Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

[melonrabbit]

@Fireblend hi sensei, I'm so happy to finally have a chance to play with you! But you are an enigma to me though so I can't justify trusting just like that, I hope you understand that.

Anyhow, are that many people seriously considering a No lynch? We didn't do it in HvV and it was advertised to be crazier than this game! From my experience (as small as it may be) lynches provides us with valuable information that will help us sooner or later.

I remember in Buffy votes helped me find two scums and I just can't justify not doing it, I'm sorry to cut someone's else fun on d1 but we just can't afford not having informations.

Also I found it funny that Stuart was the one who first mentioned it and yet seems to free surf it as if nothing happened.

Stuart, do you seriously believe that scums aren't gonna take advantage of the no lynch? Like seriously?

Vote: Stuart444

Hellos <3

Welcome to the ultimate struggle: The undercurrent of players that just wanting more fodder on D2 vs common sense.

I feel it comes down to the fact they don't want to be trapped in Sorian's game alone. Everyone must suffer.

 

[Terraforce]

Melon and Terra’s spat has just enough indignation in it for me to buy that it’s bare minimum not fabricated between scum.

It simply wouldn't be a mafia game if I didn't get into at least one argument with someone day one. Usually it ends up being town v town, but we shall see.

 

[melonrabbit]

Melon and Terra’s spat has just enough indignation in it for me to buy that it’s bare minimum not fabricated between scum.

I have never bussed a scummate and I certainly won't begin to now.

 

[melonrabbit]

Next time we post in the main thread, let's space it out more so we don't look so suspicious.

Bad, melon. Bad.

 

[heymonkey]

i don't apologize for the flurry of posts I'm about to make. Some are things I didn't get around to earlier.

Day 1 lynch discussions... They always end the same. A body in the gutter.

That said, I sense little reason to throw Faddy under the bus at this point, the night day is young. Let him speak more before we decide what to do.

Of course it does, but as melon put it, I'm dreaming of a kinder, gentler internet yelling murder game.

I didn’t realize statements made before the game that most would assume are jokes are suddenly hard stances. That being said I’m not particularly convinced scum Faddy would make such a move considering I know he’s smart enough to realize what the reaction will be.

^^^^^^yep^^^^^^^

The idea of 2 day 1's sounds painful to me. There's no vote history, no conversations to read, its just another day of vague conversations to get your post obligations in and some prodding. With 50 players, the quicker we can start trimming down the field the better. I appreciate the sentiment some have but at the end of the day, this is the game and if someone gets lynched, they'll have the spectators thread to move onto if they want to stay involved.

oh, I see you brought your logic it day one. We are shitposting, sir; did you not get the memo?

 

[Terraforce]

Fifth time's the charm

VOTE: Ferg

 

[heymonkey]

no i mean the vote on monkey, like every game she gets suspected for some form of excessively active play.

I love you the most, Stan, but I'm not sure how to feel about you taking my defense from me. Relieved that I don't have to do it? Suspicious that you're doing it? Is this a pocket?

so if monkey were to hypothetically flip scum, that make yall think stan is more or equally likely to be scum as he was at the start of the day?

see above

It's a bit early for me to actually read anything into that but Stan and Natiko are two of... uh, really maybe the only two people I feel like I can gutread with any accuracy so I'll report out on them in the fullness of time.

 

[heymonkey]

Fifth time's the charm

VOTE: Ferg

lol at your dedication to a vote that's dumber than no lynch

 

[heymonkey]

Monkey's one of the more veteran players, and she was giving another player rudimentary mafia insight so I made a light jab at both of them.

Well, actually - I've only been playing about a year. I'm just, y'know, nice.

Sometimes.

Spoiler

Don't ask Heck if I'm nice.

 

[heymonkey]

Anyway, the Apollo pop-in is the only real interesting thread I think is worth teasing out but I'll sit on my feelings until it develops a bit, considering it's already been teased and now we're just waiting on reaction.

Oh, Febe's opening vote on Include was terrible, mean harassment of a former mentee. tsk.

 

[melonrabbit]

lol at your dedication to a vote that's dumber than no lynch

Hey now, this tactically placed pressured vote on Ferg is gonna play off in spades.

 

[melonrabbit]

There's that galactic arena at least that I'm sure other people have noticed.

Nope, you're the only one.

 

[nin1000]

Goood Morning....

Yes. If anyone was against this plan they should have said so earlier.

Turbo No Lynch

VOTE: No Lynch

Let's go Day 2!

Lets not go that route mate

 

[Geno]

Yo

 

[nin1000]

So we no lynching D1? Keep everyone around for D2 shenanigans :P

we are 100% going to lynch someone trust me

 

[Include]

Hellos <3

Welcome to the ultimate struggle: The undercurrent of players that just wanting more fodder on D2 vs common sense.

I feel it comes down to the fact they don't want to be trapped in Sorian's game alone. Everyone must suffer.

Hey, you! Happy to see play again and hey we are playing together this time around too, I'm gonna be honest though, I kinda worry if you act scummy again and I tunnel on you again and then have to apologize for being dumb again. I can't promise not doing again though because I can't control my personality.

Is Stu the only #teamnolynch player you suspect? Stu mentioned it first but Faddy was the first to actually go through with the vote.

I have come to learn about Monkey's Town play when I played with her in HvV, if she is town she will put on work for us and it will show, I doubt she will be as frantically helpful if she is scum later on, nobody can fake that level of helpfulness if they are scum imo. So I'm gonna wait and see on her, assuming I don't get NK on N1, like Sorian & Brazil tried to in HvV.

Faddy is a gambler but really pationate as town, so just like Monkey I feel like I can judge them easily later on again assuming I'm still alive.

Stuart is prone to make gambit as scum and methinks he may just have done one here too, I also don't like how defensive he got after I probe voted him to be honest.

The day is still young though and so many players haven't showed up yet, so I am going to reserve my final judgements.

 

[Ferg]

@Ferg In your own words, what do you think are the cons to lynching day 1 in a game like this? And do you think those cons outweighs the pros (as in pros for NL) in that scenario?

Like I said, since we're a lot it's probably different than what I usually play (it's not Mafia but its basically the same mechanics), but usually, we don't know a lot of stuff in Day 1, so the first one to be lynched will mostlikely be lynched with barely any reason, like I said, I do understand those who still want to lynch, I'm not saying they're wrong, it's just my personal opinion.

In the games I play we usually don't lynch on Day 1 so that we can allow people to prove themselves, to prove they aren't with the bad guys, or if we lynch someone, it's in a different way, we don't vote against someone we think is Mafia, we actually chose someone we think is innocent who will pick someone he thinks is innocent and so on, and last one who's picked up is lynched. But I know the GameMaster won't do it that way which I completely understand, it's his game he does it the way he wants, I'm just saying how i usually played, but since we don't know much for now, I choose not to lynch so we won't lynch too many innocent people with little proof.

And yeah, like @melonrabbit said, I'm new here so I don't know how you usually play those games here, soo...yeah

 

[nin1000]

I'll vote to kill randomly from those that don't have a marvel avatar by end of day if nothing happens and this is as simple and unrevealing as usual day ones. You nonethemed avatar freaks have been warned

I will also show you all my master plan for today,
Players who make almost no noise will get voted on by me

 

[Stuart444]

Stuart is prone to make gambit as scum and methinks he may just have done one here too, I also don't like how defensive he got after I probe voted him to be honest.

Uhh. I've only been scum once and I don't remember making any gambit outside of saying what my role was when I was about to be lynched anyway.

'Prone' makes it sound like you've seen some pattern from me that even I've not seen from my 1 scum game.

 

[Stuart444]

Also wtf I didn't get defensive O.o (I am being defensive now I guess but whatever). I just said I explained my reason and dropped the whole no lynch subject.

If that is being defensive, lol.

 

[nin1000]

Concerning CoolestSpot
I did not get the impression that he was role fishing.
Yep i said it

 

[Stantastic]

I love you the most, Stan, but I'm not sure how to feel about you taking my defense from me. Relieved that I don't have to do it? Suspicious that you're doing it? Is this a pocket?

because if its just you defending yourself then its the exact same history i was talking about happening again, where people suspect you for over-activity, you thoroughly defend yourself, and they then suspect you for defending yourself to much, i hope the a more impartial voice can cut of this stupid argument before i see it happen for the 5th time.

this isnt much of a defense of you, you could very well still be scum, just suspecting you for excessive participation has proven itself a terrible idea so many times now that i dont want town to do it again.

but yeah god forbid i try to talk town out of its stupid ideas.

 

[Terraforce]

lol at your dedication to a vote that's dumber than no lynch

You not agreeing with a vote =/= dumb. Pressure votes are plenty useful, even more so on new players. I've caught many a noob with various tactics of mine so whatever you say is moot when I have the results to back it.

Like I said, since we're a lot it's probably different than what I usually play (it's not Mafia but its basically the same mechanics), but usually, we don't know a lot of stuff in Day 1, so the first one to be lynched will mostlikely be lynched with barely any reason, like I said, I do understand those who still want to lynch, I'm not saying they're wrong, it's just my personal opinion.

In the games I play we usually don't lynch on Day 1 so that we can allow people to prove themselves, to prove they aren't with the bad guys, or if we lynch someone, it's in a different way, we don't vote against someone we think is Mafia, we actually chose someone we think is innocent who will pick someone he thinks is innocent and so on, and last one who's picked up is lynched. But I know the GameMaster won't do it that way which I completely understand, it's his game he does it the way he wants, I'm just saying how i usually played, but since we don't know much for now, I choose not to lynch so we won't lynch too many innocent people with little proof.

And yeah, like @melonrabbit said, I'm new here so I don't know how you usually play those games here, soo...yeah

If by "basically the same" you are referencing Town of Salem or something in that vein, it's really not that similar to forum mafia. On the usual forum in which I play mafia, asking if mafia is like ToS is basically a meme because that's not at all the case.

Anyway, that's not the case at all here. We have 48 hours to poke, prod, call out, and ruminate. By the end of the day you should have some inclination on your reads which is enough as far as day one is concerned since we're guaranteed new info with a lynch. In mafia it's far easier to distrust than trust, so the route you're used to is interesting, and something I personally find can be flawed, especially if it warps the mindset of new players. You'll have "little proof" on a vast majority of people paying on day 2 as we have now on day 1, which only feeds into a cycle of passiveness if you choose to wait until something slaps you in the face.

If your mindset is to always vote for a NL on day one regardless of circumstance, you're not playing optimally.

 

[melonrabbit]

Goood Morning....

Lets not go that route mate

Hi, Nin.

Hey, you! Happy to see play again and hey we are playing together this time around too, I'm gonna be honest though, I kinda worry if you act scummy again and I tunnel on you again and then have to apologize for being dumb again. I can't promise not doing again though because I can't control my personality.

Go with your heart.

 

[heymonkey]

My role and its power is what I'm getting the info from, yeah

Not sharing much more cause, y'know, role could have some use

Yes, so you should not-

Cause in the one game I played with items they were a big deal (well the one was a big deal) and the more players know the better chances we got. We got so many players I'm betting most will be dead by day 3 and want everyone to be aware.

To clarify why I'm jumping to conclusion about gathering items well, theres the theme, but beyond that my role allows me to interact with power's beyond a player's role...and yada yada...so there's that.

I'm close to fully role claiming which makes me realize I'm playing damn stupid probably but this is only my second time as town, and I'm better with scum gameplay to be honest. With scum I know what I'm suppoused to keep to my team or not, here I don't...

Also first time as town with PR, so sorry to jump the gun, but there's plently of surpises left to make me confident it's better to share.

oh boy. I missed this wall earlier.
man, why did you put a big target on your back like this -.-

I get your enthusiasm and excitement in wanting to be like neat, items! Let me share this info! But you added "hey, kill me" as a footnote and generally that's a poor idea.

 

[heymonkey]

Because I never trust this strategy, which is why I always vote for the 1st No Kill voter every game because I believe it's either a pure Scum move, or because I am Scum & don't want to arouse suspicion. I'll probably change my vote when something more compelling comes about. I'm surprised & maybe, like 5% suspicious someone actually jumped onto my vote this early. So you 2 & Terraforce are my only suspicions at this juncture.

this is fair, btw, and I remember you doing it in a past game so at least it's consistent.

 

[Ferg]

You not agreeing with a vote =/= dumb. Pressure votes are plenty useful, even more so on new players. I've caught many a noob with various tactics of mine so whatever you say is moot when I have the results to back it.


If by "basically the same" you are referencing Town of Salem or something in that vein, it's really not that similar to forum mafia. On the usual forum in which I play mafia, asking if mafia is like ToS is basically a meme because that's not at all the case.

Anyway, that's not the case at all here. We have 48 hours to poke, prod, call out, and ruminate. By the end of the day you should have some inclination on your reads which is enough as far as day one is concerned since we're guaranteed new info with a lynch. In mafia it's far easier to distrust than trust, so the route you're used to is interesting, and something I personally find can be flawed, especially if it warps the mindset of new players. You'll have "little proof" on a vast majority of people paying on day 2 as we have now on day 1, which only feeds into a cycle of passiveness if you choose to wait until something slaps you in the face.

If your mindset is to always vote for a NL on day one regardless of circumstance, you're not playing optimally.

Wasn't a forum, it was in real life, and it was not Town of Salem, so yeah I get that there's a lot less discussion than in a forum, I'll see how the day goes, like I said, I never played here before, I might change my mind by the end of the day and start to agree to lynch someone, I get the pressure votes but I don't see why on new players.

 

[Terraforce]

Wasn't a forum, it was in real life, and it was not Town of Salem, so yeah I get that there's a lot less discussion than in a forum, I'll see how the day goes, like I said, I never played here before, I might change my mind by the end of the day and start to agree to lynch someone, I get the pressure votes but I don't see why on new players.

As I said before and as with any pressure vote, it was to gauge a reaction. Of course it always depends on the mentality and reactivity of the target, but as I said in my post, I've caught several new players with a well placed pressure vote.

And yeah, comparing this to irl mafia is probably even worse than ToS comparisons. I still don't like your mentality for voting, but I haven't seen you play before so it's hard to tell if it's pure naivete or you're trying to cover yourself for a peculiar vote.

 

[NeckToChicken]

I get the pressure votes but I don't see why on new players.

New players have no background, so poking them gives a little bit of info on their reactions. I did the textual equivalent of vomiting on my shoes when it happened to me... which no doubt swung opinions.

 

[Ferg]

As I said before and as with any pressure vote, it was to gauge a reaction. Of course it always depends on the mentality and reactivity of the target, but as I said in my post, I've caught several new players with a well placed pressure vote.

And yeah, comparing this to irl mafia is probably even worse than ToS comparisons. I still don't like your mentality for voting, but I haven't seen you play before so it's hard to tell if it's pure naivete or you're trying to cover yourself for a peculiar vote.

You'll probably be disappointied but it's not to cover myself from a peculiar vote...

 

[Ferg]

You'll probably be disappointied but it's not to cover myself from a peculiar vote...

for**

 

[Splinter]

I am Groot.

 

[Splinter]

I am Groot.

I am Groot. I am Groot.

 

[heymonkey]

New players have no background, so poking them gives a little bit of info on their reactions. I did the textual equivalent of vomiting on my shoes when it happened to me... which no doubt swung opinions.

Problem is with new players that kind of text vomiting is often NAI but may be read as AI. And probably the same thing here could have happened with a simple conversation sans vote.

I dunno, I just remember my first forum game - which is the only time I've been lynched as town - and I was just mystified by all these weird strong opinions on things that didn't make sense to me as an outsider who didn't understand the meta and the things people pressed me on seemed bonkers. I'm sure I vomited on my shoes too, and it got me killed.

So I'm biased for sure, but it also taught me a lesson. Maybe not one I've learned as well as I should but it lurks.

 

[Splinter]

Just kidding.

Man CoolestSpot says "my team" a hell of a lot. Which team is that, Coolest?

Monkey trusts Faddy at least twice in her opening posts, just because of a totally NAI following pre-game plan? Garbo. And/or pocketing attempt.

Stan defends Monkey early. Bit passive aggressive at first which is Bad, but doubles down on it so only Quite Bad.

Kawl asking easy questions. "I have an opinion but I'm not saying it tee hee"

Monkey's persecution complex shining bright as usual, zzz

Terra telling us how pro he is. Again. Gosh can't we just be more like him /dreamysigh

That self-shade, I have the best nemesis.

Stuart looking very nervous over so little pressure I didn't spot it on my skim through.

Natiko posted something weird, lemme find it

 

[Extreme Tactician]

Wow, a lot of votes immediately on you Ferg. What's your reaction?
And for the record, I don't see how voting on him will do anything.

 

[heymonkey]

I am Groot.

oh GOD I hope so.

 

[heymonkey]

DAMMIT, SPLINTER

vote: Splinter

that's for breaking my heart

nice catch on Coolest's "my team" tho

 

[Extreme Tactician]

oh GOD I hope so.

Wait, what did he say? I'm not proficient in Groot!

 

[Splinter]

That being said I’m not particularly convinced scum Faddy would make such a move considering I know he’s smart enough to realize what the reaction will be.

Why? What reaction would you expect from that? I'd expect some misguided shade, some pointless early votes, and ultimately nothing. He's not in any real danger of being lynched for it.

It's an easy, safe play to make. NAI but more convenient if he's scum, so I disagree completely.

 

[Stuart444]

and I was just mystified by all these weird strong opinions on things that didn't make sense to me as an outsider who didn't understand the meta and the things people pressed me on seemed bonkers. I'm sure I vomited on my shoes too, and it got me killed.

Heh. Now I'm having flashbacks myself. and it wasn't even that long ago for me.

 

[Stuart444]

Stuart looking very nervous over so little pressure I didn't spot it on my skim through.

For the record, I don't feel I was nervous at all there. More baffled and a tad defensive over being accused of being defensive lol.

 

[heymonkey]

After PR, I think appearing defensive just may be how Stuart comes across but we'll see, I guess.

 

[Stuart444]

After PR, I think appearing defensive just may be how Stuart comes across but we'll see, I guess.

At least it stopped people from thinking I was you like they did for a bit of D1 :P

 

[Extreme Tactician]

For the record, I don't feel I was nervous at all there. More baffled and a tad defensive over being accused of being defensive lol.

You were a bit defensive over being accused being defensive? Man, I wish I could react to accusations like you.

 

[nin1000]

If someone wants to shoot me, feel free to do it. No hard feelings

 

[Terraforce]

Quite a few people making a post or two then dipping immediately after. I don't even see the point unless you're going to post some thoughts.

Gonna flip over to Apollo for now, because even rereading his posts I have no idea what his objective is in asking these kind of questions. Feels like he's trying to feel space. I could have given him more credit if he at least tried to make his point relevant, or gave thoughts on literally anything else, but he's really one track minded right now in the direction opposite to literally every other discussion point.

VOTE: Apollo

Probably going to head in soon, but I fear what hell I will wake up to with there being 50 players and all. Timezones are a bitch.

 

[empressdonna]

If someone wants to shoot me, feel free to do it. No hard feelings

Are we talking for day 2 shenanigans because of the chances? I'd assume so but regardless this is a random post to put out there now.

 

[Yuta]

Vote: Blargonaut

 

[nin1000]

Are we talking for day 2 shenanigans because of the chances? I'd assume so but regardless this is a random post to put out there now.

Not so random if there are 50 players around

 

[Yuta]

Ah yeah I'm the 100% political correct mcu posterboy aka I have the worst mcu movie aka I haven't even seen this movie.

Of course I'm the cat person. That's life. Once I get back to desktop, I'll update my avatar for nostalgia

 

[Yuta]

@nin1000 are you scum? Be honest and just roll over

 

[empressdonna]

Not so random if there are 50 players around

You didn't answer though. Are you talking about the ITA stuff or are you floating the idea of multiple vigs around.

Still random since you just threw it out there because why not?

 

[Alexem]

Morning, gang. Ah, the joys of D1 where I can't read to save my life and either resorting to an RNG vote or following the crowd in a way that'd make Solomon Asch say "You see what he's doing? That's exactly what I was talking about." (Nice to put my year of studying psychology to work for once.)

With regards to the hot topics so far - I'm not seeing Spot's opening move as overly scummy. As much as I dislike relying on meta, this does remind me a little of his move at the start of Bill and Ted where he, as town, told a tactical lie to draw out scum. I'm not going straight for the conclusion that he's doing the same thing here, but I wouldn't put it past him. As for the no lynch, I don't really see a great deal of point in that. With so many players, D1 becomes more of a roulette than usual - the chances of a mislynch are high, unfortunately, but we have to start somewhere. Besides, what's one mislynch today against the crossfire that we'll start seeing from ITAs tomorrow?

 

[nin1000]

@nin1000 are you scum? Be honest and just roll over

I am and I give up. Party popper Nin does not want to play anymore and gives up 4 posts into the game

 

[nin1000]

You didn't answer though. Are you talking about the ITA stuff or are you floating the idea of multiple vigs around.

Still random since you just threw it out there because why not?

I think about the idea of multiple vigilantes being around.
Don't know what Italy has to do with any of this

 

[nin1000]

Still random since you just threw it out there because why not?

Not so random if you are me

 

[Splinter]

I am and I give up. Party popper Nin does not want to play anymore and gives up 4 posts into the game

Neat, who are your teammates?

 

[Kyanrute]

Dunno what my thing should be this game.

Anyone want to be my trusted super-friend?

 

[Kyanrute]

Oh yeah and I am shooting Splinter until he dies.

Gods flashbacks.

 

[Alexem]

Anyone want to be my trusted super-friend?

Sounds like more of a DC thing, dont'cha think?

 

[The Bear]

Morning.

Voting for no lynch is never a good idea - only scum is going to benefit from it.

That said, this game has so many players, that scum has really easy time to get lost to the masses during first few days. Keep that in mind.

Coolest' soft claim post is dumb, but I don't know if it's really alignment indicative at this point.

Dunno what my thing should be this game.

Anyone want to be my trusted super-friend?

 

[Kyanrute]

Sounds like more of a DC thing, dont'cha think?

I have no idea about that, I don't even like them boring zzz superheroes or their movies.

That could be my thing, my nerd things are better than yours. Rather nerdy though, don't think so.

 

[Kyanrute]

Ok Bear is my super trusted super friend. I promise I will at all times have a clear opinion about Bear.

 

[Kyanrute]

My god, random.org, has decreed that the player with the number

24

is a evil person of evilness and must die!

...

oh, cool

I promise I did not rig this.

VOTE: Kyanrute

 

[DCPAT]

Oh boy, day starts are going to be a mess for me with these times. So many posts to read already. What's up with the no lynch thing? I thought it was just a pre-game thing, but now it seems to be real? I'd want to lynch today, because how are we going to decide our Day 2 ITA's? We need something.

 

[DCPAT]

Also, I want to specifiy in advance that my name, DCPat, has nothing to do with the DC universe.

 

[nin1000]

Neat, who are your teammates?

*Splinter
Terra

And those players

Crimsonfist (he/him; GMT+1)
Blargonaut (he/him; GMT)
faircure (she/her; EDT)

 

[Stuart444]

because how are we going to decide our Day 2 ITA's? We need something.

I doubt we'll have much to go off of even with a flip today for D2.

Probably random shots in the dark on D2 is my prediction.

Maybe we'll get lucky and hit scum though, either today or tomorrow, who knows.

(I wonder how many scum there is in a game this big)

 

[The Bear]

VOTE: Lone_Prodigy

Any thoughts on the game, LP? I always feel that you in particular play scum as "get lost in the masses" type, and this game would give you an even better window to do such a thing very easily. So please enter the game asap.

 

[DCPAT]

I doubt we'll have much to go off of even with a flip today for D2.

Probably random shots in the dark on D2 is my prediction.

Maybe we'll get lucky and hit scum though, either today or tomorrow, who knows.

(I wonder how many scum there is in a game this big)

Yea sure, not much info, but info. Remind me, are you pro-lynch or no-lynch side?

 

[Alexem]

My god, random.org, has decreed that the player with the number

24

is a evil person of evilness and must die!

...

oh, cool

I promise I did not rig this.

VOTE: Kyanrute

You can get lynched a townie... or live long enough to see yourself flip scum.

 

[Stuart444]

Yea sure, not much info, but info. Remind me, are you pro-lynch or no-lynch side?

I was no lynch but after some quick discussion, I'm not anymore on the no lynch side.

 

[DCPAT]

Ok, cool.

I won't join the discussion any further, because this thread will be difficult to read already and I will just be repeating other people, but my stance is we gonna lynch somebody.

 

[Swamped]

Oh yeah and I am shooting Splinter until he dies.

Gods flashbacks.

Oooo +1 for a very old reference

I'm shooting Lord of Castamere, finally get my SW revenge.

@CoolestSpot, give me an item tonight. Something useful, like one of those shiny stones

 

[Swamped]

At a glance, i really like Melon's posts. But one thing that's bothering me. She votes for Splinter, a player she has sone history with, so she's relying on her own meta. But she also vocally defends Ferg the newbie. Why not vote for one of the players voting for Ferg?

Tbf, I'm with her on not lynching a newbie as well.

 

[melonrabbit]

That self-shade, I have the best nemesis.

<3.

At a glance, i really like Melon's posts. But one thing that's bothering me. She votes for Splinter, a player she has sone history with, so she's relying on her own meta. But she also vocally defends Ferg the newbie. Why not vote for one of the players voting for Ferg?

Tbf, I'm with her on not lynching a newbie as well.

Because it is tradition. I must vote for him. Always.

 

[melonrabbit]

Also @Swamped, you mention players on Ferg. Where is far as I've seen it is only Terra. Whom else are you including in that?

 

[Zippedpinhead]

Ok plan B is lynching @Zippedpinhead because he always rolls mafia

Hey I don’t always roll mafia. Straight town for the first five seasons!

Yeah with 50 people do we have enough information to lynch day 1?

 

[Swamped]

Also @Swamped, you mention players on Ferg. Where is far as I've seen it is only Terra. Whom else are you including in that?

Ohh you're right, just double checked the vote count, I swear it felt like more votes.

Wow, a lot of votes immediately on you Ferg. What's your reaction?
And for the record, I don't see how voting on him will do anything.

This post also biased me #shifttheblame

 

[Zippedpinhead]

I’ve thought about it while in the shower.

And I think voting no lynch is impossible in our current climate. With a town of 50 this might possibly be the largest scum team we have ever seen. The likes of which are truly unparalleled.

So despite the large town we likely have the same % chance of hitting scum as a normal game. We have to start thinking of this as a normal game, with our normal quirks, not some end all be all. #mafiashowerthoughts

 

[Splinter]

*Splinter
Terra

And those players

Crimsonfist (he/him; GMT+1)
Blargonaut (he/him; GMT)
faircure (she/her; EDT)

Wrap it up, folks

You can get lynched a townie... or live long enough to see yourself flip scum.

Recruitable claim imo

This post also biased me #shifttheblame

Oh, this might be a good catch. Scum more likely to see disproportionate pressure on a teammate (I could accuse you of that as well). Not sure if that last line also tries to dispel the pressure... "Don't bother voting here people".

 

[Splinter]

Zipped talking sense, spooky

It is mechanical though. Got any thoughts on anyone so far zip?

 

[Faddy]

Hey I don’t always roll mafia. Straight town for the first five seasons!

Yeah with 50 people do we have enough information to lynch day 1?

And what season is this???

But actually never mind that today because Terraforce is just outed mafia at this point.

Vote: Terraforce

 

[Faddy]

Monkey coach your team in scum chat pls.

Pro tip: Noob coaching works better in the your actual scum chat

So struggling to engage you had to steal my line.

 

[Swamped]

Baby is asleep! Quick, I need to vote!

VOTE: Extreme Tactician

For leading me astray. Plus, Splinter made a good point.

 

[Ferg]

Ohh you're right, just double checked the vote count, I swear it felt like more votes.

He voted a lot of times, probably just to put pressure but he switched to apollo

 

[Ferg]

Ohh you're right, just double checked the vote count, I swear it felt like more votes.

He voted a lot of times, probably just to put pressure but he switched to apollo

**my bad i accidentally included my own answer in the quote lmao

 

[Stuart444]

It felt like more votes because he couldn't figure out the vote tool :P Only one ever counted.

 

[CoolestSpot]

My team is the kool kidz team.

 

[The Bear]

And what season is this???

But actually never mind that today because Terraforce is just outed mafia at this point.

Vote: Terraforce

Can you remind me where Terra got outed as scum?

 

[CoolestSpot]

Ok, cool.

I won't join the discussion any further, because this thread will be difficult to read already and I will just be repeating other people, but my stance is we gonna lynch somebody.

Please don't stay in the shadows, that's how scum slip by. Even if youre just backing others and adding a smidget if your own reasoning why, I find it reasonable.

 

[Faddy]

Can you remind me where Terra got outed as scum?

Yeah. Right here Bear.

Damn shame about @Terraforce doing a scumtell so early

We'll be sure to write an obit written in melted ice cream on the MOON

 

[CoolestSpot]

Oooo +1 for a very old reference

I'm shooting Lord of Castamere, finally get my SW revenge.

@CoolestSpot, give me an item tonight. Something useful, like one of those shiny stones

I never said this was something in my realm of possibility

Jumping to conclusions eager fellah

 

[The Bear]

So it's because Terra voted you above that Nomad's post?

 

[CoolestSpot]

Vote: Geno

Putting a vote down since I have to at some point, and hey, Geno is always scum

 

[BladeSymphony]

I apologize for my lateness. My internet router crapped out yesterday and I couldn't access anything after work. Catching up now.

 

[Faddy]

So it's because Terra voted you above that Nomad's post?

I never said voting for me was a scumtell. Zubz did it too and I didn't care. But Nomad is literally my top town and got a soul scum read on Terra. Since then Terra has been floundering just like in Buck Bumble where he was Mafia!

 

[The Bear]

I never said voting for me was a scumtell. Zubz did it too and I didn't care. But Nomad is literally my top town and got a soul scum read on Terra. Since then Terra has been floundering just like in Buck Bumble where he was Mafia!

Kk, I didn't see why Nomad's post made Terra scummy, but this post clarified it.

 

[The Bear]

That said, I can't say I find Nomad's reads very trustworthy to make Terra into a "confirmed scum" level.