my quote unquote "slip" as cover fire to distract the thread from the fact that he's having serious problems engaging with the game. When situations like this happen early on in the game, it's common for scum to latch on like flies to fly paper, and I think that all of the attention on me fits that bill. For Bob having 31 posts, there's very little to show from it, and fmpov it's pretty much all surface level engagement. (if I could iso his posts I could do a deep dive and double check this but I'm still unaware how to do this on OM.) There was also a ton of heat on Bob early but votes never came from it which strikes me as some soft bussing going on somewhere.

Prisoner, I'm more ambivalent on. A lot of their comments don't necessarily strike me as town POV so I wouldn't be sad if they died either.

Also unrelated to the top three wagons I'm pretty sure Banana would be the second scum that has been opportunistically on me today. All of their analyses of my posts strike me as completely bad faith.



Echo this sentiment. Rey's analysis has been mostly kind of out-of-the-box in a way that'd be hard to fake for scum. Rey finding Zombie as a townread also makes me lean towards trusting them more. Probably my strongest townread.



This honestly seems like it came out of nowhere in the phase? Why? Can you make a succinct case?
Click to expand...
It lasted only 16 minutes until he agreed with Witch to vote for Banana

Dracula said:
If you had to make a definitive statement on Cereal Killer's alignment, what would you say she is?

You interested in trying this out?

VOTE: Banana
Click to expand...
I've read the interaction a million ways already lol
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
Barack Obama said:
reads:
town
baby

you seem to be meeting your quota reflecting on my post habits, in between setting up 'policy lynches' for later phases.

at what point did you decide to bus Dracula? Was it the slip, was it the fact he wasn't chatty enough in scum chat for you, making it hard to coordinate your plays? Was it the fact that he could have saved himself but didn't?
Click to expand...
Tell me someone like Rey isn't a policy lynch. As for Dracula he slipped and I caught that, you think I'd mention it if I was scum or push for him that hard? Do you think Dracula would be lynched if I wasn't pushing him? Why as scum would I sacrifice another scum member when I can avoid the situation completely and avoid Dracula's lynch entirely. Worst of all you never even said I was scummy up until now that I started calling you out on your spotty activity.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Daenerys Targaryen - 4
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,536 Post #1,719
Cinderella - Post #1,626
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,636
Rey - Post #1,645
Witch - Post #1,653

Barney - 4
Baby - Post #1,571
Prisoner - Post #1,623
Spider-Man - Post #1,688
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,719

Jack Sparrow - 2
Bob Ross - Post #1,652
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,696

Spider-Man - 1
Zombie - Post #1,648

Kool-Aid Man - 0
Zombie - Post #1,534 Post #1,584
Rey - Post #1,619 Post #1,645
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
as far as reads go that are more than just one name ;/

town
Baby
Cinderella *
Witch *
Two players who I felt pointed out my inactivity out of actual frustration and not to lay the foundations for a lunching in later days
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
Barack Obama said:
OK PIK (as of now caught up to thread but haven't reread end of day votes)

Protect: Bob Ross - Cool guy, I agree with him on the Koolaid shot
Investigate:Cereal Killer - Engaging with the game a whole heap, that doesn't equal town to mean but does mean she is either just really chatty or has a non-vanilla role
Kill: Koolaid (if he doens't use his shot :p
Click to expand...
You even said you'd protect me just yesterday, fair enough that I was wrong on CK but did I really go from person to protect from person you are sure is scum? I didn't override on CK, more people were on her you know.
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
Kool-Aid Man said:
thats what makes me suspicious aswell, heck even i get scum read even though i lynched scum.
One could ofc argue that the vote was late and it was a bus.

I go for those votes on EoD1.
Facts matter.
Feelings dont.

Get out of here with that bs that you feel attacked just because i had some fun.
Grow up.
Click to expand...
When did I feel attacked? It's a game, I'm not taking things personally, but if I feel like you're scum then idc that you wanted to have fun, I'll advocate for your lynch.
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
Bob Ross said:
You even said you'd protect me just yesterday, fair enough that I was wrong on CK but did I really go from person to protect from person you are sure is scum? I didn't override on CK, more people were on her you know.
Click to expand...
My issue isn't that you voted for CK (the majority of the game did), it's that your gameplan has barely changed, you've just moved two of your slight scum picks into your scum picks now that CK is gone
JS
DT
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
Barack Obama said:
My issue isn't that you voted for CK (the majority of the game did), it's that your gameplan has barely changed, you've just moved two of your slight scum picks into your scum picks now that CK is gone
JS
DT
Click to expand...
No shit, what else did you want me to do?
 
Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Bob Ross said:
When did I feel attacked? It's a game, I'm not taking things personally, but if I feel like you're scum then idc that you wanted to have fun, I'll advocate for your lynch.
Click to expand...

when did i call you out specifically ? at this point you are and i dont know why you are acting this way.
Sure try to, but at this stage i rather try to do something more constructive
( i know, i know thats big coming from me)
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
Daenerys Targaryen said:
I would be a little worried about the validity of my reads if my top scum flipped town.
Click to expand...
What does that mean? We all make mistakes, CK wasn't connected to DT or JS in a big way to change my other reads. If my other reads are also bad then that's me having a bad game as a player.

Kool-Aid Man said:
when did i call you out specifically ? at this point you are and i dont know why you are acting this way.
Sure try to, but at this stage i rather try to do something more constructive
( i know, i know thats big coming from me)
Click to expand...
Fair enough, thought you were talking about me.
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
Daenerys Targaryen said:
Do you have the posts from Witch that you liked at hand?
Click to expand...
1524, 1525, 1526 recap of EOD 2 with his opinions of the plays,
1542 -"It was literally just I thought I’d screwed up how he’d want to roll out his claim. I don’t like tipping a role’s hand for them."
I'm trying to find the post where Witch said he'd rather vote

Post 1558 - this didn't feel like scum setting up future lynches to me.
 
Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Bob Ross said:
Fair enough, thought you were talking about me.
Click to expand...

Sorry if i came off to cocky,

I mean i knew that soft to hard claim i made the first day was going to fall apart in the following days,
i could either backtrack or go full ham. I did the second and made my analysis out of those reactions.
I know i will get lynched for that move but for that i will leave a juicy read list for town before i leave the game.

All in all town will benefit.
 
Kool-Aid Man

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
Daenerys Targaryen said:
Uuuuuuhhhh, I don't know. Barney is just really weird, but also in a "why you so weird as scum" way. If I had to bet on some random neutral it'd be him.
Click to expand...

what bothers me its that you are less than 20 minutes away of being lynched and you just turn over without any hesitation ?

Usually town tries to sway other players into getting another player lynched in order to survive
 
Daenerys Targaryen

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
Barack Obama said:
1524, 1525, 1526 recap of EOD 2 with his opinions of the plays,
1542 -"It was literally just I thought I’d screwed up how he’d want to roll out his claim. I don’t like tipping a role’s hand for them."
I'm trying to find the post where Witch said he'd rather vote

Post 1558 - this didn't feel like scum setting up future lynches to me.
Click to expand...
None of them feel great for me, the latter mostly just feels like following conversation.
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
Kool-Aid Man said:
Sorry if i came off to cocky,

I mean i knew that soft to hard claim i made the first day was going to fall apart in the following days,
i could either backtrack or go full ham. I did the second and made my analysis out of those reactions.
I know i will get lynched for that move but for that i will leave a juicy read list for town before i leave the game.

All in all town will benefit.
Click to expand...
We'll see about that.

Barack Obama said:
Maybe reflect on your reads on the game after mislynching your top scum read? Like, I hope I'm not being obtuse.
Click to expand...
I did, I've done a few mini changes in my notes but I don't feel like the mislynch changed a lot tbh. Scum reads mostly became scummier and town reads townier, Witch is now in my top town for example.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Daenerys Targaryen - 4
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,536 Post #1,719
Cinderella - Post #1,626
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,636
Rey - Post #1,645
Witch - Post #1,653

Barney - 4
Baby - Post #1,571
Prisoner - Post #1,623
Spider-Man - Post #1,688
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,719

Jack Sparrow - 2
Bob Ross - Post #1,652
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,696

Spider-Man - 1
Zombie - Post #1,648

Kool-Aid Man - 0
Zombie - Post #1,534 Post #1,584
Rey - Post #1,619 Post #1,645
 
Barney

Barney

Costume Account
Cinderella said:
Where is @Barney anyway?
Click to expand...
I'm like hella busy, might ask for a replacement if I can't manage by tomorrow.

Vote: Daenerys Targaryen

I'm ready to share the Banana theory, names redacted, whoever inherits my chat will be able to reveal the names on that:
Long story short, Banana thinks Danny is scum because Clown's last post quoted Danny, and Banana personaly think is the best way to signal who clown was going to investigate. Also the behaviour of another player means that player is the doc, but that one is not worth to share, because doc, obviously.
 
Barney

Barney

Costume Account
As for the names redacted, I was originally going to mention what the doc did, but decided to remove that for now since it's not relevant at the moment.
 
Prisoner

Prisoner

Costume Account
Kool-Aid Man said:
what bothers me its that you are less than 20 minutes away of being lynched and you just turn over without any hesitation ?

Usually town tries to sway other players into getting another player lynched in order to survive
Click to expand...
Eh, I imagine Scum would try to not be lunched just as hard, if not harder.
 
