Pair Thread THE LOVE BOAT... OF INFLATABLE BOAT!

If you are a cop, checking Lifeboat makes a lot of sense. But what the hell are with these early claims. I would have held onto that still.
 
Unfortunately, this stupid nap left me with a headache so my thoughts aren't thinking very well now. Let's whittle our list down with the assumption the Duck claim is real, and Lifeboat isn't a godfather.

Inflatable Boat - Probably Town
Lifeboat - Town. Their super long back-and-forth with Beluga felt genuinely, and they refused to let the important of Cruise claiming even/odd go. Honestly, I followed their reasoning.
Giant Rubber Duck -
Town Cop
Gondola - Town
Submarine - Town, but I need to re-assess and make sure I still feel good here.
Yacht -
Their actions say town. My only concern with them at the moment has to do with how scum acted/played around Yacht. If there is a busser and an actor on the scum team, it's this one.
Beluga Whale -
Has felt town...? But people seem to be getting suspicious there.
Skiff -
Kayak -


I need to do a thorough look-over of Skiff and Kayak again with the new information we have now.
 
Ooof, hate those post-nap headaches. Hope you feel better soon.

Taking Duck and Lifeboat as Town leads me to roughly where you are as well on reads. Gondola feels like Town but they did have a late HB vote on D1. Sub was pretty anti-HB Day 1 despite feeling very Townie overall.

Beluga I also need to relook.

Skiff still feels too disorganized to be full scum. Maybe? but im not confident in it.

Kayak and Houseboat have a back and forth vote on Day 1 that gives me pause. Houseboat;s attempt to save themself ends with a Kayak vote - odd to do on a scummate. But Kayak's whole post and reads on Yacht/someone and then ending on a Houseboat vote could be a buss. Honestly, unsure there.
 
Better to ask now while we live.
Hrm. I feel better for now after seeing their day opener today. They read like they clearly checked Lifeboat. Though again, not hard to set this all up and act. I just wish the cop was someone else so that I felt a lot better about all of this. They were in my "I dunno" pile. But for now, I'm going to stick with they are town. The big ??? is if Lifeboat is Godfather. I spose we're all tabling for now.
 
Hrm. I feel better for now after seeing their day opener today. They read like they clearly checked Lifeboat. Though again, not hard to set this all up and act. I just wish the cop was someone else so that I felt a lot better about all of this. They were in my "I dunno" pile. But for now, I'm going to stick with they are town. The big ??? is if Lifeboat is Godfather. I spose we're all tabling for now.
Best we can do, really. This could be a Scum!Duck and Scum!Lifeboat hailmary to save themselves but I doubt it - Duck just feels too townie.

Lifeboat being the Godfather is my tunnel forever :p
 
They were on HB super early D1 (talk, reads, and vote) at a point when HB could've died down and moved on. I don't think a scummate does that tbh.
 
i have a spitball for you
in this game, we got 2 people that share the account and that alignment
so the 2 people would behave differently under stress
so hit me with a list
I wanna see where this goes because Skiff made it clear their partner was hardly around at all, so we weren't going to necessarily see 2 different versions of Skiff. At least not a ton of it.
 
high-weed.gif

What am I reading in there....
 
With that reread mostly done I think I'd be okay with a vote on either: Kayak, Sub, Skiff. Maaaaybe Skiff = Kayak > Sub

Yacht is just very consistent about their HB dislike in a way that doesnt feel fake. Gondola could be deep wolf but I still like most of their stuff - at least in comparison to someone like Sub. Beluga just feels like a good townie. It's true their D1 isnt the best and solving something post-counter claim is an easy position to take but it all feels earnest. I don't think it's them.

Kayak's seemingly fake reason for moving to HB to 'breake the tie' doesnt like up with them dropping it right after. But Hb did vote Kayak when they tried to make a big reads list and 'save themselves'. So....I dont know. Shade to seperate?

Sub acts Townie on the mini scale but in the grand scale it looks not great. Lot of 'vibes' posts about HB that are easy to fake as scum and feign innocence with later on.
 
Beluga with the mailman claim is fine since sub confirmed they got mail.

But why send mail to your town reads? Feels like you're trying to build some trust in people who could save you.
 
Starting my read while I sit here watching the battle unfold:

20230902-204645.jpg


Without having finished my re-read, I am almost 100% in alignment, but I might put Kayak a small small bit scummier than Skiff. Let's see how I come out on them when I finish.
 
I guess I don't see that as a defense considering we were minutes into the game and it was literally a joke.

Going back to your vote post:

The reason this stuck out to me so much is that everyone else was just fucking around with early joke votes, but yours straddles the line between joking (least fun flotation device) and serious (protecting players and sus votes). It reads to me as someone wanting to say something to justify their early vote and maybe plant a seed that can take that vote all the way to EoD by never letting off the "this player is kinda sus" train. Upon examination, and then questioning, I just find myself not agreeing at all that Houseboat seemed like they were protecting anyone or voting in a sus way, and so I instead find you to be the sus one for the way in which the vote came about and feeling like you were scraping for reasons to justify it.

Vote: Galleon

This reaction seems a little strong from Sub to defend Houseboat.
 
It doesn't come off as OMGUS for a teammate initially because it's a long, well-written post. Then I realize it's a long, not well-written jumble of weak reasoning.
 
We are so obviously town at this point that people going out of their way to say we're town is getting a bit of a side eye. You wantin town points or somethin?
 
Hoh boy. Re-reading stuff around the Lifeboat 2-shot shenanigans. I'm not even sure what Kayak is responding to fully here, but:
To show what type of doc they are. Even/aOdd or X shot.
So when the slip happened how did everyone else think Lifeboat would know Houseboat is X shot and the number of shots?
My eye immediately locked onto Even/Odd mention here since Houseboat later full claimed to be an Odd 3-shot doctor. I don't see mention of Odd/Even shot anything in this game up until this post. Did Kayak pick it up from scum chat fine-tuning Houseboat claim, and it naturally came out here?
 
I'm here and about doing housework. I'll drop a vote for us if needed so no pressure if you're busy. If you are busy and pop in, just lemme know and I'll take the reigns for the remainder of today and you go enjoy your Sunday :)
 
Beluga's "being stressed and nervous" posts are tripping some minor alarms....
Just going back, this is what I had D1 pre- fake claim. Tbh, Kayak's pre-occupation with Submarine is kind of making me doubt myself there since they should know it would be a hard sell. Gondola's reasoning that HB went for Galleon because it was easier helps, but I'm also always going to have a nagging feeling in the back of my head that my initial gut feeling was right, and Houseboat just fumbled a fake poke of their partner. On the other hand, WIFOM, I keep drawing back to HB skipping over Kayak, and Kayak voting for Yacht and thinking if there's something there.

I kind of wish we had more time because this is stressing me out.
Then I said I was going to vote Kayak and quickly:
Hmmm. No, that's crazy. I don't think I'll be going Sub today.
Possibly Beluga scum setting up nervous energy to vote Sub, then saw it had no chance with my post and held steady?
 
I'm so sorry, a couple of things popped up and kept me away from the game. Only skimmed so far but I agree 100% with everything you did.

Do what you gotta do and take a breather. Skiff self-voting is a big bummer but them dying over Kayak feels like a big deal, especially that Yacht vote.

<3
 
Starting my read while I sit here watching the battle unfold:

20230902-204645.jpg


Without having finished my re-read, I am almost 100% in alignment, but I might put Kayak a small small bit scummier than Skiff. Let's see how I come out on them when I finish.
also - these look incredible. The tanks look incredible and Angron is perfect.
 
I'm going to catch up and read stuff tonight despite it being the night phase. i have a feeling Duck is dead and we arent so it's worth the risk.
 
Wait a second. Beluga said they used their messenger on top town reads to see if people got switched over the night.

Why didn't they use it on the claimed doc n1? Or the counterclaim doc n2?

Is Beluga lying??
 
If Beluga is lying then the messages are either neutral tags (have x players alive with your messages) or they are bombs.

If Beluga is a liar then I would expect the former and not the latter. Because with all of these claims out it doesn't seem very strong or have a way to prevent those explosions.
 
All right. I gotta check out of here for the day. It just riles me up all over again that Skiff seemingly decided they didn't want to play anymore and shit on our game. Sooo frustrated, and I don't get frustrated easily.
Yeah go take a breather! No rush on anything here today. Do what you gotta do <3
 
Skiff (5 votes)
Submarine - #982 #1,040
Skiff - #1,223
Beluga Whale - #1,239
Gondola - #1,245
Kayak - #1,248
Yacht - #1,256
nintendo-reggie.gif


Reading this over fully makes this vote even more bizarre. Skiff starts with a self vote for crying out loud and everyone jumps on without acknowledging it? The only one who does is Beluga who hedges their bets.

I want reasons from everyone there as to wtf this happened lol. They are not all scum so town made that mistake. If kayak is scum it made an interesting stack though.

But reading over the day I must say I'm not sure kayak is scum. I did find it interesting they went for Sub and not us for scum reading them though. Sub's outburst and jumpiness is noted too - as the Celebrity or whatever proves nothing. Skiff push could've been to save them?

I do think one of the claims is lying though. Beluga could be neutral but I'm still ride or die on Lifeboat being scum.

I'm mostly interested in Yacht here. Wtf was that. Yacht was originally voting Gondola and then went with Gondola on Skiff??
 
My plans today got changed again ( ugh ) so I won't have time to look into this today like I wanted. If we're alive next phase I can dive in a ton on Tuesday
 
Gondola claims Motion Detector:
N1 Kayak - nothing
N2 Lifeboat - movement
N3 Yacht - nothing

N2 lines up with Duck checking them at least. Not sure what to make of Kayak and Yacht not moving though.
 
Alright let me try to parse this mess;

Still in the game:
[Any] Gondola - GMT(3-shot motion detector)
[Any] Inflatable Boat - GMT (Vanilla)
[Any] Kayak - GMT - (Vanilla)
[Any] Submarine - GMT (Superstar)
[Any] Yacht - GMT (Vanilla)
[Any] Lifeboat - GMT (Ghost/Green Check)
[Any] Beluga Whale - GMT (Messenger)

I agree with Lifeboat (sort of Sub) that's it likely these players in a combo (Kayak, Beluga, Sub, Yacht);
Sub and Yacht
Kayak & Yacht is possible.
Beluga & Yacht?
Kayak and Beluga - Day 1 HB and Beluga both being on Kayak right after eachother? All 3 on a team? Unlikely.
Sub & Kayak - would have to be a Hell of a bus from Kayak & Sub the last Day Phase. They went for each other and have yet to stop.
Beluga & Sub are NOT possible in my head because I dont think Scum has Mailman/Superstar. It's one or the other, not both.

Problems here (as im researching and writing):
Kayak was voted on by HB AND Beluga on Day 1. Kayak voted back on HB, but in a post where they didn't make a case on them. Could be mutual attempt to seperate, but why would HB & Beluga both do that back-to-back? And then both Beluga/HB move on to Galleon at the same time?
If anything, this move by HB & Beluga seems to put me to believing it's HB & Beluga & Yacht. D1 Yacht is off on Skiff (to not have the whole team on Galleon?), while HB & Beluga are on Galleon. It lines up with the latter two dancing around Yacht's vote.

Sub I keep returning to 'I like them' in my brain despite their actual actions/votes not aligning with Town. Could easily just be incorrect Town but...man, I dont know.
Beluga I keep doubting why they did the actions they picked. They ignored the Docs and went for people who would more likely live - which they essentially have said in thread. Could just be Town not sure what to do with the Role but I honestly don't get why they don't at least try to give it to Cruise N2 (when they tought of switch confirming).

But I don't think Scum has both Superstar/Mailman. Mailman makes more sense as a Town role to confound the Town Motion Detector - whereas Scum having a Superstar is a fun way to add in a Scum Role with a 'confirmable action' like Mailman but without the alignment clear. Scum Mailman with a compulsory need to send Mail is still possible, I guess - it still confounds the Motion Detector.

This leaves me with 3 possible combos;
Sub & Yacht
Kayak & Yacht
Beluga & Yacht

And that means a Yacht kill for today.

Thoughts, partner?
 
I've typed up a paragraph to backspace it all. Tried another....deleted it all. I dunno. I'm fried, and I think we're dead end of today when scum comes a knocking.

I'm trying to find something to grab onto. My PoE yesterday brought me to Kayak, Skiff, and Submarine. I think I need to re-read to see if I would expand it out.
 
Yeah, I think we're dead tonight unless Scum really doesn't want a Confirmed Town there tomorrow with Lifeboat.

I think it's Beluga and Yacht. :x
 
Kayak and Beluga dont work because HB & Beluga both went Kayak D1. Doesn't make sense for a team.

Beluga is really hesitant today to say it's Yacht and wants to focus soley on Sub and Kayak. They aren't giving alternatives if they are wrong there.

Therefore Beluga & Yacht are the only ones to make sense.

Maybe Sub & Yacht but idk, i havent looked much at that interaction.
 
I woud like to heavily re-evaluate the possibility of Beluga and Kayak.
I definitely want your take on that one. To me it doesn't make sense given the D1 votes I showed in the thread. Why move away from Goon HB to ??? Scum!Kayak with Scum!Beluga? I cant make sense of it from a scum POV when Town!Yacht was a viable alternative in that scenario.
 
Right now, I just can't see it as Yacht. So it has to be Kayak, Beluga, or Sub.

I'm going through to find the posts/vote shifting you're talking about.
 
You're not going to like this answer as I might muddy the waters, but I think there could be a billion reasons.

If Houseboat and their partner are active and both around, and I'm (1) struggling in a costumer game as Kayak stated and (2) my teammate isn't around as they also mentioned D1, I'd take the sacrifice. "Bus my ass." At the end of it, one of them comes out looking good. The fact we're in a position where we're struggling as hard as we are is itself a sign that if they are scum together and planned to bus, it worked since it's thrown our radars off.
 
Right now, I just can't see it as Yacht. So it has to be Kayak, Beluga, or Sub.

I'm going through to find the posts/vote shifting you're talking about.
We've got 2 scum boats left so it has to be an 'and' with all of these. The only thing left is Gondola being crazy Deep Wolf or Lifeboat really is a Godfather. The last 2 gotta be somewhere here.

I just, idk. Maybe you are right and Kayak struggling means they were gonna be thrown to the fire - but with Houseboat on the block it seems so, so risky to trade them off. Not impossible, just crazy risk.

Maybe we're all wrong and it's Gondola and Sub lmao
 
I completely misread Submarine after Houseboat's slip about their prepared statement. They're all over the damn place. They say:
It's so aggressively scummy that I literally cannot in good faith believe that a Scum player would post that in the game thread lmao.
But then post a breakdown of everything and end it by saying they think it's just a slip...? Then they tell us they'll take the egg on their face if Hboat flips scum. Just...all over the damn place.
 
We've got 2 scum boats left so it has to be an 'and' with all of these. The only thing left is Gondola being crazy Deep Wolf or Lifeboat really is a Godfather. The last 2 gotta be somewhere here.

I just, idk. Maybe you are right and Kayak struggling means they were gonna be thrown to the fire - but with Houseboat on the block it seems so, so risky to trade them off. Not impossible, just crazy risk.

Maybe we're all wrong and it's Gondola and Sub lmao
Yeah, when I say "or" I just mean it's two of those three. I feel 100% confident it is not Gondola.
 
I just, idk. Maybe you are right and Kayak struggling means they were gonna be thrown to the fire - but with Houseboat on the block it seems so, so risky to trade them off. Not impossible, just crazy risk.
And it's tough because we all play very differently. I only give that read of the situation because if I were scum Kayak with Houseboat, I would 100% be telling them to go hardo n me and take me out even if D1. To me, a win is a win even if there is 1 scum left at the end. I'm immediately thinking, "who of us has the best chance to survive to the end? How do we further cement that?" The last game I played as scum we won and I owe a big part of that to a teammate who was open and ready for us to bus early, and we did and rode it home (with a few other helpful things too, of course!)

It means more work for us scum hunting, looking for inconsistences, and looking for people genuinely putting in work. I've still got a lot of re-reading to do, but I have a vague feeling that Beluga hasn't been doing a ton of actual scum hunting. They've had a lot of back-and-forth, lots of questions and answers like with Lifeboat on why our doc shouldn't reveal Even/Odd, but outside of fluff and stuff, how much have they truly hunted? That's what I aim to uncover, and maybe when I'm done with re-read I'll have decided there was lots of good work put in.
 
One more quick comment about Sub. How do you say how scummy that slip is, then hit reverse so hard as to then put Houseboat in a "Would not Vote" list?


Would not vote today:
Jet Ski
Cruise Ship
Skiff
Gondola
Inflatable
Houseboat
Duck


So what does that leave me with?
Beluga
Lifeboat
Galleon
Yacht
Kayak


Yeah, that sounds about right. Still think Galleon hasn't done anything more than those others to make them not vote worthy today, kind of surprised how little attention they seem to be getting from anyone but me.

My vote will def change if no one else is going there today, but I'm not giving up yet lol.
It is one thing to say you think they slipped, but WOULD NOT VOTE? That's a bit too damn much.
 
A couple of thoughts. If a name isn't here that means I'm okay or neutral with them currently but not necessarily townreading.

Inflatable boat
Weird feelings here. They're consistent with not liking Houseboat and want to vote them, that doesn't change although the reasoning grows. HB seems like their primary concern most of the day. They do show an inquisitiveness to ask questions such as to Lifeboat and Cruise Ship but doesn't seem to follow through afterwards. Mentions half of them liking Sub but follows up in post #410 and #423 with some minor and joking shade. It's not enough to vote them today but I would certainly keep an eye on their vote history and read list.

Kayak
A little easier to read since it's apparently one person atm posting. Don't like that reasoning for their HB vote. It was early in the game and didn't need a qualifier of voting to make things interesting. No one is going to jump to vote because of it 12 hours into the game, it didn't need a justification so it feels like Kayak was being unnecessarily careful here. Their later Yacht vote was consistent with their initial read but they did so attached to Jet Ski's read and vote of Yacht, so I'm unsure of if they were confident in the read or needed a push. A slight scum read.

Yacht
I've read through Yacht and have a hard time knowing what they're going for. There's a lot of outreach but little introspection. I am curious when they said they had a quick read on people they haven't mentioned and didn't say anything about Inflatable despite referencing them. I think the difference is that they've talked to and about other players but we don't know what they think of them.

Houseboat
A lot of points have been said about HB but I don't know what to think here. Their initial pushback against Submarine being townread started with Giant Rubber Duck's post in #168 and then continued until they claimed the pair's opinion was split afterwards. I think not liking early town reads is an acceptable stance, but It was a strange stance and one that has me looking over towards Sub tbh, because if they were linked HBs initial reaction and then their confused retraction would make a lot of sense. They don't rock the boat (...) afterwards so it seems like they're being careful about what they post. Slight scum read.

Skiff
Not much there and I think their insistence on LB having 4 potential votes and therefore scum reads is kind of silly this early (Logically, it would be 3 at most since one pair is written as T/S). Kind of a wildcard. I won't be voting here today but would like to see something more from them.

Inflatable Boat: "They're picking on Houseboat!" (Weird Feelings = vague statement that leaves Beluga open to read us scum or town later) (We have a vote on Houseboat at this time)
Kayak: "They're picking on Houseboat!" (Kayak has a vote on Yacht at this time)
Yacht: "Lemme throw some shade on Inflatable indirectly through my read on Yacht." (Yacht has a vote on Houseboat at this time) (Hard time knowing what they're going for = vague statement that leaves beluga open to read as scum or town later)
Houseboat: "I don't know what to think here other than I think them not liking Sub being town read makes me think Sub might be scum. Also, lean scum here."
Skiff: "They're silly." (Skiff has a vote on Lifeboat at this time)

I'm not going to condemn Beluga for D1, but so far they've offered a lot of shit stirring and "I dunno" with a bunch of words.
 
Galleon is wise and sees the tides coming to them already:
We're 2 away from majority on Housboat btw.

Not sure what to make of them tbh. The posts confusing the timeline do seem to be quite damning on a reread. Why not come forward with the clarification on their own if they knew it would be a source of confusion?

Also this post feels strangely doomerish:
A damning accusation in a pairs game, but in fact, that was not the Mate speaking.

Multiple pairs said I was unclear so I posted with more clarity.

If game votes us out, please see to the people who switched slowly to being sus of Houseboat but desperately tried to revert to us. This doesn’t really include submarine since they’ve just been anti Bosun all game, but I’m not convinced they’re town either, lots of words doesn’t equal towniness. Not that I’ve reread/evaluated them, I focused on getting participation from less vocal accounts for day one, removing highly active players is not usually a good move.

Whale I have not iso’d so they’re a nonread currently, but I don’t off the top of my head remember their views like I can with other pairs.
I don't feel like there is a general sentiment against them but they seem to be convinced that if HB isn't voted out it's going to be them.
I agree that @Galleon's fear seems premature but I'm curious to know who they believe slowly switched from HB to them.
Weird that Beluga, one of two people Galleon specifically cites as someone who they have no read on, hops on Lifeboat's post to agree that Galleon is being doomy.
 
Who is town in this list? Beluga, Inflatable. We know that the read on us is a pocket. Beluga has their vote on Submarine at this time. What really throws me off is that Sub does call the prepared statement so scummy it has to be scum, but from there on out is kind of backing away from it, right...? I'm re-reading Sub on this page.

I do not know what my partner is doing currently. Their behaviour has not been particularly out of character for them as town, though I know that is harder to get across in costume. I cannot do much about getting nailed to the wall for things I have not said, so I am just going to try to do my own thing.


Submarine is very much projecting big time town now. Large reads lists, many interactions with different players. I will not worry about them unless they are still alive late game, or if their activity suddenly drops off on later days.


Beluga seems town thus far. They are posting reads, asking questions, and following up. Cannot ask for much more on Day 1. Also Beluga Whales are cute.


I like Inflatable Boat’s engagement style thus far. They are asking a lot of questions to different players. Scum can certainly ask a lot of questions too, but I personally find Inflatable’s questions are pertinent and poignant. I would find quotes but I am really running out of time here, sorry.


I liked that Galleon was active early and trying to make connections, no matter how trivial, but I do not love how Galleon has double, triple, and quadruple downed on voting and pushing for me despite the initial vote being seemingly a joke. They have used very strong language that invokes a greater severity than reality, such as “slimy”, and “super scummy”. They have stretched the truth to make their point:

Where did they get that from? Here is the post they were quoting for reference:

At most you can say it was a 50/50 based on the wording. Or, even better, they could have simply asked me. Instead they immediately jumped in and used this as fuel for their argument.

