Event Thread Volcano Island 2 Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
I feel alright with my Saw vote. I feel confident that she’s not the jester due to how she moved votes around on D1, so yeah.

I could be convinced to switch over to No Lynch if that’s what y’all want.
 
Random, if you’re the Jester, just tell us. I might let you leave with the item tbh

I’m fully in on that town-read.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Rip Nat, sorry.

And don't vote for me you dumb dumbs. Geez

I'm fine with a no vote to see where the kill lands. I agree it could out the jester (which is great) or at least make the field smaller for us to figure out.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
well

Vote: No Lynch

I think Rando is Town here unless that whole scum thing was performative. Chuggs is 100% back on the menu since he just went back to me with no issue and isnt looking elsewhere. For someone who was willing to think it out before thats some scummy shit. chain votes are zzzz

Brazil Im still thinking scum and no im not in a tunnel.

Fando im thinking is Jester for being anti-no lynch as it means he could be shot. Or he's scum and worried, but im leaning the former.

Fran could be scum as well for following on the Nat kill but to his credit, he did come in late there.

Neon should win if he is scum because imo this is impressive.
 
Feels a bit like cowardice, but alright. Let’s help Geno out with his sleeping schedule.

VOTE: No Lynch

Go, scum.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
im down with brazil/chuggs

if one of them isnt scum then i'd guess fran is the other.

thank god the jester is dead
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
You literally have to kill him to win
and again, why would i do that now? as long as he wasnt being voted on i could just let him stay and the threat of jester looms on everything.

like there's no benefit for me to kill him here. it's almost like im not scum :u
 

Franconp

Frank
I don't believe that is Neon.

Leaning to one scum between Chuggs and Saw.

Between Brazil and Rando leaning more on Rando.
 
I'm going to sleep, if you turbo when I'm gone send me the NK as well and I'll start the day when I wake up.
 
I don't believe that is Neon.

Leaning to one scum between Chuggs and Saw.

Between Brazil and Rando leaning more on Rando.
Rando is town.

I dislike things like this, but

Also remember that scum don't get a day chat, they only get a night chat, so looking for interactions between two scum on D1 will be harder than it will be today.
I don't think a player in our community would lie like this as scum.
 
Wow. Eventful day while I was gone.

Well, at least my read of Fando wasn't entirely wrong.

I'd go for Chuggs as he is the one on ly reads lists. But I'll vote Fran if you go that way. I'm somewhat tuckered out mentally right now.
 
Huh. I'm feeling fuzzy feelings with Saw backing off from me in the main game because of our little tangential adventure. Hmm...
 
bro if im scum why would i shoot fando who i thought was the jester? the better play for me is to let him live and make people second guess me lol. i would've gone for brazil or you
I dunno about this one. If I was scum I'd be 100% trying to off the jester with every opportunity.

Even if you had a hunch Fand was the jester, you didn't really know - which meant that you could've lynched someone else and, oops, jester flip, you just lost the game.

Fand flipping as the jester after you called it doesn't move the needle regarding you at all to me - it doesn't help my perception of you, nor does it hurt. But you trying to get some town points for the flip is a bit weird.
 

Franconp

Frank
What, why random?

Because I don't believe that Brazil would shot Fando.

I don't think a player in our community would lie like this as scum.

I forgot about that. So maybe it's just Saw and Chuggs then.

I may be exploiting the game but the lynch and the kills happened in only 4 minutes. So scum were around to make the kill. Neon wasn't posting before or after the kill. I don't believe it's him. The rest of you posted either before or almost after the kill.
 
At this point I Rando is the only person who I wouldn't vote.

Neon - Would make sense in a Saw/Neon pairing. And yet, when the leading trains were Saw/Neon/me on D1, they started a fourth train on Natiko instead... I think voting against me would be the easier move here.
Saw - Followed the Natiko train to save herself instead of voting for Neon. Natiko had 1 vote, against Neon's 2. Justified it by pointing at Neon putting in some effort.
Chuggs - Voted Natiko kinda outta nowhere after Saw because he didn't "think it's neeks or neon right now"
Fran - No clue. Finished the vote on Natiko, but at that point that lynch seemed like a foregone conclusion.

