Gnos

Verelios

Were-elios
I'm not sure if we resolved that or not? IDK if Random can answer that question for us? Do Mafia games normally give refunds on blocked shots? That seems weird to me but I haven't played enough games to know that or not
Yeah, mafia games normally refund on blocked shots. Not all the time, but usually.
 
IDK if Random can answer that question for us? Do Mafia games normally give refunds on blocked shots? That seems weird to me but I haven't played enough games to know that or not
Gamerunners have their own discretion. Some gamerunners refund blocked shots, some do not. I do not.
 
I think you should maybe keep LP alive. Look at what chuggs is posting. If we keep LP and Chuggs alive the more that theory looks plausible I think
 
Yeah with zips latest post I think actually keeping the doctor alive has some benefits so at least think about it. If they can't trust their doctor then what value does the doctor role actually have?
 

Verelios

Were-elios
@karkador What do you think? Should I watch HP tonight? We can take the opportunity to shoot him. It'll be good win or lose. If we get him then we can prove Wizard didn't protect HP. If we don't then we can insinuate Wizard is running a hydropump by me claiming NOT to have protected anyone tonight.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Tonight we have these characters to worry about:

Shigemitsu - Is searching for Stella each night. With 6 characters still unaccounted for (from town perspective), their odds of finding you are 1/6.
Remnan - We didn't hear from Remnan D1, but they still have at least one shot motion detect.
Yuriko - In all likelihood has not used her character-reading shot yet.

I think most people will be asking about Stella tomorrow, and there are two roles that potentially can find you. D3 you will most likely need to claim Stella.

The reality is that no one will know if you actually used her or not. At best, Remnan will motion detect you, which will look the same whether you kill or watch.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Actually i should say Shig is 1/5-1/6, because they probably used this power N1, unless they are also town pr
 

karkador

Board Game King
The big reason not to claim Stella is because if you're voted out, you can take Shig with you. But there might be more use in fake claiming a Stella read.
 

karkador

Board Game King
If we assume HP is getting the protect, you could Stella HP, i send my letter, and we no NK but you are able to fake claim a watch, i have an alibi in the letter, and town loses their minds
 

Verelios

Were-elios
The big reason not to claim Stella is because if you're voted out, you can take Shig with you. But there might be more use in fake claiming a Stella read.
That's what I'm feeling. What I'm wondering though, is how likely do you feel it is that other people target HP tonight? Just to check if Stella did it?
 

karkador

Board Game King
There's no one left to target HP, that's the thing. Only the GA could target him, and perhaps the character roles.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
If we assume HP is getting the protect, you could Stella HP, i send my letter, and we no NK but you are able to fake claim a watch, i have an alibi in the letter, and town loses their minds
Questions...questions...I think this is a good way to go.

@Randomless we can't Stella/Kill/Send mail tonight right?

If I died tomorrow would Kark be able to send mail and kill same night?
 

karkador

Board Game King
Oh one thing though - if you're claimed GA you probably need to say you protected HP or LP, which complicates things since you can't use both that and Stella.

Either you have to say you let a kill go through to use Stella, or we swap character claims lol (this might be more trouble than it's worth)
 

Verelios

Were-elios
All Yuriko tells a player is what character they are. So Yuriko would learn that HP is SQ, not anything that happened to HP
Yeah, but if I claim Stella then it's with the knowledge of everyone who targeted him tonight, is what I'm getting at. Pretty much just thinking about the risk between shooting HP and watching him.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Vere, yeah we kinda have to pick our poison here. It's LP's Doctor or HP's Engineer

If Doc reports Dark was Gnosia, there will be a lot of voting and town talk implications drawn from that. At least with Doc, we know exactly what he's gonna see and report.

If HP lives, he could report on me or you. I don't think he use his last shot on anything else, and I'm really unsure who he chooses. You came in and were way townier than me. I also have the kicker of possibly being a Bug, which would resolve nicely for him if he scans and kills me.
 

karkador

Board Game King
If we kill LP, all Town gains is confirmation that his counterclaim was Gnosia...which they're getting if LP lives anyway and reports on Dark.
 

karkador

Board Game King
if town doesn't learn that i can send letters and kill, it's pretty much impossible to catch me, seems unfair, lol.

....but it would be FUCKING AWESOME
 

Verelios

Were-elios
So that seems like it makes no difference whether he's dead or alive
At least for now there's no pressing need to kill LP, I agree.

