Finger lickin' good chat (scum)
- Thread starter FateShirou
- Start date
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Sorry to hear that. The vote on me will help. Good luck with IRL stuff.
FateShirou
ain't no law when you're drinking the claw
I'm looking for a sub for Jom atm
Thanks guys! It was fun sorry I had to duck out early and sorry for making you do extra work to find a sub @FateShirou
FateShirou
ain't no law when you're drinking the claw
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
This game really is Nier: Gestalt 2.0 Having two of the newbies be scum 
Anyways :bongocat:
I'm a seasoned mafia player at this point but I have never fucking been scum and I'm a bit nervous about outing my planned scum strat I've been sitting on for years but whatever.
The only time in mafia I haven't been town was I was a serial killer that won so :blobstab: let's open up that part of me. (Mind you that was RL mafia lol)
My current strat is try and be the towniest town to ever town like I always do when i'm town and hope it gets me to the finals, if that fails horribly feel free to bus the fuck out of me. I legit had no scum reads reading the game except for a paranoid crack theory about Ty lol but it wouldn't be smart to rely on that so i'll probably start acting like I got nothing like I did in wrestling and hope that buys me some time. Mind you I'm working sooooo we'll see how active I'll be.
currently Darkside is the most townie seeming as most of the towncore is townreading him, so you def want to keep that up Darkside! You even fooled me so it works \o/
Anyways :bongocat:
I'm a seasoned mafia player at this point but I have never fucking been scum and I'm a bit nervous about outing my planned scum strat I've been sitting on for years but whatever.
The only time in mafia I haven't been town was I was a serial killer that won so :blobstab: let's open up that part of me. (Mind you that was RL mafia lol)
My current strat is try and be the towniest town to ever town like I always do when i'm town and hope it gets me to the finals, if that fails horribly feel free to bus the fuck out of me. I legit had no scum reads reading the game except for a paranoid crack theory about Ty lol but it wouldn't be smart to rely on that so i'll probably start acting like I got nothing like I did in wrestling and hope that buys me some time. Mind you I'm working sooooo we'll see how active I'll be.
currently Darkside is the most townie seeming as most of the towncore is townreading him, so you def want to keep that up Darkside! You even fooled me so it works \o/
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Welcome Loki!
Thoughts on who we should target to kill? Keep blocking Ty?
Thoughts on who we should target to kill? Keep blocking Ty?
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Def thinking blocking Ty is the best strat we have. The longer he stays a live, the more sus people might get. I certainly wondered if he was fake claiming being RB'd.
Donnie is another candidate to keep alive. He replaced Monkey, so keeping that slot going might make peeps wonder at least a bit.
Not really sure who to eliminate at this point.
I need to catch up on day end.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Yeah, that makes sense. I thought maybe killing HP because he’s out town that doesn’t fulfill Reki’s neutral mechanic. Might be able to make people nervous about Reki’s neutral out.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
yeah good point there. Last thing I saw in thread was the Reki claim. I wonder if there's a way we can work with them
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Not at all. Discussion was really low and taking someone like Rando out would damper things even more. Even LP made a joke about how he was one of the top posters
Yeah, it’s possible a vote out could fulfill their condition and trigger our win with two players exiting plus the NK if needed.yeah good point there. Last thing I saw in thread was the Reki claim. I wonder if there's a way we can work with them
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I lean towards Rando because chatty, he won't suspect i lead the kill, and it makes Ty look sus potentiallyNot at all. Discussion was really low and taking someone like Rando out would damper things even more. Even LP made a joke about how he was one of the top posters
but LP is in consideration
in that case let's keep them around. If they prove to be a problem we'll take them out :mothgun:
omg loki!! hello!
not sure what we wanna do, keeping ty alive makes sense but no idea who to kill. I'd lean to HP, Pandy or Wizard
what should i do if they start mass claiming, can someone make a fake template for me that i can paste
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
:blobfive: lucksacks unite! Let's murder these bitches >:D
HP is a good choice, I still like Rando lol but we should consider options lol.
Pandy has some heat but would def throw peeps off.
