Scooby Doo & The Reluctant ONUW

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Oh Saw is lying too, cool cool, sorry for claiming lol

Yeah reading back on the way Stu claimed and jman backed him there is no way they can collude outside of a complete miracle.

And stu has been very townie too.

Sawneeks is aligning with Natiko anyway so I don't understand why they don't actually reveal their card and push that on monkey.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Only in the game? ;_: (JK, <3 you Monkey)

I mean, Sneeks is my ride-or-die outside games but inside I know she's a lying liar who lies. It's not that I don't love you also, it's that she's my girl!

she lying her whole face off here tho

But most of those lower targets aren’t as experienced as Saw. I was going for the best of both worlds.
keep scrambling
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I mean, Sneeks is my ride-or-die outside games but inside I know she's a lying liar who lies. It's not that I don't love you also, it's that she's my girl!

she lying her whole face off here tho


keep scrambling

I get the sneeks is BIG LYING part but why are you so convinced on Natiko? He has been a bit shady but Terra wasn't exactly forthcoming either...

You just blanking out any possibilities you are actually one of the baddies?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I mean, Sneeks is my ride-or-die outside games but inside I know she's a lying liar who lies. It's not that I don't love you also, it's that she's my girl!

she lying her whole face off here tho


keep scrambling
I hope you’re telling the truth and vote me so I can cackle at your failure lol
 
My gut is that I trust Nat and Stu. I concur that I think Terra is tanner. Not sure why else to hold out on claim and be suspicious...although there's enough information out there now to make a safe fake claim of what is remaining, right? So I dunno .
I explained why I didn't reveal my hand too soon. This isn't the same as Mafia, but I would do the same with a red check. I like to hold a reveal like that close to my chest if possible.

But looking back over everything, the Nat situation really reeks. I get called out for the late reveal, but you choose to ignore how incredibly convenient everything turned out to be for Nat. He not only chose the same card as Monkey, but he also happened to choose Neeks who is one of the players with a fat question mark over her making it easy to frame Monkey.
How does it frame Monkey at all? The only person it makes look bad is Terra.


I mean you can think what you want, but you just get to be wrong again lol I picked three on a whim, and chose Saw because I didn't think she would garner as much attention as the Sorian and Monkey's of the world and thus we'd have a cleaner chain of events.
I call bull honkey on this. Even just Sophia would have been a far more reasonable choice by that logic. But I guess that wouldn't work for your fakeclaim since Sophia would know this isn't the case.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I get the sneeks is BIG LYING part but why are you so convinced on Natiko? He has been a bit shady but Terra wasn't exactly forthcoming either...

You just blanking out any possibilities you are actually one of the baddies?
Nah, it's totally possible I ended up a wolf or similar. That's how it goes with the drunk and was always a possibility. Soon as I got my role I shrugged and resolved to mostly shitpost. I just don't believe anything Natiko has said, nor do I think he would have been so unforthcoming if he didn't have something to hide.

I also think if you want a "pure" target, you pick turmoil. But instead Natiko's responses sound like someone trying to come up with reasons to justify what he's said rather than someone's reasons for acting in the first place.

Terra being shady is more NAI from Terra than Nat being shady is. As in, I can understand Terra being shady, especially if Terra is telling the truth, because there's an objective there. There wasn't actually much reason for Nat to sit back unless he's lying.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I hope you’re telling the truth and vote me so I can cackle at your failure lol
Literally what reason do I have to lie? I'm the drunk. I have no idea what I ended up with. I didn't withhold. I always knew it was possible I'd end up a wolf. I'm not worried.

Truly, what bearing does me telling the truth or not have on any votes? None. My fate is decided by y'all and what y'all did. It always was.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Nah, it's totally possible I ended up a wolf or similar. That's how it goes with the drunk and was always a possibility. Soon as I got my role I shrugged and resolved to mostly shitpost. I just don't believe anything Natiko has said, nor do I think he would have been so unforthcoming if he didn't have something to hide.

I also think if you want a "pure" target, you pick turmoil. But instead Natiko's responses sound like someone trying to come up with reasons to justify what he's said rather than someone's reasons for acting in the first place.

Terra being shady is more NAI from Terra than Nat being shady is. As in, I can understand Terra being shady, especially if Terra is telling the truth, because there's an objective there. There wasn't actually much reason for Nat to sit back unless he's lying.

I think I agree tbh.

But none of this matters. Sorian says jman is wolf and I have no reason to not believe him.

jman is the vote.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
CryingYoshi.png

Nah, it's totally possible I ended up a wolf or similar. That's how it goes with the drunk and was always a possibility. Soon as I got my role I shrugged and resolved to mostly shitpost. I just don't believe anything Natiko has said, nor do I think he would have been so unforthcoming if he didn't have something to hide.

I also think if you want a "pure" target, you pick turmoil. But instead Natiko's responses sound like someone trying to come up with reasons to justify what he's said rather than someone's reasons for acting in the first place.

Terra being shady is more NAI from Terra than Nat being shady is. As in, I can understand Terra being shady, especially if Terra is telling the truth, because there's an objective there. There wasn't actually much reason for Nat to sit back unless he's lying.
tbh I disagree. Terra waited until everyone else claimed before giving his and it's nothing we can even remotely prove imo. If there's someone lying there it's Terra.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Oh, I was in the kitchen and I think I get now was Faddy was asking me (implicitly). (I haven't read since my last post so he may have already clarified this).

I don't care if I ended up wolfed and I lose lol. I'm gunning for the village. If my destiny is largely out of my hands, I choose to go v.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Oh, I was in the kitchen and I think I get now was Faddy was asking me (implicitly). (I haven't read since my last post so he may have already clarified this).

I don't care if I ended up wolfed and I lose lol. I'm gunning for the village. If my destiny is largely out of my hands, I choose to go v.

Ok as a completely honest broker what do you think of VA.

This is the whole game for me. If VA is town it is easy, if VA is the minion we lose.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Ok as a completely honest broker what do you think of VA.

This is the whole game for me. If VA is town it is easy, if VA is the minion we lose.
I don't understand why VA believes Natiko and I want to hear his answer on that.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I explained why I didn't reveal my hand too soon. This isn't the same as Mafia, but I would do the same with a red check. I like to hold a reveal like that close to my chest if possible.

But looking back over everything, the Nat situation really reeks. I get called out for the late reveal, but you choose to ignore how incredibly convenient everything turned out to be for Nat. He not only chose the same card as Monkey, but he also happened to choose Neeks who is one of the players with a fat question mark over her making it easy to frame Monkey.

I call bull honkey on this. Even just Sophia would have been a far more reasonable choice by that logic. But I guess that wouldn't work for your fakeclaim since Sophia would know this isn't the case.
Sophia hasn’t played much with our community in ages, so no she doesn’t hit the same level for me as Saw does in terms of concern level.

Nah, it's totally possible I ended up a wolf or similar. That's how it goes with the drunk and was always a possibility. Soon as I got my role I shrugged and resolved to mostly shitpost. I just don't believe anything Natiko has said, nor do I think he would have been so unforthcoming if he didn't have something to hide.

I also think if you want a "pure" target, you pick turmoil. But instead Natiko's responses sound like someone trying to come up with reasons to justify what he's said rather than someone's reasons for acting in the first place.

Terra being shady is more NAI from Terra than Nat being shady is. As in, I can understand Terra being shady, especially if Terra is telling the truth, because there's an objective there. There wasn't actually much reason for Nat to sit back unless he's lying.
Except the reason is to be able to catch someone out in a lie.

Literally what reason do I have to lie? I'm the drunk. I have no idea what I ended up with. I didn't withhold. I always knew it was possible I'd end up a wolf. I'm not worried.

Truly, what bearing does me telling the truth or not have on any votes? None. My fate is decided by y'all and what y'all did. It always was.
And if I was to lie as an uncounterclaimed witch that isn’t a witch why wouldn’t I just go the much easier route that Terra did and directly implicate someone? I could easily have said I saw a wolf and swapped it to someone.
 

Vincent Alexander

My best friend is a monkey
I don't understand why VA believes Natiko and I want to hear his answer on that.
I had no great reason. I was given a choice between Nat and Sawneeks, and Sawneeks made me more suspicious. Please judge nothing on my feels though because they are probably wrong and re-reading Sawneeks, I see nothing giving me pause. I dunno.
 

Vincent Alexander

My best friend is a monkey
At the end of the day, yeah---it's just a matter if I trust Sorian. Because I absolutely switched Sorian and Jman. And if we get 1 werewolf, village wins?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I had no great reason. I was given a choice between Nat and Sawneeks, and Sawneeks made me more suspicious. Please judge nothing on my feels though because they are probably wrong and re-reading Sawneeks, I see nothing giving me pause. I dunno.

It isn't Natiko/Sawneeks???

It is Natiko and Terra.
 
I think I agree tbh.

But none of this matters. Sorian says jman is wolf and I have no reason to not believe him.

jman is the vote.

Trusting Sorian always works out lol.

Sawneeks is the surefire vote. They lied, they didn't start with robber and they won't admit it. A move that could only be wolfed out by a wolf.

So Vote for Saw btw
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Trusting Sorian always works out lol.

Sawneeks is the surefire vote. They lied, they didn't start with robber and they won't admit it. A move that could only be wolfed out by a wolf.

So Vote for Saw btw

Sorian has absolutely no reason to lie.

You don't know if Sawneeks if wolf, tanner or minion.

If both Sorian and Terra are telling the truth then Sawneeks isn't a wolf.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Then why is Saw lying btw?
Nevermind, found them. So it's after my counterclaim.


significantly after.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I don’t know why I have two quotes in there. Maybe I hit a button on mobile and didn’t notice.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Trusting Sorian always works out lol.

Sawneeks is the surefire vote. They lied, they didn't start with robber and they won't admit it. A move that could only be wolfed out by a wolf.

So Vote for Saw btw
Except I 100% gave Saw card 3, so definitely don’t do this lol
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
claims
faddy-> switcher-> monkey/salva
va ->switcher-> monkey/salva
salva-> insomniac -> role change
monkey-> no claim
sneeks-> switcher jman/monkey
sneeks-> switcher turmoil instead

monkey-> drunk
stu-seer
jman-> invest-> turmoil/villager, stu/apprentice seer
jman and stu compatible
va->troublemaker -> jman was target
sneeks-> jman was target too
stu-> seer-> card 2
monkey-> drunk -> card 3
va-> tm-> sophia was not a target
sophia -> insomniac no change
sorian -> dream wolf
va-> tm-> swapped jman/pi and sorian/dw ->jman-dw and sorian/pi
Natiko didn't target sorian
sneeks robbed salva
stu -> seer-> saw card 2
sneeks robbed -> salva was mason
salva confirmed he was mason ->now is robber?
faddy confirms salva is mason, faddy is mason too
natiko claims witch
turm confirms he is villager
stu says card 2 is robber
terra ->revealer -> saw natiko is mystic wolf
natiko -> witch -> says card 3 is revealer -> swapped to sneeks



Order:
Mystic Wolf -> natiko (terra ->revealer -> saw natiko is mystic wolf) ->Natiko claims to be witch and that card 3 is revealer
Minion -> N/A
Masons-> Faddy and Salva (confirmed by both)
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 -> Card is robber (contradicted sneeks)
PI -> jman-> turmoil/villager, stu/apprentice seer (Confirmed by both)
Robber-> Sneeks robbed Salva the mason card. (contradicted by stu9
Witch -> Natiko-> Says Card 3 is revealer, swapped to sneeks (Contradicted by terra)
TM -> VA -> jman(pi)/Sorian(dreamwolf) -> jman(dreamwolf)/Sorian(pi)
Drunk-> Monkey Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Didn't trigger publicly. -> Terra claims natiko is mystic wolf (Natiko claims to be witch and that card 3 is revealer, swapped with sneeks)