Wizard should be on his last shot tomorrow too so I think we can gamble tonight. Hm. Gamble. Damn, that's scary. Let's kill HP. LET'S GO!
 

Verelios

Were-elios
You want to just do a final swan song and kill Wizard? I think if we kill wizard I'll be the train for tomorrow making it likely shige will vote for me. We get at least 2 best case scenario.
 

karkador

Board Game King
So here's something curious - LP did not vote on either D1 or D2. Maybe LP is Shigemichi and was careful to avoid voting? In both cases the character flip was unknown.
 

karkador

Board Game King
So that makes me think a stella fake report is worth more chaos points than trying to get Shig to vote for you
 

Verelios

Were-elios
So that makes me think a stella fake report is worth more chaos points than trying to get Shig to vote for you
Hm, that's a really good observation. I didn't even notice LP wasn't voting. Alright, tentative plan:

I 'watch' HP but instead shoot him.
You send him a message.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Alternatively, you claim Stella but your shot was blocked. That would implicate Yuriko or Shig as part of the scum team, since they could learn your name. We attack HP and probably whiff, or I send a letter to start building alibis.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Alternatively, you claim Stella but your shot was blocked. That would implicate Yuriko or Shig as part of the scum team, since they could learn your name. We attack HP and probably whiff, or I send a letter to start building alibis.
Not a bad plan. Let me put this in so we don't forget to do the kill. The only thing we can really think about is whether you want to send a message to HP. I think you can send something to incriminate Chuggs...but not name him y'know. Like about the PRs. Mention your thoughts on HP/Donnie and the Crew situation. Subtle like.

But would you send a message to someone you think is scum?

Kill: HP
 

karkador

Board Game King
What I'm shooting for with messages is to hit the Bug. If they Nexus, the letter will end up with someone else, but it should still read that I sent it to the Bug. So I get big town points from that, it can't be a scum plot since the bounce is random (although I've thought about us faking this anyway), it eliminates the bug, and so on.
 

karkador

Board Game King
If i keep hammering a bug suspect with a letter, they either can't use Nexus (allowing someone else to investigate them) or i catch them. This was the "foolproof plan" i keep trying to pitch to town
 

karkador

Board Game King
I mean i think this HP kill is failing. If you Stella then you would at least be able to lie and say someone else went for HP
 

karkador

Board Game King
If we shoot Donnie for instance, we likely get the NK, we get to say you couldn't GA for the Stella shot, you can fake a result (or maybe you don't, and spin it as 'i could easily frame someone but didn't, because I'm town'), and if they vote you out you flip Stella and it looks legit.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Wait we weren't aiming for Wiz with the kill?
Hm. What do you think? Donnie or HP? We can do either. There's a possibility Wiz tries to fake us out with a Donnie save but it would be wild. Especially with the Stella shout. Either way, I don't think it matters...much, who we hit since we just need more bodies down. There's a 1/3 chance HP hits me. 1/3 chance he hits you and that's great! 1/3 chance he hits the godfather Wizard =). And now that we know shots aren't refunded this is his last shot.

Kill: Donnie
If i keep hammering a bug suspect with a letter, they either can't use Nexus (allowing someone else to investigate them) or i catch them. This was the "foolproof plan" i keep trying to pitch to town
This is a plan. Are you going to try EC tonight?
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I'm between EC, Zipped, and Fate
Hm. I would take Fate out and put Melon in here, considering. I think for me the bug prob would be:
EC>Melon>Zipped

Zipped attracted too much attention to himself at EoD. Melon's parity cop usage (why not use Launch or Donnie as a test) gives me funny feelings.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Yeah I really think if the game has progressed like all scum are caught, then Bug is angling to pass by looking like they're scum-hunting, as its the quickest path to victory and hopefully shields them from the bug hunt.

