Scum Thread MGS Mafia |Scum| Patriots in Power

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Huh, I guess Hawthorn did get blocked.

I'm tempted to not do anything for a couple nights to bring the heat on HP and Leo.
 

Ephidel

How do you do, fellow mafia?
Sorry you're going through a stressful time, Fanto.

I'm fully onboard with not doing any infecting tonight, especially considering at various points in the thread people seemed to think the lack of any further infection would make Leo more suspicious, not less.

The bomb thing is up to you. Keep ahead of jman or try and throw people offkilter by doing nothing, either is good.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Ty/Feign/Hawthorn:

53avrp.jpg
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I'm still probably dead though, people are on to me now.

I'll have to find time to put in some legit work, I just have no idea who to Scum read, I'm actually lost on who could be Scum on the other team.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Seems people are content to put you into a "bad feels" category which is just vague and sheeping. Nothing to worry about yet.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Personally speaking, the lack of scum reads I've gotten at this point in the game is unexpected. I guess getting that town read from Monkey is good enough for everyone else.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
My motivation is astonishingly low. I'm waiting for that prime Kalor content to materialize. I don't understand how he goes from day end yesterday to today and chasing Vere and Kopite. I don't know what, if anything, Zeke is going to do with his vote colors, but I'd like to see something. I know I really don't want to spend more days centered on Zeke. There's a lot of rumbling about Fanto but no movement there at all. And the person I think I townread the most is... LP.

I just want to put my head on the desk.

I made it, y'all.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Wait, this is scum Monkey isn't it.

1. Hawthorn targeted Monkey N2, no kill. We assume that scum targeted her, but what if Monkey was making the kill? With all these movement trackers and whatnot, you'd pick your shooter to be the one with the least heat.

2. Monkey went out of her way to find town, i.e. pocket players. Look how happy Fanto and I were to get town read. But she's hardly interacted with me, except to...

3. Piggyback off my Kalor read D2 where I said he was a hard read. Then we get to D3 and he's in the running and Monkey is all about voting for him. What changed?

4. Liquid is hunting for Patriots. Look at these D2 votes:

Ynnek7 (6 votes)
Fanto - #2,022
Leo - #2,223
SkyOdin - #2,273
Kalor - #2,344 #2,472
TheChuggernaut - #2,393 #2,529
Hawthorn - #2,400
Verelios - #2,419
Stantastic - #2,421

Hawthorn is dead. Kalor only unvoted when Chuggs went open wolf. Leo is getting heat. Fanto is getting shade. Vere had to claim last day. It might be hard to build a case against Sky and Stan but they're not universally town read either.

Liquid is shook about the bombs and Foxdie. They'll leave jman alone even though he's confirmed.

5? Kalor is a claimed self watcher and we need to infect/bomb everyone so it may be in Liquid's best interest to keep him alive to watch for any of us visiting him. Hmm maybe I'll use this to argue for keeping him.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Derp, Sky and Stan may also be Liquid.

I think Fate, Faddy, and Monkey are Liquid. The rest are harder to parse. Could be anyone really.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
I think though, with no bombs and Leo not dead, Liquid will probably shift to town PRs. So Sparks who softed tracker and ATP who softed RB.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Oh, I'm like 99% certain that Monkey is Liquid Scum, yes lol.

Why the hell is Leo her big Scum read? Just seems like someone who will fold under the pressure she can apply tbh.

Also, notice how she always applies that pressure to almost all the leading wagons at EoD? She'll hound her target all day for sure, but she'll also hound other people's for them too if she wants to.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Like I doubt I can make a case for any other scum at this point.

If only I was town lol but I gotta keep it down to stay alive.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Lol I can see the seeds of doubt being planted by Monkey on me.

Only I had Kalor in my town reads. I mentioned talioring.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
So Leo is the FOXDIE remover. There we go lol.

I had to unvote though, it would look way to sketch to see that claim and be like "Nope, you should still die!" lol.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, that flip was hilarious lol.

Could Faddy be Scum here? :thinking:

I don't know if he would commit to a tunnel so hard for days like that as Scum, I feel like he'd want to keep himself open more.

Do we think Zem and Monkey could be on a team together? Trying to recall what Monkey has said about Zem, I feel like she's been decently protective of him, not giving him side-eyes much.

Blahhhhh, I might have to go full anti-Monkey mode tomorrow. If Faddy is still alive I might be able to tag-team it with him.

Not sure on targets yet, I'll probably be cool with whatever though. Kind of worried Sparks might Track me tonight though since he pinged me right at EoD, but he has been saying he thinks I'm Town, so idk.

Those are my immediate thoughts, I'll have more later probably.
 

Ephidel

How do you do, fellow mafia?
Do we think Zem and Monkey could be on a team together? Trying to recall what Monkey has said about Zem, I feel like she's been decently protective of him, not giving him side-eyes much.
I could have been pocketed while I was trying to make my new best friend, but he seemed town when I chatted with him.
He could have picked her to chat with one night though.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Scum gossip is rare so I'd say Zem is town. Monkey is putting down threads and others are running with it. Leo doesn't claim if she doesn't start the push. Also didn't oppose the Zeke vote and only voted at the end.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I honestly totally forgot that we know Zem is a Gossip lol.

And yes, Monkey playing to more than one wagon, this feels like it has to be Scum Monkey! I noticed how when she voted for Zeke she was trying to super justify it and say he must be lying, even though she then falls back on "it's good for info". Like, idk, felt performative and like she needed to make sure she said she thought it would be a Scum flip before voting there.

It's the same thing she did on D2 with Chugg and Ynnek. Did she ever tell me I was wrong about Ynnek? No, she would always say it was a great wagon and she super agreed he was probably Scum, she just wanted to vote Chugg.

She did the same thing on D3 as well, she wasn't opposed to either Hawthorn or Kalor, contributed to the "Hawthorn's claim is kind of sketchy" stuff, but without a full commit to it. She just wanted people to vote for either of them, she didn't care, very much like how I was playing it.

Also, it's like I said, her target selection so far, outside of Chugg who I think she truly did think was Scum, has mainly been people she can easily make fold under the pressure she can apply. This reminds me 100% of what happened in Game of Thrones, when she suddenly picked newbie Kopite playing in his first game as her target one day, and that day was her last day lol.



I think I'm gunna do it, I'm gunna go full anti-Monkey at day start lol. Hopefully Faddy doesn't die and helps me with that.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Liquid hunts Patriots during the day and town PRs at night.

Hmm I think you can definitely make a case for Monkey but considering all the side eye you've gotten and her position in the game, it'll likely result in you dying. Then you flip scum and no one will care about your reads.

I might have a better shot at it since I'm pretty town read but I don't think I have it in me to go against her lol

I would also discourage it since our team basically has to win by being as average and low key as possible, but I don't know if we can survive that long.

But if you're going for it I'll support you in here. Use any of my posts above.

Also could mention her laughable town core of 10 people (astonished no one picked that up). Like what does that accomplish?
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Yeah, I probably won't go for it, but I do hope Faddy does so I can piggyback lol.

However, I want to add another piece of evidence to the pile quick first though: Monkey would 100% shoot Aeleus on N1 lol, that is a very Monkey target.



Also, this was the list from Zeke again, just so we have that down in here for Liquid hunting purposes. I was so pumped none of us were on this lol.
Faddy
Funky Dude Sparks / Sparkster
nin
HPsauce / HP
Leo
Zem

We know it's probably not Zem, and it's likely not Leo either since he's the FOXDIE Doctor. I don't know where you all fell on the HP/Zipped thing, but I think they're probably just both Town lol.

Faddy/Sparks/Nin = at least one is Liquid Scum.

Are Monkey and Faddy Scum together? Possible, they would be doing big brain shit together that's all highly structured and coordinated for maximum Scum efficiency. Depends on how I feel about what Faddy is up to tomorrow post-Zeke though I think, namely whether or not he goes after Monkey. However, in all reality, if Faddy doesn't die tonight, I'd say that's almost enough on its own lol.

Monkey and Nin? Hmmmmm, Monkey hasn't paid him any attention really, and she basically ignored my vote on him today. If I feel good about Faddy tomorrow, I'd say this is next most likely.

Monkey and Sparks? Sparks claimed Tracker today, and I don't think Monkey would want him to do that. It's possible Sparks just up and did that on his own, but I feel like Monkey would have been able to prevent that by making sure to tell him not to fucking claim lol. On the off chance that Monkey isn't Scum, I'd say Sparks' chances go up a little though.
 

Ephidel

How do you do, fellow mafia?
Is it worth continuing to hold off on foxdie to try and shade Leo because the only one who claims it is the one who claims to be able to cure it or not?
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Leo wasn't counter claimed and his flavour and and role line up with jman so they're home free until scum starts knocking off confirmed/near confirmed town.

I'm going to sit tight in case of any movement tracking, and he's just going to cure whomever is infected.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Yeah if Faddy doesn't go for Monkey tomorrow, they're scum together. Though, considering their experience, they would know to at least butt heads to give off the air of town vs town. Not like either of them to just ignore the other.

From Zeke's list I'd go Faddy > nin > Sparks, dependent on what happens tomorrow.

Also my keyboard no longer autocorrects Faddy to Daddy.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
It must have been a forced thing then, Mind Control makes sense.

You'll need a fake claim, and then the only way to really dig out would be to somehow convince people that the FOXDIE was a ninja move and you were doing something else, but I have no ideas for how to go about that narrative.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Taxi Driver was also something I had in EZA as an item, which is like a switch, but it makes it so one person performs the other person's action. So you would have been doing the FOXDIE for someone else, but even then, its just speculation and people would want to see your flip.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
The best I can do for now is just pull the "this seems too easy/obvious" card and hope to create some FUD for you. If you can come up with a good enough fake claim then it might help, but I don't know for sure how this is going to play out.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Zem said:
"Have I voted for scum since the start of day three?"

The answer was Yes

This list of players is:

Verelios
Kenny - Town
Fanto
Kalor
Hawthorn - Town
Leo
Zeke - Town
Son of a bitch
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
All they need to do is believe Zeke's flip, and believe those claims lol.

The answer is that I am the Scum that ATP had voted for lmao.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Oh, and here's one for you on what might have happened.

Someone on Liquid team Role Cop'd you, saw you were the FOXDIE person, and then Kalor, also on the Scum team, claims you visited him.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Thermal Goggles being some kind of motion detector, but there's already a Tracker and Watcher claim on the board, so... I don't know. You mainly use the thermal goggles to see enemies in the dark.

Mei Ling was the person who invented the Soliton Radar (the map) and the Codec systens, and she was the one who you called to save your game in the first MGS. In MGS4 she was the captain of an aircraft carrier or something. So, I'm not sure there either for a fake claim.

D-Horse is the name of the horse you ride in MGSV. It can poop if you press a button for it. There's really nothing special about it other than that lol.

Paz was a triple agent in Peace Walker, ultimately working for the Patriots I think? That one is sketch because, while she was a good person in her heart, she did double cross everyone in that game, so that's like a Neutral claim tbh.


I'm just pulling a blank on what to claim, but that's the description of the characters we have at least if it helps you brainstorm.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
I'm a horse that can either eat, sleep, or poop every night. Can't repeat, and also can't go 3 nights without pooping. I assume only pooping counts as movement. So poop was N3.

I can only assume Natiko was drunk when coming up with role.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I'm realizing that I'm probably going to have to claim today tbh, since everyone else on that list has a claim on the board but me.

So I'm going to try to brainstorm something for myself lol.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Going to try to make myself seem frustrated and non threatening but I'll likely have to open wolf at some point, especially if Kalor flips.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, @Ephidel, I just thought of a pretty decent fake claim for you, so let me know what you think, ok?

So, your real role can be proven in one of two ways, right? Either you get shot and people know you got shot, or you get voted out and don't die. You only need to claim the Lynchproof part in a mass claim scenario though.

You are Mei Ling, and you are Bulletproof and/or Lynchproof. The flavor reason for you being Bulletproof is that you could see someone coming on your soliton radar and you ran away and hid, but now it's in Alert Mode so you can't see someone if they try again. The flavor reason for you being Lynchproof is that you saved your game at the end of the day and were able to reload, but you can only do it once.


Ok, now to work on mine lol.
Thermal goggles would make a great cop claim.
I'm trying to think something up for this, but I'm worried about claiming something that targets other people, especially with results.

I might also try to think up a YOLO Neutral Paz claim in case anyone wants to try to pull a Sorian on them or something and just be an open Neutral lol.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Stantastic said:
So if were thinking that Lp is the foxdie-er then not only did he go out of his way to call out his scummate, but he did it in a way directly drawing attention to their teams wincon, and adjacently his own role in that wincon since it seems to be a combo of bomb and poison.
XXi5BDv.gif
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, ok, so I decided to read the Metal Gear Wiki's entry on the Thermal Goggles, and here's a good part:
Thermal goggles are useful for [...] Seeing enemies equipped with stealth camouflage (for example, The Fear in Metal Gear Solid 3).
So, the "stealth camouflage" part. I could maybe say that I can detect whether or not someone was wearing "stealth camouflage" at night, and that I assume it's like detecting whether or not they performed a Ninja action, but not knowing who it was on, and I can spin that as thinking that both Scum teams probably have ways to be undetected at night, whether for kills or something else. I'll say it's 3 shots maybe, the flavor being that the battery runs out after 3 uses and I can't use it anymore, which is a thing that happens in MGS3 and 4.

I feel like this is weird but believable, and it's almost a guarantee that the other team does have a Ninja with all the motion detector claims, so they would maybe buy it being a counter to a double Ninja situation too.

I'll just need to figure out who my targets were, probably just my Scum reads along the way I guess, no positive detections.

The only shitty thing would be if there is a Town player who's role is literally Stealth Camouflage, but that's honestly a risk I'm willing to take.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Scum has a role cop, probably Vere. He checks me and then checks Kalor. It's too risky to claim town cop so they mind control me to visit Kalor, knowing he'd see me do it.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
So I did a search for foxdie infector...and the first result is my post. Whoops.

But Kopite and Faddy also mentioned it.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Best way to go, honestly. I would hate being voted out by Monkey for being scummy and getting shot at night isn't fun

Dream winning scenario is getting it via Leo or Ephi blocking a vote/shot to clinch it. Sorry Fanto out of 14 million scenarios I don't even see 1 in which you survive. It just be like that.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Oh yeah, I'm totally fucked too lol.

Ephi, here's the thing though, they might think me and LP were the only ones left, people have been suspecting Chugg only had two partners, the FOXDIE and the Bomber, so you should 100% feel ok with bussing us now I would say.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
Yeah sorry I figure the goggles worked better for my claim even if it's a stretch, and the horse seemed a better fake claim to save for later than some stealth camouflage.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
I just realized I can't say I was role swapped because someone else would've got my message. Oops.

Also of course scum doesn't buy my claim and they're likely onto Fanto. I think though since they know we're not a threat and a relatively easy elimination later, we'll be kept around.

Kind of an impossible situation here. If we make our move now on Liquid we basically have to reveal ourselves. But if we wait and try to survive, scum just gets a bigger grip on the game until we can't convince anyone.
 

Lone_Prodigy

Am I at 10 posts yet?
There we go.

Sorry I botched the claim.

I was going to do a reads list but after Liquid and claimed town there isn't much room for you to hide.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Well, basically, like I said Ephi, don't be afraid to bus me now, there's no reason to try sticking up for me in there, my days are numbered. If you want to go all out on a Scum read of me, be my guest lol.

With the Kalor/LP thing behind us, I'm guessing tomorrow will be the day to focus on ATP's list, and I am going to be screwed lol. Faddy also seemed to pick up on the fact that I was obviously teamed with LP today lol, so I imagine there will be some good cases to be made about me.

I'll claim as the D-Horse with a totally useless role, so I won't be saved by that, but it will be fun to claim at least lol.

If I'm at the top of the votes at EoD tomorrow, I'll likely keep the Patriot tradition alive and open wolf still though lol. If it's close I'll probably just see how it plays out just in case, but if it's going to me at the last minute I'll still make a good going out post lol.
 

Ephidel

How do you do, fellow mafia?
Well, there's a chance it could become a day to focus on Monkey or Sparks, depending on how people react to how things got shaken up.

But I might
767883192958713916.png

We'll see. I'm hoping to find some time today to give the thread a bit of a reread before day start with the lists in mind so I can work out how best to find people suspicious.

As for the bomb, go for it. Bombs away
767835171817914399.png
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I'm amazed people are still listing me as the least likely suspect of Vere/Kalor/Me, even without a claim from me, or like any legitimate scum hunting lol. If I actually live through this day I'll be amazed lol.

Monkey has to be Scum if she's not scum reading me lol, she knows but she's keeping me alive for later, or she just wants me to be in her pocket lol, idk which one.
 
Top Bottom