Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
I believed your excuses though. This is why I try not to townread based on tone. I was completely ignoring my instincts there.Why the sudden change to Terra day 3. You got me there
I believed your excuses though. This is why I try not to townread based on tone. I was completely ignoring my instincts there.Why the sudden change to Terra day 3. You got me there
It's the right move in mylo$10 that Faddy will push for a No Lynch tomorrow
Who wants to take me
Learn tone then :PI believed your excuses though. This is why I try not to townread based on tone. I was completely ignoring my instincts there.
Oh, I thought town would have 3 left and was making a bad joke :>It's the right move in mylo
but he claimed vanilla I think?Well, I can say that I slept through an entire day phase now I guess?
Great job scum for going for grizzly instead of splinter. Operation kill all sane townies. Fep still didn't claim. Lord help town.
Oh, guess I didn't see it. I wonder why he held out so long if he was just vanilla?but he claimed vanilla I think?
Just after splinter's (first) fake claim
It's 5vs1 now ,right?
Zipped will likely kill Kalor. So town will be 4v1. They still have 2 mislynches. Town should win this.
Faddy will push for a no lynch.
I was so disappointed that noone called me out for that.This is great coming from totally Real Buffy Mason™ *Splinter
We didn't know that at the time :(TY WASN'T A FULL DOCTOR BREHURFIOHAUIDNFOIASNFOIAUJSF
Ty pls :p You're one of the strongest towns in MafiEra, and I can't comment on your scum game because I remember you as town even in the games you weren't.That turned into a town read ramble lol
I write a lot, but I'm not a particularly good player.
On a related note, I enjoyed seeing Brazil call town idiots for the first pages and then being completely wrong in the next pages :pSomething I've noticed a lot too is we get a lot of hindsight bias when it comes to Spec Thread commentating on games. There's been a lot of people, myself included, that say how easy Scum is to see from here when in reality we would just be as lost and confused in the main thread.
Just quoting this for Faddy.Switching tracks is something that helps me too.
I have an issue where a player can get all of my attention as I try to read them and it's pointless because I'm not getting anywhere. I try to solve that by looking elsewhere and just leaving that read on hold.
My stomach can't handle anymore crow from the Kalor tunnel.On a related note, I enjoyed seeing Brazil call town idiots for the first pages and then being completely wrong in the next pages :p
Does this happen here? In gamefaqs if all night actions come in early the day starts right away to not waste 24h.
Sometimes, it's up to the gamerunner I think.Does this happen here? In gamefaqs if all night actions come in early the day starts right away to not waste 24h.
no uTy pls :p You're one of the strongest towns in MafiEra, and I can't comment on your scum game because I remember you as town even in the games you weren't.
I miss a good tunnel tho ._.Just quoting this for Faddy.
Does this happen here? In gamefaqs if all night actions come in early the day starts right away to not waste 24h.
hmm, I wonder if anyone's able to deduce the presence of a ninja by the fact that Splinter wasn't killed.
I wonder if zipped would dare to be the one entertaining the ninja theory
*Nods*Really the smart move here is to almost just completely disregard everything Splinter says. He made 3 different claims on who he checked and Town really has no way to verify which is true or not so it's nearly pointless to make sense of it. Either you believe one of the two red checks and hammer those people or you believe the green check and don't hammer...
No Lynch isn't too bad either honestly. Narrow the pool down a bit to see who still lives.
Who would replace a true claim with a false one?Really the smart move here is to almost just completely disregard everything Splinter says. He made 3 different claims on who he checked and Town really has no way to verify which is true or not so it's nearly pointless to make sense of it. Either you believe one of the two red checks and hammer those people or you believe the green check and don't hammer...
No Lynch isn't too bad either honestly. Narrow the pool down a bit to see who still lives.
He's kinda in a precarious spot and the green check comment is arguably a scum slip.Zipped has done a good job of simply letting the town eat itself out. NK'ing me when he did was in retrospect a good move.
Didn't you want to lynch Faddy yesterday? :thinking:Faddy should be 100% trusted for the Terra lynch, that would make a no lynch pointless since he'll just die.
FEP is too far out therePlease feps, you're my only hope
Yeah that was dumb too.Didn't you want to lynch Faddy yesterday? :thinking:
I'd love to see a bigFaddy has two votes so at least this green checks OJ as he doesn't hammer
Hope they see the no lynch light
from himThis is me not voting!
Please feps, you're my only hope
How often does scum tunnel?Yeah that was dumb too.
I couldn't believe the tunnel he was in :(
He's as wrong as it's possible to be, and still my only hope.FEP is too far out there
If no lynch into faddy NK he'll go right on Oliver lol
y e sTown's only hope is that Oliver picks up on the fact that Zipped is so casually accepting this lynch. Classic scum move right there, but he might not see it.
yesy e s
Also: has ANYONE ever been right when, as town, they insist on the absolute certainty of something? I feel like this is how town's ass forever gets bitten XD
yes
those two games when Sophia was scum
nonoTwo games? I've only been scum in one game!
Who would replace a true claim with a false one?