Dream Wolf -> Sorian ->swapped with jman
Villager -> turmoil (as said by jman, confirmed by turm)
Tanner -> N/A


Game start (uncontested claims)
Mystic Wolf
Minion
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 ->Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2
PI -> jman-> turmoil/villager, stu/apprentice seer
Robber
Witch
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Monkey -> Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Didn't trigger publicly.

Dream Wolf -> Sorian
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner

Why would the lie?
-jman: He would need to know that villager and seer are both safe roles to claim, if either stu or turm was a bad card, either would just reveal they had a bad card. jman had no reason to lie
-sophia: counterclaimed me, even if she saw the role somehow chances are she is actually telling the truth. No reason to lie
monkey-> Drunk is an easy role to claim as wolf or even tanner, but it is irrelevant since she won't reveal more than that unless there is a way to confirm the card she "got" is bad and she has to defend herself.
faddy and salva-> masons, had each other back from the start, confirmed by a third party.
va -> troublemaker -> very little reason to not reveal both targets if no one messed with him.
sorian-> Dream Wolf is a ballsy role to claim, but makes sense if swapped around. No reason to not throw jman under the bus since from sorian's perspective, if va is telling the truth sorian is town and if va is lying sorian is still wolf, it's a win-win for Sorian.
turm-> Claiming villager with the pi as back-up, normal stuff.

Contradicting claims:
1) stu vs sneeks
2) terra vs natiko

If so teams would be:

sneeks knows my role is mason, something she can know as a mystic wolf (Or she could just guess?). Stu is seer and is backed by jman and it's unlikely jman lied about that. Stu saw the robber card 2 in the center, meaning sneeks is lying.

terra claims to be revealer and that natiko is mystic wolf, natiko claims to be the witch and that card 3 is the revealer and was given to sneeks

Let's assume sneeks is lying since jman is backing stu.
Sneeks is either Mystic Wolf, Minion or Tanner. Likely Mystic since she knows the role I started with.
Terra then is lying saying Natiko is Mystic Wolf, since Sneeks is likely Mystic Wolf. Terra is probably tanner or minion. Terra could be Mystic wolf himself and Sneeks Minion/Tanner just guessed I was mason. I don't think Terra would be tanner because I feel Terra would like to be caught in a bigger lie.
And if Natiko gave card 3 (revealer) to Sneeks, it means Card 3 was Mystic Wolf (Or Tanner/minion) when Monkey got it.
And this means Sneeks is now Revealer.

Scenario Sneeks lying /Natiko is saying the truth
Mystic Wolf -> Monkey
Minion -> Terra
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 (Robber)
PI -> Sorian (Swapped with jman)
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Natiko
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Sneeks

Dream Wolf -> jman
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner -> Card 1

On the other hand if Sneeks is doubling down in the fact she was the robber, then that would mean stu is lying, but stu has no reason to lie. Natiko and Terra might

--------
Scenario Natiko and Sneeks is lying/Terra and stu is saying the truth
This is a weird one because for this one we have to assume that Sneeks somehow guessed my alignment AND is also lying about the robber thingy, meaning she is either minion or tanner, and that natiko went out of his way to protect her (Or just contradict terra to save himself)

Mystic Wolf -> Natiko
Minion ->
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 (Robber)
PI -> Sorian (Swapped with jman)
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Natiko
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Monkey -> Card 3
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> terra

Dream Wolf -> jman
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner ->


Conclussions.
Hey @Sawneeks if you believe that Natiko is the Witch, then that means that regardless of your previous role you are now town, so why not tell us if you are really the robber? Otherwise you are contradicting a confirmed seer and that looks bad.
 