I guess I should be happy I trust one of you.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Wow. Eventful day while I was gone.

Well, at least my read of Fando wasn't entirely wrong.

I'd go for Chuggs as he is the one on ly reads lists. But I'll vote Fran if you go that way. I'm somewhat tuckered out mentally right now.
Fran feels like too much of a blindspot right now to get him first. I'd go Chuggs over him (whispers but brazil tho)
Huh. I'm feeling fuzzy feelings with Saw backing off from me in the main game because of our little tangential adventure. Hmm...
i dont know why people keep saying this. :x

im not doing more in the main thread yet since your actions here paint it and i cant exactly talk about them. but i would love to know why you keep ignoring me
 
I think for today my first vote would be Chuggs. Feeling a bit more charitable towards Saw, comparatively, even though those two seem like the most logical pairing.

Neon interests me as well, but the way they voted against Natiko on D1 instead of just piling on top of me doesn’t feel right for scum!Neon at that point.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Here I’ll give you this one for free because trying to keep up with three threads is exhausting and I don’t think I can talk myself out of this and I don’t feel like trying all that hard. Really wanted to try to play up being the jester damn you Fando lmao

Vote: Chuggs
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Here I’ll give you this one for free because trying to keep up with three threads is exhausting and I don’t think I can talk myself out of this and I don’t feel like trying all that hard. Really wanted to try to play up being the jester damn you Fando lmao

Vote: Chuggs
....

wait are you claiming scum?
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
uuuuhhh, ok? well that was....easy.

uh, do we want to turbo this or talk it out?

I dont think Chuggs' memes this as Town and hands the win to Scum like this even if he was teamed with someone from scum here in the main thread. It's too obvious. Handing in the towl kinda sucks though and is WIFOM-y bullshit that makes my head hurt.
 
Sorry you feel that way, Chuggs. But, well, haha.

Not to suggest chain-lynches, but I guess I’ll revisit possible pairings.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Sorry you feel that way, Chuggs. But, well, haha.

Not to suggest chain-lynches, but I guess I’ll revisit possible pairings.

Nah it's no big deal. I feel pretty good about a lot of the players in here at the moment as far as the actual game goes which has kind of sapped my motivation a bit. Best of luck, everyone
 
Nah it's no big deal. I feel pretty good about a lot of the players in here at the moment as far as the actual game goes which has kind of sapped my motivation a bit. Best of luck, everyone
Dream scenario: everyone remaining here is town.

(Reality: half scum, half cult, secret uber scum player that’s invisible to the naked eye)
 
Well. That was easy? I guess.

Now we just need to POE Chugg's scummate.

Sorry if I've been absent this day. Yesterday was killer and real life got in the way. Tomorrow is also going to be busy, but I'll try to be both here and in the other thread.

As for the other goon. I guess I'll have to go back and see Chugg's posts and interactions to see if I can pry something out.
 
Excluding Chuggs, we have:

Sawneeks
Brazil
Fran
Random

That's it. I agree with Brazil that Random can't be scum because of the mistake (a bit of a meta read, but w/e). And I'm willing to let Saw slide because of Chuggs continously trying to throw her under the bus.

Although thinking about it, Random's mistake could be performative. A little farfetched, but food for thought.

GIven that Chuggs was a scum player trying to play the Jester card, his plan was to be suspicious enough to remain voteless for the rest of the game. It is likely that the other scum member is lying low in order to avoid gathering attention to themselves.

Out of the remaining players, only Fran looks suspicious to me.

Yeah I think I agree with Fando here. Just really don't see jester doing this. Most likely scenario he just wiffs it anyway
This was in response to me feeling that Brazil was the jester. Now, as scum, Chuggs probably thought that Brazil was being jestery because fo the Kawl incident (knee jerk reaction) and was probably trying to steer off a possible Brazil train. This only makes sense if Brazil is not Chugg's scummate since we know that both of them had a chat from the beggining and thus, knew one another. If Brazil was scum, then Chuggs would have probably followed the "Brazil is jester and therefore we shouldn't vote fo him" line of reasoning.

Honestly, I'm feeling either Random or Fran.
 
Wait, does that still count or do I have to spell it like his username here. Does it count if it has the The and the space?
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Dream scenario: everyone remaining here is town.

(Reality: half scum, half cult, secret uber scum player that’s invisible to the naked eye)
It's in the back of my mind can't even lie lmfao

Wait, does that still count or do I have to spell it like his username here. Does it count if it has the The and the space?

Eh I doubt it's going to matter too much in here. Big reason why we have to be all "It has to be what's on the list" is because of the vote tool
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Excluding Chuggs, we have:

Sawneeks
Brazil
Fran
Random

That's it. I agree with Brazil that Random can't be scum because of the mistake (a bit of a meta read, but w/e). And I'm willing to let Saw slide because of Chuggs continously trying to throw her under the bus.

Although thinking about it, Random's mistake could be performative. A little farfetched, but food for thought.

GIven that Chuggs was a scum player trying to play the Jester card, his plan was to be suspicious enough to remain voteless for the rest of the game. It is likely that the other scum member is lying low in order to avoid gathering attention to themselves.

Out of the remaining players, only Fran looks suspicious to me.


This was in response to me feeling that Brazil was the jester. Now, as scum, Chuggs probably thought that Brazil was being jestery because fo the Kawl incident (knee jerk reaction) and was probably trying to steer off a possible Brazil train. This only makes sense if Brazil is not Chugg's scummate since we know that both of them had a chat from the beggining and thus, knew one another. If Brazil was scum, then Chuggs would have probably followed the "Brazil is jester and therefore we shouldn't vote fo him" line of reasoning.

Honestly, I'm feeling either Random or Fran.
i was thinking Fran too but chuggs did vote him first. it was a meme vote but given we all said we wouldn't be taking this suuuper seriously would he do that even as a joke? it could easily take off. or it was for distance?

or is it you and i had the wool pulled over my eyes to well?

blegh

not gonna vote so Rando and fran have a chance to check in. if they both do so and want to turbo, go for it.
 
Chuggs has died, he was scum.
Randomless died in the night, he was vanilla townie
Day 4 begins and ends in 12 hours
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Hrm. I think I'm in a Brazil tunnel because I still think it's him.

But I want to hear from Brazil and Fran first before making a vote given it's mylo
 
True. I forgot about that.

But there is no need to rush a turbo when we have the time ro discuss and plan.
 
Extremely concerned about Fran staying under the radar. Ugh...

Well, I might be free of responsibility in a few minutes anyway.
 

Franconp

Frank
Extremely concerned about Fran staying under the radar. Ugh...

Well, I might be free of responsibility in a few minutes anyway.

I'm just more interested in the main game than in this one.

As I said in the main game I won't be around for a while. Our best move is to no lynch and start 2-1 the next phase.
 
Well. What are you guys reads?

Even if it is a minigame i would like to think this through.

But on the other hand, I really have little time today, so either way, a quick end wouldn't be bad either.
 
I'm just more interested in the main game than in this one.

As I said in the main game I won't be around for a while. Our best move is to no lynch and start 2-1 the next phase.
The main game is too scary. 8 million people in there. This is my refuge.
 
Well. What are you guys reads?

Even if it is a minigame i would like to think this through.

But on the other hand, I really have little time today, so either way, a quick end wouldn't be bad either.
Not much to it, but I feel good about you. The wording in your ISOs, and some of the points you raised about Chuggs (like how they probably aren't paired with me, because otherwise he'd have hyped up the possibility that I was the jester) made me think like you were genuinely solving, and not just hedging as scum.

I'm cautious about Saw since the beginning, but Fran is creeping up on my thoughts. I can so easily see Chuggs overexerting himself in here because a partner Fran wasn't doing much, and then getting tired and bowing out the way he did. The nonchalant vote that sealed the deal against Natiko is the bow on top.
 
I was sure we were gonna get a no kill night after Geno’s instruction, lol. I always forget that’s a possibility.

I have thoughts, though.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Mobile ruined my joke so now I’m gonna just go sit in a corner and cry.

/backtodeathbeforemodkill
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I was sure we were gonna get a no kill night after Geno’s instruction, lol. I always forget that’s a possibility.

I have thoughts, though.
what are your thoughts? because i have 10 pages of the main thread to read and i have little energy for this lol
 
Given his activity, I unfortunately have no reason to look towards Fran other than paranoia. There's no case to build there. No interactions with Chuggs, nada.

Meanwhile, I'd already been suspicious of Saw, but looking back at the D1 vote, Chuggs packages it really neatly.

At some point near EoD, people were just throwing votes around. It wasn't consolidated at all. Zipped had a vote, Fand voted for Saw, Rando and I voted for Neon.

Then Chuggs threw a vote against Saw:

I think I'd rather go Sawneeks here. Feel like she tried to use the games action to push in the direction of a brazil vote and that's a very unjester thing to do.

Vote: Sawneeks

... Which was followed by Natiko voting against Saw as well, putting her in the lead.

Kinda not feeling a Zipped vote anymore. I could see Saw. Spicy take would be Rando, but ehh.

VOTE: Sawneeks

Neon then posted some reads, including a "vibe" town read of Saw... And Chuggs immediately backed down from his vote, before asking for more on Saw from Neon.

He regretted his vote so much he unvoted before getting more of an explanation from Neon.

Unvote

@Neon walk me through your town read on Neeks a bit. Is it just vibes?

god damnit i did not want to think about this game this hard

Okay yeah I see your point about the scum strat for neeks there being kind of short sighted. The one part that does give me pause is Neeks did seem to kind of throw in the towel which did give me kind of jester vibes, but we can't really do anything about that

Then Chuggs "accepted" Neon's reasoning and kept his vote off of Saw.

Vote: Natiko

Because I like what Neon is putting down and therefore trust him, this is a vote to save myself because I know I'm town, and people don't seem to want to follow me on Brazil for some reason. I have little against Nat but I think other players (like Fando) or more likely to be Jester than he is. Plus, he might actually be scum here lol.

Gnight folks. It's been fun.

i'm about to go to sleep and I don't think it's neeks or neon right now and i don't think i can get this to move one way or the other if I go for anyone else.

Vote: Natiko

if you're town i'm sorry

And in the end quickly followed Saw herself against Natiko, in the train that saved Saw that day.

Even the way Chuggs bowed out of the game with Saw opposite him in the thread fits into the picture. Knowing Chuggs, there's no way he'd throw the game before consulting with his teammate first - so they were in the thread at the same time, with Saw distancing herself from knowledge of the situation through apparent shock.

I'm confident voting against Saw.
 
I guess proper etiquette would be for me to wait for the others to position themselves before voting on LyLo, but I really don't see myself changing my mind here, and you both have literally said that you don't have the energy for this, so lol

Just a final ISO of Fran to be sure u.u
 
Yeah, there's nothing there lmao

If Fran is it, there's no convincing me that Saw isn't it, nor Saw that it isn't me.

Best wishes.

VOTE: Sawneeks
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
you realize chuggs just went right back to me the day after, right? what i thought was him taking a chance to solve the game and work it out with others was clearly performative to look townie and seem invested. he didnt care about a vote on me since he zoomed right back to it the first chance he got.

i know you wont believe me but I am Town and now knowing chuggs is scum it's clear he was just doing the song and dance to look townie.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Yeah, there's nothing there lmao

If Fran is it, there's no convincing me that Saw isn't it, nor Saw that it isn't me.

Best wishes.

VOTE: Sawneeks
im willing to work it out a bit lol. im just not doing a deep dive.

and if it's fran then gg to him since you're handing it to him
 
you realize chuggs just went right back to me the day after, right? what i thought was him taking a chance to solve the game and work it out with others was clearly performative to look townie and seem invested. he didnt care about a vote on me since he zoomed right back to it the first chance he got.

i know you wont believe me but I am Town and now knowing chuggs is scum it's clear he was just doing the song and dance to look townie.
He did, but then he did this:

I feel alright with my Saw vote. I feel confident that she’s not the jester due to how she moved votes around on D1, so yeah.

I could be convinced to switch over to No Lynch if that’s what y’all want.

Yeah that's kind of where I'm at too. Between Neeks and no kill
And promptly followed us into the No Lynch afterwards with no other word about you. Given the escape route, he took it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom