Spectator Thread Pass the Meat, Enjoy the Show!

SalvaPot

YEAH
inside_the_colosseum18934.jpg


This is the Spec thread!
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
For jman: the role you wrote is #20.

.....

No honestly, did you expect a different answer?
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
I gave in. I thought 'This is going to be a complicated one to follow, just skim it and see what people come up with', but no. I had to spec it.

This is all down to your damnably effective promotion tactics, Salva.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Fran’s shitposts of just quoting the moderator comments/rules back at people are giving me life.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I lied about how the mechanics worked, players made roles with the swapping in mind, but it didn't work because swapping didn't work exactly like that. This game was bastard from the very start.
I think it's important to get clear on whether roles were switched between factions or not. The answer is: they were. This is not ambiguous. Salva said so very clearly, multiple times, including before the game started. While this game is now bastard due to the awesome roles that we all made, it didn't start with a bastard set up; Salva is not lying to us about how the roles were swapped.
hmm
hawthorn back to scum? Or just gullible?

”you made it work” about town developing a core. Lol. This is bad, haw. Dunno if you’re actually scum with that slip, but from spec, i’d murderize you.
 
Last edited:

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
turmoil's Role-design:
(REVIEW IN PROGRESS #1)​


A "post-count x prime numbers" Jack-of-All-Trades? An inspired mix of a stipulation for Power(s) access.​
​
Yet only 2 purported possibilities, either Bomb (7-multiple) or Lunchproof (41-multiple)? Seems quite tame as claimed; I expect there's more to the Role but if not, there should've been.​
​
Fun of playing as a JOAT is in weighing what exactly to use from your repertoire in a given situation... more options is more fun! So only two options is a bit lacking, in my opinion.​
​
Hence for now, I rate this custom Role-design...​

5.8 / 10

G9UYUbF.gif
​
 
Man, maybe I should have played just to see how powerful a role I could get into a game here.

One of my older roles for comparison's sake:

Dark Knight (Serial Killer)
Your abilties are as follows:

Copy Cat: Once during the day phase if you have proof of an ability's existance, you may quote it for me and I will give you a matching ability if you are right (if you are wrong you waste this power for that day).

Order of Darkness: You have gained the powers of the Angels, but in a corrupt, hellish form. They are the Anti-Commands. Most abilities unless said otherwise happen at the next vote count that I make (or lynch, whichever is sooner). Lynches made give you no morale. However, each day that ticks by gives you either 25 Morale or 25% of your current Morale, whichever is higher. You also gain 100 Morale for every no lynch made while you are still alive. You cap at 300 Morale.

Off the Radar: Neither Hector nor Nessiah can see what actions you are making nor can they prevent it. All they can do is try to kill you.

Dark Pendant's Protection: You are Immune to the first kill attempt made on you. (This does not prevent Pierce abilities).

---

Anti Commands

Lies and Slander (40): Send a 100 character message to a player of your choice. This person will not know who sent it.

Backstab (80): Choose 1 player and send messages to them without them knowing who you are.

Corrupted Order (100): The next order granted on a player will be corrupted against them. A doctor will only work 50% of the time. A vig only fires half the time. A cop that can only work half the time. etc. The victim learns that this corruption has taken place but not by whom.

Wire Tap (140): Learn a conversation one of Hector/Nessiah is having with either a member of the royal army or 1 or more of the scum group for that entire day. Names will be removed.

Phantom Eye (170): Learn what abilties are going off this day and by what faction. Also learn who exactly is using these abilties that are not factional or Holy Commands.

Power Jack (250): Gain an order meant for someone else on yourself.

Final Arsenal (300): Instantly kill a player without restrictions no matter how many players are currently alive.

==

Your SK kill method is "slain by a darkened blade"
You win when either...
A) Both Nessiah and Hector have been killed.
B) Everyone is dead or it is impossible to prevent everyone from being dead
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I can’t even finish reading one of these roles, lol. This is why i’m not playing, i don’t read more than half a line before just jumping in.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Scum’s not writing a watcher role that saves after death, come on. That cancels the most difficult part of playing as a watcher: making it to the sharing phase.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
So I think Zeke is scum and made his own role or got a scum role. Suspect scum didn’t trade, just couldn’t coordinate, though a lot of people haven’t posted yet (and maybe part of this is the truly bastard aspect). If Zeke is a vig and town made the role, I’d just guess it doesn’t have the drawback he claimed. But I think I nailed him right out of the gate and he took the shot thinking town would let him slide.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Or maybe scum had an extra thing they could add that they kept. I got to make an extra thing. I was trying to find out of that got separated and went to different people.

ugh. Anyway. I think Zeke, Terra, jman, and one other. That’s my too-early guess. (Solely based on entrances or lack thereof lol, plus Zeke’s shot.)
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
zeke's Role / ???'s design:
(REVIEW IN PROGRESS #2)​
​
While I appreciate the attempt at the fusion of "pro-Town self-sacrifice" with "Russian Roulette-y risk vs. reward", forgive me for my personal disdain of instantaneous Day-kills which reduces my liking of this Role-design as a whole; like jumpscares, I find instant Day-kill shot(s) to be a cheap spice of a Power. You may have heard me say this before during my own gameplay.​
​
I much prefer Day-kills when they are of the slow-cooked variety: like Poison, or mod-confirmed Dousing for Arson. Best-2-out-of-3 "loser dies" minigame contest?​
​
The rush is undeniable but it leaves me wanting more.​
​
Hence for now, I rate this custom Role...​

4.1 / 10

o0dpp71.gif
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
malus' Role / Fran's design:
(REVIEW IN PROGRESS #3)​
​
​
Oh, Town can now publicly chat at Night? *yawn*​
​
I look forward to the promised twist because right now this just doesn't do it for me, sry. NEXT!​
​
Hence for now, I rate this custom Role...​

2.6 / 10

HTdHqIS.gif
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Got to admit that I was hoping Zeke and Jman would get into a quick-draw duel to see who'd use their command first.
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Launchpad's Role / ???'s design:
(REVIEW IN PROGRESS #3)​
​
​
A Role that kills you if you talk about the Role you made? How relevant!​
​
This restriction is a solid foundation for the design; yet alone, it is just full of spite and little substance. It would benefit greatly with the addition of risk vs. reward, or else the Role-player will only be bitter from its uselessness.​
​
Perhaps a complement of having to hunt for your created Role for a reward, with a somewhat milder edit of this restriction as the risk?​
​
Hence for now, I rate this custom Role...​

2.7 / 10

b5ERP0d.gif
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I’d throw in some modkill restrictions if i made a town role, just because i enjoy restrictions....
Also i don’t think people NEED to talk about ROLES as much as they like to. It’s not really playing, it’s trying to find a cop to follow, instead of thinkin.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
this is scummy, plain and simple. I can understand dealing and discussing so that one of you takes it, but to actively tie is completely horse hockey. You signed up, you play.


but....but zipped....
did you notice the game itself is tic-tac-toe?

you CAN’T win without someone taking a dive deliberately....
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
If zeke turns out town, kyan could indeed be scum, since all of his work has been to discredit zeke, the people saying he sounds different have hit on a correct point but they don’t realize what the point is: kyan is not talking about enough variety of things.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Is Launch trying to spin that I gave him the extra thing? Because there's no way I would put a restriction on there and then obviously it wouldn't be a scum role. Or is he just talking about extra things in general?

Regardless, I think he lies.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Yeah, I agree that Vere is probably town. I think Kyan is, too. At least, if this is cooked up between the two of them, it's a VERY good fakeout and I give credit where it's due.

Zeke scum. Launch maybe scum. Still betting it's four scum, not sure who else.

eta: jman I'm still iffy on. Seems weird that he didn't really react to my death after his show last game but maybe that's why he didn't really react? I don't know. It stands out. From my earlier reads, though, I was wrong on Terra, I'd bet he's town.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
But what if zeke is town?
I’d go hawthorn scum in that case. Because the scum team is probably sitting back quietly just watching town shoot each other and she is doing that.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
So.
Thoughts on tic-tac-toe being a secret thunderdome? Does one of them die if there’s a non-tie? Is that why nobody will admit to starting that party which also confused the heck out of the thread re: malus, certainly affecting zipped?
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
the prize is a fruit.
So either that’s a devil fruit, which i don’t know what that means except someone used the term earlier, because i don’t watch anime....or like, um. Scum wrote a really weirdly pointless role hoping town got it?

.....or a fruit vendor is really a poison serial killer?....
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
lol no, you don't let someone suck the air out of the room for two phases in a row, especially with a public night chat in between, which will then also be dominated by "how soon can we kill this person we can't trust at all." Sorry, Zeke. Though the night chat will be relatively flat this evening unless they start to trace who engaged Zeke and who didn't.

wee, IF he's town (and I don't think he is, this scramble to stay alive cements it for me), I'd probably look harder at Terra then.

(and his argument is weird because they also learn if Kyan is lying from... Zeke's flip. So.)
 

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Dr. Monkey's Role / TheChuggernaut's design:
(FLIP #1: "BROOK, THE HUMMING PIRATE")​
​
​
A 3-shot Watcher who checks/Marks a target at Night for if they visited somebody & also who visited them; and if a Marked target dies later, the results about them from when they were Watched are publicly revealed alongside their Role PM...​
​
So utilitarian. I could eat this off the floor yet not feel totally worthless!​
​
It is a Watcher made redundant in the engineering sense. That to me is not inherently Mafia-aligned?​
​
This would've been quite valuable as team support amidst Role Madness and while "gotcha!" moments are the height of infotainment, it's still very plain itself. It could've done with a bit more selfish flair to balance off that supportiveness; maybe that for each of your Marked you helped to vote out, one of your remaining shots (if any) would be upgraded to something like a Role-Investigate. Or maybe a stacking, spreading effect; if you chose to Watch the same player over consecutive Nights, it actively begins to buff you or debuff them, and their visitors and/or visited too.​
​
I rate this custom Role, a final...​

5.4 / 10

89AoNEY.gif
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I really wish I’d gotten to use it. I was trying to stay alive by saying it was really bland and boring. :(
 
Same. But I think Terra is just wrong town. And turboing here is exactly the right thing to do.

wee: no, but I thought the marks were neat.
Yeah, no harm in a turbo with an open night chat. Town needs to clear up Zeke's alignment, I'm interested in who goes after loki if Zeke is scum.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Yeah i am having trouble with words today. Janitor.

Still, no extra votes came in when Salva said “not Ended” and then it was ended. So it must be a twilight thing.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
So. Scum wrote the role....and ....hmmm. Maybe not?

if don quixote wrote the role, why phrase it to allow for neutrals/alternate scum team?

also, who said rocinante earlier? What does that book have to do with one piece? Why is flavor??

wait, kyan claimed to write it as ‘parity’. That would be a mod-adjustment during cross-team swap, or kyan is just scum. Zeke going on about how sure it was that it was written by scum, and the timing of kyan’s claim. I could see scum mate work here, well done if so, but i’d be looking into kyan.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom