Gnos

karkador

Board Game King
I honestly don't know what to add to town chat about your situation with Wiz, lol. I know it looks bad. Any suggestions?
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I honestly don't know what to add to town chat about your situation with Wiz, lol. I know it looks bad. Any suggestions?
Hmmm. I would say, you can echo Wizard that me saying characterblocked seems prescient. That seems more iffy to you and where you would vote rn of the two.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Donnie also hasn't voted, probably Shigemichi if Fate is Yuriko. If true we have to push Fate.

But what to do about LP tonight? If you survive, Town should expect you protect LP. If Wiz goes, we have to kill LP unless we can come up with a case for him being Godfather.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Donnie also hasn't voted, probably Shigemichi if Fate is Yuriko. If true we have to push Fate.

But what to do about LP tonight? If you survive, Town should expect you protect LP. If Wiz goes, we have to kill LP unless we can come up with a case for him being Godfather.
Hm. Kill Donnie. It would explain Wiz not targeting HP. Because he couldn't!
 

karkador

Board Game King
Could you explain that? Not following

Also Wiz being coy about saying who he targeted makes me wonder if he didn't use the shot
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Could you explain that? Not following

Also Wiz being coy about saying who he targeted makes me wonder if he didn't use the shot
Wait, wait. We go for LP. If it goes through then I say I protected Donnie to save LP for the next day. I count it as a win since LP has unlimited shots, we can sacrifice me and get you into a good position. If it fails then Wizard has a lot of splaining to do, he can't expect people to believe not only did he not protect HP OR LP today, but that he just so happened protect Donnie ;)
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Losing the AC follower early on really messed us up =(. Thinking about how beautiful it could be if we were able to kill LP and HP last night and Chuggs and Donnie tonight. Beautiful.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Yuuuup. Honestly I thought all was lost at that moment. I still dont' think we have the numbers to get to the end, so this is gonna be more like a score attack
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Yuuuup. Honestly I thought all was lost at that moment. I still dont' think we have the numbers to get to the end, so this is gonna be more like a score attack
Yoooo Kark and Vere going on a rip through town. Nothing but fun and wild tones!
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Town. Town pls. Sometimes I just want to turbo and I KNOW none of you are going to bust in with a fresh take.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Bug Role PM

"If you are killed, the following message will be publicly broadcast at the start of the next Day Phase:
The Bug in spacetime has been resolved"

They don't get confirmation til the next day phase!

If we actually kill the Bug at night, this frame job is complete
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Bug Role PM

"If you are killed, the following message will be publicly broadcast at the start of the next Day Phase:
The Bug in spacetime has been resolved"

They don't get confirmation til the next day phase!

If we actually kill the Bug at night, this frame job is complete
<.< That's going to be hard when we have to get all the confirmed towns. And are you sure? @Randomless can you confirm if the bug was killed at night whether the broadcast would be the day after or the day following? So, if the bug was killed N4, would the broadcast be D5 or D6?
 

karkador

Board Game King
"Start of the next day phase" seems pretty clear to me in either NK or vote-out scenario.

LP reading Fate as Human does not concern me because Bug also reads as Human. Wiz can go waste the shot he's probably holding onto, too.
 

karkador

Board Game King
I thought you'd say the hard part was finding the Bug, lol. I mean we have it narrowed down to 4 people max?
 

Verelios

Were-elios
We can lower it to Malus>Zipped>Melon after seeing his response. He doesn't think Fate is the bug. I think we got our bug.
 
<.< That's going to be hard when we have to get all the confirmed towns. And are you sure? @Randomless can you confirm if the bug was killed at night whether the broadcast would be the day after or the day following? So, if the bug was killed N4, would the broadcast be D5 or D6?
In this situation, if the Bug is killed N4, the broadcast would be at the start of D5.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
In this situation, if the Bug is killed N4, the broadcast would be at the start of D5.
b16.jpg


Alright.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Here's the interesting thing about malus being Bug - if he's Sha-ming, he will take two days for them to kill, which might buy us more time than killing him ourselves
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Chuggs or Melon for tonight, who do you like? We can give LP the free pass. Bug is announced publically and Melon's parity claim means that Fate couldn't be Gnosia.

We're going to push Wiz as scum hard. By not going after LP we can say I protected him, while Wiz shouldn't have been able to if he PROTECTED him N2.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
What? Aren't they gonna be really really mad at me tomorrow when dead Bug doesn't announce?
Mad, possibly. But a little mad is still preferrable to wiped out? We can still quibble and look for bug. What I mean is that if we kill bug now, there's nothing stopping them from tearing through us.
 

karkador

Board Game King
That's true, if we think Sha-mingMalus is Bug, then that buys us time, like we said. But they're gonna vote me out tomorrow for sure, since the letter claim is falling apart without clear results. Town still hasn't understood that a Godfather claim reads like Human to LP, not Gnosia (this was asked of Rando a while ago and he No-Answer'd it). Melon's claim does not rule out Godfather for Fate, but I think this will be an uphill battle to climb.
 
Were you seeing wacky numbers and letters, like I posted gibberish? Or was it just the accidentally too long day clock? If it was the former somebody else had that issue too, don't know what is up with that
 

Verelios

Were-elios
That's true, if we think Sha-mingMalus is Bug, then that buys us time, like we said. But they're gonna vote me out tomorrow for sure, since the letter claim is falling apart without clear results. Town still hasn't understood that a Godfather claim reads like Human to LP, not Gnosia (this was asked of Rando a while ago and he No-Answer'd it). Melon's claim does not rule out Godfather for Fate, but I think this will be an uphill battle to climb.
You can def fight it. It'll be hard because most people will just want to speed the day along, but I think if we switch over to looking for the bug we'll be able to do better.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Were you seeing wacky numbers and letters, like I posted gibberish? Or was it just the accidentally too long day clock? If it was the former somebody else had that issue too, don't know what is up with that
It was rewinding time lol. So it would go down then up again.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Can we run down some scenarios based on who we kill? I still think they easily flip me tomorrow and turn on you soon after, unless we deliver the Bug
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Can we run down some scenarios based on who we kill? I still think they easily flip me tomorrow and turn on you soon after, unless we deliver the Bug
Sure. Um.

So, if we kill LP then you're boned. They'll flip you for lying. I'm boned too since I said I protected HP yesterday and LP is fine.

If we kill Malus and he's bug, you're in a good position. Announcement will happen and make it seem like Fate was bug! Congratulations everywhere. I will likely die, as will Wizard because we have leeway. But you also won't be going to F3 because there's going to be a lot of questions about WHY malus. Counterpoint! Maybe Fate really was gnosia. But Melon did parity cop check with Chuggs and Fate. Impossible for Fate/Melon/Dark/WiZ to be teamed. Messy. But also a fun situation. We CAN go here.

We Kill Chuggs. Not special, it's a very meh hit. You probably die today and I can get to F3. I mighhhht die against Wiz, depends on who's left with us.

We Kill Melon. She might be bug. Same as above with Malus, but slightly better because she's townread.

We kill Zipped. He might be bug. Same as Malus.

Leaving out EC, but I don't think he's bug. His kill is meh.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Sure. Um.

So, if we kill LP then you're boned. They'll flip you for lying. I'm boned too since I said I protected HP yesterday and LP is fine.

If we kill Malus and he's bug, you're in a good position. Announcement will happen and make it seem like Fate was bug! Congratulations everywhere. I will likely die, as will Wizard because we have leeway. But you also won't be going to F3 because there's going to be a lot of questions about WHY malus. Counterpoint! Maybe Fate really was gnosia. But Melon did parity cop check with Chuggs and Fate. Impossible for Fate/Melon/Dark/WiZ to be teamed. Messy. But also a fun situation. We CAN go here.

We Kill Chuggs. Not special, it's a very meh hit. You probably die today and I can get to F3. I mighhhht die against Wiz, depends on who's left with us.

We Kill Melon. She might be bug. Same as above with Malus, but slightly better because she's townread.

We kill Zipped. He might be bug. Same as Malus.

Leaving out EC, but I don't think he's bug. His kill is meh.

Correct me if I'm wrong (as I have been known to do): Melon's Raqio looks at two roles and checks for the same role name. Chuggs and Fate cleared as the same. However, in this case, a Godfather would read like Crew, and match Chuggs anyway.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Correct me if I'm wrong (as I have been known to do): Melon's Raqio looks at two roles and checks for the same role name. Chuggs and Fate cleared as the same. However, in this case, a Godfather would read like Crew, and match Chuggs anyway.
You could be right! Let me check. You're right, that does happen for Godfather. So what do you want to do?
 

karkador

Board Game King
As it stands, this will happen tonight:
- LP reads Fate as Human
- Wiz will use his shot on LP
->>> if he's really smart, he has caught on to the possibility of us killing the Bug ourselves, and will protect the Bug himself to trap us. If he ends up protecting Malus? lmao
- Shigemichi will probably check you for Stella


If we push the Fate-was-Godfather theory, Town will probably have trouble believing that LP's Human result doesn't contradict that. We would have to argue it while staying confined to the vague public answer Rando gave about it.
 

karkador

Board Game King
You know, I really did think Town would buy the less-complicated version that Fate was just scum and kept the letter. Fate DID communicate his confusion about it pretty well, so maybe they didn't believe that he was hiding it. But have these people never heard of occam's razor?
 

karkador

Board Game King
Anyway, during the last day, I tried to project how long we would last whether we try going for the Bug or not.

Format:
Day/Night - Players Left - Eliminatiion


We kill the Bug:

d3 - 11 - Fate
n3 - 10 - Malus (Bug??)
d4 - 9 - Vere (worst case)
n4 - 8 - Wiz
d5 - 7 - ???
n5 -
d6 - 5 - ???
n6 -
d7 - 3


We don't kill the Bug:

d3 - 11 - Fate
n3 - 11 - ???
d4 - 9 - Rover
n4 - ??
d5 - 7 - malus
n5- ??
d6 - 6 - malus
n6 - ??
d7 - 4 - Vere - Town wins (but if they don't get you here, i think we win?)
 

karkador

Board Game King
The really juicy part is that if I'm the last scum left, I get to send my letters and kill at the same time, which might just be enough of an alibi to protect me for the rest of the game (or get me to that F3)
 

Verelios

Were-elios
You know, I really did think Town would buy the less-complicated version that Fate was just scum and kept the letter. Fate DID communicate his confusion about it pretty well, so maybe they didn't believe that he was hiding it. But have these people never heard of occam's razor?
Because it doesn't help him not to admit to getting a letter. What we CAN do is stress that maybe scum wanted a situation where they couldn't be touched, so Fate decided on the cuff to hide getting the letter. It would need to be for a reason...so, perhaps Wizard was telling the truth when he said scum wanted to force town to waste time looking for the bug. But who really benefits between us? Most people trust Wizard more now...so the situation is more beneficial to him. Perhaps that's exactly why they're going through with this! Hmmmm, I think if we get bug you need to start hammering for a thunderdome amongst me and Wiz.
 

karkador

Board Game King
If Malus us the bug, though (or even if he's not!), the fact that they might waste a whole day with that is really beneficial to us, seems like a waste to kill him
 

Verelios

Were-elios
If Malus us the bug, though (or even if he's not!), the fact that they might waste a whole day with that is really beneficial to us, seems like a waste to kill him
Alao true. I have a feeling they'll try and push Malus to use his PR early tho.
 

karkador

Board Game King
Timeline could instead be:

We don't kill the Bug:

d3 - 11 - Fate
n3 - 11 - Wiz
d4 - 9 - Vere
n4 - ??
d5 - 7 - malus
n5- ??
d6 - 6 - malus
n6 - ??
d7 - 4 - Rover - (If they're still convinced I can't be scum, we win)
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Timeline could instead be:

We don't kill the Bug:

d3 - 11 - Fate
n3 - 11 - Wiz
d4 - 9 - Vere
n4 - ??
d5 - 7 - malus
n5- ??
d6 - 6 - malus
n6 - ??
d7 - 4 - Rover - (If they're still convinced I can't be scum, we win)
I'd say that's a good timeline. I'll try and force the thunderdome today.

How do you think peeps will respond to it?
 

Verelios

Were-elios
So bro, we got:
LP
Chuggs
Melon
Zipped
EC

Who do you want to kill most and second most?

I'm okay with all of them. LP would be a good way to move us toward the TD period.
 

karkador

Board Game King
We could kill LP to make Fate's flip look like something Gnosia is trying to protect.

The problem is that I'm 99% sure Wiz has saved a shot to save LP tonight.
 

karkador

Board Game King
The other people on the list just don't make a difference IMO.

Killing Wiz will throw you under the bus, intentionally, if you want to take the fall tomorrow. But that means the scumteam is You-Fate-Dark, or You-Fate-LP (claiming Dark was the real Doc) and we leave LP alive the whole game
 

Verelios

Were-elios
We could kill LP to make Fate's flip look like something Gnosia is trying to protect.

The problem is that I'm 99% sure Wiz has saved a shot to save LP tonight.
He doesn't need to. He has 3 shots T_T So if he saved one then he actually has 2 more.
 

karkador

Board Game King
I don't really see a need for LP to die this game. Like once he delivers that 2 Gnosia are down, Town has to switch gears to find the Bug. The sooner that happens the better, probably, with a wider pool of people to try
 

Verelios

Were-elios
>.> I suppose that's true. So you want to go Wizard tonight?

I'll be dead today so I can have some fun =D. What if town keep me alive to search for the bug and second gnosia tho?
 

karkador

Board Game King
Well maybe we do. In any case, no matter what, I think you have to go out first for them to see the Bug Clock is on
 

Verelios

Were-elios
It's the same gamble assuming Malus will take up 2 days. if he doesn't, i dont' think we make it
It's not when there are a lot of extenuating circumstances. If they find the bug quickly then we're dead very soon.

If we do kill the bug tonight, how confident are you about fighting through Zipped/Melon/EC?
 

karkador

Board Game King
To: malus

::Meow!::

Today's password is: "SEATBELTS - Cats on Mars"

Please report this message in day chat at your earliest convenience. I will be asking you for the password, so don't forget it. Otherwise, ::HISSSS::
 

karkador

Board Game King
I was floating both theories yesterday. like i said the only hole in the fate-as-gnosia theory is that LP's Remnan result shows him doing nothing D2. I guess you could argue that an activity check also bounces off of Nexus? Sounds like a question for Rando to not answer.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I was floating both theories yesterday. like i said the only hole in the fate-as-gnosia theory is that LP's Remnan result shows him doing nothing D2. I guess you could argue that an activity check also bounces off of Nexus? Sounds like a question for Rando to not answer.
Hmmm, true. Can't have us not keep up on the gnosia theory.
 

karkador

Board Game King
theyr'e gonna come running out of the gate today accusing me, so I gotta prepare for more quote notifications than i've ever gotten
 
Top Bottom