Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Shower done and yet nobody is around to react to my post yet? I'm honestly disappointed.

Smooth move Include. Smooth. You want to live past the day? Spell it out, otherwise come the next set of ITA's, I won't miss.

Go ahead and just like Geno, you will feel real embarrassed to have shot one of our most important PR in my not so humble opinion, unless you are an anti town of course in which case it will explain your random eagerness to off me.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Also, I don't think we should give Extreme too much town credit with the kill on Vere and let him slide. At that point Vere was already the favorite to be lynched.
Agreed - not only that, but it was pretty much guaranteed by then that Vere was going to die somehow. Might as well pick up town cred. After the first ITA, when Vere played the part of raid boss, anyone who went onto him after that should be suspect.

Only one person really found that odd. And what I was saying was that I didn't scumread anyone during that period of time.

Anyway, I get that you're all suspicious of me for killing someone that we were planning to lynch. But I wasn't even planning to shoot Vere in the first place. The only reason I did was because he was the current suspect, and that I missed the first phase. I was planning to shoot ryanm beforehand. I even said that we should use our ITAs as soon as possible. So why are you suspicious of me? I was only lucky enough to get the hit.
No, the thing is that people were suspicious of you before then and that's the only thing you've done that was remotely pro-town. How about some reads? If you were going through various people to shoot, then I'm sure you have some reads.

Such as:
Anyway, I agree with Stuart about people voting Mazre. There's something off about so many people suddenly voting for him, though because so many did, it's hard to get a solid reading on what happened.
Who? Don't be vague. Who's suspicious? It might be hard but it's not impossible.

more coming
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Mhm, this is pretty understandable. Can you point me to where you nailed scum this game please?

If you feel strange about Saw, what do you think of her big readlist? Did something come to your mind when reading?
I mean, let's not pretend I wasn't very early to crawling up Grizzly's ass over his treatment of Stuart. I already quoted all those posts twice.

As for Sneeks, man, it's hard to tell. I'm cautious of Sneeks because she's a very good scum player, good at making herself seem cute and useful and very smart (I mean, she is smart, but you know what I mean here). Her reads, too, are usually early and robust. To be one of the first here to push reads pings my radar just a little bit but I don't have anything concrete on her since we've mostly agreed on reads so far. I find the people who took shots at her intriguing.

And while I'm talking to you:
You are playing, but it feels like you are avoiding to tell me the truth. This is a difference.

This is nothing personal, if you are town I'm sorry this is getting on your nerves. Something just feels wrong here.
I don't see being suspicious of melon and pushing melon for her items as the same. I'm glad to have melon's result on Stan (apparently she got at least a one-shot track or something?) but pushing for item reveals... I dunno. I think now that she claimed one she should full claim on it, and that will allow us to know whether or not we need to push for a reveal on the second. I'll respond here to Stan, too-

(This is quoting monkey but its really point for everyone)

I dont think that thinking in the usual Day 1, Day 2, terms is really going to work in this game.
Like you said this when we had had like 10 deaths and 3 scum flips, expecting scum, or really anyone, to still act like its only a regular day 2 is never going to work.
Dude, you don't have to tell me. But the people claiming after the late event yesterday was just weird. The lynch was pretty set, there were no more ITAs... people claiming/pushing for claims, that doesn't give town an advantage in my eyes, since the next move is scum's.

Though faircure's eagerness to claim vanilla when she didn't need to claim is notable, maybe.

Did Salva leave a breadcrumb?
No. I posted about this earlier. Gorlak, it feels like you're missing stuff.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Gah. My gut told me I shouldn't've voted Mazre, despite thinking he was Scum. Should've trusted my gut.
This feels like such a blatant scrabble for town cred and it does nothing to move the game.

Something just struck me about this. Apollo tried to kill Verelios. Is this an attempt to appear as town? It could be possible that he made himself have a 0% chance of hitting.
I dunno if I believe he did but this is an interesting thought nonetheless. It's a possibility, since Vere was almost certain to get taken out Day 2 somehow.
 
Go ahead and just like Geno, you will feel real embarrassed to have shot one of our most important PR in my not so humble opinion, unless you are an anti town of course in which case it will explain your random eagerness to off me.
Okay, I'll play ball. I think I found your crumb. Let's talk about @Brazil. What's your read?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Wait, so you found someone who is not town Day 2? That's important information!
I'm gonna start here because I'm trying to understand everything that happened. One thing I noticed: Brazil was involved in this discussion and only commented after Polter, and then his Include vote seemed weird. To anyone but me? A sad turn of events?

Tonally, it seems very off.

Did you get the result before sending me the information, or was it you investigate, and then that information gets sent to me without your knowing the result?

I do my command, a basic check command, it gets sent straight to you, I do not see the result at all. If I did, I'd be very hesitant about going as hard at Kawl as I did (despite feeling uneasy on them)
So Stu sends a check: player and Ynnek gets the result, except he only gets it as "someone," so they have to eventually talk in thread. Is that the case here? I'm trying to figure out how to weigh Stu's posts from before Ynnek claimed because they do not sound like someone who got a red check. But they wouldn't if he didn't know.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Thought about not revealing it. But, meh, what the hell. Might as well throw it out there, especially for the reason as to why there was no kill tonight.

giphy.gif
Totally not important, but I love that gif. Oh, Tony, you irreverent asshole.
 

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
I'm gonna start here because I'm trying to understand everything that happened. One thing I noticed: Brazil was involved in this discussion and only commented after Polter, and then his Include vote seemed weird. To anyone but me? A sad turn of events?

Tonally, it seems very off.




So Stu sends a check: player and Ynnek gets the result, except he only gets it as "someone," so they have to eventually talk in thread. Is that the case here? I'm trying to figure out how to weigh Stu's posts from before Ynnek claimed because they do not sound like someone who got a red check. But they wouldn't if he didn't know.

Yeah, Stuart doesn't get the results, they come to me. That's why even after checking Kawl Night 1, he didn't change his opinion on him.
 
(don't ask why I'm still awake pls. I'll go soon I hope x.x)

So Stu sends a check: player and Ynnek gets the result, except he only gets it as "someone," so they have to eventually talk in thread. Is that the case here? I'm trying to figure out how to weigh Stu's posts from before Ynnek claimed because they do not sound like someone who got a red check. But they wouldn't if he didn't know.

I check player, Ynnek gets the result, we need to communicate at some point, ideally we would have caught onto each other without claiming but that didn't happen.

So yes, I didn't know the results of the check. Only Ynnek would know that a result happened, and only I would know who was checked as I do the checking.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Yeah, me too. I'm gonna be heartbroken if she really is scum; who will be my take-no-shit ladybuddy? D:
 
Heading to bed, will check in first thing in the morning before I head off to work, but I doubt I'll be heavily active throughout the day due to work since I'll be swimming in code. Apologies in advance; will try to make spot appearances when I can.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Walls of text incoming.

I have a lazy sunday. I've the time, energy and motivation. With my schedule I don't want to waste this opportunity to research even if it could be in vain. This digging into the game often is the most fun part for me. And somehow I doubt that I'll be nightkilled. Other people are more in the foreground.
I hate when people say this. Feels like scum trying to plant the seed that they should be expected to live. WIFOM aside, it’s good to see you showing up today.

That seems pretty arbitrary.


I'm not liking your insinuations, but I'll indulge you.

Probably Town:
Geno - Self-explanatory, he's been on many if not all scum lynches and not just bussing, but early on.
Melonrabbit - I don't see scum needlessly doing a thunderdome of two of their members. One might think they wanted to get some town cred for the surviving one, but how the whole thing was pushed towards no lynch, partly by melonrabbit himself, makes me rule out that possibility.

Suspicious People:
This is harder. The remaining people who had a successfull shot yesterday and could have been boosted by scum.

I'm not liking how LP is playing, but it's not unusual.
This post screams neutral to me. With as many posts as you have I’d expect to see more meat in the scum reads regardless of if you’re town or scum. Neutral though..

Gah. My gut told me I shouldn't've voted Mazre, despite thinking he was Scum. Should've trusted my gut.
What else does your gut say? Has it been harder to figure out what to talk about as more of your team has died?

My check last night aka the red check is Include.
Wow, did not see that one coming.

VOTE: Include

Neat roles too, good job Sorian.

I kept my ear low last night. Listened in on what happened to Zippedpinhead. There was a KILL attempt, but he was JAILed. His role was blocked by our Jailkeeper. All is well.
Did you have any pertinent results N1? Specifically looking for anything that sounds like scum, no need to reveal Town roles.

Yes. I got something.

Stanley didn't move last night.
I’m going to be vague and say I can confirm a portion of what Melon is saying. Not going to go into details unless I need to claim. Just wanted to put that info out there since she’s a hot topic of discussion.

You didn't call shit, you just cannot stand anyone who goes against you. Like Terra before me.

You are gonna feel embarrassed real soon buddy, prepare for reality check.

By the way Stu, I'm not your red check but you got one still, so congratulations. I'm going to prove my green check to you all, prepare for fireworks :D


I also breadcrumbed my role, who is smart enough to find it first?

Gonna get ready to go to my internship for now, I will try to be back soon enough.

Have fun with the hints I gave :D
Errr..what? I have to go to bed soon as am wiped from the concert (god the sun kills). I don’t have time to go on an Easter egg hunt. Out with it.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
While we wait, I made this in case anyone else finds it useful. With the roster so big, it's nice to see a just-living-person version. Down to 35 and too many people who have not made an impression at all. A plea: if you are town, please, please do something to distinguish yourself so we're not throwing ITAs at you.

  1. briefs_cat (he/him; EST) NEW
  2. Ferg (he/him; EDT) NEW?
  3. BladeSymphony (he/him; UTC-4) NEW
  4. StanleyPalmtree (he/him; UTC+12)
  5. DCPat (he/him; CEST)
  6. NZJubJub (he/him; UTC+12)
  7. melonrabbit (she/her; EST)
  8. Natiko (he/him; EST)
  9. Dr. Monkey (she/her; EDT)
  10. Gorlak (he/him; GMT+2)
  11. Geno (he/him; UTC+1)
  12. Muffin (he/him GMT+2)
  13. Ynnek (he/him; EST)
  14. Lone_Prodigy (he/him; EST)
  15. Stuart444 (he/him; GMT+1)
  16. Include (she/her; CEST)
  17. Nomad Sparkster (he/him; CDT)
  18. Alexem (he/him; BST)
  19. Blargonaut (he/him; GMT)
  20. faircure (she/her; EDT)
  21. Brazil replaced Fireblend (he/him; GMT-6)
  22. zippedpinhead (he/him; CDT)
  23. Extreme Tactician (he/him/ UTC+8)
  24. Sawneeks (she/her, PDT) replaced TheGamingNewsGuy (he/him; GMT)
  25. CoolestSpot (wtf man give me the deets)
  26. LuxCommander (he/him; CDT)
  27. Poltergust (he/him; EST)
  28. oreomunsta (he/him; UTC-6)
  29. hom3land (he/him; EST)
  30. Zubz (he/him, EST)
  31. Kawl (he/him; CDT)
  32. EzekelRAGE (he/him; CDT)
  33. NeckToChicken (he/him; EDT)
  34. Xbro (he/him; UTC-6)
  35. Swamped (she/her; EDT)
 
Okay, one last post.

Did you have any pertinent results N1? Specifically looking for anything that sounds like scum, no need to reveal Town roles.

No. There were no actions against my target for Night 1. If you'd like the identity revealed I can do that as well.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Okay, one last post.



No. There were no actions against my target for Night 1. If you'd like the identity revealed I can do that as well.
I personally don’t, but others can say otherwise. It doesn’t really tell us much other than who you feel is likely to have visitors. I’d say keep it to yourself for now in the chance someone contradicts it later actually.
 
I just noticed that I'll most likely be missing the first ITA phase for today. :<


I'm gonna start here because I'm trying to understand everything that happened. One thing I noticed: Brazil was involved in this discussion and only commented after Polter, and then his Include vote seemed weird. To anyone but me? A sad turn of events?

Tonally, it seems very off.

Can you rephrase this? I don't understand what you're trying to say here.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Polter: you seemed to be the first to notice the skipped/not revealed red check. Brazil, who was involved in that conversation, only mentioned it after you did, and then posted something that rings false to me as his response to a possible-scum Include.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Or let me put it this way - as I was reading through the posts, I was sitting here like WTF WHAT IS THE RED CHECK but you were the first one to echo those sentiments.
 
Or let me put it this way - as I was reading through the posts, I was sitting here like WTF WHAT IS THE RED CHECK but you were the first one to echo those sentiments.
That was just a reaction to Stuart admitting to being the secret admirer. Brazil and I posted asked for the deets at roughly the same time, so I don't think it's all that weird.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I’m about to go to bed. If anyone has anything to direct at me now is the time otherwise it’ll wait until sometime tomorrow when I’m not too busy at work.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I don't think there's many here right now, Natiko.
Yeah, I generally try and be available for day starts and ends. Was surprised there weren’t more posts to catch up on with how late I got back, especially given all the claims. At least wanted to check since I missed the start.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
That, too, since he'd already been involved in the conversation. But his reactions also just feel unnatural.
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
Includes burst of righteous in-your-face obstinance makes me definitely think she might in-fact be town,
at least that was the indicator last time when i was on the receiving end of it.
 
No, the thing is that people were suspicious of you before then and that's the only thing you've done that was remotely pro-town. How about some reads? If you were going through various people to shoot, then I'm sure you have some reads.
Ok then reads. I guess making random remarks really didn't help give me favors.

Can't read:
Kawl
Still don't know what the hell he is thinking. He just seems so erratic.
Melon
I just have a weird feeling because of the thunderdome thing.

Scum:
Lux
Swamped
Brazil
Bladesymphony

Mostly come to just do their business. They participate sure, but they are discussing so little.

Who? Don't be vague. Who's suspicious? It might be hard but it's not impossible.
Everyone from Muffin onward seem to be just bandwagoning. I'm not saying that they shouldn't have voted, but they didn't even discuss about it.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Shower done and yet nobody is around to react to my post yet? I'm honestly disappointed.

To be honest I read the post and just did something else. As much fun as mystery claims are I'm not about to play the dance with you since you're standing on a red check. Other's have said it but a claim, with breadcrumb receipts, would be great. As well as these 'fireworks' you hinted at.

Ok then reads. I guess making random remarks really didn't help give me favors.

Can't read:
Kawl
Still don't know what the hell he is thinking. He just seems so erratic.
Melon
I just have a weird feeling because of the thunderdome thing.

Scum:
Lux
Swamped
Brazil
Bladesymphony

Mostly come to just do their business. They participate sure, but they are discussing so little.


Everyone from Muffin onward seem to be just bandwagoning. I'm not saying that they shouldn't have voted, but they didn't even discuss about it.

Muffin? He fits your Scum category but isn't there.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Not entirely. I shot knowing that the RNG was against me. If it missed, I hoped it would make noise. People weren't pushing Include enough outside of Geno, whose playstyle I am more familiar with, and I wanted to put pressure. I did not expect as harsh of a pushback, but if Stuart is correct, then it's likely a good thing.

For the record, my shot was a second choice; my original planned target was Verelios, but he was already taken down.

Can other folks give me a second opinion on this btw? I asked Lux these questions because with Include now being read-checked I find the random shot at her even more suspicious. :x

We already have Scum trying to shoot teammates so what's the possibility a scummate would do that preemptively?
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Doing some rereading before bed but an open question to folks: was there anyone who did not submit an ITA on D1? Have a thought regarding Alexem's theory on ET depending on the answer.

Oh shit, I completely missed the 100% hit rate part till I saw this post quoted. That throws huge shade on Mazre. Yep, gonna vote there.

VOTE: Mazre

Might have been answered but was this really what go you to vote Mazre? Just this?

I can get behind killing Mazre. Zipped’s by far the safest player. But I till want to return to Melon tomorrow.

VOTE: Mazre

What did you mean here by 'Zipped's by far the safest player?'

I am about 4 pages behind (100 ppp) but I know the deadline is soon and I want to actually vote this time lol.

VOTE: LuxCommander

Why Lux, Swamped?
 
I think they definitely used the 100% boost. Maybe they didn't take the shot in the end, but I definitely think a scum was boosted.
This is were I'm leaning towards also. But we can't forget about Hecht's power, he may have used it as well, no crumbs though.

I'll give a list of the people who abstained from shooting D2 soon.
 
Something just struck me about this. Apollo tried to kill Verelios. Is this an attempt to appear as town? It could be possible that he made himself have a 0% chance of hitting.
That's a good point, I haven't thought of that possibility myself.

Still much is depending on a Extreme Tactician reread.
 
@Gorlak This has been the thing about the TD. It seems no one wants to discuss the ppl who voted for a no lynch. Some ppl like Nat,DC, and Stuart iirc wanted to actively go after the ppl that voted melon/Splinter for various reasons. instead of starting with those who voted a no lynch.
Ya, I see where you are coming from. But looking at the no lynch voters now, won't give us much to work with, will it? There are 15 on that vote, 3 dead, 2 scum already revealed. How many more do you expect to find in there?
 
I want to say who I investigated but result 1 is throwing me off and wondering if it was a real result or not As in, was it an actual Town or a scum with a role power that makes them appear as Town even with no Godfather. (a one time town read power if checked? otherwise, idk)
You’ve got a green check on me we already have The Godfather revealed and you are still tunneling your way across the channel here
more than one?
Grizzly functioned as a Godfather though it was a side passive ability with his active ability being RB.
Unless there is two Godfathers that is. Maybe he's Godfather + BP since he claimed 2-shot BP? otherwise, I don't know.

Interesting about the reactions to the Ynnek/Stu reveal is that Kawl is immediatly aware that Grizzly was a Godfather. Kawl is barely hanging around, but remembers the second ability of the first dead scum?

1-shot alignment change (another joat maybe) or redirection or switching, why is everyone putting it out of the possibilities that a scum team would somehow interfere with the results of a suspicious Kawl N1?

This is just for the record, it becomes increasingly likely that Kawl is town. My take is that I'll trust this check to the point that only other scum flips/power reveals could change my opinion.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
hey Ynnek, for the benefit of the others who haven't caught up with youe Role-claim yey, who was the last person you voted against on D1 and D2? Thank you for your time
 
I don't see being suspicious of melon and pushing melon for her items as the same. I'm glad to have melon's result on Stan (apparently she got at least a one-shot track or something?) but pushing for item reveals... I dunno. I think now that she claimed one she should full claim on it, and that will allow us to know whether or not we need to push for a reveal on the second.
What are you talking about?! I never even pushed her for info about items at all? Why are you constructing this?

No. I posted about this earlier. Gorlak, it feels like you're missing stuff.
Oh excuse me that I missed that two sentences in your posts at 1.06 am. ffs, I wrote about the time and situation I was in (like literally just woke up to post my stuff) then this interesting conversation with melon happend and I stayed up until 3am on a sunday night. Yes, I missed this post, but regarding the info I put together this jab at me seems seriously insidious.
 
@Blargonaut ! How are you? You finally made it to the game?
so what happened to Mafia's kill last Night
Well, we have three claims to that, Zipped and Lux confirm their stories.

Zipped was jailed by LuxCommander and hit/protected.
Zeke was shot but survived.

--
Who is your most suspicious player at the moment? Do you townread someone?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
What are you talking about?! I never even pushed her for info about items at all? Why are you constructing this?


Oh excuse me that I missed that two sentences in your posts at 1.06 am. ffs, I wrote about the time and situation I was in (like literally just woke up to post my stuff) then this interesting conversation with melon happend and I stayed up until 3am on a sunday night. Yes, I missed this post, but regarding the info I put together this jab at me seems seriously insidious.
What are you so mad about?

Were you not asking melon about the items/rewards? If not, I misunderstood; please correct.
 
What are you so mad about?

Were you not asking melon about the items/rewards? If not, I misunderstood; please correct.
I asked her very specifically if executing the thunderdome results in a benefit for her. The tight restrictions make it look like there has to be reward (an x-shot power, scum would likely get an extra nk or sth.?)

This was not about the items she received.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
What did you gain from the TD? (What was your reward for executing it?)
Oh. Because she was also talking about the things she received, it looked like this was about the items; that was the confusion on my part.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Ya, I see where you are coming from. But looking at the no lynch voters now, won't give us much to work with, will it? There are 15 on that vote, 3 dead, 2 scum already revealed. How many more do you expect to find in there?
At least 2-3 more. Think there is a slight chance Nat is one. Maybe Alex.

Think ppl who went out of their way to avoid the Melon/No lynch talk need a good looking at. Or those who wanted to look at splint/melon voters first instead of no lynchers. Which includes Nat and DCP.
 
Re: Ynnek/Stuart

The claim is believable and reasonable at this time. Stuart gave reasons why he'd check Include before. To this point we have no information that would lead to mistrust this check.

I've skimmed all of Include's posts. Before I hadn't looked closely, but whenever I saw a post of her, it gave vibes of her previous plays being busy with players I wasn't focussing on, thus I townread her.
She spent a surprising amount of her posts not playing though. It was rather commenting on off-topic situations or how she is catching up.
She went after Stuart for being the first no lynch advocate, which now seems kinda random? But for the point that @Stuart brought up, that she suddenly forgot about him. That's not entirely true : #1192 and #1198.

Furthermore she completely zeroed in on Geno afterwards. She really tunneled on him. Apart from that there was some talk with Sawneeks.

So looking at it alltogether this is a small amount of people she has been looking at.

@Include who is your top two scum and town at this point?

Only role related talk I could find was maybe #486 where she is suspicous of rolefishing (nin, donna and dayvigs). Other than that my skim was unsuccessfull.

Her reaction looks bad to me. Immediatly claiming and giving receipts would be more trust evoking.
 
At least 2-3 more. Think there is a slight chance Nat is one. Maybe Alex.

Think ppl who went out of their way to avoid the Melon/No lynch talk need a good looking at. Or those who wanted to look at splint/melon voters first instead of no lynchers. Which includes Nat and DCP.
I think pushing in Natiko's direction isn't the best choice today, given all the reveals we already had. I'll give Alex a look later.

One more thing: why are you so trusting of me? It looks like you have zero doubts that I'm town, which is a bit off-putting.
 
Ah my opinion on melonrabbit:
If it were not for Include and the red check, I'd probably vote melon. My paranoia always pushes me in the direction of her. Falling over for the no lynch so quickly, just doesn't add up to her reasoning of why she did it in the first place. She took away no reads from the whole thing.The revealed voters say no lynch was preferred by scum. Also only Zeke being interested in all this, makes me think scum really doesn't want to have us look at melon. The meltdown yesterday is NAI. I officially scumread melon at this point.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
PSA:
If you can't think of anyone to ITA, always go for the lowest-activity player nearest you! Do your part for Tomorrow, Today.
 
I'm sorry, I'm in my internship and I can't read your messages until later today, so I'm just going to give some infos already.

I am, just obviously acknowledging that.

If you take each later from each word this sentence after the comma, you will have.

I'm, JOAT.
This message was posted early on D1 during my questioning of Stuart, you can click on the link of the quote to see the context.

One of my power is switch. That's why I congratulated Stu. One of my other power can be verified as well, I'm not sure if it good to reveal this much, after all the red check will clear me anyway.

Quote me or @ me if you want to know more about the other power, I am keeping the last one a mystery regardless though, so don't bother asking, if you want to kill me because I wanna protect it then so be it.

To be honest I read the post and just did something else. As much fun as mystery claims are I'm not about to play the dance with you since you're standing on a red check. Other's have said it but a claim, with breadcrumb receipts, would be great. As well as these 'fireworks' you hinted at.

You seem concerned Saw, aren't you interested in collecting data from my "mysterious" claim? Don't you think it's a golden opportunity to see who is scrambling and who is doing what? Are you worried Saw? ;)
 
I've written before the only one I could see would be Terra and Hecht couldn't self-target. Do you see any reasons why he maybe could've chosen you?
Nope. I was an inactive idiot suring that time.
Ah my opinion on melonrabbit:
If it were not for Include and the red check, I'd probably vote melon. My paranoia always pushes me in the direction of her. Falling over for the no lynch so quickly, just doesn't add up to her reasoning of why she did it in the first place. She took away no reads from the whole thing.The revealed voters say no lynch was preferred by scum. Also only Zeke being interested in all this, makes me think scum really doesn't want to have us look at melon. The meltdown yesterday is NAI. I officially scumread melon at this point.
Why makes the meltdown NAI? IMO, there's no reason for her to be so offended if she was mafia. I read her more like a defensive townie.
I'm, JOAT.
Jack of all trades?

I want in on what that other power is.
 
@Include you have a crumb ... ehr, great?

Your switch is nowhere near confirmed. Reveal who is the redcheck if you switched yourself obviously.

Stalling this only hurts town. Revealing more than that seems unnecessary as well?
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Geno, Kawl, melonrabbit, Ynnek and Stuart are my top Town

Gorlak's compensating, your paragraphs come off to me as desperate, forced intuition hence I highly suspect you

someone should ITA Ezekel or heymonkey so we can uncover the, uh... what was the term I used to use? Social links? War bonds? Between them and their reads. They're better off flipped ASAP, IMO. Thanks

Muffin's probably scum

Lone_Prodigy's probably a Town Citizen

We should eliminate Natiko today. Is Terraforce still alive? Think about it
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I think pushing in Natiko's direction isn't the best choice today, given all the reveals we already had. I'll give Alex a look later.
Idk why Nat would even confirm nat did something/stanley didnt move. No one ever questioned that part on Melon. I easily believe someone wouldve given nat something since ppl town read her due to TD. So it seems he put himself out there for nothing.

One more thing: why are you so trusting of me? It looks like you have zero doubts that I'm town, which is a bit off-putting.
It's funny, I'm not really that trusting of you. You, along with maz iirc. seem to be the only one who agrees with me that the melon thing/play was fishy. Others just chalk it up to "Scum wouldn't do that" And have just given her 100% townie points, disregarding any of my arguments.

Also remember you were one of the ones that questioned why melon/splinter flipped on not voting for each other in the TD to then wanting to shoot each other in the ITA. Or to appear like they were going to anyway.

I just havent decided if you are legit town following my logic or scum/neutral pushing me to go in on the TD again due to it being a good derailer of discussion for me.
tumblr_p0idcfZwAx1rwpuwqo1_400.gif
 
@Include who is your top two scum and town at this point?

Unlike with Buffy and HvV, I had basically less to do and a big part playing, now though it's different. So it's kinda unfair to compare my activity. This D3 only and I could only be here half of D2. So when can I really play? However, I didn't tunnel, people accuse me of that but I didn't, my scum leans are my scum lean and I questioned them and went after them.

Why is it tunneling? I went with the data I had and my reasons were freaking legislate, I don't care about what anyone say, don't dismiss my work please.

You also have my read list from yesterday. Today I didn't even really read after I left, so no clue if shit changed meanwhile.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
btw, next Event; for those of us not participating in it, be sure to ITA as many of the volunteers as you can as they return from the Galactic Arena. Trust me
 
@Include you have a crumb ... ehr, great?

Your switch is nowhere near confirmed. Reveal who is the redcheck if you switched yourself obviously.

Stalling this only hurts town. Revealing more than that seems unnecessary as well?

I switched with Natiko. Thank you for killing my super announcement though, but I don't have time to play now and I know scums will use this as an excuse to shoot me for "stalling". Whatever.

Anyhow, I hope we have enough since this morning.
 
Holy shit.

@Include
WHY did you switch yourself with him? Come on the nature of your claim looks iffy, are you making it up 1 by 1 or are you telling the truth? Where is the point in holding that info back?
 
Oh yeah @Blargonaut I'm desperate for your posts.
Have you ever not found me highly suspect?

Can you elaborate on your Zeke read? What's so suspicious, that the guy who shot scum!Splinter out of nowhere deserves to be flipped?
 
It feels a bit too convenient that the person Stu targets is a bus driver who drived herself. Usually the power is not used that way.
 
Scum has Joats too, they also have bus drivers. This isn't enough to prove you. Give more details.
Is revealing more of her power better than testing Natiko? It would be a 1:1 trade if we believe the cop claim of course.
 
It feels a bit too convenient that the person Stu targets is a bus driver who drived herself. Usually the power is not used that way.
Wouldn't scum try to use a scum switcher to get a guaranteed kill?
I agree that it's strange and the way she drops information piece after piece doesn't look good.

We pretty much have to kill Natiko first now. We are ahead so losing a town isn't a big deal.
@Natiko - you've become the centre of attention here.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Why did you all gun for Mazre again?
I didn't gun for him, but I was ok with the lynch since, him shooting Zipped to prove his claim BP/Role Cop vs shooting Vere who many agreed we would lynch first didn't make sense. Also, i dont remember him really trying to defend himself that much either.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Include you should just full-claim. What's your other Power(s)? I personally guarantee that no one will ITA you, that would be a serious scum-tell and they'd definitely be held accountable for such a brazen display of preemptive striking
 
Include you should just full-claim. What's your other Power(s)? I personally guarantee that no one will ITA you, that would be a serious scum-tell and they'd definitely be held accountable for such a brazen display of preemptive striking
So where is the benefit in her claiming fully, if you already believe she should be left alive?
 
Top Bottom