Game Thread Love Boat: The Spin-off |OT| We Bare Boats

The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
==== DAY 4 VOTES ====
Day Start

Yacht (2 votes)
Kayak - #1,277
Gondola - #1,480

Beluga Whale (1 votes)
Inflatable Boat - #1,477

Inflatable Boat (1 votes)
Beluga Whale - #1,499

Gondola (1 votes)
Yacht - #1,376

Not voting: Submarine, Lifeboat

Post Counts:
Submarine: 68 Inflatable Boat: 43 Beluga Whale: 35 Yacht: 33 Gondola: 21 Kayak: 16 Lifeboat: 15

Current Countdown:
voxbqreexx



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
And I would need to assess that after the flip or at least not chain vote. If we get scum we would get +1 day until mylo so we can be wrong in that case. If Kayak is town then we would need to switch up how we're going about scumhunting as there would be a deepwolf.
Click to expand...
What was all that then? I thought you were going to vote Kayak?
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Yacht said:
What was all that then? I thought you were going to vote Kayak?
Click to expand...
I would prefer Kayak, but I realized that in the chance the final 2 are Sub and Inflatable then we're boned. If Kayak flips town then scum must already be setting up a chain and Sub has been doing that with Kayak+me. If Kayak flips scum then Inflatable has already been sowing seeds for me+Kayak. Scum will likely target Lifeboat tonight, or Gondola if they're afraid of being seen moving.

Realistically, I feel the best chance for town is to vote me out today and then add Sub and Inflatable to the PoE tomorrow since my flip leaves them less wiggle room.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
I would prefer Kayak, but I realized that in the chance the final 2 are Sub and Inflatable then we're boned. If Kayak flips town then scum must already be setting up a chain and Sub has been doing that with Kayak+me. If Kayak flips scum then Inflatable has already been sowing seeds for me+Kayak. Scum will likely target Lifeboat tonight, or Gondola if they're afraid of being seen moving.

Realistically, I feel the best chance for town is to vote me out today and then add Sub and Inflatable to the PoE tomorrow since my flip leaves them less wiggle room.
Click to expand...

"If Kayak flips scum then Inflatable has already been sowing seeds for me+Kayak." Huh?
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
I would prefer Kayak, but I realized that in the chance the final 2 are Sub and Inflatable then we're boned. If Kayak flips town then scum must already be setting up a chain and Sub has been doing that with Kayak+me. If Kayak flips scum then Inflatable has already been sowing seeds for me+Kayak. Scum will likely target Lifeboat tonight, or Gondola if they're afraid of being seen moving.

Realistically, I feel the best chance for town is to vote me out today and then add Sub and Inflatable to the PoE tomorrow since my flip leaves them less wiggle room.
Click to expand...
I'm sorry but I don't understand the logic behind this. You prefer Kayak but some people are sowing seeds therefore you must vote Inflatable because if it's Inflatable and Sub we're screwed? I think it's very fair for players to theorize who the final 2 scum might be, there's no sowing seeds being done here.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Submarine said:
"If Kayak flips scum then Inflatable has already been sowing seeds for me+Kayak." Huh?
Click to expand...
Inflatable Boat said:
When you have a moment can you explain why Beluga/Kayak isn't a possible team? We noticed something about that pair and I'm curious for your take on it.
Click to expand...

Inflatable Boat said:
Here’s my Beluga reread that my partner and I agree on. And yes, this is the condensed version of the mess.
--

Day 1 Beluga stayed out of the Houseboat/Galleon/Duck arguments and only semi-involved themselves when asked directly. Even then the reads weren’t strong (NAI on Houseboat & Scumish on Sub) and changed shortly after.

They have 2 early reads list that are important for a few things:
Sub becomes a Townread
Dislikes Kayak’s HB vote and how the following Yacht vote was attached to Jet Ski’s vote
Houseboat is a slight scum read BUT the read ties Sub to them, suggesting Sub is a better vote first
Yacht is ‘hard to read’
NO reads on Galleon or Duck despite being central to Houseboat.