The only thing is that I claimed Fate as my #1 bug suspect, and EC as #2, so it would make sense to send Fate a letter tonight
 

karkador

Board Game King
Unless I claim I sent fate a letter D1 and never heard back about it. But if he flips and isn't Bug, that will be hard to explain
 

karkador

Board Game King
To: EvilChameleon

::Meow!::

Today's password is: "Beyoncé - KItty Kat"

Please report this message in day chat at your earliest convenience. I will be asking you for the password, so don't forget it. Otherwise, ::HISSSS::

 

karkador

Board Game King
catjam-cat-jamming.gif
 

Verelios

Were-elios
So, do you think I should claim characterblocked or fake what I see? I did have a reaction to using Stella and with the thinning number of people maybe scum knew to take a chance on me.
 

karkador

Board Game King
We have two options, assuming Donnie dies:

1) You claim you used Stella to target HP, and successfully got a read.
  • In this read, you would logically not find the killer, because the killer shot Donnie.
  • LP will report that Dark was Gnosia. HP will also give a report, so Town will conclude Dark was the Roleblocker.
  • If no one a claims a character block tomorrow, it might look bad on you, but I'm not sure.
  • In terms of useful fakeclaims, I guess you could claim that the character blocker visited HP. But I'm not sure why they would do that.

2) You claim Stella, targeted HP, but got character-blocked, so you have no read.
  • LP will report that Dark was Gnosia. HP will also give a report, so Town will conclude Dark was the Roleblocker, thus the Character blocker is still at large.
  • Claiming you were blocked implicates Shig or Yuriko trying to stop Stella. But the Characterblock works with playername, so it's not impossible that the blocker got you without the name.
  • To implicate ShigLP as scum, we would have to make a case for a LP - Chuggs - ???? scum team, because they collaborated on the D1 Comet claim.
  • To implicate Yuriko, we would probably like to know who that is first. (Please don't be Donnie).
  • Also in a scum team, Character blocker is not necessarily the same person as either Shig or Yuriko, they would share info.
 

karkador

Board Game King
I'm not sure if Rando will answer this for us, but what's the order of the Role/Character usage limit?

For example, if Zipped used his Protag ability D2, would be be unable to use a role power the following Night, or did he have to skip the night power on N1?
In other words, what resets the "counter" for players who might have split day/night roles?

My guess is these daytime vote powers are emergency/impulse uses, so they would lock you out of your Night role for that following Night, and it's simply contained in one day/night cycle.
 

karkador

Board Game King
The reason being, once that topic comes up in chat, people will effectively eliminate Zipped or EC as having done anything tonight, since they threw down their vote powers D2.
 
I'm not sure if Rando will answer this for us, but what's the order of the Role/Character usage limit?

For example, if Zipped used his Protag ability D2, would be be unable to use a role power the following Night, or did he have to skip the night power on N1?
In other words, what resets the "counter" for players who might have split day/night roles?

My guess is these daytime vote powers are emergency/impulse uses, so they would lock you out of your Night role for that following Night, and it's simply contained in one day/night cycle.
I cannot answer this
 

karkador

Board Game King
It's a gamble but shooting Wiz kills you, shooting LP closes the door on your Stella claim completely, Donnie is just not gonna be seen as scum. So unless we shoot a bystander for the NK
 

karkador

Board Game King
Actually, shooting LP doesn't close the door on your stella claim, any characterblock scum could have targeted you, it's just that we don't implicate shig/yuriko on the claim. maybe we try to get pressure on LP to vote, once we send you off
 

karkador

Board Game King
Though as confirmed town he probably doesn't have to do anything for the rest of the game. Removing him would at least remove that
 

karkador

Board Game King
Sorry man, I'm going in circles and it's essentially your call since you'll be facing scrutiny either way. Let's go with what you feel most comfortable defending against
 

karkador

Board Game King
I'm thinking of switching my letter to Fate. EC used his ability to push for Dark to get voted out, and playing along wiht my letter will just add more town confirm vibes. There could be an argument that a Bug would push for scum to die, but let's save it for later
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I'm thinking of switching my letter to Fate. EC used his ability to push for Dark to get voted out, and playing along wiht my letter will just add more town confirm vibes. There could be an argument that a Bug would push for scum to die, but let's save it for later
Hm, who were you most down about? If you have a gut feeling then switch, always follow your gut.
 

karkador

Board Game King
The list of potentials is not that long, and shorter if we assume Day Action = No Night action.

Fate
EC - acted D2
Zipped - acted D2
Chuggs
Melon
malus
 

karkador

Board Game King
Yeah I am getting a sense of ambivalence from him, but does it benefit me to send him the letter? doesn't really line up with who i've bug-hunted. if he confirms the letter that might be seen as cooperative and trustworthy
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Well, let's see how the pin drops. I'm sure you're laughing at us Randomless, from your giant spacestation in the...space. The humanity.
 
Top Bottom