Which could be entirely true but doesn’t change that Saw is now Revealer lol

Would involve trusting you of course.

though that's a better option than trusting Sorian lol btw.

Eh, we have plenty of time to hash out everything before the voting stage anyway
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Trusting Sorian always works out lol.

Sawneeks is the surefire vote. They lied, they didn't start with robber and they won't admit it. A move that could only be wolfed out by a wolf.

So Vote for Saw btw

You realize that two roles in this game actively want you to vote for them right? This logic is horrible.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Is Stu doing btw in every post supposed to be a crumb?
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
I've been thinking a lot about 4-D Chess Sorian, and here is where I am.

-Sorian starts as Dream Wolf.
-Sees that VA is claiming jman and sorian where swapped AFTER he claimed dream wolf.
-Sorian then happily pushes for jman vote since sorian knows that is where the card has to be now. PI didn't look at Sorian, Robber either targeted someone else or is at the center, Witch didn't mess with either too.

Now let's assume Sorian is lying.
Would town Sorian lie? No, because if they vote jman and jman is a wolf or tanner, Sorian loses.
Would tanner Sorian lie? No, because if they vote jman and jman is tanner, Sorian loses.
Would minion Sorian lie? No , if they vote jman and jman is a minion, Sorian loses.

But that still leaves a chance that Sorian is lying about what type of wolf Sorian is.

For Sorian to lie you would have to assume that VA is lying too, they are both partners and are backing up each other, and for that to work:
-First, VA would have to be either Minion or Mystic Wolf and hope no one counterclaims troublemaker.
-Second, VA would see the Dream Wolf claim and say "Sweet I can just claim he was swapped with jman" and that way they direct jman there.
-Third, Sorian would back the now framed jman vote.

Now, this is not 100% unlikely. There is a chance Sorian is the Mystic Wolf and just claimed dream so Sorian didn't have to give more info than that, like who the partner is or who they checked. There is a chance VA is minion and was waiting for either of the wolfs to claim to claim it was "swapped" with poor jman. And if a counter troublemaker appeared before that he could be voted out instead and have the wolves win this way. But this still means it's unlikely that sorian lied about been wolf.

So let's assume that VA is minion and Sorian is Dream Wolf. How would this fit with the rest of the game?

Well, for starters, who could their teammates be:
-Sneeks as Mystic Wolf or Minion, guessing who I am. But in this case there is the loose end of Terra, who in this scenario could only be tanner. Also Sneeks would know Sorian is telling the truth, or if she was minion, would know that VA is lying.
-Terra as Mystic Wolf or Minion. Explaining why lie about Natiko. But in this scenario he would also know that Sorian is telling the truth, or if minion, know that VA is lying.
-Natiko as Mystic Wolf or Minion: Same as above.

But if any of this three knew the other two are teammates, why not do something to support it and pile on jman? They instead all 3 went for their own gambits pretty much away from the claimed dream wolf.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
i crunched my numbers, did some maths, and unless im being hard bamboozled by Nat then monkey is now the minion.

the only other wolf in the game was sorian so i know the 3rd wolf was in the middle. meaning idk what Terra is doing since he isn't a wolf
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
i crunched my numbers, did some maths, and unless im being hard bamboozled by Nat then monkey is now the minion.

the only other wolf in the game was sorian so i know the 3rd wolf was in the middle. meaning idk what Terra is doing since he isn't a wolf
...how did you get my role then?
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
So current scenario


Scenario Sneeks/Natiko is saying the truth

Game Start

Mystic Wolf -> Card 1
Minion -> Sneeks
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu
PI -> jman
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Natiko
Troublemaker -> VA
Drunk-> Monkey
Insomn ->Sophia
Revealer-> Card 3

Dream Wolf -> Sorian
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner -> Terra


Current

Mystic Wolf -> Card 1
Minion -> Monkey
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 (Robber)
PI -> Sorian (Swapped with jman)
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Natiko
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Card 3 (Left there by monkey)
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Sneeks

Dream Wolf -> jman
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner -> Terra
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
All this proved further is that jman is the vote lol
Hmm let's see if I can find holes.

