Purely off of you starting D2 with a vote on them. Though I suppose yeah.....why would you vote on someone that you'd already poisoned unless you wanted to leave a crumb or something. So okay. Yeah, I should've thought about that more.
Relax, you aren’t confirmed town.
I'm leaving you alone for now so you might as well do the same. I'm tired of dunking on you and proving you wrong for a while.
We're about to flip town. If we don't, Oscar goes.
Ok, enough jokes. For real tho this is just speculation on my part of why Kermit claims. Easier answer is that Kermit is just scum that did a bad gambit. Or town player that wanted so hard to be useful that missed how the claim put them on a bad spot. Either way Kermit kinda has to go.
Either oscar or kermit for me, I think.
It ain't easy being green
There is 0 world where Kermit is scum only someone else is a poisoner and has purposely been keeping quiet.
It’s basically just the scum team and Bert, so all easily ignorable voices.
So you are saying there is a world since the only way Kermit would know someone is dying of poison without being the poisoner is if they have the same info, as in, the same team.
Kermit could easily just be a day vig and he is going to shoot Howdy, you won’t have any way of knowing it’s poison. Kermit is very clearly killing but there is a very convoluted world where he’s lying about being a poisoner.
We're gonna send you to the big rainbow in the sky
Seriously Fozzie you keep trying to impose your voice as the correct one and you keep being wrong. You voted for headdy, you were wrong, you wanted to let Piggy go, you were wrong. Always trying to steer the conversation to deadends.
In what world would Kermit claim poison when someone else claimed poison mirror to then just be a vig?
Headdy vote was pretty good, I liked that one.
Like a 2% chance. It’s very obviously unlikely which is why Kermit is never scum here. That’s been my point the whole time, you are the one trying to fit that square peg into the round hole. The worst Kermit is is neutral.
You said Shang was scum which was a horribly wrong assertion lol
I’m literally voting on a scum read right now, you reading the same thread? Or you going to keep riding Oscar’s coattails?
I said Shang wasn't solving because they already knew what the flip was going to be.
Shang was solving, she had investment in whatever her second win con was. She just knew she could manipulate you all easily into what she needed as well. You can re-read her yourself and see she didn’t guide you all into Dynamite until close to day end. Before that she had no interest in him.
explain
People are trying to say Oscar is crumbing an investigator with green checks on Charlie and Oscar. Oscar has not confirmed this in any way and I don’t fully buy it personally.
Lol then, Howdy isn't even close to confirmed.
Thankfully you are going to flip Howdy.
My guess is doctor protecting you last night which would suck but that’s what Howdy seems to be insinuating if he’s telling the truth.
I can hear the sadness in your voice.
As much as it goes against my wincon, I would love for you to be out of the game already, you are more of a detriment at this point
Only because I don't agree with you.
We can't be sure the poison will go through. What are we supposed to do until then, just wait?
People can talk, I’ve said my piece. I think Kutaro (sp?) is Piggy. I think Grogu is being opportunistic ready to jump on the bad vot Kermit or Oscar if Howdy isn’t town, Triumph is also in the scum wagon of trying to convince people it’s worth our time to consider Kermit. And as already said a billion times, Kermit is never scum here.
Didn't like their day 1 and a few small things I noticed made me think it's Grogu's alt.
That actually makes a lot of since considering how Grogu reacted after you claimed the target today.
OK I think that happened in the time I wrote this post.
I keed, I keed!
Solid defense.
If Kermit was off the table who would be your maybe scum vote?
Howdie always says how suspicious they are of Grogu, never cast a vote, not a single time. I'm thinking it's scum trying to distance themselves. Additionally in D1 Grogu and Howdie were'nt using a . to end a sentence, not uncommon but it piles up.
Since you at least seem more genuine than Grogu, I’m willing to give you more benefit of the doubt so I’ll say a couple things to this.
And bonus point 4
How would it be protective? If Kermit is town then scum has a way to kill an extra town by returning the poison. That just seems mean, it's like having a vigilante that can be killed back if they aim at the wrong scum, what would the point of giving a town player a kill be if they have an automatic counter?
Basic game design? It’s not really rocket science.
Basic game design is my argument too. It's overkill.
This assumes Kermit perfectly only hitting town. His first pick was solid imo so it’s not like he’s trying to hit town on purpose if he is neutral. So no, I still don’t think he needs to go.
Do you honestly TRULY believe he is 1 shot? If he is neutral then chances are he already hit a second target that will die tomorrow, and if we let him live today then he hits another target the next day. You don't seem worried at all about that.
I’ve considered this but
If this game has a lylo, Bert can’t be there. That would be crazy.
You make me laugh, how can you trust a D1 scum read? Come on now, how is poisoning a town member in town interest? You keep sounding so sure of yourself as if your reads are law but you keep being wrong. You were wrong about Piggy, you are going to be wrong about your howdy scum read on day 1 if howdy flips town, and who knows what else you'll be wrong about later.
Thanks, I don't really have strong feelings on Pinocchio or Kutaro and would probably have trouble telling them apart. Grogu has started pretty weak but did seem to be working through things with Piggy's claim yesterday.
You really want that Piggy credit when I landed on the vote all the same, I just actually pulled back to consider the information (that was true) first.
Mew has already abandoned me and said Howdy should have been in that spot, good try though, try to keep up.
That's 3 potential town kills+the scum kills +the votes. Who else would you rather get that would get us more info?
It could be a slip. Of course that wouldn't help you.
I don’t really need help. You’re the only one blind to what I am at this point lol I would apologize for knowing that Mew is clearly town but I’m not really sorry
It eliminates the risk of more poison killing townies. It's also wild to use poison on night 1 with so few knowledge. It's ballsy to use your only vig shot like that. What's more likely, Kermit is town or Kermit is something else? If you think it's more likely he is something else, then why wait until more corpses show up?
This is a legitimate question. If this were just a regular vanilla vig shot that was used N1, would you still be pearl clutching about it? It really feels that your issue is that it’s a poison.
Yes, a vig shot is something we can see faster. And the natural counter to a vig would be a BP vest or a veteran, maybe a hider. We know thow game haw a scum counter to the poisoner, so poison has to exist.
I highly doubt there are multiple scum factions, the game would have likely been graded differently.
Make a compelling argument for someone and I might follow you.
I mean I’m not really going to tread old ground.
I somewhat agree on Kutaro but I don't think that's piggy's alt, but Kutaro has been in my list for a while.
