claims
faddy-> switcher-> monkey/salva
va ->switcher-> monkey/salva
salva-> insomniac -> role change
monkey-> no claim
sneeks-> switcher jman/monkey
sneeks-> switcher turmoil instead
monkey-> drunk
stu-seer
jman-> invest-> turmoil/villager, stu/apprentice seer
jman and stu compatible
va->troublemaker -> jman was target
sneeks-> jman was target too
stu-> seer-> card 2
monkey-> drunk -> card 3
va-> tm-> sophia was not a target
sophia -> insomniac no change
sorian -> dream wolf
va-> tm-> swapped jman/pi and sorian/dw ->jman-dw and sorian/pi
Natiko didn't target sorian
sneeks robbed salva
stu -> seer-> saw card 2
sneeks robbed -> salva was mason
salva confirmed he was mason ->now is robber?
faddy confirms salva is mason, faddy is mason too
natiko claims witch
turm confirms he is villager
stu says card 2 is robber
terra ->revealer -> saw natiko is mystic wolf
natiko -> witch -> says card 3 is revealer -> swapped to sneeks
Order:
Mystic Wolf -> natiko (terra ->revealer -> saw natiko is mystic wolf) ->Natiko claims to be witch and that card 3 is revealer
Minion -> N/A
Masons-> Faddy and Salva (confirmed by both)
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 -> Card is robber (contradicted sneeks)
PI -> jman-> turmoil/villager, stu/apprentice seer (Confirmed by both)
Robber-> Sneeks robbed Salva the mason card. (contradicted by stu9
Witch -> Natiko-> Says Card 3 is revealer, swapped to sneeks (Contradicted by terra)
TM -> VA -> jman(pi)/Sorian(dreamwolf) -> jman(dreamwolf)/Sorian(pi)
Drunk-> Monkey Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Didn't trigger publicly. -> Terra claims natiko is mystic wolf (Natiko claims to be witch and that card 3 is revealer, swapped with sneeks)
Dream Wolf -> Sorian ->swapped with jman
Villager -> turmoil (as said by jman, confirmed by turm)
Tanner -> N/A
Game start (uncontested claims)
Mystic Wolf
Minion
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 ->Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2
PI -> jman-> turmoil/villager, stu/apprentice seer
Robber
Witch
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Monkey -> Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Didn't trigger publicly.
Dream Wolf -> Sorian
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner
Why would the lie?
-jman: He would need to know that villager and seer are both safe roles to claim, if either stu or turm was a bad card, either would just reveal they had a bad card. jman had no reason to lie
-sophia: counterclaimed me, even if she saw the role somehow chances are she is actually telling the truth. No reason to lie
monkey-> Drunk is an easy role to claim as wolf or even tanner, but it is irrelevant since she won't reveal more than that unless there is a way to confirm the card she "got" is bad and she has to defend herself.
faddy and salva-> masons, had each other back from the start, confirmed by a third party.
va -> troublemaker -> very little reason to not reveal both targets if no one messed with him.
sorian-> Dream Wolf is a ballsy role to claim, but makes sense if swapped around. No reason to not throw jman under the bus since from sorian's perspective, if va is telling the truth sorian is town and if va is lying sorian is still wolf, it's a win-win for Sorian.
turm-> Claiming villager with the pi as back-up, normal stuff.
Contradicting claims:
1) stu vs sneeks
2) terra vs natiko
If so teams would be:
sneeks knows my role is mason, something she can know as a mystic wolf (Or she could just guess?). Stu is seer and is backed by jman and it's unlikely jman lied about that. Stu saw the robber card 2 in the center, meaning sneeks is lying.
terra claims to be revealer and that natiko is mystic wolf, natiko claims to be the witch and that card 3 is the revealer and was given to sneeks
Let's assume sneeks is lying since jman is backing stu.
Sneeks is either Mystic Wolf, Minion or Tanner. Likely Mystic since she knows the role I started with.
Terra then is lying saying Natiko is Mystic Wolf, since Sneeks is likely Mystic Wolf. Terra is probably tanner or minion. Terra could be Mystic wolf himself and Sneeks Minion/Tanner just guessed I was mason. I don't think Terra would be tanner because I feel Terra would like to be caught in a bigger lie.
And if Natiko gave card 3 (revealer) to Sneeks, it means Card 3 was Mystic Wolf (Or Tanner/minion) when Monkey got it.
And this means Sneeks is now Revealer.
Scenario Sneeks lying /Natiko is saying the truth
Mystic Wolf -> Monkey
Minion -> Terra
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 (Robber)
PI -> Sorian (Swapped with jman)
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Natiko
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Sneeks
Dream Wolf -> jman
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner -> Card 1
On the other hand if Sneeks is doubling down in the fact she was the robber, then that would mean stu is lying, but stu has no reason to lie. Natiko and Terra might
--------
Scenario Natiko and Sneeks is lying/Terra and stu is saying the truth
This is a weird one because for this one we have to assume that Sneeks somehow guessed my alignment AND is also lying about the robber thingy, meaning she is either minion or tanner, and that natiko went out of his way to protect her (Or just contradict terra to save himself)
Mystic Wolf -> Natiko
Minion ->
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 (Robber)
PI -> Sorian (Swapped with jman)
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Natiko
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Monkey -> Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> terra
Dream Wolf -> jman
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner ->
Conclussions.
Hey
@Sawneeks if you believe that Natiko is the Witch, then that means that regardless of your previous role you are now town, so why not tell us if you are really the robber? Otherwise you are contradicting a confirmed seer and that looks bad.