Scum Thread Evil League

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Looks like two votes for Chugg, one vote for Fran. I can live with either.

I guess this is going to seem like an obvious slip, but I’ll say it just in case - we should be careful not to throw shade on Chugg’s direct neighbors immediately. Try to let town get to the conclusion that kills typically need to take place from an adjacent square themselves if you can. We can still bring it up ourselves, but we should be very careful on how we approach it.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I think Fran died early in a game recently and was quite bummed out so I say Chuggs. Plus it was Stu’s request to us lol

If the thread’s sentiment was to not attack then that’s fair. I bet a dollar that shit gets tossed out the window tomorrow though.
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
fuckin ell, nother busy day and another crapton of pages to catch up on.

That said i agree that theres really not much i aught to do tonight, and the plan of action layed out seems good to me.
Personally id also say to go with chuggs, Fran is so caught up in his J-man tunnel that he will be pretty useful to keep around tommorrow.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Kill: Northwest Territory

I feel kind of bad typing that out, as a Canadian

Geno, we want to install puppet mafia battalions (we do, right?)
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Looks like two votes for Chugg, one vote for Fran. I can live with either.

I guess this is going to seem like an obvious slip, but I’ll say it just in case - we should be careful not to throw shade on Chugg’s direct neighbors immediately. Try to let town get to the conclusion that kills typically need to take place from an adjacent square themselves if you can. We can still bring it up ourselves, but we should be very careful on how we approach it.

Also, don't worry, I won't make that same mistake again!

Stan, I guess that means you're immune to attacks XD
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
So...there’s an egg. Maybe we have the puppet troops attack it? We can do that right? Do we post the command in here or what? When available of course.

One of Ynnek’s territories got blown up, and he went from 5 and 5 to 9 total, so not sure how that worked out when he should’ve been at 8 I think?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Wait duh, we don’t attack the egg because it’s from Jman durr. Would clear him more than we probably want.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
So...there’s an egg. Maybe we have the puppet troops attack it? We can do that right? Do we post the command in here or what? When available of course.

One of Ynnek’s territories got blown up, and he went from 5 and 5 to 9 total, so not sure how that worked out when he should’ve been at 8 I think?
I think what happened to Ynnek is that someone used a night action that killed all his battalions except, and that battalion retreated to his remaining territory, then he gained the 3 battalions from the refresh.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I guess I’m just not sure why the one battalion would live but who knows
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Jman kept saying that his powers would take days to take effect, so I'm thinking something happens when the egg hatches. But I bet everyone will think it's connected to our puppet battalion, so I agree let's not attack it for now & see what happens

No idea what happened in Britain!
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I say we let the puppet sit, Town can waste time taking it out if they want and it’ll be easier to cast suspicion on the player that does attack it because scum would want to take the initiative with their real territory for the dice bonus.

Also if we have any choice in a scum flip (say it’s between multiple of us) having me, Terra, or Launch flip first are the best scenarios. We want to obscure the long range kills as long as possible. If we pick our kills carefully a flip in that pile will fuck town up so much as they rush to figure out who to suspect.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I say we let the puppet sit, Town can waste time taking it out if they want and it’ll be easier to cast suspicion on the player that does attack it because scum would want to take the initiative with their real territory for the dice bonus.

Also if we have any choice in a scum flip (say it’s between multiple of us) having me, Terra, or Launch flip first are the best scenarios. We want to obscure the long range kills as long as possible. If we pick our kills carefully a flip in that pile will fuck town up so much as they rush to figure out who to suspect.
I agree. Especially me, when I saw my PM, I thought for sure long range kills would be a unique ability, not that we’d have two players with it.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
We’re about to only have one unfortunately. It’ll be too sketch if Haw declines to break the alliance short of claiming the country of origin but then you need an explanation as to what your bonus is.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Still catching up, but I was thinking of 1) saying that I don't want to break the alliance until day 4, since we can't make new alliances until then anyway, & last resort claiming territory of origin. I was thinking ultimately a good claim for me would be the 2-shot rolecop part of my role, but wouldn't want to openly say that part yet. Sound plausible? Not going to post at all until I read the whole day start so far
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I forgot about the delay to start a new alliance so you may be safe
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I'm not actually suggesting we do this, but it would be really funny if we had puppetmon attack the egg to show that puppetmon's not such a bad guy
 
Gut reaction was for Puppet to attack jman when he moves to alaska to waste more of his units, but that would instantly clear Jman to a lot of people.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
We all know the egg is jman, because it wasn't us. I think he needs someone to attack it for some reason, like it hatches when it gets attacked
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Good old puppetmon.

I forgot Weemad could move out of Ukraine. There goes my long range kill-- good thing I used it last night
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
*jesus christ*

okay imma at least try to give today ago but honestly at this rate i might also be replacing out yall.

waking up to pages upon pages of inane chatter about the boardgame aspect that i just dont really care about is completely ruining any enthusiasm for this game and it sure doesn't seem to be getting any better.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Good old puppetmon.

