Spectator Thread Mansion and Simon Spectator Thread

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Just got caught up.

So Splinter wants to force a claim out of WSD now because of GF's breadcrumb? Ok.

One of Hecht and Splinter is Scum.

If Hecht is Scum, B-Dubs is probably Scum with him. I don't buy their little flirtatious readings of each other.

I still think Hecht is more likely to be a Neutral though. The idea of Town/Scum/Neutral each having a BP on their side (likely to counter the DayVig) makes sense to me.

As for Splinter, if he's still alive in a couple days, and Hecht doesn't flip Scum, I'd be going for his naturally sketchy ass.

WSD, well we obviously know he has a PR, but PR != Scum, and I don't like the idea of forcing him to role claim just to let Scum know what power he has. Then again, this is the only info they have from the now deceased Watcher, so maybe they should get some more info if it exists?

If WSD is Scum, then what did he target GF with on N1? A kill, but they hit the BP? So then Hecht is just big lying in that case? So they are Scum together? Otherwise he hit him with some sort of investigation role? Tracker? Would make sense next to Turmoil's claim too.

If WSD is Town, he's probably got a good role, he's probably a Cop or a Doctor I would guess.

-------------

Ok, there's my morning ramblings lol.
 
Yeah, WhySoDevious was the visit N1. I had no idea what role it may have been cause he never really talked about it that I could tell. I thought maaaybe Cop since he didn't go after me on D2 at all.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
For Simon Says, let's see...

I'll stick with Vere on the Zeke scum read, because I love it.

If Zeke is Scum here, who is Scum with him? Guessing 3 Scum total based on game size, with Cabot down, 2 left.

Malus? Possible. My initial read on Malus was "Oh, he seems Town" which made me think he was probably Scum, because why am I not immediately suspicious of Malus?

Zeke + Malus. A match made in Mafia Heaven.
 
Jesus Christ zipped. I voted for kitsune because she's been scummy all game.

If she targeted me, why would i say she was town read? If I thought my N1 visitor was scum, I would have claimed differently and outed them immediately, as well as posted my theory on hecht's claim being bullshit.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Hecht said:
But that doesn’t change that scum tried to kill me.
Repeating it doesn't make it true.
Hecht said:
Z-Beat said:
So what specifically do you think they targeted GF for on N1?
Roleblock? I don’t know. It could have been a town PR. There’s nothing there that makes me think one way or another, just that the way people reacted to D1 GF makes sense to leave him as a lynch topic for D2.
So WSD targeted GF with LuxCommander's Roleblock on N1? What?

"Could have been a Town PR" Yeah, just like GF was saying yesterday! Lol.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Hecht said:
So either I'm telling the truth or scum decided not to kill anyone on N1, which is equally as dumb as shooting GF.
giphy.gif
 
WIFOM but wouldn't that be an incentive? Unlikely to be protected, likely to be a PR target, gives a confusing D2 start.

Well look at it from D1 voting perspective. Kaz(scum), Lux(scum), me, and grizzly are up. Grizzly is lynched to save lux and kaz, though we don't know that for sure at the time. When he flips town, we're going to look at the other 3 lynch candidates now. If they killed me N1, that leaves just two people to look at, who are both scum. Killing me N1 is one of the dumbest things they could have done. Gets even worse if some of the voters on me were scum, which I suspect they were.

It would be a really bad play.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Well look at it from D1 voting perspective. Kaz(scum), Lux(scum), me, and grizzly are up. Grizzly is lynched to save lux and kaz, though we don't know that for sure at the time. When he flips town, we're going to look at the other 3 lynch candidates now. If they killed me N1, that leaves just two people to look at, who are both scum. Killing me N1 is one of the dumbest things they could have done. Gets even worse if some of the voters on me were scum, which I suspect they were.

It would be a really bad play.
There's some truth in that. Maybe I'm just overly suspicious.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I'm more taking issue with the way he is presenting it as "Either I'm telling the truth, or you have to believe one of these unlikely things!"

It's actually far more simple than that. Either I think Hecht is telling the truth, or I think he's lying. That's it lol.

There are plenty of scenarios here in which Hecht is lying in some way, none of which make him Town.

It just reminds me of when I would give all of these elaborate scenarios to explain my Scum Gambit in Conspiracy, while always leaving out the simple answer of "I'm just lying to all of you right now" lol.
 

cabot

Why.
Two Sleepwalker on the same team has happened, but it was only once.

It's unusual.

I think devious is scum. Possibly a role cop?
 
I have no idea what to make of that claim. 2 Town Sleepwalkers is apparently legit?
lol, I mentioned it in thread, but our very first game ever had two sleepwalkers. Kalor was in it for sure. maybe zipped too. I don't think we have any other old timers in this game though.

Spoiler about devious' claim from an outside source!
He's not lying. The irony here is he couldn't directly verify my claim D2, but I had no way of knowing that.
 
Just cause I was curious, here's the cast of our very first mafia game:

AbsolutBro
Amir0x
Barrylocke
Duress
egruntz
El Topo
Foshy
irfaanator
johnnyquicknives
Kalor
Karkador
kingkitty
Lord of Castamere
Mattyg
nin1000
Palmer_v1
pants
QuantumBro
Rembrandt
RobotNinjaHornets
Timeasis
tomakasatnav
traube
ultron_87
Ward
Xpike
Zippedpinhead

Some were never seen again, a few are still regulars.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Whoa, that's cool. I've played with Absolutbro, Kalor, Nin, and ZippedPinhead. Possibly others if they've had name changes? I knew they were all veterans, but I didn't know they were in the community's very first game haha.
That list though...
:eyes:
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Damn, DCPat died before he could enjoy his Confirmed Town status. Unlucky.

Also, Chuggernaut, the perfect Simon, and he picked the BEST POSSIBLE MODIFIER! THANK YOU CHUGG!!! <3
 

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
I also thought DCP would get out alive :c But he helped Town a great deal and used his PR well!
 
Yoyoyo!

So? I'm now leaning scum on Faddy, but that can also be because he's almost personally attacking me lol. Even a few kicks after I'm dead.
 
Damn, DCPat died before he could enjoy his Confirmed Town status. Unlucky.

Also, Chuggernaut, the perfect Simon, and he picked the BEST POSSIBLE MODIFIER! THANK YOU CHUGG!!! <3

Thank you so much for that gif. Im going to save it and pray I ever get to use it. I was looking forward to being confirmed town so much.

Before the game started I was praying to get vanilla town, but this was even better. Finally a game without real worries about fucking up as scum or town pr.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Thank you so much for that gif. Im going to save it and pray I ever get to use it. I was looking forward to being confirmed town so much.

Before the game started I was praying to get vanilla town, but this was even better. Finally a game without real worries about fucking up as scum or town pr.
Lol, glad you liked it! I hope you get to use it someday too, being Confirmed Town comes with a lot of luxuries (in my experience at least).
 

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
Hm, are there really 2 "lynchproofs" in Simon Says? If so, what kinds of counters are in place for them?

#HammererLeftTooSoon
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Stella and Luna, Star and Moon, the Town Sleepwalkers?

I buy it.

That was a legit good idea from Turmoil to ask that question.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
An updated Mansion read list (now with comments!)

Mainly for Brazil to enjoy. <3

Town:
  • turmoil7 - I buy the claim.
  • WhySoDevious - I buy the claim.

Lean Town:
  • BronsonLee - Townish votes, seems to be trying to solve things on his own.
  • Fat4all - Seems more legit as a Town role now that there isn't a vote being stolen from someone on the same day he claims it.
  • Kalor - Votes seem like Town ones.
  • Z-Beat - Nothing different here about Z-Beat from what I've seen from him in the past. Accusing him of being coasting Scum is like, the easiest thing to accuse him of. His votes look solid to me though, if he's Scum here I highly doubt he looks to bus his Roleblocker friend with that Lux vote, at that time, on D1, when he easily could have voted elsewhere at the time or kept his vote on Zipped. If he did, then man, that's some shit that I would not expect from him.

Null:
  • Girlofgotham - Townish votes, but terrifyingly hard for me to read (she was a SK in GoT).
  • Kitsunelaine - Seems Town, but she is also a hard read for me, trying to look past her general goofiness for a motive, if there is one, currently.
  • saenima - Worries me at times, bad vibes from some posts, could just be over-eager newbie though.
  • *Splinter - Probably just Town, but is hard for me to read, and I have firsthand experience being Scum with him, he's very good.
  • Stuart444 - Called out Kaz, but could be a teammate just bussing him. I just feel like I'm not getting enough from Stu to town read him yet unfortunately, even though he makes lots of posts.
  • Zippedpinhead - No fucking clue.

Which leaves me with...

The Suspect List:
  • B-Dubs - His latest posts have really not made me feel good about him, I think he's faking all of these reads. His vote on FEP was bad also. He had a vote on Lux on D2 before he got shot, but his reasoning was so wishy-washy, and he only really did it because GF claimed so he couldn't keep his stuck vote there anymore.
  • Hecht - Not Town at best. He's sitting here going after people like Z-Beat and WSD now. Why? Probably because he knows he can bully up on players that won't fight back against him much and he can get people thinking scummy thoughts about them.
  • Muffin - Almost a complete non-entity in my mind. I can't even think of what Muffin is up to in this game. The vote tool shows him wanting GF, Kalor, Kits, and FEPs so far... yeah not a good look to me.
  • StanleyPalmtree - I usually find it really easy to town-read Stan from what I recall, but he is not on my Town radar in this game at all, which worries me enough to put him in the Suspect list instead of the Null list. Had a bad vote on FEPs too in my opinion. Had a vote on Lux on D1, but it could totally be a "hmm, let me just vote for my teammate how about, hehe" vote if you ask me.
  • weemadarthur - Has not been filling me with confidence with her reads so far, and her votes are pretty rough in my eyes. She's also joining Hecht in trying to downplay Turmoil's read on WSD's claim being extremely similar to his own. Turmoil is pretty sure she's Scum here too, and I'm town reading Turmoil pretty hard.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
That was maybe the most subtle post I've ever seen from Zeke lol. I knew something was up with that, and then spotted it right away lol.
 

Z-beat

only here for the flavor
Just put your alignment in a spoiler tag, I don't want to wait til EoD lol.
Town

My only hope is that I'll take hecht with me. His claim seems like the most preemptive "covering all my bases so they can't vote me out without hard evidence" claim in the world. I'm also starting to realize that wee is most likely scum as well.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Town

My only hope is that I'll take hecht with me. His claim seems like the most preemptive "covering all my bases so they can't vote me out without hard evidence" claim in the world. I'm also starting to realize that wee is most likely scum as well.
Ok, rough but that's what I thought. I just put together a big read list a few posts above, and I had you as Town because of your vote for Lux on D1.

Hecht and Wee are two of my top scum reads for sure. Also side-eyeing B-Dubs, Muffin, and possibly Stan, though I just remembered that Kits thought he might be the Vig when Hecht brought that up again, so maybe I'm wrong there.
 

Z-beat

only here for the flavor
Ok, rough but that's what I thought. I just put together a big read list a few posts above, and I had you as Town because of your vote for Lux on D1.

Hecht and Wee are two of my top scum reads for sure. Also side-eyeing B-Dubs, Muffin, and possibly Stan, though I just remembered that Kits thought he might be the Vig when Hecht brought that up again, so maybe I'm wrong there.
Suspicion on Stan came from him getting on the bandwagon with his D1 vote with Grizzly. He provided no reason of his own as to why. Then he went after panda and Godfather. He also had less of a presence in Day 3 than even me, and the presence he did have was pure fluff, yet no one opted to acknowledge this.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
To go back to Simon quick before I go to bed:

If that is a breadcrumb for some kind of protection role from Zeke, and I'm pretty damn sure it is, then I would say...

Apollo/Zeke/Faddy/Chugg/FluxWaveZ are my Town reads. If one or more are Scum, I would be shocked.

Other than that, I've got what I like to call my two Trios of Uncertainty.

The first Trio of Uncertainty is Malus/Fran/Exodus. Malus probably gets my pressure vote here today, I think he's Scum. Fran seems kind of scummy too. I would not be opposed to voting for him today, would probably want both of them to be in contention. Exodus is kind of apart from these two as I don't think I'd want to vote for him today personally, but I could still understand it if it happened.

Swamped/SalvaPot/Meatwad make up the second Trio of Uncertainty. Could they all be Town? Yes. Are they all Town though? I don't think I'd bet on it. I don't feel as strongly about my reads on this Trio, but I would not be surprised if at least one Scum was within this group, if not the rest of them
 

cabot

Why.
I love that swamped is still trying to go off my posts.

So much great useful content less than twelve hours in.

#dontshootimcabot
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Just got caught up on both games.

Mansion: Hopefully they go for Hecht or Wee, but I'm guessing they don't. They better not go for WSD though, that would be a bad call as far as I can tell. It's possible he's a Scum Sleepwalker that mirrors Turmoil's role I guess, but I'm doubting that.

Simon: Yeah, I'd probably vote for Fran or Malus, don't like their arguments here today at all. Not sure if they are Scum together though. I think Fran had a weird subtle defense of Malus yesterday that I noted, but that doesn't mean they're teammates necessarily.
 

Kopite

Quickdraw King
Are players like Stan (who just play the same way Day 1 where they whine at everything and scold town) just unreadable on D1?
 

Kopite

Quickdraw King
Occam's razor is to get people to assume I did it since you were tunneled on me. Sorry man!
No worries, I agree it was a bad scum play both to NK you when you were a strongish lynch target (maybe they were worried that you were a stronger PR than you let on?) and to silence me to cast suspicion on you (even with Occam's razor I don't think any of them really pushed this point? Maybe they just wanted to get a claim out of you, scum Kits would make sense here)

I also shouldn't have focused so much on you, I genuinely thought you were trying to target a new, slightly inactive player. FWIW Kits push on you really did make me reconsider but after I got silenced I just decided to go with Occam's razor really.

Also just realised my push on you lead to both of us and Aeleus getting killed :(
 
No worries, I agree it was a bad scum play both to NK you when you were a strongish lynch target (maybe they were worried that you were a stronger PR than you let on?) and to silence me to cast suspicion on you (even with Occam's razor I don't think any of them really pushed this point? Maybe they just wanted to get a claim out of you, scum Kits would make sense here)

I also shouldn't have focused so much on you, I genuinely thought you were trying to target a new, slightly inactive player. FWIW Kits push on you really did make me reconsider but after I got silenced I just decided to go with Occam's razor really.

Also just realised my push on you lead to both of us and Aeleus getting killed :(
At least having bad near tunneling pushes is something we have in common (sorry about that Z-Beat)
 
No worries, I agree it was a bad scum play both to NK you when you were a strongish lynch target (maybe they were worried that you were a stronger PR than you let on?) and to silence me to cast suspicion on you (even with Occam's razor I don't think any of them really pushed this point? Maybe they just wanted to get a claim out of you, scum Kits would make sense here)

I also shouldn't have focused so much on you, I genuinely thought you were trying to target a new, slightly inactive player. FWIW Kits push on you really did make me reconsider but after I got silenced I just decided to go with Occam's razor really.

Also just realised my push on you lead to both of us and Aeleus getting killed :(

Mostly just bad luck. Sorry I was a dick, but seeing how people react to it usually tells me a lot. Your vote or scum read of me honestly had nothing to do with why I went after you a bit D1. You just seemed too passive to me, and I target like half the game at one point or another. Making people vote and take firm stances is all you can really do on D1. For D2, I totally get it. Once you lost your vote and knew you were dying it's demoralizing.
 
People say he's easy to read, but he's always town. So, like, no one knows that hahaha
Yeah, same here. You always get varying degrees of drunkenness, aggressiveness and some hint of trying to solve the game when he has time between the slurs. And I never feel safe to townread him for anything.

<3 u, stan
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
It's like, on the one hand, I really want Hecht to be Scum, but on the other hand, she could totally be lying, but this is just setting up a 1v1 with her and Hecht then?

Are they both Scum? I would fucking love that lol.
 
Top Bottom