Daenerys Targaryen

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
Barney said:
Long story short, Banana thinks Danny is scum because Clown's last post quoted Danny, and Banana personaly think is the best way to signal who clown was going to investigate. Also the behaviour of another player means that player is the doc, but that one is not worth to share, because doc, obviously.
Click to expand...
This doesn't make much sense
 
Bob Ross

Bob Ross

Costume Account
If that was why Banana thinks DT is scum then might as well throw the doc theory out the window right now lol. There's reasons to think DT is scum, that's not one of them especially when we don't know how Clown died.
 
Barack Obama

Barack Obama

Costume Account
Barney said:
I'm like hella busy, might ask for a replacement if I can't manage by tomorrow.

Vote: Daenerys Targaryen

I'm ready to share the Banana theory, names redacted, whoever inherits my chat will be able to reveal the names on that:
Long story short, Banana thinks Danny is scum because Clown's last post quoted Danny, and Banana personaly think is the best way to signal who clown was going to investigate. Also the behaviour of another player means that player is the doc, but that one is not worth to share, because doc, obviously.
Click to expand...
Clown did go on to post two more times though
 
Barney

Barney

Costume Account
Bob Ross said:
If that was why Banana thinks DT is scum then might as well throw the doc theory out the window right now lol. There's reasons to think DT is scum, that's not one of them especially when we don't know how Clown died.
Click to expand...
Sure, but that was a theory I could get behind, but yeah, banana was just town.

I was planning on making a bigger case on prisoner and witch, but sadly I was just busy to really dig into the game, sorry for that. I think DT is a good flip, since I was convinced by banana during our chat.
 
Witch

Witch

Costume Account
Minecraft Steve said:
If Barney is scum, and wanting to specifically target DT for a day lynch, then that's a bad trade. 1 for 1 town for scum tends to be a better trade, but scum sacrificing themselves for a specific townperson is ridiculous to entertain.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I get what you're saying and I think you're right.
 
Prisoner

Prisoner

Costume Account
Barneys Banana-Theory is the same we already dismissed on D2 and why did Banana not vote Daeneris on D2 if he had that theory?
 
Baby

Baby

Costume Account
Barney said:
I'm like hella busy, might ask for a replacement if I can't manage by tomorrow.

Vote: Daenerys Targaryen

I'm ready to share the Banana theory, names redacted, whoever inherits my chat will be able to reveal the names on that:
Long story short, Banana thinks Danny is scum because Clown's last post quoted Danny, and Banana personaly think is the best way to signal who clown was going to investigate. Also the behaviour of another player means that player is the doc, but that one is not worth to share, because doc, obviously.
Click to expand...

But, that wasn't Clown's last post? And it wasn't an unprovoked quote, it was in direct response to someone
 
Cinderella

Cinderella

Costume Account
Minecraft Steve said:
If Barney is scum, and wanting to specifically target DT for a day lynch, then that's a bad trade. 1 for 1 town for scum tends to be a better trade, but scum sacrificing themselves for a specific townperson is ridiculous to entertain.
Click to expand...
Barney isn’t redchecking her or anything though, this isnt a 1 for 1 scenario at all
 
Prisoner

Prisoner

Costume Account
Minecraft Steve said:
If Barney is scum, and wanting to specifically target DT for a day lynch, then that's a bad trade. 1 for 1 town for scum tends to be a better trade, but scum sacrificing themselves for a specific townperson is ridiculous to entertain.
Click to expand...
But this isn't really a trade. He can just hide behind it being just a theory by Banana.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Vote Count:

Daenerys Targaryen - 7
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,536 Post #1,719
Cinderella - Post #1,626
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,636
Rey - Post #1,645
Witch - Post #1,653
Bob Ross - Post #1,765
Barney - Post #1,770
Minecraft Steve - Post #1,780

Barney - 5
Baby - Post #1,571
Prisoner - Post #1,623
Spider-Man - Post #1,688
Kool-Aid Man - Post #1,719
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,778

Spider-Man - 1
Zombie - Post #1,648

Jack Sparrow - 0
Bob Ross - Post #1,652 Post #1,765
Daenerys Targaryen - Post #1,696 Post #1,778

Kool-Aid Man - 0
Zombie - Post #1,534 Post #1,584
Rey - Post #1,619 Post #1,645
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Crowd: Hey, I heard this Daenerys character is evil or something. Surely they're evil.. Get her!
Daenerys: But, wait, no, I'm misunderstood, you don't understand.

Daenerys Targaryen has died!

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as Daenerys Targaryen, a Vanilla Townie.

You have no special abilities, but you do have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE
Click to expand...

Night 3 Ends In:
jf9nthcha8


Actions are due two hours before night end.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom