Spectator Thread Mansion and Simon Spectator Thread

Fanto

Confirmed Town
NhPV2PL.gif
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Wow, I really like the sound of that role. They get lynched together but not killed at night together, and they'll gain a roleblock shot if the other dies at night? That is a really cool role lol.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
It wasn't meant to be :lol
I don't know what this is supposed to mean, but from a design perspective, a role that is part lovers, part masons, and part backups is kind of cool at least, or am I wrong to think that?
 
I don't know what this is supposed to mean, but from a design perspective, a role that is part lovers, part masons, and part backups is kind of cool at least, or am I wrong to think that?
Oh, I like the role as well, haha. I meant that it wasn't meant to be in the sense that they never had a chance to shine.

The idea behind it was to create a cool dynamic for them around breadcrumbing. If they did breadcrumb too hard or outright claimed to avoid a lynch on one of them, scum would know who to target to hit the roleblocker post-flip. If they didn't rely on breadcrumbs and still managed to survive through lynches, though, they'd hit the jackpot, and scum would be left struggling to find the roleblocker.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
*Splinter said:
Ok in light of recent events I should probably reveal that double vote isn't my own power, rather it was thrust upon me by some unseen hand.

So it's entirely possible that someone gave me Kopite's vote for some reason
The plot twists in this day just keep coming! I love it!
 

cabot

Why.
Yeah that was some unfortunate timing.

Difficult to arrange pacing around games unless you've got someone in charge of scheduling who knows what all games designs are. Not sure if anyone would take up that mantle.

I may bring this up in season end. I understand it's a bit of a shit role but I think maybe someone like roy/neuvo would do it since they're essentially not playing in any games anymore?
 

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
I may bring this up in season end. I understand it's a bit of a shit role but I think maybe someone like roy/neuvo would do it since they're essentially not playing in any games anymore?
If the Scheduling Team would have me, because I don't know if they would want to arrange games that way, I could do it. I also don't play in games, and I think I have more free time than cappa or roy. But yeah, we can talk about it later.
 
saenima said:
Or the ones not on the scum train are most likely not scum. Scum trains don't build themselves.

Oh saenima, you should really check out some of the previous games where scum mates were busing each other hard.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
hey, at least you got to play a little.


I was getting changed after badminton when i read my own fuckin' flip.
Was legit surprised you died d1. Thought we were being casual d1 and then Bang! And I'm apparently completely oblivious because I didn't think you were a front runner for Simon.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Is no one going to ask Faddy why he picked a wildly anti-town effect for today? I'm guessing the answer is going to be he wanted to use it now when the roster was high rather than later at mylo.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I really like NF's scum read on DCPat there, he's a really astute player. That is, assuming he's Town and I'm not just being royally fooled lol.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, here's a Mansion Read List. Lot's of nulls and lots of #GutFeels for the Town and Scum reads, but it is what it is. Not really looking at any votes either, so I'm guessing there are some things that might make no sense in here lol.

Town:
Kopite
Aeleus
Hecht
Splinter

Lean Town:
Turmoil
Kitsunelaine
SaucyKaz

Null:
saenima
BronsonLee
WhySoDevious
Stuart444
LuxCommander
ZippedPinhead
B-Dubs
Godfather
Z-Beat
FEPs

Lean Scum:
Girlofgotham
StanleyPalmtree
weemadarthur

Scum:
Kalor
Muffin
Fat4all
 
Claims abound!

Ok, here's a Mansion Read List. Lot's of nulls and lots of #GutFeels for the Town and Scum reads, but it is what it is. Not really looking at any votes either, so I'm guessing there are some things that might make no sense in here lol.

Town:
Kopite
Aeleus
Hecht
Splinter

Lean Town:
Turmoil
Kitsunelaine
SaucyKaz

Null:
saenima
BronsonLee
WhySoDevious
Stuart444
LuxCommander
ZippedPinhead
B-Dubs
Godfather
Z-Beat
FEPs

Lean Scum:
Girlofgotham
StanleyPalmtree
weemadarthur

Scum:
Kalor
Muffin
Fat4all
This is fun to read, thanks for this :)
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
saenima said:
Is there any role where one can steal a vote and give it to someone else?
I'm pretty sure Stan had this role as Town in Conspiracy. He had 3 shots of it too if I remember right. Never used a single one, and eventually got mislynched while he was asleep.

In case anyone ever wonders why Stan is so angry all the time lol.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I think one of my new Mafia pet peeves is people calling each other "dumb town" or "stupid town" just for, like, playing the game? Why the insults to other players' intelligence? As if they're so smart? I'd be on Hecht so hard for that shit right now lol he's lucky I'm not in the game.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Yeah, and I'll say there is definitely a line between like, legit criticism and just being mean. I think if someone is clearly giving an honest effort and just trying to provide some theories to the thread, or give a scum read on someone, there's no need to call them dumb just because I disagree or because they aren't expressing themselves in a way I can fully understand at first. If they're just being a nuisance and/or getting in the way, but are clearly Town, then yeah I'd criticize that.
 

cabot

Why.
Hecht as scum makes little sense but I'm still struggling to fully believe his claim.

It seems really powerful?
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Just got caught up. Not sure about the Mansion here right now, I'd probably be voting for Kalor if I was in there, he just reads really scummy to me right now. As for Simon Says, top scum read there is DCPat.
People still are voting Godfather? Bleh.
Yeah, the votes on Godfather are not ones that I can fully understand here. I'm not the biggest fan of his attitude at times either, but I have bigger scum reads than him.
Hecht as scum makes little sense but I'm still struggling to fully believe his claim.

It seems really powerful?
I've been going back and forth on this too. Right now, I think he might have just been a 1-Shot BP but wants to fake like it's more than that in the thread. If he really does have multiple BP Vests, then yeah, that would be pretty powerful unless he has to hand them out to other players now that he used one on himself maybe?

The other options would be that he's a Neutral with some sort of NK immunity, or else he's Scum and they know they hit protection last night or were roleblocked or something. I think the Neutral theory is more likely than Scum, but him just being a 1-Shot Town BP is probably the Occam's Razor solution here.
 

cabot

Why.
yeah i buy it if it's one shot, and obviously it's pretty silly to claim 1-shot, so he's just saying he's got more than one to ensure they dont try again.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Kalor said:
Just because someone is good at mafia doesn't mean that they can't get stuff wrong. Apparently I'm good at mafia and I get a bunch of stuff wrong.
Still scum reading Kalor, but this post is me.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I will say, until now, I thought that Sorian was the cockiest player I had ever seen, but not anymore.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok so what is this, the 5th role claim of the day? Splinter's double vote, Hecht's BP, the Lovers, Fat4all's double vote giver or whatever, and then now a Town Watcher. Plus the info of what is most likely a Scum role that prevents people from voting. That's quite the D2 lol.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
And this is why I called that the vig would not use it to save town. Great shot.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Simon is quite messy. Several people seem scummy to me, and I'm coming around on Faddy+DC being a team. Only problem is that Zeke's immediate bus theory gives me pause, because that would be too coincidental.
 

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
I'm so sorry to what happened to you, kaz and feppi :cc sorry to see you leaving like that
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Huh, guess I was wrong about Kaz. I am really bad lol. Why was Stuart so sure he was right about that? I could not understand that scum read, or anyone else's scum read on him. But whatever I guess, I just suck at reading people.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Huh, guess I was wrong about Kaz. I am really bad lol. Why was Stuart so sure he was right about that? I could not understand that scum read, or anyone else's scum read on him. But whatever I guess, I just suck at reading people.

He gave out the vibes of scum who was afraid of really posting and interacting with the game, in the fear of giving out clues.
 
Top Bottom