I do think it is scummy to dive deeply into a tunnel on Day 1, when little is known. It is easy to focus most of your attention on one player, with some asides about others, and look as though you are busy.



Additionally, this is such a weird post. They had 1 vote on them as of this time, why are they worried about getting voted out?

I do think Galleon is scummy and I am willing to vote for them.


I am still not liking Kayak despite the increased volume in their posts.

I do not like this boohoo this is so hard woe is me post:

Yes, it is hard for all of us. We have not done a game like this in this community before. This feels an excuse for other behaviour, perhaps to come, that they can lean on later.

Their vote on me felt opportunistic as my wagon was just taking off, even though this post:

Seems to be leaning more towards a vote towards Yacht than myself, but then votes me anyway. Also says Yacht is more interesting and also voting me is more interesting in the same post, so which was it? I appreciate they later changed their vote to Yacht, but only after being called out by Lifeboat in #372.

I do not like this interaction with Gondola. Why are they being antagonistic towards someone trying to get town to work together? You can say that Gondola is saying nice platitudes that anyone regardless of alignment could say, but why attack them for it? And then act dismissive about it later in response?


This reads to me as a very “twitter waffles” type reaction.
E3jKMXkWQAM3Hfd.png

Gondola’s post did not mention ignoring scum, but rather finding town. Yet ignoring scum is what Kayak got out of it.

I feel Kayak is scummy. I would also vote there.


Jet Ski has been mostly pleasant and around just often enough to be seen, but I have not seen a particularly town mindset from them thus far. They have been floating along and not making waves. I would say NAI so far but will keep an eye on there for later.


People do have to work, you know. I thought we were trying not to do this as a community anymore.


I believe Gondola has been mostly townie. They have been friendly and positive, asking questions and making reads. Obviously I do not like their vote, but it has more thought behind it than Galleon or Kayak’s votes for myself. I believe I may know who is behind one half of the Gondola, and if I am correct I do not really want to vote them Day 1 purely on principle. Unless of course they are making a total fool of themselves, which they are currently not.


Anybody who I have not mentioned here or previously is NAI to me.


I will vote Kayak now, as I can see at a stretch how Galleon could possibly still be overconfident, deeply tunneled town, whereas with Kayak I cannot find anything particularly town about them. Obviously I am not in a great position here so I am more than willing to self-pres and change my vote. I will not vote for my town reads.

Vote: Kayak


I would still like to ISO Yacht and Cruise Ship because I remember a few points about them in my head but it is not clear enough. However, I am running out of time here. I vaguely liked Cruise Ship and found Yacht to just be around.
 
When you get a chance, can you re-read:

Post 433
Following up on this post:

Ok, looking at Gondola's ISO reminded me who they were lol, not a blank spot in my mind. I don't think I'd vote there on D1, I want to hear more of what they have to say when they're around again.


Looking over Kayak, I think the second voice may have just started posting, but other than that, they aren't pinging me in a bad way at all, posts feel "pure" as they like to say, lean Townish.

Beluga Whale has def been commenting and present in a way I like, but I think I see Inflatable's point about them in that they really haven't rocked the boat with their opinions at all, and their vote seems to be up in the air still with no hint of a direction other than #265 where they say Galleon seems sus. There's a lot of "this or that just seems NAI to me" and some Town reads given, but I'm not sure who they think is sus at all.

@Inflatable Boat thoughts on the above about Beluga?
Nothing huge. Just curious if you are able to spot a difference in Kayak's posting. Kayak doesn't confirm until 463 that their partner is around. So does something in Kayak's posting before 433 stand out to you? If you say, "Nothing at all." Then I put on tinfoil and say Sub knew Kayak partner showed up because of scum chat.

Post 443
Kayak
A little easier to read since it's apparently one person atm posting. Don't like that reasoning for their HB vote. It was early in the game and didn't need a qualifier of voting to make things interesting. No one is going to jump to vote because of it 12 hours into the game, it didn't need a justification so it feels like Kayak was being unnecessarily careful here. Their later Yacht vote was consistent with their initial read but they did so attached to Jet Ski's read and vote of Yacht, so I'm unsure of if they were confident in the read or needed a push. A slight scum read.
Post 463
And you would be wrong, but guessing trying to see if it's one person posting or two shouldnt matter.



Wasnt antagonistic at all and idk why you are trying to frame it that way. I also didnt mention anything about ignoring scum. I wasnt dismissive, from Gon's response I could tell the discussion would go into a place that leads nowhere, so decided to nip it in the bud.

Beluga followed up on this with Kayak questioning if they read it wrong that they were by themselves:
Did I interpret this wrong?

It sounded like one partner hadn't posted in here until this point, so everything before was one person.
And Kayak's responses are kind of weird and defensive. Honestly, the votes didn't make me think they weren't paired so much as their back-and-forth bickering on this point that seemed to bleed into other points.
 
To continue from above, Post 378:
I’d have to check again, but I don’t think my partner has posted at all in here. I’ll also freely admit that it only dawned on me shortly ago that my new post notifications and from what point “my” reading would be continued from in a thread would be impacted by the other, so, uh, I kinda ghosted them for half a day in our chat and honestly can’t be sure I didn’t miss some posts in this thread lol I made the neutral post because orange is just mild red in case that joke totally whiffed.
Very odd to not be aware if your partner is chatting, to ghost the thread, all that jazz. And then to have others mention this, and for Kayak to respond like they did. It's odd.

I'm back to saying that yes, Belug and Kayak are definitely not aligned. And if I don't think Yacht is scum.....Kayak and Sub? I dunno. I have to pause for the night on my re-read. About to come up to the Houseboat doc claim.
 
Wait. Why did I forget Beluga. Lol. Beluga and Kayak def not aligned. Both are still in my overall pile, but the Whale suspicions are growing.
 
When you get a chance, can you re-read:

Post 433

Nothing huge. Just curious if you are able to spot a difference in Kayak's posting. Kayak doesn't confirm until 463 that their partner is around. So does something in Kayak's posting before 433 stand out to you? If you say, "Nothing at all." Then I put on tinfoil and say Sub knew Kayak partner showed up because of scum chat.

Post 443

Post 463


Beluga followed up on this with Kayak questioning if they read it wrong that they were by themselves:

And Kayak's responses are kind of weird and defensive. Honestly, the votes didn't make me think they weren't paired so much as their back-and-forth bickering on this point that seemed to bleed into other points.
Honestly yes I can see someone thinking it is two different kayaks. You have a post the page before about them being unsure of what to do in a costume game to a big reads post and vote. It's not until a post shortly after that they clarify their HB vote isn't on strong foundations but it wasn't a vote due to pressure - they just wanted to put a spotlight on one of the two trains. I would read that as two people if I wasn't paying 100% attention - one who voted and one who was unsure.
 
And it's tough because we all play very differently. I only give that read of the situation because if I were scum Kayak with Houseboat, I would 100% be telling them to go hardo n me and take me out even if D1. To me, a win is a win even if there is 1 scum left at the end. I'm immediately thinking, "who of us has the best chance to survive to the end? How do we further cement that?" The last game I played as scum we won and I owe a big part of that to a teammate who was open and ready for us to bus early, and we did and rode it home (with a few other helpful things too, of course!)

It means more work for us scum hunting, looking for inconsistences, and looking for people genuinely putting in work. I've still got a lot of re-reading to do, but I have a vague feeling that Beluga hasn't been doing a ton of actual scum hunting. They've had a lot of back-and-forth, lots of questions and answers like with Lifeboat on why our doc shouldn't reveal Even/Odd, but outside of fluff and stuff, how much have they truly hunted? That's what I aim to uncover, and maybe when I'm done with re-read I'll have decided there was lots of good work put in.
This is really good to know though, thank you. I'm still used to a scum meta where bussing is bad so knowing about this helps lol. Grats on the win btw.

Then kayak wouldn't be impossible as scum here. It's just who they are teamed with.
 
Why not those two? Just so I have it straight in my head.
Go up two my post 259 in here where Beluga gives a read on Kayak and mentions it being one person. Then follow it into mainy thread. Read only Beluga and Kayak's back and forth leading from that. It goes all the way to bottom of page and feels very genuine, snippy, and unteam-like. Could be performative, but I think it's genuine bickering between people not scum aligned.
 
Kayak could be town, but good lord, the entire last page is just them throwing shade at people's reads whilst providing nothing back in return.
 
At the same time I understand their frustration and confusion at Beluga/Yacht just not giving more names and teams. It's baffling me that Beluga just refuses to do it.
 
At the same time I understand their frustration and confusion at Beluga/Yacht just not giving more names and teams. It's baffling me that Beluga just refuses to do it.
I agree, but Kayak has gotta lead by example.

Beluga is definitely on my radar. All the quotes and posts from above start to stack up....I still don't like the end of previous day when Beluga was stressed. I called it out here in realtime. Post 227 of mine in here.
 
I agree, but Kayak has gotta lead by example.

Beluga is definitely on my radar. All the quotes and posts from above start to stack up....I still don't like the end of previous day when Beluga was stressed. I called it out here in realtime. Post 227 of mine in here.
They have when I asked them. They still want Yacht as per last Day and find Sub to be very sketchy. I agree Kayak has done more questioning/defense of themself than hunting but part of me cant blame them seeing as so many are just accepting them as the kill.

and if we want to get a little meta-y, Sub taking a nap right after Cruise counterclaimed read like frustrated scum who had to step away seeing the plan implode.
 
Do you think we are over-complicating this by trying to solve for the pair?
Possibly lol. But I think it helps figure out the best vote for today too. If we can whittle down pairs and see whose flip would give the most clarity i think it would help us.
That sub outburst felt purty genuine.
Yeah. I was going to say the same with Yacht forgetting about the Cop check - which I dont think Scum does lol.
 
But it still has to be one of Yacht OR Kayak since it can't be Beluga/Sub.

SO if it's not Sub (outburst) then I'd say Beluga.

Kayak's flip would give us insight into Sub. Town!Kayak means maybe on Sub, Scum!Kayak means Sub is Town.
If we go for Beluga who does that reveal to us?
Same with Yacht? I think Yacht's would clear up D1.
 
I am good with narrowing our options to Beluga and Yacht and heavily scrutinizing those two today. I need to finish my reads after work to see if Beluga continues to be slippery and vague.
 
I am good with narrowing our options to Beluga and Yacht and heavily scrutinizing those two today. I need to finish my reads after work to see if Beluga continues to be slippery and vague.
I'm fine with this as well. If I have time I'll look over both.

My gut reaction is to say Yacht - they were possibly dead D1 so if they are Scum we could gleam more from their votes. Beluga, while I scumread moreso over time, has not been under fire so we'd have to look at what they did vs what others did to them.
 
Still paranoid that Kayak is the first in the entire game to bring up Odd/Even shot doc, which Houseboat then goes on to claim:
To show what type of doc they are. Even/Odd or X shot.
So when the slip happened how did everyone else think Lifeboat would know Houseboat is X shot and the number of shots?
Were scum prepping for when the counter-claim comes?
 
I've gotta go make supper. I'll be very eager to hear your thoughts on Beluga when you finish.
Just finished and now I need to sort my thoughts. Something that did pop out was how Beluga goes Kayak D1 and then just drops that entire thing for the rest of the game. They never bring them up again or focus there, it's odd.

but let me get myself composed lol.
 
My Google Doc for mafia notes just grew 4 pages from Beluga notes alone :thisisfine:

Day 1

Beluga stays out of the early Houseboat/Galleon kerfuffle and doesn't involve themselves in it, the only time they do is by direct questions and it's scumreading-ish Sub and giving an NAI to HB. They then post 2 reads lists (i think from 2 different people) and give Sub, Gondola, and Lifeboat Townreads in one with the other being more indepth:
443 - Second Reads List
Inflatable Boat - Keep an eye on. VERY focused on HB.
Kayak - Doesn’t like how careful they were with their HB vote, and how the Yacht vote was attached to Jet Ski’s vote. Slight Scum.
Yacht - Unsure. Hard time reading.
Houseboat - Doesn’t like HB being careful about what they post but does so by pointing at Sub being tied to them and Sub's vote as Beluga's likely target. Slight Scum.
Skiff - Wont vote there but wants more. WIldcard.
“If a name isn't here that means I'm okay or neutral with them currently but not necessarily townreading.”
Aka Galleon, Sub, Lifeboat, Duck, Gondola, etc

Beluga/Kayak back and forth happens here and it is a weird thing. I agree to a point it means they are likely not teamed but Beluga's later actions make that way harder to figure out. I think this does show that Beluga is willing to have back-and-forth discussions and just isn't doing it - which is notable, since they still havent covered Galleon/Duck despite Houseboat being a big deal.

Their vote was still on Sub from the joke phase at this point. After HB's Doc claim they eventually move it to Kayak of all people - but not mentioning the partner thing as a reason. They never floated the idea of voting out HB despite slightly scumreading them (and tying them to Sub) BUT, despite that, every time they bring up HB they say it in an odd way that suggests they don't believe the claim:

504 - “If I were to believe HB's claim then my vote is going to be between Kayak and Inflatable. They both were scum reading HB but Inflatable's insistence is more odd if knowing HB will flip town. Seeing as Kayak is in contention I'll go there for now.

Vote: Kayak”
“Reading back, I can see a scum Galleon if HB is town. They seem to just really dislike HB and instead of having a reason it's like the reason follows the intention of voting for HB. I'd say that Galleon's HB read is like a more disorganized Inflatable.” - 554

Eventually drops Kayak, goes Galleon with HB. Again, noteable considering that they never talked about Galleon until the post above. Doesn't even seem to consider Yacht an option.

--

D2 was more active but also heavily tied to Cruise's counterclaim. I like their questions (especially asking Lifeboat about his scum methodology post) but this can be an easy place for scum to blend in considering Houseboat was Dead the second Cruise claimed. Taking the anti-Houseboat stance would've been easy for any Scum.

Of note is Beluga saying they would have prefered Kayak over Galleon/Us and Yacht goes from an 'unsure/no comment' to 'not scummy'. This is the second Kayak push in 2 Days - and it will be suddenly the last.

--

D3 comes in hot with reads. Note the suspicious lack of Kayak in that.
894 - “Lifeboat is scum for sure. RIP Cruise Ship. Gondola/Inflatable feel town. Coming around on Duck. Yacht seems Townie. Sub seems good despite D1. Skiff is ???” Oddly no comment on Kayak.

899 - “If Lifeboat is town then yeah, I would say Yacht gets more scrutiny.”

908 - “Their[Yacht’s] reaction to HB day 1 and 2 seems fine to me. It could be a deliberate bus on HB but I haven't thought about that yet or went back to iso. This is my first impression. When I say good, I mean I'm neutral on them now.”

When asked about their Mail targets:
1120 - “One of the reasons was to see if they were redirected. The other was that we felt they were towny and wanted to.”
Again, note the They. Beluga was absolutely trying to say they wanted to switch-check for N1 and N2.

Again a huge opening for Beluga to go Kayak here but just...doesn't. Instead they say they 'won't go for Sub' and ends on Skiff. They even say later they would have preferred a Skiff/Kayak trains instead of Sub/Kayak despite seeming to consider Sub as suspect.
1139 - “I just read through Houseboat's D1 and they are weird there. First they say that Kayak is low hanging fruit and they don't want to vote there, only to switch over and forget what they said, scum reading them hard. After their claim they drop Kayak for Galleon despite it being 1 vote apart, but doesn't want to go for Yacht because Kayak is voting there (a strange reason given they scum read Galleon before and didn't need to say that...almost like it was a fake reads list lol). From my PoV that seemed like it could be distancing.”

“Just going back, this is what I had D1 pre- fake claim. Tbh, Kayak's pre-occupation with Submarine is kind of making me doubt myself there since they should know it would be a hard sell. Gondola's reasoning that HB went for Galleon because it was easier helps, but I'm also always going to have a nagging feeling in the back of my head that my initial gut feeling was right, and Houseboat just fumbled a fake poke of their partner. On the other hand, WIFOM, I keep drawing back to HB skipping over Kayak, and Kayak voting for Yacht and thinking if there's something there.

I kind of wish we had more time because this is stressing me out.”

--

And today. It's taking A LOT to get them to name people they scumread or even suggest teams. See this hesitation (in spoilers, god this post is long);
I see.

How is it hindsight? We only ommitted the name N2 from our message to Submarine because we realized it would be useful if there was redirection. Did you think Cruise was going to survive the night?

It was unfortunate for a lot of reasons. It looks bad because Skiff flipped town, but if they flipped scum then it wouldn't be an issue. It's hypocritical of me to scum read people for going there but I do feel worse about the train. As for Kayak, I'm thinking after that Gondola reveal that it's 50/50 for me. If we believe it then Kayak didn't move N1 and Yacht didn't move N3.

Town has a doctor and 1-shot cop. Do we think scum has a goon and what? Godfather? With a 1 shot cop it's unlikely. They're both not moving? Maybe there's a ninja since there's a motion detector. If there's a ninja then I would start looking at the vanillas.

