Gossip Thread Neighbor Chat
- Thread starter heymonkey
- Start date
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Sup
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
*truffleshuffle*
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Least if you die this time you confirm a chat exists lol.
*flashbacks of chat denial in brexit*
*flashbacks of chat denial in brexit*
Fanto
Confirmed Town
You proving that we were actually in a chat by posting paraphrased versions of my long-winded reads was my favorite thing to watch from spec lol.
-----
I kind of like that we're Neighbors and not Masons, I feel like I play differently when I already know someone's alignment. Happened to me in the last two games as a Mason, just having that secret green check can mess up my flow for some reason I guess.
Basically what I'm saying is, I'm looking forward to being paranoid about you lol.
-----
I kind of like that we're Neighbors and not Masons, I feel like I play differently when I already know someone's alignment. Happened to me in the last two games as a Mason, just having that secret green check can mess up my flow for some reason I guess.
Basically what I'm saying is, I'm looking forward to being paranoid about you lol.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Lol
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Hmm such a fitting game to have 2 ppl share a chat that don’t know each other’s alignment.
Would be a fitting game to have differing alignments share a chat.
*truffleshuffle*
Would be a fitting game to have differing alignments share a chat.
*truffleshuffle*
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
I’m very tempted to claim lol
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Who needs to wait 24hrs
*shrug*
*shrug*
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
I honestly don’t know what to think in regards to you but thinking you are scum in this situation is fun. Idk.
Worst case scenario I die and we don’t lose a PR.
Fireblend - I feel a Lil scummy about him asking if the other person posted.
Depending on my answer he could assume the other poster wouldn’t have posted in the game thread either, possibly fishing for other person.
Worst case scenario I die and we don’t lose a PR.
Fireblend - I feel a Lil scummy about him asking if the other person posted.
Depending on my answer he could assume the other poster wouldn’t have posted in the game thread either, possibly fishing for other person.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
More important PR*
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Really though, I actually love this play lol.
Our role is really no big deal, and an early role claim on D1 in Role Madness is a pretty good conversation starter, especially in a smaller game. People will have to weigh in on this now, could be useful for finding a scummy reaction.
I agree about FB's reaction to it, that felt odd.
Our role is really no big deal, and an early role claim on D1 in Role Madness is a pretty good conversation starter, especially in a smaller game. People will have to weigh in on this now, could be useful for finding a scummy reaction.
I agree about FB's reaction to it, that felt odd.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Oops, guess I screwed up saying “chat at night”
lol
lol
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Wouldn’t be surprised if zipp is a commuter of some sort.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Went back and checked his posts, possible breadcrumbs there yeah.
He is making a reference to the episode in his first post, but it could also be seen as a commuter breadcrumb.
He later makes a reference to The Mansion Mafia game, where he spent all of D1 using a room movement command in each post he made. Could also be seen as him breadcrumbing about "movement" though.
He is making a reference to the episode in his first post, but it could also be seen as a commuter breadcrumb.
He later makes a reference to The Mansion Mafia game, where he spent all of D1 using a room movement command in each post he made. Could also be seen as him breadcrumbing about "movement" though.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Yea, I’m feeling the same
*wonders if he is being lead around by scum*
Anyway I’m going to bed.
*wonders if he is being lead around by scum*
Anyway I’m going to bed.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Then there's Stu. I always seem to think Stu is Scum early on. He seems to have wanted to pick on you from the start before you ever pulled out the claim, and now he might want to latch on to this as a reason to keep pointing a finger at you.
------------
This is all super early stuff based on almost nothing, but I love it lol. It'll be fun to see how this conversation evolves.
------------
This is all super early stuff based on almost nothing, but I love it lol. It'll be fun to see how this conversation evolves.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Oh, and as for my early read on you, I've definitely seen some strange things from Scum players, so I'm not ruling it out, but that play doesn't seem to me like something Scum would do immediately? I don't want to go down that road too far though, too much wine trying to put itself in front of me.
-----------
I do have an early conspiracy for you though: What if we're all paired off as Neighbors, and that's the Role Madness? :thinking:
-----------
I do have an early conspiracy for you though: What if we're all paired off as Neighbors, and that's the Role Madness? :thinking:
Fanto
Confirmed Town
For the most part, I feel like I get better reads on people who I can get to put down some real thoughts on game related things.
I hate trying to read through a bunch of fluff posts on D1 about flavor and/or game mechanics. I much prefer talking about who is Town and who is Scum, which is how we solve things, even on D1.
That's why I'm really going hard about this claim from you here and trying to get people to talk about it and not brush it aside lol.
I hate trying to read through a bunch of fluff posts on D1 about flavor and/or game mechanics. I much prefer talking about who is Town and who is Scum, which is how we solve things, even on D1.
That's why I'm really going hard about this claim from you here and trying to get people to talk about it and not brush it aside lol.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
I’m claiming.
No matter what, you don’t claim.
You don’t know my alignment and if you are town, nothing is gained from you claiming.
No matter what, you don’t claim.
You don’t know my alignment and if you are town, nothing is gained from you claiming.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Ok, I'm awake.
FB's response to me is weird, I still felt like that was somewhat of an odd question to ask you, and then the implied post about you being the real fisher was like... what? Just feels like he's really doubling down on that question being not weird, even though it totally was.
FB's response to me is weird, I still felt like that was somewhat of an odd question to ask you, and then the implied post about you being the real fisher was like... what? Just feels like he's really doubling down on that question being not weird, even though it totally was.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Yea, it reads scummy.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Aeleus has a bit more meta than the average newer player, I think they lurked around the games for a bit before signing up for their first one.
In the mini costume game we just played, they were a SK and they were making references to past games, including Brexit 2, and also tried to impersonate me by using my gifs lol.
I've got my eye on them, but so far they're playing a lot less safe than they were in the last game, there they pretty much just sheeped the opinions/reads of the room rather than making their own. The fact they called out Kopite there before anyone else for example was something they didn't really do much of last time.
In the mini costume game we just played, they were a SK and they were making references to past games, including Brexit 2, and also tried to impersonate me by using my gifs lol.
I've got my eye on them, but so far they're playing a lot less safe than they were in the last game, there they pretty much just sheeped the opinions/reads of the room rather than making their own. The fact they called out Kopite there before anyone else for example was something they didn't really do much of last time.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Z-Beat and Ynnek have some kind of connection here.
Z-Beat quoted one of his posts and responded to it earlier out of no where. And now when I mention both Ynnek and Panda, Z-Beat singles out Panda from the group.
It's reminding me of how I've played when having a Mason partner, in my two prior games with a Mason partner lol.
Z-Beat quoted one of his posts and responded to it earlier out of no where. And now when I mention both Ynnek and Panda, Z-Beat singles out Panda from the group.
It's reminding me of how I've played when having a Mason partner, in my two prior games with a Mason partner lol.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Yea, aeleus connecting the claim to me and you in brexit was weird.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Is this a conspiracy about me and Aeleus being Scum together? Because I like it, lol.
--------------
I'm starting to actually think we might not be the only Neighbor pair in the game by the way, mainly for flavor reasons, but I've also noticed some things.
WSD somewhat softed as a Neighbor in his first post, and as I pointed out above, I can see a hint of a connection between Z-Beat and Ynnek as well. Fireblend also had a soft defense of FEP that I noted, which might be nothing, but could be something to add to the pile of possible connections.
Thoughts?
--------------
I'm starting to actually think we might not be the only Neighbor pair in the game by the way, mainly for flavor reasons, but I've also noticed some things.
WSD somewhat softed as a Neighbor in his first post, and as I pointed out above, I can see a hint of a connection between Z-Beat and Ynnek as well. Fireblend also had a soft defense of FEP that I noted, which might be nothing, but could be something to add to the pile of possible connections.
Thoughts?
Fanto
Confirmed Town
So how's it going Zeke?
I feel like I'm talking to myself in here.
I get it, you probably think I'm Scum, but I'm not lol.
I don't really think you're Scum so far. If you are, then this is some crafty shit for sure.
I also just love talking in private chats because I always seem to get them, so even if you are Scum, I don't give a fuuuuuck lol.
What's the worst that could happen? You pocket me for a while? Meh, I'm numb to the effects of being completely wrong about someone's alignment at this point. Feed my reads to the Scum team? Meh, I usually make them all known in the thread anyways. Try to persuade me to vote for Town members instead of Scum members? Meh, Town can do that too lol.
I just hope we have a good night chat like last time again.
I feel like I'm talking to myself in here.
I get it, you probably think I'm Scum, but I'm not lol.
I don't really think you're Scum so far. If you are, then this is some crafty shit for sure.
I also just love talking in private chats because I always seem to get them, so even if you are Scum, I don't give a fuuuuuck lol.
What's the worst that could happen? You pocket me for a while? Meh, I'm numb to the effects of being completely wrong about someone's alignment at this point. Feed my reads to the Scum team? Meh, I usually make them all known in the thread anyways. Try to persuade me to vote for Town members instead of Scum members? Meh, Town can do that too lol.
I just hope we have a good night chat like last time again.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
--- Day One ---
It's been almost 29 hours now since the game started.
I certainly wasn't expecting Zeke to just come out and claim so quickly like that, it makes it difficult for me to read him without wondering whether Scum would ever do something like that or not, to which the answer is always "Yes, Scum can and will do the craziest shit."
I'm probably still Town leaning on him more than anyone else so far though, just based on meta and that he seems to be using the claim to formulate early reads based on reactions.
I sure do wish he would talk to me in here more often though.
I think he thinks that I'm Scum. Which is unfortunate, because I'm not, so it would be sad if that's why he doesn't want to talk to me.
I'd still talk to him even if I thought he was Scum.
Just sayin'.
Anyways, let's see...
As for the other things happening, we've got some major coasters out there in Kopite and Flatearthpandas.
Ynnek and LP are coasting decently as well.
LP knows how to say just enough to get on people's good sides while still making 5 posts a day, so I don't trust him worth shit.
Fireblend still gives me bad vibes, I feel like he's not engaging much. Also had probably the oddest reaction to Zeke's claim in my opinion.
Weemad was Scum in Mansion and did decently if I remember right, so she's definitely one to watch closely. I like her level of involvement here though, she wants answers to her questions.
CaptainNuevo has game presence but almost no substance, got a bit touchy when votes fell on him. I want to see more reads from him.
Aeleus, WSD, Saenima. They were all new in Mansion.
Aeleus and WSD I played with in the costume game.
Aeleus was a SK and won the game, they did a lot of sheeping in that game, basically just copying everyone's reads so they could lay low and not be a target.
WSD got incorrectly scumread by me and a lot of others and... well bad things happened there.
Saenima, I haven't played with yet, just spectated his games. Nothing is sticking out to me that's very different so far, pretty much what I would expect.
I'm more interested to see how those three are going to play on D2 after we see some flips and really get going.
Z-Beat is pretty much doing what I would expect from him as far as meta goes, no cause for concern there yet.
Zippedpinhead is coming and going, sometimes he's got some thoughts, other times he's got not a whole lot.
Stuart was a bit lost it seemed before he subbed out, not going to hold that against him though.
Vincent hasn't given us much yet, but I expect him to stay somewhat active based on playing with him in the costume game.
Who haven't I talked about yet?
Is that everyone?
Ok, good.
Hopefully Zeke will talk to me again now that I poured my heart out to him and shared all my thoughts with him.
It's been almost 29 hours now since the game started.
I certainly wasn't expecting Zeke to just come out and claim so quickly like that, it makes it difficult for me to read him without wondering whether Scum would ever do something like that or not, to which the answer is always "Yes, Scum can and will do the craziest shit."
I'm probably still Town leaning on him more than anyone else so far though, just based on meta and that he seems to be using the claim to formulate early reads based on reactions.
I sure do wish he would talk to me in here more often though.
I think he thinks that I'm Scum. Which is unfortunate, because I'm not, so it would be sad if that's why he doesn't want to talk to me.
I'd still talk to him even if I thought he was Scum.
Just sayin'.
Anyways, let's see...
As for the other things happening, we've got some major coasters out there in Kopite and Flatearthpandas.
Ynnek and LP are coasting decently as well.
LP knows how to say just enough to get on people's good sides while still making 5 posts a day, so I don't trust him worth shit.
Fireblend still gives me bad vibes, I feel like he's not engaging much. Also had probably the oddest reaction to Zeke's claim in my opinion.
Weemad was Scum in Mansion and did decently if I remember right, so she's definitely one to watch closely. I like her level of involvement here though, she wants answers to her questions.
CaptainNuevo has game presence but almost no substance, got a bit touchy when votes fell on him. I want to see more reads from him.
Aeleus, WSD, Saenima. They were all new in Mansion.
Aeleus and WSD I played with in the costume game.
Aeleus was a SK and won the game, they did a lot of sheeping in that game, basically just copying everyone's reads so they could lay low and not be a target.
WSD got incorrectly scumread by me and a lot of others and... well bad things happened there.
Saenima, I haven't played with yet, just spectated his games. Nothing is sticking out to me that's very different so far, pretty much what I would expect.
I'm more interested to see how those three are going to play on D2 after we see some flips and really get going.
Z-Beat is pretty much doing what I would expect from him as far as meta goes, no cause for concern there yet.
Zippedpinhead is coming and going, sometimes he's got some thoughts, other times he's got not a whole lot.
Stuart was a bit lost it seemed before he subbed out, not going to hold that against him though.
Vincent hasn't given us much yet, but I expect him to stay somewhat active based on playing with him in the costume game.
Who haven't I talked about yet?
Is that everyone?
Ok, good.
Hopefully Zeke will talk to me again now that I poured my heart out to him and shared all my thoughts with him.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Sorry, schedule all messed up. I’m going to bed around 2/3 central and waking up around 1/2 in the morning.
Seeing lp this active day 1 is weird lol
Seeing lp this active day 1 is weird lol
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Ynn posts seem surface level/repeating what’s been said
Fanto
Confirmed Town
The fact that Kopite and FEPs both show up and proceed to do very little, or no, actual scum hunting, don't put out any read lists, but do decide to get into nitpicky arguments with you? Side-eye activated.
And yeah, Ynnek's posts are pretty barebones. Definitely putting out some "don't rock the boat" kind of reads.
And yeah, Ynnek's posts are pretty barebones. Definitely putting out some "don't rock the boat" kind of reads.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Yea, was just going over fep’s posts.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
It was odd he chose to comment in that issue after he reread the thread. Especially with his main issue being him not knowing who the partner was.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Yeah, when I was reading through all of that, his one main point seemed to be "I want your partner to claim" which is like... not good lol.
As has been mentioned in there plenty of times, all that does is confirm that you were not lying about your role. It tells us nothing about your alignment, or mine, and all it does is tell Scum two power roles that they really don't need to worry about (assuming we are both Town) which means they can narrow down who to target because they might have more powerful roles instead.
Asking for the partner to claim is anti-town lol.
As has been mentioned in there plenty of times, all that does is confirm that you were not lying about your role. It tells us nothing about your alignment, or mine, and all it does is tell Scum two power roles that they really don't need to worry about (assuming we are both Town) which means they can narrow down who to target because they might have more powerful roles instead.
Asking for the partner to claim is anti-town lol.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Weeds being so subtle about getting any kind of info on you.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Weem*
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I was hesitant to vote for FEPs exactly because it ties us together, and discerning readers may make a note of that, but let's be honest, he's not looking too hot here. I just broke down exactly why when he tried to be all like "Ah, but you are concerned about inactives, but not voting them! What does this mean!?!!?" It means I like to get inactive people to talk, and if they do and it's a bunch of baloney, I'll call it out, like I just did to him lol.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Yep that is my guess lol
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
*shrug*
Fanto
Confirmed Town
It worries me because this does remind me of the aggressive FEPs from GoT, where he had an Override. He never used it though.
But you are right that it is also similar to the way that Fran wanted to push for Faddy in Simon.
Meta is Meta I guess lol.
Occam's Razor says he's being super defensive and his reads kinda suck, which is scummy in my book.
Meh, it's a tough call.
If he is an Override though, RIP one of us lol.
But you are right that it is also similar to the way that Fran wanted to push for Faddy in Simon.
Meta is Meta I guess lol.
Occam's Razor says he's being super defensive and his reads kinda suck, which is scummy in my book.
Meh, it's a tough call.
If he is an Override though, RIP one of us lol.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I don't know what to do basically, just overrun with paranoia at this point, that's why I'm not posting.
FEPs could be Scum.
He might just be Town though.
You could be Scum.
Probably not though.
I already know I'm Town, which means if you are, this is a Mason chat dude.
If fucking LP is right here, then god dammit.
FEPs could be Scum.
He might just be Town though.
You could be Scum.
Probably not though.
I already know I'm Town, which means if you are, this is a Mason chat dude.
If fucking LP is right here, then god dammit.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Lol
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Ynny is a good vote. He had very weak reasoning for voting me.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Ok, so I fucked up really bad there.
I probably should have kept my vote on FEPs.
I'm Town dude, I'm just fucking full of paranoia and really bad at this game. I can't even imagine why you would do something like this as Scum other than to just completely fuck with me, so I just desperately want you to be Town too. Fuck.
I really fucked up. I just couldn't do anything for the last few hours there, I just broke.
I'll try to put some shit together later. I just feel like shit right now though because this is yet another game where I'm just fucking falling apart.
I probably should have kept my vote on FEPs.
I'm Town dude, I'm just fucking full of paranoia and really bad at this game. I can't even imagine why you would do something like this as Scum other than to just completely fuck with me, so I just desperately want you to be Town too. Fuck.
I really fucked up. I just couldn't do anything for the last few hours there, I just broke.
I'll try to put some shit together later. I just feel like shit right now though because this is yet another game where I'm just fucking falling apart.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Lol
Wouldn’t be surprised if fep and ynn are both scum.
Wouldn’t be surprised if fep and ynn are both scum.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Ok, I'm gunna go through and read the whole thread and grab a shit ton of posts and put together a read list. You know how I do.
First couple posts will just be scattershot notes, a bunch of quotes and my thoughts on them.
After that I'll consolidate it into some kind of a read list.
First couple posts will just be scattershot notes, a bunch of quotes and my thoughts on them.
After that I'll consolidate it into some kind of a read list.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Here's notes for up through post #200, so early game stuff.
Didn't fucking realize we almost made 900 posts today lol.
-------------------------------------------
Weemad... instant bad vibes from her reaction post to your claim. Possibly looking to pocket me? Post #96
She immediately starts wanting the other person to claim.
Random shade thrown at LP.
Random comment meant to butter me up.
Random shade thrown at you.
No sir, I don't like it.
Fireblend still had a really weird set of posts there, which he later explained away as him not wording himself correctly. I don't want to fully hold it against him if that was the case, but it's undeniable that if you had answered his question, it would have narrowed down the list of possible partners.
Weemad shows up in #118 and asked if someone wanted to "be your Neighbor" which she later clarified to me in #135 was supposed to be a Mr. Rogers reference. Ok, well she was also asking for a claim. Straight up.
Stuart was really... off? I don't know, I expected a bit more from Stu than what we got, but then he said he wasn't feeling well, so it's like... I don't know.
CaptainNuevo feels like he was just being performative with that No Lynch vote. He caught Kopite trying to be concerned about it at least if that was the case, which was interesting because Kopite didn't have a lot to add before that.
Weemad tells me in #147 she has a lot of experience playing with Fireblend. I remember she later came in and said something about him seeming like his Scum Self. It was strange considering she never voted there, especially since he was in the running for a while.
Saenima is a tough read for me. His reaction to you when he first got into the game was troubling now that I look back at it.
#159 and #160. This series of reactions to the opening part of the day was... odd.
Like, he starts out with a joke response to FB's vote on him, then reacts to your "hypothetical" claim with an emojj, then straight up side-eyes FB for his post asking if the other player posted yet. Then next post, he quotes me and says you must have been doing that to try to get reactions like Fireblend's.
Next up, you actually claim and remove the hypothetical part completely. Saenima's reaction? Now he is suddenly scum reading you for the claim and has completely dropped the bit about you doing it to look for reactions. Weird.
Weemad is just... I can't figure out what her game plan is. She'll just like randomly ask a bunch of people questions, and then doesn't really seem to use them for anything? Like, I just don't get it. She isn't trying to get people's thoughts down, she'll just like randomly ask WSD if he thinks you are Scum or something? Just feels weird.
Didn't fucking realize we almost made 900 posts today lol.
-------------------------------------------
Weemad... instant bad vibes from her reaction post to your claim. Possibly looking to pocket me? Post #96
Let's break this thing down.weemadarthur said:
She immediately starts wanting the other person to claim.
Random shade thrown at LP.
Random comment meant to butter me up.
Random shade thrown at you.
No sir, I don't like it.
Fireblend still had a really weird set of posts there, which he later explained away as him not wording himself correctly. I don't want to fully hold it against him if that was the case, but it's undeniable that if you had answered his question, it would have narrowed down the list of possible partners.
Weemad shows up in #118 and asked if someone wanted to "be your Neighbor" which she later clarified to me in #135 was supposed to be a Mr. Rogers reference. Ok, well she was also asking for a claim. Straight up.
Stuart was really... off? I don't know, I expected a bit more from Stu than what we got, but then he said he wasn't feeling well, so it's like... I don't know.
CaptainNuevo feels like he was just being performative with that No Lynch vote. He caught Kopite trying to be concerned about it at least if that was the case, which was interesting because Kopite didn't have a lot to add before that.
Weemad tells me in #147 she has a lot of experience playing with Fireblend. I remember she later came in and said something about him seeming like his Scum Self. It was strange considering she never voted there, especially since he was in the running for a while.
Saenima is a tough read for me. His reaction to you when he first got into the game was troubling now that I look back at it.
#159 and #160. This series of reactions to the opening part of the day was... odd.
Like, he starts out with a joke response to FB's vote on him, then reacts to your "hypothetical" claim with an emojj, then straight up side-eyes FB for his post asking if the other player posted yet. Then next post, he quotes me and says you must have been doing that to try to get reactions like Fireblend's.
Next up, you actually claim and remove the hypothetical part completely. Saenima's reaction? Now he is suddenly scum reading you for the claim and has completely dropped the bit about you doing it to look for reactions. Weird.
Weemad is just... I can't figure out what her game plan is. She'll just like randomly ask a bunch of people questions, and then doesn't really seem to use them for anything? Like, I just don't get it. She isn't trying to get people's thoughts down, she'll just like randomly ask WSD if he thinks you are Scum or something? Just feels weird.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Here's up through post #400, mid-game stuff.
Probably going to skim for the rest because it was all from today and it's mostly just FEPs yelling at you. So, one more short recap post after this, then I'll start putting together a read list.
------------
Is LP Town? He was kind of throwing shade your way a bit early on, but later he kind of switched gears into a more analysis focused mode. Hmm... He was totally wrong about Zipped though.
More bad vibes from Saenima. Post #240. Just... I can't imagine what was compelling all of these people to keep asking you so many fucking questions about your role? What does it matter? You have literally claimed as a fucking Neighbor at this point. They can go read the Wiki and learn everything! Why do they want to keep asking you specific questions, which eventually just ended up leading to "Yeah, ok, who's your partner though?"
But I digress, his comments on players in that post, #240, basically just saying facts, no opinions, throws Fire's read on him right back at him, and then says he's trying to "figure out Zeke" Just felt like a really weak post.
WSD's infamous "Well, take my ignorance as proof of being town." post, #242. Honestly, trying to read into that is just WIFOM. NAI I suppose.
Post #287, I literally have to give a speech to WSD, Z-Beat, and Aeleus about why it's ok for them to vote for people they don't think are Town on D1.
Votes then proceed to start pouring in no problem.
LP votes for Zipped.
Aeleus votes for CaptainNuevo.
WhySoDevious votes for CaptainNuevo.
Z-Beat votes for Ynnek7.
Saenima votes for Weemadarthur.
Weemadarthur unvotes from LP.
Z-Beat unvotes from Ynnek7.
The above activity all happened within about an hour and a half.
A read list from Saenima, in post #324. It's mostly Null reads, and again like I pointed out earlier, a lot of his reads are just giving some factual observations on players, but not many opinions, and not much on how that makes him feel about their possible alignment.
Like, look at his reads on us for an example of what I'm talking about here:
Z-Beat... possible Scum. Major paranoia there, I'll try to expand on that later.
Weemad's weird ass read list in post #361. This is the one where she said that Fireblend was like his Scum self. I don't even know, just go look at that and let me know what you think, the whole thing gives me bad vibes lol.
#367 is when FEPs finally shows up and starts playing. It's a weak post, and then he just straight up says he wants the chat partner to come forward. And he just. does. not. let. it. go. Fucking shit, I just realized most of what I'm about to read through now is just FEP yelling at you about useless shit. Ugh.
#381, FEP wants to Protect me. I decide to vote for him later, and I turn into his top Scum read lol. And he was trying to act like he would still be thinking scummy thoughts about me if I hadn't voted him? Get the fuck out of here. Wish I would have remembered that post while the game was still going, would have rubbed that one in his face since he wanted to point out "contradictions" aka "gotchas" so much lol.
Probably going to skim for the rest because it was all from today and it's mostly just FEPs yelling at you. So, one more short recap post after this, then I'll start putting together a read list.
------------
Is LP Town? He was kind of throwing shade your way a bit early on, but later he kind of switched gears into a more analysis focused mode. Hmm... He was totally wrong about Zipped though.
More bad vibes from Saenima. Post #240. Just... I can't imagine what was compelling all of these people to keep asking you so many fucking questions about your role? What does it matter? You have literally claimed as a fucking Neighbor at this point. They can go read the Wiki and learn everything! Why do they want to keep asking you specific questions, which eventually just ended up leading to "Yeah, ok, who's your partner though?"
But I digress, his comments on players in that post, #240, basically just saying facts, no opinions, throws Fire's read on him right back at him, and then says he's trying to "figure out Zeke" Just felt like a really weak post.
WSD's infamous "Well, take my ignorance as proof of being town." post, #242. Honestly, trying to read into that is just WIFOM. NAI I suppose.
Post #287, I literally have to give a speech to WSD, Z-Beat, and Aeleus about why it's ok for them to vote for people they don't think are Town on D1.
Votes then proceed to start pouring in no problem.
LP votes for Zipped.
Aeleus votes for CaptainNuevo.
WhySoDevious votes for CaptainNuevo.
Z-Beat votes for Ynnek7.
Saenima votes for Weemadarthur.
Weemadarthur unvotes from LP.
Z-Beat unvotes from Ynnek7.
The above activity all happened within about an hour and a half.
A read list from Saenima, in post #324. It's mostly Null reads, and again like I pointed out earlier, a lot of his reads are just giving some factual observations on players, but not many opinions, and not much on how that makes him feel about their possible alignment.
Like, look at his reads on us for an example of what I'm talking about here:
He doesn't say anything about whether we are Town or Scum for these things that he has observed, they're just words that describe things we have said or done. It's the same for every other player too, except Fireblend who he does seem to be scum reading at this time, but for basically the same reasons me and you have given for having our votes there at that point.
Z-Beat... possible Scum. Major paranoia there, I'll try to expand on that later.
Weemad's weird ass read list in post #361. This is the one where she said that Fireblend was like his Scum self. I don't even know, just go look at that and let me know what you think, the whole thing gives me bad vibes lol.
#367 is when FEPs finally shows up and starts playing. It's a weak post, and then he just straight up says he wants the chat partner to come forward. And he just. does. not. let. it. go. Fucking shit, I just realized most of what I'm about to read through now is just FEP yelling at you about useless shit. Ugh.
#381, FEP wants to Protect me. I decide to vote for him later, and I turn into his top Scum read lol. And he was trying to act like he would still be thinking scummy thoughts about me if I hadn't voted him? Get the fuck out of here. Wish I would have remembered that post while the game was still going, would have rubbed that one in his face since he wanted to point out "contradictions" aka "gotchas" so much lol.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Ok, I'm just going to cheat and go post the Timeline from FB's tool here to take a look at the EoD votes.
This is everything from after the last vote that I posted in my last post, which was when Z-Beat unvoted off of Ynnek7.
There wasn't another vote placed until FEPs voted for you.
I even went and sorted it in a Word Doc so that it can be read from top to bottom lol.
#381 - flatearthpandas voted for EzekelRAGE (Unvote: #843)
#390 - EzekelRAGE voted for flatearthpandas
#410 - Kopite voted for Ynnek7
#419 - weemadarthur voted for WhySoDevious (Unvote: #768)
#428 - Z-Beat voted for flatearthpandas
#490 - Fireblend voted for Ynnek7 (Unvote: #529)
#503 - Fantomas voted for flatearthpandas (Unvote: #736)
#529 - Fireblend voted for Ynnek7
#681 - CaptainNuevo voted for flatearthpandas
#683 - WhySoDevious voted for flatearthpandas
#708 - saenima unvoted
#721 - Lone_Prodigy voted for Ynnek7 (Unvote: #790)
#736 - Fantomas voted for Ynnek7
#739 - Ynnek7 voted for flatearthpandas (Unvote: #797)
#758 - Zippedpinhead voted for Ynnek7
#768 - weemadarthur voted for Zippedpinhead
#782 - Aeleus voted for Zippedpinhead
#790 - Lone_Prodigy voted for Zippedpinhead
#797 - Ynnek7 voted for Zippedpinhead
#803 - saenima voted for Zippedpinhead
#806 - Vincent Alexander voted for EzekelRAGE (Unvote: #842)
#842 - Vincent Alexander voted for Zippedpinhead
#843 - flatearthpandas voted for EzekelRAGE
#850 - Day 1 ends!
#853 - Zippedpinhead was eliminated!
My shitty quick analysis? If Ynnek is Scum here, then they got shook by that push for him and went all in on Zipped.
FEPs could still be Scum as well. Not sure on the likelihood of both FEPs and Ynnek. FEPs did straight up refuse to vote for Ynnek even out of self preservation, which is weird. Ynnek had no problem with the self pres votes at EoD, but FEPs stayed on you. Hmmm... food for thought at least about the differences between their actions there.
Ok, I'll be back with a read list in a little while, going to let this all sit for a bit.
This is everything from after the last vote that I posted in my last post, which was when Z-Beat unvoted off of Ynnek7.
There wasn't another vote placed until FEPs voted for you.
I even went and sorted it in a Word Doc so that it can be read from top to bottom lol.
#381 - flatearthpandas voted for EzekelRAGE (Unvote: #843)
#390 - EzekelRAGE voted for flatearthpandas
#410 - Kopite voted for Ynnek7
#419 - weemadarthur voted for WhySoDevious (Unvote: #768)
#428 - Z-Beat voted for flatearthpandas
#490 - Fireblend voted for Ynnek7 (Unvote: #529)
#503 - Fantomas voted for flatearthpandas (Unvote: #736)
#529 - Fireblend voted for Ynnek7
#681 - CaptainNuevo voted for flatearthpandas
#683 - WhySoDevious voted for flatearthpandas
#708 - saenima unvoted
#721 - Lone_Prodigy voted for Ynnek7 (Unvote: #790)
#736 - Fantomas voted for Ynnek7
#739 - Ynnek7 voted for flatearthpandas (Unvote: #797)
#758 - Zippedpinhead voted for Ynnek7
#768 - weemadarthur voted for Zippedpinhead
#782 - Aeleus voted for Zippedpinhead
#790 - Lone_Prodigy voted for Zippedpinhead
#797 - Ynnek7 voted for Zippedpinhead
#803 - saenima voted for Zippedpinhead
#806 - Vincent Alexander voted for EzekelRAGE (Unvote: #842)
#842 - Vincent Alexander voted for Zippedpinhead
#843 - flatearthpandas voted for EzekelRAGE
#850 - Day 1 ends!
#853 - Zippedpinhead was eliminated!
My shitty quick analysis? If Ynnek is Scum here, then they got shook by that push for him and went all in on Zipped.
FEPs could still be Scum as well. Not sure on the likelihood of both FEPs and Ynnek. FEPs did straight up refuse to vote for Ynnek even out of self preservation, which is weird. Ynnek had no problem with the self pres votes at EoD, but FEPs stayed on you. Hmmm... food for thought at least about the differences between their actions there.
Ok, I'll be back with a read list in a little while, going to let this all sit for a bit.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I have a really hard time giving anyone a Town read these days.
I think the MafiEra game literally broke my ability to town read people. Monkey and Natiko... Those two made it so that I literally cannot distinguish between Town and Scum anymore.
I used to always break my lists down into Town, Lean Town, Null, Lean Scum, and Scum.
Now it's just Null and Scum.
Here's my pathetic read list:
Lean Town:
EzekelRAGE
Null:
Fireblend
Kopite
Z-Beat
Vincent Alexander
WhySoDevious
Aeleus
CaptainNuevo
Lone_Prodigy
Scum:
weemadarthur
Ynnek7
saenima
flatearthpandas
I literally have no town reads. Everyone has been acting scummy, even you, but I still lean town on you just to keep my god damn sanity.
Here's some quick thoughts on my Nulls I guess, just to give something on them.
Fireblend - Fished for info related to the Neighbor partner early on, blended in more with the crowd later. Looks suspect.
Kopite - Ghosted on the thread for most of the day, not too impressive when he showed up.
Z-Beat - Seems like he might be trying to subtly pocket me with his opinions, otherwise he's just being himself really.
Vincent Alexander - New player, his second game, he was sketchy last time as Town and he's being sketchy here again.
WhySoDevious - Naturally sketchy. Fishing for all sorts of info.
Aeleus - I'd like to think their Town, but I just don't trust them worth shit after the last game we played.
CaptainNuevo - Being sketchy as fuck, shitty votes.
Lone_Prodigy - Lol
I think the MafiEra game literally broke my ability to town read people. Monkey and Natiko... Those two made it so that I literally cannot distinguish between Town and Scum anymore.
I used to always break my lists down into Town, Lean Town, Null, Lean Scum, and Scum.
Now it's just Null and Scum.
Here's my pathetic read list:
Lean Town:
EzekelRAGE
Null:
Fireblend
Kopite
Z-Beat
Vincent Alexander
WhySoDevious
Aeleus
CaptainNuevo
Lone_Prodigy
Scum:
weemadarthur
Ynnek7
saenima
flatearthpandas
I literally have no town reads. Everyone has been acting scummy, even you, but I still lean town on you just to keep my god damn sanity.
Here's some quick thoughts on my Nulls I guess, just to give something on them.
Fireblend - Fished for info related to the Neighbor partner early on, blended in more with the crowd later. Looks suspect.
Kopite - Ghosted on the thread for most of the day, not too impressive when he showed up.
Z-Beat - Seems like he might be trying to subtly pocket me with his opinions, otherwise he's just being himself really.
Vincent Alexander - New player, his second game, he was sketchy last time as Town and he's being sketchy here again.
WhySoDevious - Naturally sketchy. Fishing for all sorts of info.
Aeleus - I'd like to think their Town, but I just don't trust them worth shit after the last game we played.
CaptainNuevo - Being sketchy as fuck, shitty votes.
Lone_Prodigy - Lol
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
The issue is FEP whether town or scum made so much added noise with his tunneling on me it allowed scum to possibly hide and spec.
On the off chance FEP is town, we need to look at the ppl who were on the fence when it came to me and fep being evicted.
===========
Curious, what did I do that was scummy?
On the off chance FEP is town, we need to look at the ppl who were on the fence when it came to me and fep being evicted.
===========
Curious, what did I do that was scummy?
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Currently I kinda like CN, at least from the fep vs me situation. he seemed to try and wade through the bs of me/fep.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Yeah, he literally made 100 posts within the last few hours of the game, most of it was arguing with you or scum reading anyone who voted for him. There was very little substance in there.
I can try to go back through EoD, but honestly I couldn't stand reading through that shit last night. FEPs just turns into such a fucking dick sometimes.
I'm not sure lol I wrote that right before I went to bed. I think I was just being paranoid about the claim and whether or not it was ultimately helpful for us.
His vote on FEPs felt a bit bandwagony, but I don't fully remember what else he was saying during all that. As stated above, I kind of skipped rereading EoD and just looked at the votes instead so I didn't have to read 100 angry noisy posts from FEP.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
I just realized this is how everyone feels when I tunnel lololololololol.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
FEP is still just crawling in the back of my head.
Speculating that about the partner.
Not wanting to call me scummy at first.
Then the narrative he wanted to paint saying I called my partner a scumread. He had to purposely go out of his way to ignore anytime weems asked me for a a real read, I said it was null.
Him quoting me saying "conspiracy rage: partner is scum" was weak. Ive seen several players do that b4 or saying "tinfoil hat" or something. Rarely ever taken seriously.
Speculating that about the partner.
Not wanting to call me scummy at first.
Then the narrative he wanted to paint saying I called my partner a scumread. He had to purposely go out of his way to ignore anytime weems asked me for a a real read, I said it was null.
Him quoting me saying "conspiracy rage: partner is scum" was weak. Ive seen several players do that b4 or saying "tinfoil hat" or something. Rarely ever taken seriously.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
I want it on the records of Mafiera
I did not tunnel yesterday.
I was tunneled upon!
*truffleshuffle*
I did not tunnel yesterday.
I was tunneled upon!
*truffleshuffle*
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
"I didn't have intentions though. I just asked him to clarify what he meant by his partners flavor to see if it was just the name. You'll notice he uses the word "flavor" by itself a lot early in the claim, not "flavor name" so wanted to check it. He basically went on attack from there and i responded with a vote when he started contradicting himself, as one would, i should think"
Like this here, what else would I mean by saying I know their flavor?(putting aside there were multiple times I said flavor name)
Like this here, what else would I mean by saying I know their flavor?(putting aside there were multiple times I said flavor name)
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Although a lot more subtle than FEP it appears to me weems spent a large amount of time on my claim as well.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I don't know if I have much of a plan here today.
I expect to catch a lot of scum reads because of my behavior at EoD.
I wasn't really saying anything and just kind of let FEPs walk all over me. Then I got all flippant.
I tend to get quiet when people are scum reading me because I figure no one wants to hear what I have to say if they think I'm Scum.
----------------
Yeah, FEPs, Weemad, Saenima, Vincent, probably some others too. They all had way too many questions and tried to get way too much information out of your claim.
I told this to FEPs, that this is why I was so suspect of people doing that, and he says I can't know if the claim is real or not. So I told him to his face that I do know it's real, and I don't even know if he understood what I was saying there.
I expect to catch a lot of scum reads because of my behavior at EoD.
I wasn't really saying anything and just kind of let FEPs walk all over me. Then I got all flippant.
I tend to get quiet when people are scum reading me because I figure no one wants to hear what I have to say if they think I'm Scum.
----------------
Yeah, FEPs, Weemad, Saenima, Vincent, probably some others too. They all had way too many questions and tried to get way too much information out of your claim.
I told this to FEPs, that this is why I was so suspect of people doing that, and he says I can't know if the claim is real or not. So I told him to his face that I do know it's real, and I don't even know if he understood what I was saying there.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Like, I don't know man, I don't think I was being too subtle about this:
Fanto
Confirmed Town
So, when FEPs did the Protect/Investigate/Kill, his choices were Protect Me, Investigate WSD, Kill You.
A few hours later, after some votes are cast on him, he says that his top scum reads are You, Me, and CaptainNuevo. No more mentions of WSD, and I move from Protect, to #2 biggest Scum Read.
He shouts to the thread that I will most likely claim as your Neighbor.
But he thinks we're both Scum?
So he thinks the Neighbor role doesn't exist, and this is a Scum Gambit from both of us?
A few hours later, after some votes are cast on him, he says that his top scum reads are You, Me, and CaptainNuevo. No more mentions of WSD, and I move from Protect, to #2 biggest Scum Read.
He shouts to the thread that I will most likely claim as your Neighbor.
But he thinks we're both Scum?
So he thinks the Neighbor role doesn't exist, and this is a Scum Gambit from both of us?