The Viewing Lounge

Welcome to the the Viewing Lounge, where you can view the stars, and view the stars (of the game).

Please be nice!
 
Yes there are a few very interesting combos. There's only really 1 combo that is a bit redundant but the role is interesting enough on its own that it's not a huge loss. I'm excited to see how things play out.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I would like to propose that this and all open setup games get rerun sometimes if only because this is very cool and I wanna play it sometime :(
 
Nobody is realizing that the Bug, AC Follower and non-Godfather scum players can just claim Vanilla as well. Picking from 10 vanillas to vote is better odds than 15 players, but then you tell scum who the PRs are lol.

I don't think this will go the way they expect.
 

Hedin

Oops, All Scum!
Staff member
If I was scum I would think about at least one of us claiming. Make them feel like they have to pick off PRs.
 

Hedin

Oops, All Scum!
Staff member
If I was scum I would think about at least one of us claiming. Make them feel like they have to pick off PRs.

Oooh they did it. I wondered if the Sparks thing would change their calculation...unless they said something before Sparks did....
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Not following super closely, but it's cool seeing the roster figure out how they want to handle an open design since we don't run those too often.

Also makes me want to try designing an open game too lol.
 

Hedin

Oops, All Scum!
Staff member
This is fascinating. I'm with Fanto in wanting to create another open game (I have one done but its very basic) but try to find ways where claiming could have the potential to backfire spectacularly.
 
I wanted spec just to see what people thought about this strat.

I've only been following casually, but they were talking about scum getting themselves caught up a bit. How bad is it for scum? Is the POE really that limited?
 
I don't believe the bucket strat would've worked, especially if Sparks didn't decide to throw the game, he could've punished town for that quite heavily.

As things stand it's looking bad for scum but

the Bug is *not* in the bucket
 
Have to take my hat off to you, Random, this looks like a really interesting game design.

+1 to people saying it should be run again and again to see what situations we end up with.
 

Hedin

Oops, All Scum!
Staff member
I don't believe the bucket strat would've worked, especially if Sparks didn't decide to throw the game, he could've punished town for that quite heavily.

As things stand it's looking bad for scum but

the Bug is *not* in the bucket

Yeah this would have been perfect for the AC, it could have been punished pretty hard.
 

Hedin

Oops, All Scum!
Staff member
that was so long ago that I hardly remembered!

It does bring to question if reviewers of an open setup could play in the game. In theory the reviewer would have thought about the setup a bit more and may have an advantage because of that but also like you said and like I thought when we went back to check things before it ran I didn't really remember everything.
 
Sorry random, I just couldn't get my head into the game and I thought it was better to replace out than just be a passenger.


The open setup through me a little to be honest then coming back to seeing all the claims I just felt this really weird disconnect where the game was moving on without me and I just couldn't keep up.
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
hello. I’ve put off coming into spec until now because I was scared to see what people were saying about the bucket claim strat

:laughing:

Rover said:
Anyway I'm crew. Also my PR
I gave in because I needed somewhere to scream into about this post where it looked like Rover had started typing a change in claim then changed his mind part way through the post about the strategy, but people only read the “I’m crew” part and took it at face value. Now Rover has just kind of rolled with it. Right or wrong, I wouldn’t have let that slide if I were still alive
:angry:
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Open setups can be REALLY cool and lead to some really neat strategic moves but I personally can't comment here 'cause I was traveling and I ain't reading all that lol. I will assume it was a great idea, Launch, and you singlehandedly set the tone for the entire game. Good job.
 

Hedin

Oops, All Scum!
Staff member
I think the bucket strat would work better in a setup like Among Us where scum didn't have access to scum chat during the day to coordinate how they were handling it. It will still work out here but they did have a chance to figure out how they wanted to react to it. Also the AC Follower should have been able to punish this a bit as well, town is spewing a lot information that would have been very useful on that front.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
at a glance I agree with Zipped here and it’s part of why I tend to be meh re: big claims. I’ve seen some interesting claims solving but forcing scum’s hand and working to obfuscate, especially in open games, usually yields great results.

I’d have to think about it here but quick agree.
 

HPSauce

Wait, I was right? Fuck
200w.gif
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
It's crazy how scum knows Vere is the real GA, but chooses to character block him instead of role blocking him. And he also just happens to be Stella, after they did the whole set up around HP yesterday. What a wild coincidence!

Chuggs said:
I'm not touching the GA's today. I get it's obvious to y'all but I'm going to kick that can down the road a bit because our real one still has shots left.

Going to focus on the crew. I really don't think it's Melon or EC and how last day phase played out didn't real change anything there. I kind of want to hit the bug here because that's going to be a pain in the ass down the line which will probably rule out Fate so I'm looking at a pool of Rover, Zipped, and Malus
However, yes, this is a good plan.
 

HPSauce

Wait, I was right? Fuck
It's crazy how scum knows Vere is the real GA, but chooses to character block him instead of role blocking him. And he also just happens to be Stella, after they did the whole set up around HP yesterday. What a wild coincidence!


However, yes, this is a good plan.
Yeah if they kinda just ignore how absurd this is I'm gonna be pissed
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
Interesting development with the messages and Fate potentially being the Bug. I didn't receive any messages the night I died, did I random?

:eyes:
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
I was feeling like Rover was town last day phase after he expanded on what he was thinking when he went into the town PR bucket. It felt misguided but genuine. The message stuff also feels legitimate. Which puts the crosshairs squarely on Fate here, who I think was doing a good job looking town throughout the game and probably would've (justifiably) skated through to the end had Rover not claimed the N1 message shenanigans with melon's clear. It was ultimately a good play by Rover if this ends up nabbing the bug.

Vere is very clearly scum at this point. Kudos to him for slotting in there and making himself look legitimate, but I think nin being so quiet, the CC, and Wiz being so active did some irreversible damage to the slot long before the very suspicious order of operations on HP's death and Vere's alleged blocking. It is never easy coming into that position and Vere seems to do it often and always makes the absolute best of it. There is probably a case to be made about gaining a certain skillset from slotting into that position so often, makes me want to go onto replacements more to get that experience lol

I think someone dropped a pretty accurate read of malus, it might've been Wiz, saying that malus is popping up just enough to stay relevant but not doing much else outside of that. I think he's probably the last scum.

Where I'm sitting right now, I think the breakdown is:

Town
Donnie
Chuggs
LP
Rover
Zipped
Wiz
EC
melon

Scum
Vere
malus

Bug
Fate
 

LaunchpadMcQ

...can I smell you?
How can Chuggs be town and Fate be the bug when the check said they both had the same role by melons check?
From what I’m understanding, the Bug using the nexus ability would’ve caused each individual night action to be redirected, so the message and parity check both would’ve been directed.

But I see Random has liked your post so maybe this play is a pure fabrication from Rover and no message was actually sent out on N1

:eyes:
 
From what I’m understanding, the Bug using the nexus ability would’ve caused each individual night action to be redirected, so the message and parity check both would’ve been directed.
That is how the Bug Nexus works, yes. To go further, the message and parity check would each be rng'd separately to find who they'd be actually sent to.

:donnieyes:
 

HPSauce

Wait, I was right? Fuck
I do want to say I found it very funny that people gave the two GAs shit for not trying to protect me on Night One and they both just avoided me again on Night Two
 
Top Bottom