Taking Sneeks information. Why would sneek choose minion over mystic if she is still somehow lying.

Well, maybe sneeks don't want town to vote for monkey, and go for jman. But if that is the case, if Sneeks knew Sorian is wolf and now wants people to vote jman, then that would mean Sneeks believes she is town now. Hmm

If she is minion she knows VA and Sorian are both wolfs and goes along with the plan, but for that she would need to be sure Natiko is not actually witch, yeah that makes no sense...

If she is mystic wolf and realized va is minion and sorian is dream wolf, yet again that would be a risky jump to make.

Hmmmmmmmmmm.
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
And if Sneeks didn't believe Natiko then she wouldn't lie about beeing minion I think, because she would still like to get the votes in that case.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Oh monkey is in defense mode, I think she is worried she is minion now.
No, I’m saying the same thing I’ve been saying all day?
Legit I do not care if I win and I don’t care if you believe me or not. I have zero investment here.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Or maybe it’s more apt to say I only care if I’m right about things or not. That’s way more satisfying than playing follow the card.

Like Sneeks was lying. I appreciate her confession tho, it made me laugh. But being right is better.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Monkey could also be the third partner wolf or minion and just claimed drunk to seem busy.
Nah. I'm the drunk, card 3, and then if card 3 was manipulated prior, I'm that. I don't see any reason to lie and if I wanted do I'd have waited to be the last card reveal.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Conclussions.
Hey @Sawneeks if you believe that Natiko is the Witch, then that means that regardless of your previous role you are now town, so why not tell us if you are really the robber? Otherwise you are contradicting a confirmed seer and that looks bad.
Yeah, this is the thing I'm stuck on. It just generally doesn't make sense to me, especially since she had any number of potential outs.

Idk, I'll think about it and come back later.

potential minion out
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
hmm that makes sense, as minion you'll want people to vote for you.

Now I'm waiting for natiko to go "sike"
No, my claim isn't shifting lol

“If I was lying I would have implicated someone,” says Nat, who is implicating me but thinks it’s okay if he just doesn’t say it.
Oh, you know I don't think I realized the order of operations on this one. I feel like you all forgot I'm quite bad at ONUW and have only played it like three times and literally every time I bumble around and then just follow the loudest voice for the vote.
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
Honestly I feel like VA and Sorian both gambitting together to frame jman is such a 300 IQ idea I think if they got us they deserve the win.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Or maybe it’s more apt to say I only care if I’m right about things or not. That’s way more satisfying than playing follow the card.

Like Sneeks was lying. I appreciate her confession tho, it made me laugh. But being right is better.

Sneeks ultimate lie tell was saying "and whatever the hell Sorian is doing" when I'm making the most basic play possible.
 
i crunched my numbers, did some maths, and unless im being hard bamboozled by Nat then monkey is now the minion.

the only other wolf in the game was sorian so i know the 3rd wolf was in the middle. meaning idk what Terra is doing since he isn't a wolf
Also what is this supposed to mean? Why are you so easily falling for Nat's claim??? What I'm doing makes plenty of sense because I am telling the truth. He's the only variable that "contradicts" me and just so happens to rely on a pile of evidence that points a finger at monkey.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Also what is this supposed to mean? Why are you so easily falling for Nat's claim??? What I'm doing makes plenty of sense because I am telling the truth. He's the only variable that "contradicts" me and just so happens to rely on a pile of evidence that points a finger at monkey.

The evidence doesn't finger Monkey though, no one cares about killing the minion.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Sneeks ultimate lie tell was saying "and whatever the hell Sorian is doing" when I'm making the most basic play possible.
Right? Unless I lie, every person in the game will know more about what I am than I did, and I don't feel like maintaining a two day lie, so basic it is.