It should be obvious that the only true claim - if any - is the one on Zipped. Hopefully they either decide they were all fake or consider scum counter roles, because otherwise we're boned.
nono
I nailed you in those games. I remember clear as day. I think it was your birthday or something in one of those games.
lie lie lie
just make your checks clear
Zipped has done a good job of simply letting the town eat itself out.
gambit for informationWhy would you lie about your checks though? Especially a Red Check? Town is always grasping for info so why fuel that fire with false info?
I feel like no lynch would be the best option for this town. Regardless if fep, oj or faddy die, someone will have their tunnel dead and can move on. I don't see them lynching scum this day phase ):
I'm not defending the fake red checks, that was bad playWhy would you lie about your checks though? Especially a Red Check? Town is always grasping for info so why fuel that fire with false info?
We have 4 players, 3 town 1 scum. This is mylo. If we mislynch, we lose. We can technically no lynch. Faddy will nk zipped and then try and discredit splinters check on him, using zippeds flip as a proof that splinter checked zipped last night instead of faddy.
gambit for information
not to die with a fake check, but put something out there and see if it trips scum or confirms town
I'm not defending the fake red checks, that was bad play
BUT
Faddy's reaction to his red check gave me another reason to townread him. His response wouldn't make sense for scum unless he guessed I was bluffing and that I'd retract it. It's the reason I withdrew it.
Same with feps, and he had even less reason to think I was bluffing since I did him first.
This post here hides literally the only hope town has:
Did anyone lolSplinter did you expect them to turn around and lynch you so fast? Reading your conclusions here it seems like you had more in mind to do before they murdered you.
If he doesn't see the light in this phase, then it's game over. Both FEP and Faddy are in full-on thunderdome mode against one another.Hm. Understandable.
Splinter did you expect them to turn around and lynch you so fast? Reading your conclusions here it seems like you had more in mind to do before they murdered you.
Help them OJ, you're their only hope.
None of it was really planned.Splinter did you expect them to turn around and lynch you so fast? Reading your conclusions here it seems like you had more in mind to do before they murdered you.
Technically speaking we need a night phase though lol
He might forget!Yeeeah uh no. :p
Exactly!He might forget!
And with all scum on the counterwagon lolReverting a 5 vs 1 is some accomplishment
https://www.resetera.com/threads/buck-bumble-mafia-lets-rock.22251/page-22#post-4703359
So what faddy did here is insinuating that Fire complained to the mods when Faddy was pushing for Fire, thus basically saying that Fire was misusing the rules as part of gameplaying strategy.
It's not ok to insinuate that kind of thing openly in the game thread. If you suspect a player is misusing the rules you should pm a mod and NOT do this.
And with all scum on the counterwagon lol
This is why you keep notes kids
Lol, that smarts. Yeah, should probably always do the nl in myloThis post here hides literally the only hope town has:
I would vote for the microwaved ice cream policy lynch
You're right, it's much more reasonable to believe that I had 5 checks in 4 nights. My two conflicting red checks on the last day totally solved the game. Turboing me when I couldn't possibly be scum and my claim was unclear was fantastic play. Etc. Etc.For me it is always the people on my vote, I don't think anyone even suggested doing anything else until Splinter fake solved the game.
And at that point who cares, we lynch Splinter, we lynch FEP and that is a win. FEP and Oliver read it as lynch Splinter, lynch me and win.
Once Splinter flips not trusting his checks is stupid. Constructing a narrative where Splinter is straight up spouting bullshit for no reason is pointless.
I lied to get my scumreads lynched. That's Mafia. Fuck off with these "sabotage" accusationsSplinter you are off the rails man.
You are trying to say it was obvious your checks were fake when it really wasn't.
Night 1: Oliver , Night 2: Kalor , Night 3: Zipped , Night 4: FEP then you switch to me and it just looks like you are taunting me as the final mafia. All 3 surviving town players believed it.
Your unwillingness to co-operate when most of my town reads are willing to lynch Terra, then you vote on me to put me 1 from Turbo and then vote off wagon and last second untie it is all shady as hell. I was a single vocal player who thought you were scummy, I was wrong. But there was no opportunity for anyone in town to correct that mistake because you put fake red checks into the game.
If the last phases were unplayable, then don't play. But don't lie and wreck the game for everyone else.
I lied to get my scumreads lynched. That's Mafia. Fuck off with these "sabotage" accusations
I do think the criticism is valid as it pertains to lynching Splinter. The vote swapping last second, the missed check, and finally throwing out so many checks could easily be seen as trying to sow confusion as a scum that expects to be lynched. That being said I also think Splinter has a valid point that the next phase featured town players primarily discussing all of his “checks” right before the lynch which literally could not all be true. That’s where town fell apart. Don’t get me wrong, I still think even if town had correctly surmised that all red checks were fake and only the green check is real it turns out any different. The ninja role really fucked you all. I just think there were some missteps by Splinter, but also by the remaining town the following day phase.Night 1: Oliver , Night 2: Kalor , Night 3: Zipped , Night 4: FEP then you switch to me and it just looks like you are taunting me as the final mafia. All 3 surviving town players believed it.
Your unwillingness to co-operate when most of my town reads are willing to lynch Terra, then you vote on me to put me 1 from Turbo and then vote off wagon and last second untie it is all shady as hell. I was a single vocal player who thought you were scummy, I was wrong. But there was no opportunity for anyone in town to correct that mistake because you put fake red checks into the game.