I just mean to say that it further increases the likelihood that a Superstar role could be on the scum team
I think a kayak or yacht flip today will reveal more one way or the other

I'm getting confused. Are you saying that it's hindsight that I said Cruise seemed certain to die and not HB after the fact? You realize I'm saying this post flip right?

If there's scum on the wagon I would say Kayak has the greatest chance.

This half of the beluga whale would, ideally, like to see another scum flip today to help narrow down possible options for the last baddie power-wise; I agree with my other half about Kayak being scummy, but after that the waters get a little murky for me, and so some clarity via role flip would help me determine if the Superstar would be scum or not

I think that's a fair argument. My reasoning is that a Superstar is a very strong mechanic, and especially since we know Town has quite a few good roles by this point (infinite doc, 1 shot cop in a game that appears to not have any switchers (nobody has claimed switcher at the very least), motion detector (claimed) ) I would not put it past a given gamerunner to include a role name confirm for the baddy team to help give them a bit of an edge in that regard, depending on when the Superstar claims. It could have drawn a doctor protect or the cop shot, in theory.

I can see where this is coming from in PoE. Why are Sub and Yacht connected?

It's very likely that there's scum in this group. I just want to put forward that if we go through with this group today, not to chain vote but re-assess. Today is the last 'free' day I would say, since if we misvote, tomorrow is mylo.

If you want to justify it, with Kayak going for self-preservation the worst vote there would be Yacht. So I could say that's the answer, but I've already mentioned today that I don't believe Yacht is scum with the information we have.

You have to remember that you're talking to two people. I can answer some of your questions but I don't want to misrepresent my partner in others. And I have been hesitant today; I came into today thinking Kayak->Sub was a sure thing from PoE but the claim from Gondola is making me hesitate. I sent as much in our message last night. In my mind it still comes down to them but I'm less sure on Kayak being scum now. So I'm mainly going to let my partner prevail here because I'm lost other than who I don't want to vote today.

And I would need to assess that after the flip or at least not chain vote. If we get scum we would get +1 day until mylo so we can be wrong in that case. If Kayak is town then we would need to switch up how we're going about scumhunting as there would be a deepwolf.

On who you could be teamed with? I don't know, I could scratch in and cross out posts and reads but I would rather not atm because I can only take 3-4 min at a time at work and I want to be sure of the flip first.

On who else could be scum, I've talked about that.
 
ALL THAT IS TO SAY

What townie things Beluga has done could be faked by Scum. D2's involvement was post-counterclaim of the Doc. That's easy for Scum to hide in. They also havent really hunted in any sense - the one time they seemed so into it was Lifeboat and that fizzled out.
They danced around HB Day 1 and didn't give reads on that entire situation despite showing they COULD have done so (see; Kayak's partner kerfuffle, Doc counterclaim, etc.).
They also hesitate to give a direction/reads for today.

Weirdly seems very into Kayak as scum but just drops it completely with no reason given. Floating Scum!Sub for a few days with no backing. Yacht suddenly becomes 'townie' at one point despite no real interaction there either. Goes to Skiff in a very oppertunistic manner despite Kayak having being their D1 and D2 focus.

I can see a Scum!Beluga. IF Beluga is Scum then it being Kayak could fit - despite the weird 'partner' argument that both don't push on. Yacht could also be possible here though as Beluga suddenly Town Reads them.

brain hurt. i still have yacht. ow
 
getting through yacht now and im coming out of this shockingly positive on them. this in particular feels so earnest and from two different players that its hard for me to read them as scum figuring out how to react in scum chat.

Not really.

I don't want to drag this down and I think we have enough to work with so fuck it:

Houseboat is not the doctor. I am.

Lifeboat very likely did a slip and posted the fake claim discussed in scum chat here.

I know that people wanted to wait some more for the counterclaim but I think we have a good lead.

Fucking called it btw.

stephen-colbert-popcorn.gif

We were just discussing HB and Cruise right before this and leaning scum on both lol. Gonna see if that counter checks out, gut says HB has more smoke around them.
 
Yeah. You're hitting the shit that makes me really struggle to see Yacht as scum. Their D1 around Houseboat's prepared statement, along with what you have above, is so genuine to me.
 
I'm still curious what you think of Beluga's "nervous" energy end of yesterday. Do you think that was genuine, or setting up smoke for when they get called out on a bad vote?
 
Yeah. You're hitting the shit that makes me really struggle to see Yacht as scum. Their D1 around Houseboat's prepared statement, along with what you have above, is so genuine to me.
im in the middle of Day 3 with Yacht and if they are Scum, hats off. This all reads so Townie to me. The worst I can say about them is being so on top of HB it could be a bus for points but....it just reads too genuine. Plus they are hunting and searching even around that + after it.

I'll still finish the read but I don't think it's Yacht. I think you're right on that read.

re; Beluga energy let me look. I believe Kayak was an almost vote there? Could be nervous Beluga not wanting their buddy dead so soon.
 
Yeah, no, I dont even feel the need to do a big Yacht post. If they are Scum they deserve the win imo. Firmly Town in my book.

Leaves us Sub/Beluga/Kayak. Maybe we should consider Gondola?
 
Yeah, no, I dont even feel the need to do a big Yacht post. If they are Scum they deserve the win imo. Firmly Town in my book.

Leaves us Sub/Beluga/Kayak. Maybe we should consider Gondola?
Awesome possum. I'm glad you landed there because when you posted that scummate pairing, it threw my world for a loop. That's why I was wondering if looking for the pair was going to cause more of a headache because things were so confusing. lol.

I think it's fair to consider Gondola. So let's look at our pile...

Lifeboat - Green Checked Town
Us - Town
Yacht - Town

Sub
Beluga
Kayak
Gondola
 
Gonna head home soon, have dinner, and relax with some games. we should probably try to come to a conclusion soon though. Work for me is hit-or-miss so idk if I'm around at Day End tomorrow, dont know about you.
 
Top Bottom