Beluga/Kayak get into a small ‘fight’ early on about how many Kayak(s) are responding so far - which Kayak gets defensive about while Beluga explains. At first I agreed with my partner this meant they were teamed - but later Beluga actions make me doubt that. Know that Beluga NEVER uses this or brings it up against/for Kayak.

HB’s Doc claim gets them to move their vote to Kayak. Despite never openly suggesting to vote out HB they always seem to qualify HB’s read in an odd, ‘this wont last’ sort of way. Almost like they knew it wouldn’t last/didn’t trust it. See:



Eventually they drop Kayak and go for Galleon. Note they never gave a read on Galleon up to this point. Again, I point out that their reason for town reading us and scum reading Galleon are the same.
Doesn’t seem to consider Yacht an option either despite them being an ‘unknown/hard to read’.
--

Day 2 Beluga was more active but it was mainly in regards to Cruise’s Counterclaim of Houseboat - a place that Scum can easily pick a side on and go in. Beluga is also notably active here (as they were in the Kayak ‘partners’ argument) which tells me they have the ability to go in depth back-and-forth on topics but chooses not to. The ones they do choose are either easy or not scum hunting related.

Of note is Beluga saying they would have preferred Kayak over Galleon/Us and Yacht goes from an 'unsure/no comment' to 'not scummy'. This is the second Kayak push in 2 Days - and it will be suddenly the last.
--

Day 3 Beluga comes in hot but with a noticeable lack of Kayak read/push. I’m paraphrasing here but these are the reads with post numbers (i know, i know, im sorry);



It’s odd that Kayak was Beluga’s big push Day 1 AND Day 2 to suddenly them…not being their vote choice for Day 3? They have a chance to go Kayak in these 2 posts but instead take from all of it….that they shouldn’t go for Sub.




And then end on Skiff - their ??? after being on Kayak for Days.
--

Today. My partner put it perfectly that Beluga is ‘slippery’ - they are vague and indecisive in easily defensible ways. I won’t quote everything but take a look at Beluga’s responses to my questions today when asked for groups or what they may do if X or Y flips Town. Lots of indecision, dancing around questions, not answering questions, etc. - they are being slippery and don’t want to be pinned down. I think it’s highly likely Beluga is Scum and knows they don’t have many avenues left to push misvotes and it’s why they didn’t want to theorize - it shows just how cornered they are. See their post where they finally spitballed with me. They end up saying it ‘must be you I guess’ and can’t come up with other working pairs to help solve the game.

Their teammate is more of a question. I’m very happy I did the Yacht reread because I’m firmly in the camp that they are Town. This leaves Sub, Kayak, ….and Gondola.
Sub with Beluga I struggle with because of their claims. I don’t think Scum has both. Possible, but unlikely. Beluga tying Sub to HB seems odd if Beluga is Scum.
Beluga and Gondola I would need to look into but I don’t have the time to today. Beluga has nothing notable with Gondola or against them. Entirely possible for a team.
Beluga and Kayak have problems as previously discussed: the two’s argument on which partner posted Day 1, Beluga & HB’s vote on Kayak (odd for 3 scums), etc. HOWEVER, my partner brought this up and I think it’s worth considering: HB’s big reads list/vote (which we believe was HB’s attempt to save themselves) nails down Kayak as scum but when another option presented itself (Galleon) they jumped ship immediately to it and claimed Kayak’s train to be ‘dead’. My partner believes this more than I do but they think Kayak was possibly a sacrificial Scum player to save HB - it explains Kayak’s odd HB vote, HB going after them and dropping them so fast, etc. If Beluga does flip Scum today I wouldn’t immediately go for Kayak tomorrow however, I’d still want to read over Gondola before making that decision.
Click to expand...
It means what I said. They're saying if Kayak flips scum then they'd want to chain to me.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Yacht said:
I'm sorry but I don't understand the logic behind this. You prefer Kayak but some people are sowing seeds therefore you must vote Inflatable because if it's Inflatable and Sub we're screwed? I think it's very fair for players to theorize who the final 2 scum might be, there's no sowing seeds being done here.
Click to expand...
We're at +1 to mylo and while I would like to be 100% sure of my Kayak read, I'm not. If they're town then we'll fond ourselves in a bad situation. I would rather err on the side of caution and most aren't thinking of the possibility of a Sub/Inflatable team. My vote out would do that.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
How did they throw their teammate under the bus?
Click to expand...

"They're saying if Kayak flips scum then they'd want to chain to me."
"If Kayak flips scum then Inflatable has already been sowing seeds for me+Kayak."

You are saying Inflatable is trying to throw their teammate under the bus to chain you. Why would they do that?
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
I just don't understand how people think Sub can be scum, this role is innocent child light. I mean I'll ask sorry from everyone if it does turn out they're scum but voting them out at this stage sounds like throwing the game.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Submarine said:
"They're saying if Kayak flips scum then they'd want to chain to me."
"If Kayak flips scum then Inflatable has already been sowing seeds for me+Kayak."

You are saying Inflatable is trying to throw their teammate under the bus to chain you. Why would they do that?
Click to expand...
It's a read on possibility. Sub and Inflatable are also possible, to which it's just FUD.

Anyway, I'm saying to vote me out today as the best option. I have my reasoning and I doubt they'll magically change minds today as seen by Yacht losing it; I just want people to remember what I said on flip.
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
Anyway, I'm saying to vote me out today as the best option. I have my reasoning and I doubt they'll magically change minds today as seen by Yacht losing it; I just want people to remember what I said on flip.
Click to expand...
First of all I didn't lose my mind or anything like that. Second you cannot be saying that voting you out is our best option unless you are not town, it's like saying us moving to mylo is our best bet at winning.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Yacht said:
First of all I didn't lose my mind or anything like that. Second you cannot be saying that voting you out is our best option unless you are not town, it's like saying us moving to mylo is our best bet at winning.
Click to expand...

Yep, its the same thing as self preserve votes, if you are town then what does your town flip do other than put scum closer to winning?
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Yacht said:
First of all I didn't lose my mind or anything like that. Second you cannot be saying that voting you out is our best option unless you are not town, it's like saying us moving to mylo is our best bet at winning.
Click to expand...
From my perspective if we move to mylo as we are now we're almost assured to lose, so yes it's our best option.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
It's possible, they were late to vote for HB despite scum reading them.
Click to expand...

It's really interesting that you didn't mention Inflatable all day until they made their post against you. Even then you're not putting together an argument, you're doing an OMGUS. You are completely reactive instead of being proactive in building a case, pretty much what a panicked caught scum would do.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Submarine said:
It's really interesting that you didn't mention Inflatable all day until they made their post against you. Even then you're not putting together an argument, you're doing an OMGUS. You are completely reactive instead of being proactive in building a case, pretty much what a panicked caught scum would do.
Click to expand...
Sub, there's no need to psychoanalyze this. From PoE, in my mind it can only be one of you three. I'm offering to be the vote today to get us to a good position. You can shade me if you want but it'll be ineffective as I'm offering what you want with your shade.
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
This is so hard.

I think today is Beluga Whale day. I just don't feel like they are town. And reading the whale mail stuff it comes off as weird. Why do you need to send your town reads. It feels in some way performative and manipulative.

Voted Skiff, voted Galleon. i thought they were suspect around the doctor claim too.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
I just want to tell town not to trip yourselves up and default to Kayak or Yacht tomorrow. For my partner, sorry for making the decision myself, but I thought this was the best for town.
 
Yacht

Yacht

Costume
I talked with my partner and they won't be around for EoD, and I'm 50/50, since I'm tied with Beluga in votes I'll vote there to avoid not being here and having to vote for self preservation.
Vote: Beluga Whale
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Yacht said:
I talked with my partner and they won't be around for EoD, and I'm 50/50, since I'm tied with Beluga in votes I'll vote there to avoid not being here and having to vote for self preservation.
Vote: Beluga Whale
Click to expand...

What? A self preservation vote? In this game? How dare you!

I'm just waiting for my partner to chime in, if they don't in a little bit I will vote but I want to give them a chance to at least catch up.
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
Yacht said:
Sub has been very consistent in being open about their thought process. Even little things like the italics to differentiate feel like a town strategy to me. And their read on Kayak, I really feel that is something the believe rather than something they are trying to force. The high strung emotions from end of day yesterday speak to that as well.