Wizard what's your reasoning for this one?
You are the lucky one LOL you are a goon so you can just claim vanilla and hide in the lot of them. Just pick the flavor you want from the group Shirou gave us on post 1 that'd be a good vanilla \o/what should i do if they start mass claiming, can someone make a fake template for me that i can paste
I know nothing of the flavor so if you could give me a good flavor from the list that'd be great too lol
Also if you are unsure on how to claim, then you can always ghost the thread until some other peeps claim but again all you gotta do is just say
"I'm [flavor name] and I'm vanilla"
If people are just claiming rolls then just say "Vanilla" but def keep in mind who you want to claim.
We should decide as a unit who and what we are claiming so we don't claim the same flavor and get ourselves fucked. That has happened a few times including in my first ever mafia game LOL so def want to avoid that.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
hmmm would a manager be a good vanilla claim?
And who should I claim ;w;
LOL again this is my first time as scum so maybe don't take my choice right out the gate, but if you guys think it's a good choice then let's go \o/
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Anyways my plan of attack for tomorrow will be to walk in and be mad scum didn't kill me again for memes 
(call back to wrestling mafia last game) and then vote Reki as a meme vote because of them being scum when I replaced in to end game in stardew valley lol.
Of course I'll immediately unvote.
(call back to wrestling mafia last game) and then vote Reki as a meme vote because of them being scum when I replaced in to end game in stardew valley lol.Of course I'll immediately unvote.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
looking at the wiki for the fake claims Shiro Ashiya seems appealing. I'm tempted to claim vanilla since if for some fucking reason town has a tracker I won't have night actions anyways.
Albert Ende seems like a power role, though Vere's PM dude looked like a fighter like him and he was vanilla...
loki why you trying to plan around flavor when you don't know it.
Albert Ende seems like a power role, though Vere's PM dude looked like a fighter like him and he was vanilla...
loki why you trying to plan around flavor when you don't know it.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Nope. None of us have claimed.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Yes I think we agreed to block Ty again. Rando is a fine kill AFAIC.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Block: Ty
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
My main worry with us picking Rando is what if he’s Reki’s target and we make Reki a survivor lol. Wanting to vote out town makes Reki more useful for us. Survivor Reki will side with who ever can net them a win and doesn’t go well with our math.
but I just feel like Rando is probably our best bet.
new def want to target the town core for sure confirms and the major posters so if kills town momentum.
but I just feel like Rando is probably our best bet.
new def want to target the town core for sure confirms and the major posters so if kills town momentum.
to be honest im not sure, the manager role of mgronalds being vanilla would be weird i guess since our sentucky fried chicken assistant manager / manager roles were -not- vanilla. so im gonna change my mind and not do that.
ill claim shiro ashiya to be vanilla town instead that seems safer
Random already claimed to be Reki's target on day 1 I just checked. Voting for Random is going to force Reki into a survivor role.
Do you want us to switch, I assume we can still switch before the deadline? I'm fine with that, just tell me who you wanna go with if its not random
ill claim shiro ashiya to be vanilla town instead that seems safer
Random already claimed to be Reki's target on day 1 I just checked. Voting for Random is going to force Reki into a survivor role.
Do you want us to switch, I assume we can still switch before the deadline? I'm fine with that, just tell me who you wanna go with if its not random
I do think though letting Reki be survivor is okay though? Town -has- to vote Reki out at some point in order to claim victory. If we play a game of chicken involving Reki town is going to have to bite the bullet at some point if they don't want the neutral to be the winner. Mafia has the advantage of just waiting till closer to the end, we know how many people are in mafia - town has a rough idea but not exactly how many mafia members are left .
Maybe I'm wrong though idk. Maybe town is fine with not winning and just wants us to lose and will let a neutral take the win
Maybe I'm wrong though idk. Maybe town is fine with not winning and just wants us to lose and will let a neutral take the win
oh my bad i thought survivor win meant survivor won on its own, i guess its not like that? survivor just tags along as a win with mafia if mafia wins and its a win for survivor if town wins?
i will say though i think we can get town to turn on reki either way, if we keep reki alive then we can put some doubt on the claim or the way reki presented the claim and the win conditions or something like that. We could try to push the angle that Reki is lying about Hanzo being the 2nd name because Reki listed Hanzo -after- Random already claimed Hanzo was the 2nd name, the 2nd character needed for the hunter kill could just be someone else entirely.
Either way I think not killing Reki has its advantages, there are ways to get them pushed to get town to kill them even if we do take out Random right here
i will say though i think we can get town to turn on reki either way, if we keep reki alive then we can put some doubt on the claim or the way reki presented the claim and the win conditions or something like that. We could try to push the angle that Reki is lying about Hanzo being the 2nd name because Reki listed Hanzo -after- Random already claimed Hanzo was the 2nd name, the 2nd character needed for the hunter kill could just be someone else entirely.
Either way I think not killing Reki has its advantages, there are ways to get them pushed to get town to kill them even if we do take out Random right here
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
I have no idea. I’m terrible at the history of roles and what’s believable. I got voted out of Trek because I didn’t realize my claim wouldn’t be believable despite it being my actual role.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Lol you planning to claim the person I was going to, but you are right that he seems good for a vanilla claim.
I have no idea who to claim tho so any suggestions out of the remaining three?
As for Reki. That does suck that Rando is supposedly Reki’s target. Reki being able to leave after Reki’s target is voted out helps us number wise, but here’s the issue with that.I do think though letting Reki be survivor is okay though? Town -has- to vote Reki out at some point in order to claim victory. If we play a game of chicken involving Reki town is going to have to bite the bullet at some point if they don't want the neutral to be the winner. Mafia has the advantage of just waiting till closer to the end, we know how many people are in mafia - town has a rough idea but not exactly how many mafia members are left .
Maybe I'm wrong though idk. Maybe town is fine with not winning and just wants us to lose and will let a neutral take the win
Rando is never being voted out. He got green checked by the claimed cop.
so even if for some reason they doubt Ty being cop (which I’m banking on) they will just assume Rando is actually town.
so at this point Reki is never exiting and has to win as a survivor.
so yeah let’s still kill Rando lol
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Before day start we need to fully agree on who is claiming what. I do not want to fuck up my first game as mafia via claiming the same roll as a fellow scum so I want this ironed out.
I’m good with Darkside claiming Shiro.
out of the three remaining claims.
the manager probably would be a power role but what role would that be?
that one adventurer is super strong so sounds like a power role to me as well unless he’s like Vere’s character and is vanilla.
so that leaves the third fake claim as being the second best bet at claiming vanilla.
so what we need to decide is between me and Anex who is claiming a role I guess lol
I’m good with Darkside claiming Shiro.
out of the three remaining claims.
the manager probably would be a power role but what role would that be?
that one adventurer is super strong so sounds like a power role to me as well unless he’s like Vere’s character and is vanilla.
so that leaves the third fake claim as being the second best bet at claiming vanilla.
so what we need to decide is between me and Anex who is claiming a role I guess lol
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Fuck me I hate playing mafia on phone. This is going to suck.
—-
Anyways just a heads up @anexanhume since you have gotten some heat I will probably be pushing you in my reads if that’s cool. We should try and put some distance between us so that if/when one of us flips the other looks better. Just need to keep it not obvious.
Darkside is currently our best bet at victory so def want to do what we can to make things smoother for him.
I’ll be pushing you Anex, but you are our roleblocking keeping the cop at bay lol so I will def not do it too hard if I can
—-
Anyways just a heads up @anexanhume since you have gotten some heat I will probably be pushing you in my reads if that’s cool. We should try and put some distance between us so that if/when one of us flips the other looks better. Just need to keep it not obvious.
Darkside is currently our best bet at victory so def want to do what we can to make things smoother for him.
I’ll be pushing you Anex, but you are our roleblocking keeping the cop at bay lol so I will def not do it too hard if I can
FateShirou
ain't no law when you're drinking the claw
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Meaning gamerunner laughing at us
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Town has:
Loved
Cop
Protector of two vanillas
Override
Vig
A fuck ton of vanillas
so what fake role claims can we have hmmmm
funny enough hammerer can be a town role but normally it’s a auto passive or public when town. So probably for the best I do not claim it lol.
could always try and claim a night action noise role, but if there is no tracker type power it will look sus.
also suspect there isn’t one because we don’t have a counter to it like a ninja or ascetic.
they really didn’t throw us a bone here man :/
our best strat might be to all hide in the vanillas and hope for the best
out of the remaining fake claims:
chiho and Albert probably work best as vanilla??? Vere’s flavor from looks alone was a fantasy type dude that was vanilla bad Maou was too so wouldn’t seem too weird?
it’s that or claim the manager and say she has no power because she’s a fucking manager in a fast food joint lol
mind you Shirou has been doing no flavor so would be weird to try and give an explaination…
Fuck it. I’m claiming Chiho Sasaki. Vanilla
Loved
Cop
Protector of two vanillas
Override
Vig
A fuck ton of vanillas
so what fake role claims can we have hmmmm
funny enough hammerer can be a town role but normally it’s a auto passive or public when town. So probably for the best I do not claim it lol.
could always try and claim a night action noise role, but if there is no tracker type power it will look sus.
also suspect there isn’t one because we don’t have a counter to it like a ninja or ascetic.
they really didn’t throw us a bone here man :/
our best strat might be to all hide in the vanillas and hope for the best
out of the remaining fake claims:
chiho and Albert probably work best as vanilla??? Vere’s flavor from looks alone was a fantasy type dude that was vanilla bad Maou was too so wouldn’t seem too weird?
it’s that or claim the manager and say she has no power because she’s a fucking manager in a fast food joint lol
mind you Shirou has been doing no flavor so would be weird to try and give an explaination…
Fuck it. I’m claiming Chiho Sasaki. Vanilla
FateShirou
ain't no law when you're drinking the claw
i am a poor blob
:blobtearful
FateShirou
ain't no law when you're drinking the claw
FateShirou
ain't no law when you're drinking the claw
I'm just having fun
when day starts please dont hate me
:blobhug
when day starts please dont hate me
:blobhug
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
What if Rando claimed to be Reki target to bait them in case they have a night power and we got fucked because of it. Like wonder if Rando is a self watcher or commuter .-.
I do not think we have a doctor at all because we would have gotten strong man shots
I do not think we have a doctor at all because we would have gotten strong man shots
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
I don’t want to fuck it up .-.
While there is chance town has some kind of roleblocker, I strong suspect Rando might just have a role that guaranteed his protection last night like I said.
aka him being a commuter. So don’t give up!
We still have a shot. It doesn’t look great but maybe we still have a chance. People were sus of Anex and jom but maybe if we play it right one of us can still stick around long enough for victory.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Right now we need only 3 non mafia alive. Rando not dying doesn’t help with the heat but if we play it right we’ll be fine.
I did worry Rando might have some sort of protection, but I thought it was paranoia about ducking it up so my bad for wanting him out.
I did worry Rando might have some sort of protection, but I thought it was paranoia about ducking it up so my bad for wanting him out.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Pushing the neutral isn’t a bad idea at all.
I’m going to play the confused replacement card because honestly spectator me was until I have time to fake some isoing.
lp is town reading me so that’s for the best at this point. Makes me debate whether to keep him or not. He’s def town core and is pushing you two, but killing him might cause suspicion he was right.
I’m going to play the confused replacement card because honestly spectator me was until I have time to fake some isoing.
lp is town reading me so that’s for the best at this point. Makes me debate whether to keep him or not. He’s def town core and is pushing you two, but killing him might cause suspicion he was right.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
maybe since he's getting voted for he's ghosting even us :cor:
I have a feeling we'll have to kill Ty tonight because we are probably losing Anex. I was going to hop into the game and try and do some fake reads or whatever but I'm exhausted after work.
I will try my best to get town read some one of us can hopefully make it to the finale but we 100% got fucked by Random surviving for whatever reason.
It def is some power he has based on his first post. So better to leave him alone but part of why i wanted him out was because he might catch us.
fuck me. I should have realized he was trying to bait night activity on him. Why else would he claim to be reki's target. I should have realized what he was doing.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Also no wonder scum is always sweating bullets in these games. Feeling the pressure to solve as town is a lot, but you aren't normally one of the few doing it.
There are only three of us, but we are pretty fucking cornered right now and our odds are massively against us lol.
There are only three of us, but we are pretty fucking cornered right now and our odds are massively against us lol.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Sorry, was out with friends last night. Trying to catch up now.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Loki, I want to post and say thank you for coming in here and livening it up, but I have to apologize because my brain simply does not have the quantity of thoughts to keep up with you LOL. I am reading everything you write though.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Ok, I’ve mentioned Fran a bunch and now people are starting to lump him with me. That was my end goal, so I hope I actually caused it lol. Need to feel like I achieved something as scum.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Okay got an email initial post done and laid down my ground work for scumreadijg anex. Lol
entering this game I really did have like shit takes on everyone so tapped into that for this post.
almost townread Darkside but I don’t want to link us.
plan to make Fran and anex my biggest scum reads with a side of paranoia about pandy lol.
entering this game I really did have like shit takes on everyone so tapped into that for this post.
almost townread Darkside but I don’t want to link us.
plan to make Fran and anex my biggest scum reads with a side of paranoia about pandy lol.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Did we sort out who’s claiming what if the call to mass claim happens?
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Dark picked Shiro and I picked Chiho
so you have a choice between Albert and the store manager.
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Okay I had some thoughts about everything and here are some plans/ideas I have
1. as soon as any town train is close to turbo we have me hammer. If town gets stupid enough to let it happen we take advantage of it as it will save us a ducking day. Hell even if it’s Reki let’s do it especially if it can happen today to save Anex.
2. Ty has gotta go. If Anex makes it we should rb and kill him just to make sure. I am basically 100% certain Rando lived because he’s an commuter but just in case if we rb Ty it keeps him from red/greening us even if he lives. If Anex dies, we kill Ty anyways.
3. there is no way there’s a doctor. We don’t have any form of counter to one which is why I think Rando is a commuter. I lean towards Him being even odd because he didn’t want the mass claim today but tomorrow. If he’s even odd he will want to claim a day he can protect. And it’s line up with him being protected like he was last night if he waits till tomorrow to claim.
4. if he’s x shot we will have yo catch him off guard as he’s probably going to save that last shot till endgame. He could be x shot due to claiming his flavor and surviving last night. He probably used it just in case Reki lied about having a killing power.
1. as soon as any town train is close to turbo we have me hammer. If town gets stupid enough to let it happen we take advantage of it as it will save us a ducking day. Hell even if it’s Reki let’s do it especially if it can happen today to save Anex.
2. Ty has gotta go. If Anex makes it we should rb and kill him just to make sure. I am basically 100% certain Rando lived because he’s an commuter but just in case if we rb Ty it keeps him from red/greening us even if he lives. If Anex dies, we kill Ty anyways.
3. there is no way there’s a doctor. We don’t have any form of counter to one which is why I think Rando is a commuter. I lean towards Him being even odd because he didn’t want the mass claim today but tomorrow. If he’s even odd he will want to claim a day he can protect. And it’s line up with him being protected like he was last night if he waits till tomorrow to claim.
4. if he’s x shot we will have yo catch him off guard as he’s probably going to save that last shot till endgame. He could be x shot due to claiming his flavor and surviving last night. He probably used it just in case Reki lied about having a killing power.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
I’m good with this.
anexanhume
My logic is based on the famous “goat problem”
Has there ever been a town role with a BP mechanic but for voting? Like taking an extra vote or being immune to voted out? That could make flavor sense with Albert Ende as he’s very strong
lokiduck
Awww yiss mothafuckin' breadcrumbs
Fanto was loved and so she took an extra hit to be voted out. She was 100% the counter to my role.
in these games we have had lunchproofs or escape artists that can survive one lynch. The issue with those is 1. With a loved they may doubt it. 2. With that kind of role they may want to test it.