I forgot Weemad could move out of Ukraine. There goes my long range kill-- good thing I used it last night
yeah phew

*jesus christ*

okay imma at least try to give today ago but honestly at this rate i might also be replacing out yall.

waking up to pages upon pages of inane chatter about the boardgame aspect that i just dont really care about is completely ruining any enthusiasm for this game and it sure doesn't seem to be getting any better.
Ah sorry stan. It’s been rough to read up on. 7 pages in 4 hours is insane
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
You can do it Stan!! I'm going to catch up tomorrow. I negligently neglected mafia tonight. It was my night to have a netflix party with my long distance friend & now I'm too tipsy to post. Good thing no one suspects me yet.
 
Yeah sorry for bussing you Launch, but I'm going to be gone for the next 10 hours or so and that's how I could see the day trending based on yesterday. It's also something I'd probably do as town considering the case I made for you yesterday.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Yeah sorry for bussing you Launch, but I'm going to be gone for the next 10 hours or so and that's how I could see the day trending based on yesterday. It's also something I'd probably do as town considering the case I made for you yesterday.
It's fine. If you're going to be gone, I can at least make the case that you're going for an easy target and then disappearing. I think people will buy it.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I had 0 idea who the person you claimed was until I looked it up lol
I figured. I didn’t mention it here but I spent some time looking at different angles and went for someone a little more obscure so I didn’t have a counter claim, but that would make sense.

Also I love Stan just tearing me down as a scum player.
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
I figured. I didn’t mention it here but I spent some time looking at different angles and went for someone a little more obscure so I didn’t have a counter claim, but that would make sense.

Also I love Stan just tearing me down as a scum player.
anytime, lol.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
It took me forever to get caught up, and once more an entire page of posts happened while I was typing, LOL.

I feel like I can afford to not suspect Launchpad, hoping that the trap claim continues to go over well.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I’ve seeded enough to move off Launch depending on how things go. I wouldn’t worry too much Launch. Would rather force Blarg to attack you so we can still get some benefit to your role while keeping you around longer.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
They brought it up on the last page, so you may not have a choice, but I figure we can play phone tag for awhile and let nothing come of it. I’m probably not posting tonight, anyway. No one’s really buying what I’m selling anyway
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Kawl used my conquer action! It's a power town can have! I wonder if I should use it at some point.

I'm also thinking about the Indonesia situation. Wondering if I could get away with attacking Launchpad's one troop and installing myself there before you can set the trap. I've been public that I don't like the trap plan, and I could say that I'm suspicious of Blarg's warmongering. Either way, if he moves in there and attacks me, I'll attack back, it's what I would do as town.

Terra, I smiled reading the nice things you said about me in your reads list, even though I know it's to bolster your teammate!
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Kawl used my conquer action! It's a power town can have! I wonder if I should use it at some point.

I'm also thinking about the Indonesia situation. Wondering if I could get away with attacking Launchpad's one troop and installing myself there before you can set the trap. I've been public that I don't like the trap plan, and I could say that I'm suspicious of Blarg's warmongering. Either way, if he moves in there and attacks me, I'll attack back, it's what I would do as town.

Terra, I smiled reading the nice things you said about me in your reads list, even though I know it's to bolster your teammate!
Blarg doesn’t have any more attacks left this phase. I’d be worried about you looking like you’re defending me, but that’s up to you. I was thinking of attacking Blarg back tomorrow, but I am not sure I’ve made a decision yet.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Blarg doesn’t have any more attacks left this phase. I’d be worried about you looking like you’re defending me, but that’s up to you. I was thinking of attacking Blarg back tomorrow, but I am not sure I’ve made a decision yet.

I can justify it... I know it's the kind of thing Maol would have told me not to do, but I really want to take a Risk action!
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
I cant say i think its a great idea, but if youre confident in your ability to pull it off then i wont stop ya.

I would say to take care that it doesn't look like your just trying to take advantage of the current chaos. Getting the smell of opportunism on the plan will make it a lot harder to sell.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I cant say i think its a great idea, but if youre confident in your ability to pull it off then i wont stop ya.

I would say to take care that it doesn't look like your just trying to take advantage of the current chaos. Getting the smell of opportunism on the plan will make it a lot harder to sell.
I agree with Stan, it might look opportunistic at this point
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Here's what I would post. I'll wait a while if you guys think it's a bad idea


Attack 2: Indonesia, New Guinea

Why I am making this move:
-I believe that Launchpad will likely be voted out today if Polter is killed. Three scenarios exist: Launchpad is mafia, Launchpad has the ability to set traps, or both.
--If he is mafia, I have no problem attacking him.
--If he has the ability to set traps, possibly he booby-trapped Indonesia last night, in which case my attack will give us some information. Possibly he is lying about setting traps being a night action, and will go out swinging like Malus by setting one at the end of the day, in which case my attack will at least limit him to Western Australia. Possibly he's telling the truth about everything, in which case I still think the elaborate plan to test the trap set-up is foolish and I am happy to unilaterally prevent it.
-If Launchpad is voted out, Indonesia will go either to some random person who votes last, or to myself or Blargonaut, whoever grabs it first. I don't trust Blargonaut not to attack me.
-I believe that this move is for the good of the town, and I'm willing to stake my reputation on it. Feel free to ask me any questions.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Here's what I would post. I'll wait a while if you guys think it's a bad idea


Attack 2: Indonesia, New Guinea

Why I am making this move:
-I believe that Launchpad will likely be voted out today if Polter is killed. Three scenarios exist: Launchpad is mafia, Launchpad has the ability to set traps, or both.
--If he is mafia, I have no problem attacking him.
--If he has the ability to set traps, possibly he booby-trapped Indonesia last night, in which case my attack will give us some information. Possibly he is lying about setting traps being a night action, and will go out swinging like Malus by setting one at the end of the day, in which case my attack will at least limit him to Western Australia. Possibly he's telling the truth about everything, in which case I still think the elaborate plan to test the trap set-up is foolish and I am happy to unilaterally prevent it.
-If Launchpad is voted out, Indonesia will go either to some random person who votes last, or to myself or Blargonaut, whoever grabs it first. I don't trust Blargonaut not to attack me.
-I believe that this move is for the good of the town, and I'm willing to stake my reputation on it. Feel free to ask me any questions.
Ok, that’s not the worst approach. I do think we need something drastic to distract from Polter, because if he dies, I’m next. Worst case scenario, you have your vig shot to fire off at Blarg depending on how he reacts. Fuck it, let’s have some fun
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
So I have an idea. If we work this out and use Stan’s second kill and I use the faction kill tonight to take back Indonesia, I can demonstrate my supposed night attack and then come into D3 being all coy about it.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Actually if I had that ability and it was 2 shot, I’d save it if I was town. I’m going to day attack back, what do you think?
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
I wonder if we fully thought this through, but regardless it's fun to play risk, even if it's an all-mafia game, LOL. Whatever, we created something to talk about, we created separation between us without me having to vote for you, and you won't kill me b/c my general will flee back into New Guinea.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I wonder if we fully thought this through, but regardless it's fun to play risk, even if it's an all-mafia game, LOL. Whatever, we created something to talk about, we created separation between us without me having to vote for you, and you won't kill me b/c my general will flee back into New Guinea.
Did you move your general there? I missed that oops haha
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I just meant, there's no danger of killing me from getting me out of Indonesia
Oh you know, maybe I should’ve attack New Guinea directly. I forgot you could retreat, I was worried about attacking in case I whittled down your battalions to your general
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
It's fine this way, it just seems like you're invested in your trap-testing plan & want Indonesia for that reason
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
I wonder if we fully thought this through, but regardless it's fun to play risk, even if it's an all-mafia game, LOL. Whatever, we created something to talk about, we created separation between us without me having to vote for you, and you won't kill me b/c my general will flee back into New Guinea.
Oh we definitely did not think it fully through.
Its just town will inevitably think it through even less.
 

Hawthorn

I'll explain my reasons later
Oh we definitely did not think it fully through.
Its just town will inevitably think it through even less.
Nice of you to say "we" didn't think it through, but basically it was all me who attacked a teammate for no good reason, LOL. I think I'm going to get out of it ok though
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Nice of you to say "we" didn't think it through, but basically it was all me who attacked a teammate for no good reason, LOL. I think I'm going to get out of it ok though
Didn’t even wait for a second ok lmao

it’s all good. Playing safe was getting boring
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
Nice of you to say "we" didn't think it through, but basically it was all me who attacked a teammate for no good reason, LOL. I think I'm going to get out of it ok though
No i do include myself in that, i did look at and basically go (pardon my Kiwi) "yep, shell be right"
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
How can I be mad about anything when I'm not around to contribute my opinion lol As long as this gambit doesn't outright get one of you killed prior to day end I think we're good. The biggest fear is if Launch loses all troops, his general will flee to me. Then we'll have two scum in one spot, with another scum right next to us. Will severely limit our NK options
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
@Geno Can we kill people that are next to our allies if our ally is town? Guessing no, but I had to check
 
Nah this is great. It seems to be going well so far. And after flips it'll be even more confusing. I was laughing my ass off as I was catching up this morning. Y'all BOLD bold today.

Like Nat said, we need to do more spreading out though. We're really consolidated right now and the town players are being more aggressive than we are right now.
 
Top Bottom