So if these two are town, where are scum? IMO they are sitting pretty on the sidelines not doing much. That's why I think the team is Gondola + Beluga. Both have played it very safe with their votes in a way that feels like they are more concerned with looking towny than being towny. They do not have the consistency of IB or sub and they don't have the willingness to get things wrong and throw out theories that Lifeboat showed.
Click to expand...
Sub Read - the "emotions" from yesterday are NAI at best. Also sub hasnt done anything. All this "openness" and they still want to push this slot.
What happened to Gon and Bel cant be teamed?

How have iBoat and Sub been consistent?
Which of their votes make it look like they were going for town cred?

Yacht said:
@Kayak what made you want us more than Sub going in to today? Was there something particular?
Click to expand...
I didnt want to bother with pushing the slot.
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
I think Gondola is okay and I'm fine town reading them. After their motion detecting claim, realistically they would be absolutely fucked if Kayak or Yacht had a PR that could move those days. Even if it were 2 shot, that would wreck their credibility.

There are only two situations I can see a scum Gondola doing that and they're both less likely to me than Gondola playing it straight.
Click to expand...
What if Gondola is a Scum motion detector?
One thing I've been wondering for a while: We have a cop; why do we also have a motion detector?
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
This half of the beluga whale would like to ask the assembled boats and boats-adjacent what you do / think when we flip Town. I agree with my partner that our flip is probably best today, as if we guess wrong today, we would get heat tomorrow and put us into mylo. I think Gondola idea is interesting, but the way they claimed leaves them too open to Kayak or Yacht being not-vanilla and counterclaiming, so I'm not so sure about that.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Lifeboat said:
What if Gondola is a Scum motion detector?
One thing I've been wondering for a while: We have a cop; why do we also have a motion detector?
Click to expand...
I'm unsure why scum would have a motion detector. But assuming Gondola is scum, their partner would be Yacht, Kayak or an undisclosed player right? They were really going after Yacht yesterday so it would be weird for them to be teamed. A gondola/Kayak team falls apart if Kayak is voted out and isn't vanilla. If scum Gondola actually motion detected Kayak and Yacht and they're town, who's their teammate? It comes back to Inflatable or Sub, to which might be difficult to parse.

Not that I believe the hypothetical is great, because all Gondola's claim did for me was clear some of Kayak and Yacht Wifom.
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
Submarine said:
Only a one shot cop is not much in the way of investigative roles.
Click to expand...
It's still basically two confirmed alignments. Also the messenger is basically a counter to the motion detector, but once it's in the open the md becomes a straight up mafia killer detector. Maybe I'm just overthinking it.
 
Lifeboat

Lifeboat

Costume
I guess all I'm saying is if we flip Beluga today and they are Town I'd be very skeptical if Gondola comes into the thread tomorrow with a positive motion result.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Lifeboat said:
I guess all I'm saying is if we flip Beluga today and they are Town I'd be very skeptical if Gondola comes into the thread tomorrow with a positive motion result.
Click to expand...
I don't think we would give Gondola much credit either way. If Beluga flips town (which I don't think is likely) a scum Gondola could also claim movement from a townie to try to setup a miselim.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
This half of the Beluga Whale will admit they had intrusive thoughts about hammering themselves, but they decided not to because it would be rude. We look forward to the Kayak Essay
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Submarine said:
Man, I tried to make it as obvious as I could without coming right out and saying it! Also makes me wonder if people were really reading anything from us the past day or so because I feel like I have a different tone of voice than my partner.
Click to expand...
I 100% believe this. I feel like I’m talking to the void because Kayak seems to be the only one responding to my posts and that’s mostly just to scum read and diss me like saying for example we did nothing all phase.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
I backed my partner on Beluga because they have been doing their own scum hunting and feel they are the strongest suspect, and because of Inflate’s excellent argument made last night.

besides Beluga was in my scum pool besides Kayak and Yacht.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
I also know kayak is going to pull some bullshit and get on my case for not voting him, but I literally said all day phase while I was committed to it, I was willing to hear other takes and that was part of why I didn’t vote especially with majority being 4
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Also did not appreciate Kayak implying my emotions are fake and it’s all an act.

not at all.

emotional manipulation is a tactic in mafia and i unfortunately except it as a thing, but I fucking hate it because I am so tired of my genuine and real emotions being invalidated and called fake.

I’ve been trying my best to contain my emotions to my partner chat this game because I want to be civil, but I can’t help but get upset about it.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Why the fuck do I play mafia if I put everything I can tears and all into presenting an argument and be called fake. Why do I play when people are just going to tell me my emotions aren’t real.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Submarine said:
Why the fuck do I play mafia if I put everything I can tears and all into presenting an argument and be called fake. Why do I play when people are just going to tell me my emotions aren’t real.
Click to expand...
This half of the beluga whale thinks you and your partner are both being genuine in your emotions and words/deeds, at least. <3
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
The fact they no one seems to ever read my posts or arguments including the ones I spent hours working on last day phase just further cements why I stopped making big iso posts in mafia oh every player.
 
Beluga Whale

Beluga Whale

Costume
Submarine said:
Why the fuck do I play mafia if I put everything I can tears and all into presenting an argument and be called fake. Why do I play when people are just going to tell me my emotions aren’t real.
Click to expand...
Mafia is a game of concealing and revealing emotion and intent through action and words. Your arguments and feelings can be genuine but I don't think Kayak's words were an attack against you personally.
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
Mafia is a game of concealing and revealing emotion and intent through action and words. Your arguments and feelings can be genuine but I don't think Kayak's words were an attack against you personally.
Click to expand...
I know. It’s just have had had people call my emotions an act in other mafia games so it’s pretty triggering for me.
 
Inflatable Boat

Inflatable Boat

Costume
I gotta vanish again for a short bit. I'll be placing my Beluga vote again when I get back so I don't accidentally forget getting swept up in work.
 
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
Submarine said:
Also did not appreciate Kayak implying my emotions are fake and it’s all an act.

not at all.

emotional manipulation is a tactic in mafia and i unfortunately except it as a thing, but I fucking hate it because I am so tired of my genuine and real emotions being invalidated and called fake.

I’ve been trying my best to contain my emotions to my partner chat this game because I want to be civil, but I can’t help but get upset about it.
Click to expand...

Submarine said:
Why the fuck do I play mafia if I put everything I can tears and all into presenting an argument and be called fake. Why do I play when people are just going to tell me my emotions aren’t real.
Click to expand...

giphy.gif
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Kayak said:
Sub Read - the "emotions" from yesterday are NAI at best. Also sub hasnt done anything. All this "openness" and they still want to push this slot.
What happened to Gon and Bel cant be teamed?

How have iBoat and Sub been consistent?
Which of their votes make it look like they were going for town cred?


I didnt want to bother with pushing the slot.
Click to expand...
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Okay clearly I need to step away. This half of the sub is going to switch to lurker mode and wait on Kayak’s big ole essay.
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Let me remind ya'll about game behavior rules again:

Game Behavior:
10. While mafia can be an intense and stressful game, with play becoming heated at times, please try to keep discussion as respectful and congenial as possible. Take a break if you feel heated. If someone is breaking a rule you are encouraged to alert your gamerunner and game watchers. Reports about in-game action and behavior will be handled by them, and the gamerunner will issue final rulings in the event of disagreements. If you need any support or assistance, reach out to a gamerunner or watcher.
11. Being overly hostile towards your fellow players is not allowed. If the gamerunner and game watchers find a player has been overly aggressive, action will be taken. First a private warning via PM will be given. Failure to stop the behavior will then result in another private warning and the offender will be given a priority penalty. If these behaviors still continue then that player will be removed from the game.
12. Treat players, gamerunners, and game watchers with respect. Players who are bothered by behavior they perceive as uncomfortable or as targeted aggression should make their positions clear in game as everyone has a different threshold. If a player feels someone has crossed a line they should contact the gamerunner and game watchers, listed in the first post, about the issue.

This is not aimed at any specfic player, but all of you. This will be my final warning as a gamerunner.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Kayak said:
Is you reading too much into things.


You should tell your partner to cool it then, not me. They were the ones that brought all that into the game thread. This is on top of them taking a shot earlier that I ignored.
Click to expand...
I am telling the correct person. You are the one bringing it up and dismissing what the pair was going through. I will not comment after this and let the mod staff handle it as they see fit but the bullying attempt is not what need in this community.
 
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
Submarine said:
As the other partner I am going to tell you that you need to cool it on this front.
Click to expand...
Hi, as also the other partner I’m going to say you can tell us anything you’d like, but short of a mod enforced violation for, I don’t know, telling another player to fuck off, there’s not much reason for us to be anything but exasperated with the treatment we’ve received at times. I’m sorry that you/your partner haven’t had a super awesome time the whole game. I guess if nothing else we can agree on that!

Now to actually catch up before day end, been busy. Thank you kayak buddy for holding it down.
 
Gondola

Gondola

Costume
Alright, I'm just coming back from dinner so I'm kind of around. The beluga vote is a better attempt than the kayak vote imo, I still don't think it's the best place we could look today but for where everyone is at, it's better on my PoE. In the most understanding way towards everyone, whatever has been going on above does not make the game super appealing to want to come and play and you all should hit up the gamerunner with any more issues.
 
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
Tldr: Scum moved to save Yacht D1. Yachts wagons seems to be pure.

Let's revisit Day 1 again.

This is the vote an hour and a half before eod.
15f5c94a3a7f154cf3d4dfcc42c3ae37.png


HB posts this right after that vote snapshot
Houseboat said:
Kayak being on Yacht makes me not want to join in there. I am staying put.
Click to expand...
Weird post since HB gave Yacht neutral read earlier, so no one expected HB to go to Yacht. Them staying put makes sense. I was one of their biggest scum reads.

Vote 35 minutes before eod D1
080c7a9f8a11eb1edeaa96d72953fa0a.png

Im town, we know Gal is town.

Everyone on yacht's vote is town. So where all the 3 other scum at votewise? We know one was on me.
If all 3 of these wagons are town, scum wouldnt care at all who goes. They should be content with whoever goes. So why does HB make it a point to move at all?

30 minutes before EoD
This vote opens the flood gates for the galleon wagon
Houseboat said:
Vote: Galleon

Kayak wagon is not taking off. I do not love Yacht but I actively dislike Kayak and Galleon so I prefer them as the vote.
Click to expand...

Bel follows:
Beluga Whale said:
Seems Kayak's train is dead now. Between Galleon and Yacht I'd vote for Galleon. The most I can say about Yacht is that I have no idea where their head is but they do keep poking.

Vote: Galleon
Click to expand...


Votes for Day eod
61412e934882cbaab9f9766f6766df1e.png

So once again with iBoat being heavily town read, yacht's wagon seems to be pure.



Day 2 - HB
Me asking them how they thought about Yacht Day 2.
Kayak said:
With the other wagon being town, how do you feel about Yacht now?
Click to expand...
Houseboat said:
The votes were very even and could have gone either way. If Inflatable had voted a few seconds earlier Yacht would be dead instead of Galleon. I find it likelier it was T/T than T/S, because I do not see why scum!Yacht would not have self-pressed. Leaving it up to chance would be a very risky scum play that could jeopardize the team. Both players behind the account would need to agree to the risky play, which is an even lower chance.

I am not ruling them out as scum. As I stated previously, I found their Day 1 to be pretty NAI. Scum have skated by on risky plays before. For the time being, I am content to let them try to prove their towniness while I look elsewhere. If they are still NAI or worse by day end, then I think it could be worth looking into voting them to clear up the Day 1 wagons.
Click to expand...

There is no reason to say that it was T/T last day phase, that's an easy layup for a misvote.


Ducks read of Yacht's reaciton to HB claim.
Giant Rubber Duck said:
i saw you trying to twist and see if you could puzzle piece the world where cruise ship is the list here

you likely realized that was never going to fly
Click to expand...

This post from Yacht Day 1 also reads like they trying to bait the real doc to claim
Yacht said:
Nah, how come when we're about to vote scum out it's always a doctor or a cop? Am I the only one that thinks it's a fake claim?
Click to expand...
 