#teambasic
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Sneeks ultimate lie tell was saying "and whatever the hell Sorian is doing" when I'm making the most basic play possible.
"Like by heymonkey"

feeling so attacked rn
Also what is this supposed to mean? Why are you so easily falling for Nat's claim??? What I'm doing makes plenty of sense because I am telling the truth. He's the only variable that "contradicts" me and just so happens to rely on a pile of evidence that points a finger at monkey.
because I only saw 1 wolf (sorian) so that means between you and Nat I know there are no wolves. If you WERE telling the truth about your role you would have said Nat was the Tanner because I know he can't possibly be a wolf.
 

SalvaPot

YEAH
Scenario Terra is saying the truth about Natiko as Mystic Wolf/Natiko is lying AND Sneeks(minion) is lying about Natiko NOT being the mystic wolf

Game Start

Mystic Wolf -> Natiko
Minion -> Sneeks
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu
PI -> jman
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Card 1 or 3
Troublemaker -> VA
Drunk-> Monkey
Insomn ->Sophia
Revealer-> Terra

Dream Wolf -> Sorian
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner -> Card 1 or 3


Current

Mystic Wolf -> Natiko
Minion -> Sneeks
Mason 1 ->Faddy
Mason 2 -> Salva
Seer- > Stu-> Card 2 (Robber)
PI -> Sorian (Swapped with jman)
Robber -> Card 2
Witch -> Card 1 or Monkey
Troublemaker -> VA -> jman/sorian
Drunk-> Card 3 (Left there by monkey)
Insomn ->Sophia (No Change)
Revealer-> Terra

Dream Wolf -> jman
Villager -> turmoil
Tanner -> Card 1 or Monkey

The problem with this is that, for it to work...
1)If sneeks is minion, then she knows Natiko is lying about the witch claim, AND knows Sorian is telling the truth about dream wolf, so sneeks knows that she still is minion, and if she knows that she still is minion then she does not want jman voted out because jman is now the wolf.
2)Also if sneeks was minion and knows Natiko is mystic wolf then she would know terra is telling the truth and wouldn't want people to vote Natiko. But if that is true then Sneeks could claim Mystic Wolf to frame monkey as a safe alternative to jman.
3)If sneeks is tanner, then she could believe that maybe natiko is indeed witch, but then claimed she is minion instead? Maybe to make sure no one votes monkey either. She just confirmed what we all know: That sorian is dream wolf.

Conclussion
The reason why terra claimed he saw Natiko as Mystic Wolf is because it just made logical sense, since dream wolf was taken, no one claimed revealer, and it would make sense someone might contradict it.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I don't know why Sawneeks would lie here about being minion. It makes complete sense. Her earlier play of believing Nat but also holding onto the lie of being Robber was not making sense. It seals up voting for jman too since Natiko is now probably telling the truth and Terra is the tanner.

I'm trying to think of how we lose. And I don't see it.

There is no scenario where both Sawneeks and Sorian are playing to their win condition and VA is their partner.
And if VA is lock town then it is as simple as vote jman and win.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
When the voting stage starts, how long is it, 24h? or just a "once all votes are in" sort of thing?

Usually 24 hours officially but your vote is locked once it’s sent so usually it’s just announced at game runners convenience once all votes are received
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Start of GameEnd of Game
FaddyMasonMason
SalvaMasonMason
SophiaInsomniacInsomniac
TurmoilVillagerVillager
Vincent AlexanderSwitcherSwitcher
StuApprentice SeerApprentice Seer
JmanParanormal InvestigatorDream Wolf
MonkeyDrunkMinion
NatikoWitchWitch
SorianDream WolfParanormal Investigator
SawneeksMinionRevealer
TerraTannerTanner
Card 1Mystic WolfMystic Wolf
Card 2RobberRobber
Card 3RevealerDrunk
 
Top Bottom