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
I think Yacht is the better flip. Bel could still be mafia with them moving to Gal with HB, but flipping Yacht tells us more about that.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Gondola said:
Alright, I'm just coming back from dinner so I'm kind of around. The beluga vote is a better attempt than the kayak vote imo, I still don't think it's the best place we could look today but for where everyone is at, it's better on my PoE. In the most understanding way towards everyone, whatever has been going on above does not make the game super appealing to want to come and play and you all should hit up the gamerunner with any more issues.
Click to expand...
Believe me, I’m sure all 5 of us would avoid this if we could.

And for what it’s worth Kayak, I’m sorry my partner told you to fuck off last day phase. That was out of line.
 
Submarine

Submarine

Costume
Beluga Whale said:
Just to reiterate, beyond fuckery, the smartest vote tomorrow is Inflatable.
Click to expand...

Here's the thing that is making me feel like we caught you...you're not making any case and just willing to go down with the ship (sorry not sorry). If you are really town you would be fighting and putting up reads and an argument otherwise. Instead if you are town then you're giving up and putting town in yeetlo tomorrow.
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Kayak

Kayak

Costume
Submarine said:
I am telling the correct person. You are the one bringing it up and dismissing what the pair was going through. I will not comment after this and let the mod staff handle it as they see fit but the bullying attempt is not what need in this community.
Click to expand...
Stop with the bs. Aint not bullying going on from the boat.
Did you not read where Yacht said they are giving your slot townread because of the emotions? So not I didnt bring it up first. All I said was it was NAI at best.

Submarine said:
And for what it’s worth Kayak, I’m sorry my partner told you to fuck off last day phase. That was out of line.
Click to expand...
For what it's worth the emotions thing was dismissing anything. Was just me saying they NAI, since that was brought up in a read of your.
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
AdobeStock_194719879-scaled.jpeg

6720.jpg
Click to expand...

Beluga Whale has died!

Welcome to the Love Boat Spin-Off Mafia!

You and another anonymous player have invaded the body of a costume account Beluga Whale. You both will post in the game using this same account.

You are aligned with THE BOATS which means Town.

Your shared role is Postman. During the night phase you may send mail to another costume account with command YOU’VE GOT MAIL. The message has a max length of 10 000 characters, and you are not allowed to tell explicitly your identity (either who the postman’ costume account is nor who your real identities are) via the mail. You may only use words in your mail. Of course, profanities are not allowed as well.

If your shared costume account dies during the game, both of you leave the game in the process.

You do not know who the other player controlling the account is. But you both share the same alignment and role.

You may talk with the other player in the special Partner Chat during the game. You both must use the singular costume account to post in that chat.

You win the game, when all threats to THE BOATS have been defeated.

Costume account username: Beluga Whale
Costume account password: Removed

Please confirm that you have received this role PM by replying here.
Click to expand...

Night 4 Begins

Day 5 Begins in:
sq0n4kiwaw


Night actions lock in two hours before Day 5 Begins.
 
The Bear

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
raft-flip-fail.gif

giphy.gif


Inflatable Boat has died!

Welcome to the Love Boat Spin-Off Mafia!

You and another anonymous player have invaded the body of a costume account Inflatable Boat. You both will post in the game using this same account.

You are aligned with THE BOATS which means Town.

Your shared role is Vanilla Town. You have no special powers, but may vote.

If your shared costume account dies during the game, both of you leave the game in the process.

You do not know who the other player controlling the account is. But you both share the same alignment and role.

You may talk with the other player in the special Partner Chat during the game. You both must use the singular costume account to post in that chat.

You win the game, when all threats to THE BOATS have been defeated.

Costume account username: Inflatable Boat
Costume account password: Removed

Please confirm that you have received your role PM by replying here.
Click to expand...

Day 5 begins

Majority is 3

Day 5 Ends in:
bqwzph17pc


Still in the game:
[Any] Gondola - GMT
[Any] Kayak - GMT
[Any] Submarine - GMT
[Any] Yacht - GMT
[Any] Lifeboat - GMT
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom